Property Boundary Dispute Over Sequential Conveyances
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over property boundaries, specifically involving sequential conveyances from a common grantor, where the description in a later deed was argued to encompass a larger area than intended due to an ambiguous reference point. The court reasoned that the subsequent deed's boundary call, which referred to a monument or line that was already implicitly fixed and controlled by the prior conveyance, must be interpreted as incorporating only the portion of the property not previously conveyed, thereby limiting the later grantee's interest to the remaining, unencumbered land to preserve the integrity of the earlier grant.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Boundary Dispute Over Sequential Conveyances: The court reasoned that the subsequent deed's boundary call, which referred to a monument or line that was already implicitly fixed and controlled by the prior conveyance, must be interpreted as incorporating only the portion of the property not previously conveyed, thereby limiting the later grantee's interest to the remaining, unencumbered land to preserve the integrity of the earlier grant.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied to order the appellant to pay the procedural costs of the federal court.
Testo completo
!"#$" $%&" '() ! "#$%
%
') ))' * + ')
)' , , ) * ) + !"##-! # !%!&$#$%
!"#.!%# //"01".) # !'' '#$%
()*+,(
+1 !%' (2 3% 4%' &'% %5' !'&#%55!''1
' #' "6'7"'865 % ' %5'1
)1 %' '55%"''9%5'!'&:1 1;'(9<:11= %' '2% '$' 1
'6:11%' ''5 2 "'(6%<
( >,)%55?@
( >+//)%55!''@
( > +.0A %55 !''# 7 6'' ..B)./5)#2 %$ 3C !'L .D.5) 5"3' "C '5 2' % 5@
( > +.0- %55 !''# 7 6'' )E,7E,D-5)2'"' '2"C '5 % 65..-5)1
%$ % F%&'%1
,1 ++5')//.#!%'GH%'!2'!%' ' %( 55 :$%' % ' ' ( '% :11 % '4 &%" IG+,B0//B///1(1
.1 )- % %" )//.# % 5 % $% # :11 %'' 2 %55''% 6%'9 &'% ;'(9< G % %55''%= %% '$''%%+.0A +.0-#'%%('' ''2%(J '5 %$>+-+E8%'6 %' 6%'.% %"+DD+;GK:)++1.+)1++=1
%$'$''%%'' 8''%>+.0A4 %(%+.0A +.0A15'9#76'')07))E5)# &%"' % 6 '5% 8 7&' # % 2 4'95# 7 6+DB/+.5)%5' % '%'' '% $% '% &'%$' L 5' 1
