Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/33/2007 • CJ GE ATA/33/2007 Generato dall'IA

Rescission and Restitution for Property Sale Agreement Breach Due to Failed Consideration

Numero d'incarto ATA/33/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court addressed whether a party was entitled to relief after the opposing party breached an agreement concerning the sale and transfer of property interests, where the breach was related to a disputed interest in the underlying property. The court reasoned that because the initial agreement was conditioned upon the existence of a specific, valid property interest, and that interest was ultimately determined not to exist or not to be fully transferable as contemplated by the parties, the party seeking relief was entitled to rescission and restitution of payments made under the breached agreement, effectively voiding the contract due to failure of consideration or a fundamental mistake regarding the subject matter.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 106 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Rescission and Restitution for Property Sale Agreement Breach Due to Failed Consideration: The court reasoned that because the initial agreement was conditioned upon the existence of a specific, valid property interest, and that interest was ultimately determined not to exist or not to be fully transferable as contemplated by the parties, the party seeking relief was entitled to rescission and restitution of payments made under the breached agreement, effectively voiding the contract due to failure of consideration or a fundamental mistake regarding the subject matter.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
restituzione della proprietà compravendita violazione essenziale del contratto diritto alla risoluzione del contratto nullità delle intese pagamento di interessi

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 106 LTF

The decision rejects the appeal as inadmissible because it was filed against a non-appealable interlocutory decision (implied by the context, as other grounds for admissibility are not cited in the dispositive).

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The appellant is ordered to pay the court fees.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



        

       

  

    

 !"

#$!%!&' (





(% !" )))))) 



* + ** ,, ** * +- , 





     !"# 

* 

()  *+ ,,,,,,- .  ,,,,,,(/00-  1+++.  2,,,,,,- (!'3 45)++671++.+5.#.18(//%)

!)  9+618++:+75+18+ 5+;+<+ 74=9 >-?..1+4 +++4)

3)   $ @+ !''#- A (/B!'- 6+.. ++  5+     C+  ++  45- D?+ ? 7 ..  1 ?  7++. A  :  +D   1+- @B.   +E  5  B.7;.+.57)

$) ) *) ,,,,,,  .. ..  B:  7+ 7  74  ?:- *+ C,,,,,,- F @ 7 )  +  ++D. D  @ A- + 5+  +  7  5  :11   :+  ?77G+ A 5C+7;7.;.17H- .AB?++5?5I+;)5+?.+G. 7+771+J) +5.:;-+5+7J 5.B+?+..-D+5+1G1+5D?G8+. @5?5I+;)5+7.D?G+)D?+ 5+ 17+ D   + 7  - + ?5+ 7 D  7.+7+   B. 7 +  :+- D+ ?5+ DD 7 5.)  5+ .+ A ;+77?: + +?5+7..B.) 5.B+?5+:K. 7   5. 5+ .. B.) ?18++ 5+ 7+5+    :++LF-11?+?.+7J+)

  9.7B:7+-*)C,,,,,,+77.:+!$ @+ !''#)   1+  .++-  5+   :+ E .. 1+  ;7171:+:)

 8) *) ,,,,,,  ..  A  ;1+  ;  ($ 718 !''#)   F7. D?+ ++ A 5+ %' L1"B     C+  ++5+) B7-+5+7J;7 7+.) 745+5.DD14-+5+.D?+E5+F    :- @B.   5.)  7 ?.+ ;;.   7; 7.;.)  5+ +1. D?+ + ;1  17  7  ?G-  ?: 5+  B.  ;B A + 7 77 A  1B.+71+J7;) +1 AD?+5+7.-?:-D+5J+-?.+7G. :; ) ?E 7  17  :+- + ?.+  .7.  7 7+8+:+?.5+5?:) +.+7.

"$%&'"!''# 3"# 

 74    +4 ;B   5+)   5+ F 7- D+ + M 1+F 5+  :+)   ?.+ 7 G.-  + 5+ D?+ ?5+7B.?:-1++5+47)

%)  (#8!''#-9 +5+.*),,,,,,A7:+ 7.+.- D+ + 5+ .. +;. 7  7+ 7+- 7 G.  3' 8 !''#- + +  .  5+1- +. D?+ ?;++ ? +:+.;4?+(#+.(+:.. +++4(/.18(/%&<  90$()'(>

#)  *) ,,,,,,    +8 1+++:  # .18 !''#   A ?+  ?5+1 7.+.)   .  :  7++.D++.+7B.-7+.?.+7-7+D?+++A 5.7;7.;.) 7-D?H.+..+7. 1++?7;77+.-+?.+7+++ 7+  7; D?A 7+  11 N +  5+   :;  D+)

  :+- + .+   78  7  ?5+ @1+ :+ ?8@1+11+++57+F+)

0)  7+..17+7(%@5+!''0)

 ) *) ,,,,,,:+1. ) 745+.+F ;1-+7.+. DD?+5+7J;77+.-+.+A 5+5+; +D147;77+.) F +5+D+ ++.A;B) 7-+:+1.)

