Authentication of Post-Conviction Evidence
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned whether certain documents, introduced to support an application for post-conviction relief based on newly discovered evidence, were sufficiently authenticated under rules requiring documentary evidence to be shown to be what it purports to be. The court held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the documents because the moving party provided adequate foundational testimony establishing the documents' identity and nature, even if that testimony was less formal than might be required for an ordinary trial exhibit, as the standard for authenticated evidence in support of such motions is less stringent and can be satisfied by the movant's own direct testimony regarding the document's source and authenticity.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Authentication of Post-Conviction Evidence: The court held that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the documents because the moving party provided adequate foundational testimony establishing the documents' identity and nature, even if that testimony was less formal than might be required for an ordinary trial exhibit, as the standard for authenticated evidence in support of such motions is less stringent and can be satisfied by the movant's own direct testimony regarding the document's source and authenticity.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal proceedings.
Testo completo
!
"# $ %&'
'$ ! ())))))))))
* + ** ,, ** * +- ,
!"#
*
&) *+ ),,,,,,,,,,-.,,,,,,,,,,&/00-1+++.2- ,,,,,,,,,,-0$&'' 1)++341++.5 .+6.07+!'''44.89)
!) : + 4+ 4 6+ 19+ 6+5+ ;+ 4<=: >-343..1+<++ +<:+)
%) !/7+!''(-?&(@!&-3+..++5+31 *5 ++ 2 ? &&( A1"@- 15 .+. .+-?+B6+.++1+.?#'A1"@) ++-.41 6++...((A1"@)
C36+.D.444+?3+..-+ 8+.3E<6+-6!!7+!''%-?&'@$$- *F+)3+..6++.<5+1G11F ?/(A1"@-15.+..+-H6+.++1+.?#'A1"@? +) .+ C@@ 3D 4 6+ 6+ 4+8+)
$) 6+.4: ?4+96+-*) ),,,,,,,,,,++H.- & 619 !''(- H3+ + 4 3E< 6+ 11+ *5) 4-+++.8+H34.3 +++ + ++ @6.+H- + + 4 < 9+ 118871++2+6+ :+) 4- + 36+ 4 3.. 2 4.+ 7 4+41++)
() G. 0 619 !''(- : ++ ? *) ),,,,,,,,,, 8+541++.5+++4H 1+-44++3+&#+8..+++< &! .19 &/(I ;: 0$&)'& >) 8+E H+. 1- 3+. 14 319 +- 11 3+14 3E< 6+ 39 9+ 48+ .1+7+4)
#) %' 619 !''(- *) ),,,,,,,,,, ++ +9 1+++8 3 E4 H3+ 6+ 11+ 3+8+ H+ 5+ 31636+-114.+?: ) ?+.++H..E1+- : 3F 1+81 4 14 96+ &
"$!%&"!''( %"#
619)++.8+H3?3+3+8+- *514+E8+E6+.4.4+.+.)
0) 4+ .. 14+ 4 &/ 419 !''()
) 5+4.19-75..5.+81.H3 413.+ 5+. .++ H.=3E<6+6+.4 4..++6+99+..11+5+31F- 636+)
9) *) ),,,,,,,,,,8+1.1)34. 8+ H+ + .+ 4@.) 6++ H+. @@ + 3+..+68+)+6+.48+- +.4J++16+-?E8+41+)6+ 6.@+41++? 1?+6+ ?<6)
) : 4+. .++- E4 H3+ 3.+ .. 1++11.5+3+143E<6+)35++3 8 56- H+ 6+ G +. 4 1 3. 1++11 .5+1+): ++H.H3+36+4+ 3+8+11+4?*F+!''%) +. .+?4..++-+J+?+)
* ,
&) 7. 14 + 6 7+++ 14.- 69;)(# +K5++7+++!!619&/$& !'(L)#%)&+)+ 4.1+++6&! 419&/I( (&'>)
!) @ + 4 +5E 1H - 4++- +5E8+E6+1E+1;)!0)& L&#!!K +5+++<(419&/0/M: :0$&)!&- 2&'I #!>)
%) N+.-6+1E+15..6.@+4+I' A1"@- H ++ - ++ 6++9++. 869 K+ $ +. & K <5 +++<&%619&/#!; :0$&)&&L 2&!&&!0L &//(##$>):K+.(1G1+4++-+5E46 ++H K 6+ 1E+1- + . 44+9 + 4 +1++5..6+)
"$!%&"!''( $"#
: 7+4 +9 8.. 1+< KE< 6+ ? KE.+K+..416+1E+1+.(? !( A1"@ + +8+ .5< H+ 7+8+ +14 6+1 K+&#+.% ; 2&!%&'#- &//00!(-+)!9- 44)0!I 0!/.8)+)>) 3+8+4++<1.5<-+. ?11+++6;)&#)$ >)
H.41+!#!/A1"@-856+. 1F; 2&!$!(/>)
6@-.41%'A1"@4O4++4 8 1+8 E4+ 46 7+8+ KE< 6+ E 8 K19++ +9+5+41++-4+61 +++ + :+- 6 56+. 1+ 5 HK+ 46H) + - 7+4 +< H 11+6++5+<K<581;) &#)!))/'@)! L 2&!%&'#- &//00!(-+)!-4) 0%'.8)+)>)
+4++444+9H+++++ 869 H .. 8+8 + 9 16+)K5+88K.+.+1+<86+ H4+9K.5+.+17++9; 2&&/9&(#L: &//%4)(%(L 2&&I&/'L&'I9#0L&'$9(&>)
K4<- .41 6+ +.- 1 .-..((A1"@-4<.+15.+.)35+3 56- ++ 4 3+ &# +. & - H+ +14+H + 9+5+41++-4+61++++ ++@6.+H)
$) : 3+ &# +. ! - . 1++1 + 41++1+4<11++3+8+56)
K5 K 41+ + .5 4 G ++ 6 +4++H+K44+H+41+++; 2&'I9 #' #&L)$(3.5K1++46.@+ ?+++<!09&/0# :0$&)(&>)
4.-: G..1?H1+- H+44++444++.66+4++ - . 6+5 76+ !''( ; "I0$"!''( !' .19 !''(>) 4. 3 E< 6+ 3 14- : .+ 88 8. ? 3. 1++11 .5 . 3+++) .H-.++8+1.-.4+9+4
"$!%&"!''( ("#
8+.) .54.+.1- +91+++844? *) ),,,,,,,,,,H3+4-4.1-+6.@+ .5+ 4.+ 2- * 6.@+ 4 H 41+ +34.+)
() 6 H+ 4.<- 7. .11 N2%'') 1+?@5H+19;)I0 >)
. *, *
/01'!# 2
. 69 +7. & .19 !''( 4 *+ ),,,,,,,,,, .++ 6+ 19+ 6+5+ 0 619!''(+8++++ ++++4H 1+L
1'2
7L
1?@5.11 N2%'') L
+ H- 81.1 E + /0 +6 + 8.. K5++ 7+++-4.G4G4.-46++1+++8- 7 < +8++- 4 6 +9 8..) 1.1+ +++H+-1+81F464+5 1+) . + E14+ 1+ +9 8..- &''' &$) 4. G 4+< 4+ -+6H.111F46-+6G7+?K6+)
11+H 4. G ? *+ ),,,,,,,,,, ++ HK 6+ 19+6+5+?K88+8..?)
:+.5= *16F-4.+-)F@< @.+-75)
"$!%&"!''( #"#
1 +91+++8=
588+< 7+7)= 6+ 4.+= *) + )6F
4+81G..11+H.E4+)
<6- 588+<=
"$!%&"!''(