'$''%%'' &5 8''%>+.0-4 %(%+.0- +.0-15'9#76'')0-B/005) %$' $% '% &'% % 2 4'95# 7 6''
*,-,.*)//0 (,*+,(
0B0-.5)# ' '5%87&' $27' ' %%&5 6%L %$ '%1
6' #:11%'' ' '%%(% +.0A +.0- %>+-+E#76'',/B-+/5)# %( %+.0A +.0- %>+-+A#76'')AAB/ED5)1
01 ''%)0J$')//0# G 2L '$" 5% '6 27 7$' %" ' '&5 '% ' $ :11 !1 ! 5 % M ' (' ' J ' % %8G1
E1 +. $' )//0# :11 '' G 7 %$ 2L 1 %'' ' % '% 2 '% ' ( '% 7$' 8 L %' 9 % 2 '6 7 ' '5 &'%1 % #'%'%2L 1
:11 4%' 27 %3' ' &$ %' 7 3?% 392 8 % IG)B///B///1(#'%%2%'' ' 6'' '% % ' %' ' %"J '$5 '%' 8 7&' # 2' '5'2' '$''%# % (' F%&'%1
7'5#:11%' % 74 '% '6%' 1% ' 2$ % '6%' ' '5 8 IG +,B00D7D0)1( % 2 '6 8 $% '% &'% ' '58 IG0B.D/BD0)1(1:7&' '# '95 ' F% &'%# 4 $' ''# %6%55 8 '2 % # %66'' 3%'2 /#) % 4 6 3 ' ' 4' 6'4$59 8 IG.//1(#% ''$ 3%'27 '8"C '2'' 7% IGE//1(59 1
%2 # :11 ' %' ' 7 '6 &'% 2' ' 2./#0)N % ' $%'1 ''#%% '% '6 &'% '6' 8 0/ N# '6 :11 %' ' ''5 '%'55"&'%1
A1 EJ')//0# G %8 % '# 8 $%' !1 ! % %# 75'' :11 G 1 %'%# (' % 2 %J '$''% '% :11 5&' 5'9 2 $ %5' &'% 2' ' %' 2' ' J ' 8 G1
-1 )+J')//0# G ''%J''2 % ' 2 '% ' ( '% :11 7 ' %5' 8
*,-,.*)//0 (.*+,(
%' '%#"'('7 %5%%5%'0/N7 '&'%1
D1 %% %' 5L5 J%# G # % 27 7 ' %5 % %''$''%'%%'' # 5' %' 5 B5&5 # B2'5 %&5 ;'( 9< % 5 # $ ' % 5 % '% 3%%&'B'6%5 '%@'(9< =%''% 7 '.G $'7&' ;'(9<$'= 5 7' '# 7&' 7$'%5 $ ' % 5 ' %';'(9< =#%27' 5 '$''%'%%+.0A +.0-1
' ''%7 % '6'8!1 3% 1
+/1 %'0J' )//08 G #!1 3% #%5 % $% # 7 2' 7 $ % % $ %5'1
3 # ' %3' ' 6' $%' %' 5 '% 65' 2'%6' 7 '.AG1
++1 +/ %O )//0#$'#"%'5 '%' 6%':11# %'7% '%'$''%'%% +.0A +.0-1
+)1 +0%O )//0# 5 % 2% '%' > +.0A ' %6%5 4 '%' '% & 5 '9 75&5 ' %'1 ' &5 %>+.0-#8 74 '% 7 "2 % 5 $' % 8 4'& 5%' '%$%' 1
+,1 +, 5" )//0# !!1 ! 3% % %5 '%% G 1
!1 3% '6%53%%%&'$5 ''% ' ( '%1
'4'22'' '%%"'8655 ' ' '%'66'' 27'%3' ' 6'$%'%' 5 '% &'%1
G %6'5 8 !1 3% 27 ''% J'' $' )+ J' )//0 % 2 '% ' ( '% :11 7 ' %5'8 %' '%1 ''%'' % '6'%6%55 87 '-,')G1
*,-,.*)//0 (0*+,(
+.1 ''% 5L5 J%# H )D 5" )//0 !1 3% # G %% J '5 > +.0A # %5 ''% $' +/ %O )//01 ''% +, 5" ' 4''%J'' 7%% %' G )+J')//01
+01 ++% %")//0# G ''% '6' '$2 %%H' J '5 >+-+E#''% %(%+.0A +.0-1