  ?++D+-+?.+7G.)5+;.  .5+  5+ . D  + 8+)  5+  7  5+ 7.:..  7 ?G-  +  + .5.) D?+ 5+ 7J  ;7 11J  5  B.- + 5+ +.. D?+ 5+ ;1  1775+..+:AD+7+75:+)  ?.+ D?A 7F+1+. +11.+  7; D?+ ?.+  17 D ?: A 5.- 5J 7 5+ D  - +;+  :;  + 7+55.?G)5+.A+7?.5+- + 1G1  75+ 7 ?G) :+- + +.+ D  7 + MK:)

 8)  9   7+.   .++) ?+ #  ?   4;   ++ +4  (3 518 (/#!     9 0$()((> +1++5.?:F7+.-D818+@B. ;+ 8..:+++   7++.  1G1 + D  +   7; 7.;.)   ?5+ 7 .. ::+11 +:)  + M + D?+5+7J;77+.) 1-774?:

"$%&'"!''# $"# 

+.++D+:+?5+7..B.-1+1:K.7 +4  5.B+- ?.+ 7 D?+ ?.+ 7.+7+.   B. 7  +)

&)  9D+-?::+..;.A@;)

* , 

()  @.  17 + 5  @+++ 17.-    58<)%# +6;++@+++!!518(/$(    !'%O)#3)()+7.1+++5(! 718(/&%    %('>)

!)  :++F7+.5.B.<)33)(  >)

  57;77+.-+57 7++4 -  8+- 6G 7 +  7++. F 7+. D+  5.@A7;6E;;<)33)! >)

3)   5+  7 7++4 +17. F 18++ A677B 6 7; 7 7+.   ..1 +   .+. :: 7  7;) 9 5++ + ++  : 6 ;5+. + < "%&!"!''$  # @+ !''$  .:) +)>)    6+ #  64;+++4(3518(/#!<   90$()((>-5+;7+(@+(//$-:5+ 18++.7++.F;D+.7A7+)

$)   . +1  +7++ 7.+. D   + 6G D6+ +5 5  7; 7.;. N  5  7+. E 6++-1+:-5B.-:++D?+.@A ;;.)  7++7  .;1 58 7  7; 17  H -11??74)

%)   +  5+   + .+ + -    5+.  +7++ 7.+.)  5+  :: G ? 7 5+;+  ?G-  ? D?+ . +1   .+ F ;1 1+5 +81+++::+1. 17+ 7  D?+ 5+ 8  8+ 5  7+. ;;.   7;7.;.-1G1D?:5.)

     +17 ++       5+1?+(#+.( -?+.7.

"$%&'"!''# %"# 

 1 D+ ? 1+:1 7 F+5)  .D-  .++ D.5G:+1.)

#)  7+1:.-@.)

   ?+  ++;-  .11  PC $'')   1+ A  B;  -D+18<)&0 >)

.  *,  *    

/01("$!2

.58+@.#.18!''#7*+,,,,,,  .++  5+  18+    5+;+  3' 8 !''# + 5+1O

1(2

@O

1AB;.11 PC$'') O

+ D- :1.1 F + &!  +5   + :..   +8 :..  (0 @+ !''% < C 9 (03)(('>-  7. G 7 G 7.    @ D+ +5  +:++ 7 5  +8 :..- 7  5+  1+4+78+O1.1++++D+- 1+:1E757+;1+O+ + G .  +8 :..- ('''  ($- 7 5+ 7  7 5+ .+D F ++  6+ $!  C)  7. G   7+4  7+  - +5D. 11 1E  75- +5 G @+ A ?5+O

11+D7.GA*+,,,,,,++D65+18+ 5+;+A6::+:..A)

9+.;= *15E-7.+-)EB4 B.+-@;)

"$%&'"!''# #"# 

1 +81+++:=

.+ @+=  5+ 7.+=     9)PQ R )5E   

7+:1G..11+D.F7+)

 45-  ;::+4=           

"$%&'"!''#