+E1 ,+ % %" )//0# !1 3% ' J % 9 '" 5'' '6 % ''% J'' 7%% %' G )+J')//0 ''% G +, 5")//01%8 % '% ' '% ' $ %$ '% ++ 5' )//.#87 '%''%J'' 7%% %' )+J')//0 8''% G +, 5")//01 6'#' 5' 7% %'7'5' %1
'%' ( '% ' %5'8 %' '%7 ' E+G#4 '%$87 'E)G7 5'1# 7 'E,'+ G '6'4%$#6' 25% '6 6872'' '% '#7$' 45'1
''#%6%55 87 'A/G#'% ' 6' ' L &' %' '%% '1
:7&' & 5 '# 7 ' E/ ' + G 7'2' 9 % 2# $ F% &'%# ' 7 ' %'" ' 27 ' 7'55" $' 35 7' '% %'1 7&'' 5'4 7 '55" 8 & 5'4 7 ' ) ' ) G1
74 '# 27 ' $ F% &'% J278 IG.//1(5)# ' P5'6 5 'Q1
+A1 %'''%.%$5")//0# '"%%# ' '% 7 ' A+ %' % 5'' '$ +) 5"+D-0; ( 0+/=#7:11#!1! !1:$%'1
+-1 % +E%$5")//0#!1 3% %% ''% '6' '$ ++ % %" )//0 9 '" 5'' '61 % "5 8 J% '% %$ % K &' % *./0)*)//0 K $ *,-,.*)//0# 7&' 7 5L5 %54 6' 1 6%# ' ' %'% J% % 6%' $'% '%7 'E.G1
*,-,.*)//0 (E*+,(
+D1 )5")//0# G ' %'%1
7 ' %5 % %' 5 '%% 65'$ 7 '.AG1
% '%' ( '%#('7$' 8L %' %55''%1 3'66 74 ' $'6' %55''%6'' "'%' 2'7 ' %5%% 0/N7 '&'%1
'4'55"&'% '%7 ' 6' # '454'55'' %"'&'% IG-1(*5)1
265'#!1 3% 7$' 2' %%'% ''%J '5 1
87 %' '%'$''%'%#!1 3% ' O %'% ''%$'+/%O )//01
6'# 7 ' 8 %# !1 3% 7$' 8 L %$%2 % EJ')//01
)/1 +, 5" )//0# !1 ! :1 % 6' $' %"$ '% % 4 %1 % % "5 8 J% '% #6%#8%6'5 '%''% 2#$ ' 6' 1
'%' ( '%:11%5'!'&7 ' %5' 8 %' '%# :11 7 %' ' 7 '6 '5 &'%1
7 ' 8J ' 2 G $' %%J '5 >+-+E1 66 #% '"6#'?$' ' '%5 7 ' 9 "J '6# 8 $%' 7 '' '% 66 '$ %& 1 ''# 766 '% "J '$ 3C !'& 2' ' L %' %55 &'%# $' 75% % %"J '6 2# 7 6H%&# % 6 '%$ ' %8 1
6'# ' 7? $' ' 3 7' '% 7 ' E. G# & J '5 6' ' %$ 2 '% '$44 '%''74%' '% 8 ' %1
)+1 )) 5" )//0# !1 :$%' 6' %"$ '% %1
' % 86' &' '&%% !1 3% 8:11
*,-,.*)//0 (A*+,(
? %J% "%% $%''&$!1 3% ' 2' %6'%'5 '# ' 7$' J5' 7' '%5 ''"'&'%1
8%'"'' %65'74%' 5 '%# ' 7 % ' 8 J '# ' 5%' 2# %5 '%27' ' $!1 3% #'' ' % 53% 5 8'%'$8%& 574%' '%%5'1
6'# 2 ' '5%' %55 %# %5'!'&$' L % &1 &#!1 3% $' #' %5"# ''8$& '5%'1
))1 .J$')//E# '"5'' '6%%J% '% *,-,.*)//0 *./0)*)//0%5% *,-,.*)//01
),1 )E J$' )//E# J& & ' ' %5 '%%1
!1 3% %6'5 5%%1"'865% ' ' ' '7$' % '':11 %5 ' 9' $' P"%' %' &Q1 % ' 7 ' %5' &'% 8:11>+.0A$' 3 $&'%1 (' $' % '5 8'& "'1
5'5 ' 3&' ' 8 $ &'%# %$ > +-+E ? 5L5 ' '2 2 >+.0A1
%$ %& $' % 66 % ' ' 6 2'% ' 6%'17&'' ''9 '"%' >+.0A 1
%3' ' 4%%' 5 '%&'% $' 5%?17 ' ' 872'' '%P 3C Q1
74 ' 5 )//0 % ' ' " ' 7&' 7$ '% &'%1 '&'%&%'' 8 IG.#0/ 59 1
G '2'454'55'' 7$' 8 IG-1(59 1
!1 ! ''2 2 :11 7$' %J % ' &'% %5'1 ' $ 2 !1 3% # 8 ' # ' 2'
*,-,.*)//0 (-*+,(
' '%'(5L51:6'' %$'&' '%5'17?' %% "'8651
!1 3% ' $%' 6' 8 !1 ! % %3' 2 8 72'' '%7 ' '&'%%5'!'&1'$' %J%' 27'4' %%' 5 '%1
%$%&7 ' % '%''1 7$% '% % "'# % $ ''% %'"'' 5 74%' '%8% 6'7' ' "'1 ''#%%' '% !1! 85 6'65&%5 '$' '7 ' '6' 1
!1 ! % $%' ''% J %' 5 '%1 ' 2 :11 7$' 7' '% '$' % 5%%%5' '$$ '1
!1 3% '$%'% ''%$' %' '$''% '# %' ''% +/ %O )//0# 6 ' $%' % '6'17$' '%'2%%' '%$ G +, 5")//01
:7&' 74 ' 5 )//0# G ' 2 6' 27' 7&'' 74 ''$7$' %66 '$"1 %55''% $' 66'55 '' % %$%' 5' ' 3'66 '4 '%%' 8' 531
:% !1 3% # 4 ' $' 5 % J '6' '4 ? % "% ' 8 %'% 2 &'% ' ' '6'8 %&'%1
!1 ! ' 27' 7&'' 4 ' 6' 8 %% $ %5'1 % "% '' 8 5L5 %'%1
:%!1 3% #' ' %5%' % 27$'%3 2 (3' 2%5 ' %5'5 ' % '7 ''( '&' '%%' 6%'1
G ''2 2# %27' 7&'' $%' # '2 ' 75 %66'' /#) '4F%8"C '% ' % "C '5 %&'%' F%&'%1
!1 3% 6' $%'2%%' ' % '7 '%5' &'%357' '%%' 6%'1
*,-,.*)//0 (D*+,(
:11'2D0N%5'5' J '%' 6%' 1
:2%'# &8J&1
)
+1 J 5 '#4%% $"%' $ ; 1 -- G@ 1 0E %' B%&' '% J''' )) %$5" +D.+@( )/0@ 1+,%'7' '%%'6%' 6%'@ G(!++/=1
)1 % % 5' ' $'' '% ' ( '%% G %%% %')+J')//01
,1 ' ' ''% ' '&'# !1 3% 2' % %' ; 1E/ 1 =1
.1 72'' '% 7 ' % 7 '55" &'% %5' 8 %' '%; 1E+1+G=17', '%' '%'2% 2'' '%# 6 %' # '' 2 % J''2 2'$ %%5'25 8 6 %' 1
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
*,-,.*)//0 (+/*+,(
01 1 G %' 5'' '$ %%5 5'9 ' % %& $' B' '% B %' 5'' '$@ %' L %' %55 %' 5'' '$ ' + ') 0 & ; *,E-*+DDD+0J'+DDD=19&%""0! B'2 %8'''% G ; 1+1+ =1
B %' "' 6' B%66'@B '5' & %66$ '; 1+D =1
"1 G %5%K%7 ')'+9&5 74 '% %' 7' '% %' 6 %' 6%' ;! + +/1/+= ( %' 7 &'9$# %' '% 6R '9 7&' &$%'# 7 35" % '# 7 35" &$%' '55%"''9# 7 %5 %' ' "''55%"''4 7 "&$%'1G%5% ''' #%55''% ''4% M 3'2 2 '"5'' '61
79#%74 '5'8 G #$"' :11 '8 IG+,B0//B///1(%2$$ '68 $% '% &'% IG 0B0//B///1( % 2 "' %' ' %5%%0/N7 '&'%1 G # % 8 % 8 %5 '% %# 66 % 5 7' '% '1 6' # $'6' ' % %72 '%3'66 74 '$' '1 74 ' % 6' 7%"J 7 45 5' '4 %55''% 2' $ J '4 1 % # % 79& 5 ' 2' ' 5 74 ' )//0 % 27'%%"J '$5 7 1
'% # 7 8 "% %' 2 G % 2 '% ' ( '% 7 ' %5' 8 %' '%1 ''% '%2 %6'51
7' 2#% '5 82% ' % # 'E) '$ G7% 8L 45'1
E % % &5 7% %' 7 %' '% 4 '% % &5 ' '&'%1
A1 %$' 745' ' '" "' %5 % %R ' '&#'('45' 7%66'%5 1
1 5 7 ' E. ' ) # % 8 %' '%5 5' 7%66' 8 J'' '% 5'' '$ %5 1 7 %8 82' 85'9 %' 1
*,-,.*)//0 (++*+,(
"1 :%B 'A', G#5%5 7'55"' F% &'% ? 6' 7%"J 7 5'5 ' %5' 4 ' '%7 '-D%'5'% '%6%'9; !(!+ /0=1 '%' '%'2%$7 %' '% 5 # 5%5 ' &'% 5' ' ' '5' 5 2 2 %' 6 8 1 ''% 5 '"%8%55''% 5'% '% 6%'9; 1D) !=1
79# $' %' 7% '% '$''% '% 1
2'92%%!1 3% %' L 5' 8 %55''% 5'% '% 6%'9 % '% %5 1
%%'$"%' 1
-1 $2'9#''% G +, 5")//0 ++% %")//0% #''%$'7 6'' '$ % 2% '%% 7 %' ' '5 5 1
D1 !1 :$%' %" ' &' 7&' ''% )+ J' )//0#''%2'%1 5%5 5'83& 7? % %'% # '5' ' %1
5%5 IG0//1(5'83&:112'7%" ' 2 '5 &'1'5' %# IG+B///1( %8!1 3% 83&%' 1
5%5 5' 8 3& !1 !# % %5 ''%)+J')//01
5%5 IG 0//1( '6'& 8 !1 3% 2' %" ' '5 &' 1 '5' %# IG0//1( %83&8!1!''27'5' 5L55% 8 :11
5%5 IG 0//1( 5' 8 3& G % 4 ''%% 1'5' %# IG0//1(%8 !1 3% 83&7 9$1 SSSSS
*,-,.*)//0 (+)*+,(
2' )
304#/"5
'$" % ' J ,+ % %" )//0 !%' (2 3% % ''%%55''%6%'9&'%+, 5")//0 27'$'''%$'7&' +/%O )//0@
$"%6
415
J 27'$'''%% '%)+J')//0@
75 27'% ''%+, 5" ++% %")//0@
''%+, 5" ++% %")//0@
$%' %' 8 %55''% 6%'9 &'% % %$ ''% 9 %' J&%55''% 5'% '%6%'9@
5 % 8 %55''% 5'% '% 6%'9 27' % ''%$'7&' +/%O )//0@
5 83&% 5%5 IG0//1(@
5 8 3& %' '55%"''9 %5' !'& 5%5 IG0//1(@
5 83&%55''%6%'9&'%5%5 IG0//1(@
%'5' % IG+B///1(83&%' '55%"''9 %5'!'& IG0//1(83&7 9$@
%'5' IG0//1(8%' '55%"''9%5'!'& '5' 5L55% 8!%'GH%'!#83&% @
' 2# %6%55 4 ' DA '$ %' 6 B%&' '% J'''# L L % #$%'%%' 5'' '6# J% 9 % '6' '%# ($ '" 6@ 55%' %%' ''2%'%#5% '6 5%?$ % '& % %%5 '@'%' L %'45'5%' '" 6# +/// +.@ L '9 %'% % #'$%2%555%?$#%'$ L J%' 8B$%'@
*,-,.*)//0 (+,*+,(
%55'2 L 8 ! "# $% % # 8 ! '' '# $% !%' ' %( 55 :$%'# 8 ! % !&$# $% !%' GH%' ! %' '55%"''9 %5' !'&##''2B8%55''%6%'9&'%#8B%66'6 J ' 8%55''% 5'% '%6%'91
:'& < !5%$?#' #!1?39#!5I'#!1 3'#!5%# J&1
%5 '"5'' '6<
&66'9(J' J1< $'(' < !1 %%' 1%$?
%'%6%5 L %55'24 '1
9$# &66'9<
*,-,.*)//0