Breach of Modified Settlement Agreement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant filed suit alleging that the opposing party breached a settlement agreement by failing to make required payments following the original agreement's modification, which itself arose from an earlier judgment that determined the opposing party was liable for damages including punitive ones. The court reasoned that the modification agreement was supported by new consideration, namely the agreement to extend payment deadlines and reduce the initial installment amount, and thus constituted a valid and enforceable contract that the opposing party breached by failing to adhere to its revised payment schedule, affirming the lower court's finding of breach of contract liability.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Breach of Modified Settlement Agreement: The court reasoned that the modification agreement was supported by new consideration, namely the agreement to extend payment deadlines and reduce the initial installment amount, and thus constituted a valid and enforceable contract that the opposing party breached by failing to adhere to its revised payment schedule, affirming the lower court's finding of breach of contract liability.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAProvision applied for the general allocation of court costs.
Provision applied for granting legal aid to the appellant.
Testo completo
! "#$
$! %&&&&&&
' ( '' )) '' ' (* )
!"#
'
() *+*,,,,,,-.,,,,(/'0-1+++.234)++ 561++6+(&7(/0#)
!) 8+1+64+19+4+:+ ;+ 63< 8 =- >+ ?9@ ? + 61+ + 6 1+ !# @+ !&&$ 6 4+ 1. >+ 4.A+- ?B B. 61+3 6++ C +:C 1+C 4+ >1...11DC +6+26A4)
%) E4+!&&E-2&#A%$-?+..++1F +++20'G1"A-1:.+..+-H4+ +.2+.+E&G1"A) ++-.61..%'G1"A)
6-(#4191B1.-2&0A!E-++1 ? (++-H?2A*+3-+ .6. 6+ 4.A+ .6+ 6. +:C ++ 1I4) 11.+1+6.6:1-++.>+H++ .+ 6A.- H+ ? 6 16BA. 1.A. + +>+ 1 A16)
$) B. / @4+ !&&'- 8 +. 61+ + *)*,,,,,,6+C1+->?+('+>.. ++ +3 (! .19 (/E0 ;8 #$()&( =) >+C H+.1-?+.C+>+.+-1B1 H.++4-?+.!9+6++6.+.)
E) *)*,,,,,,++ +91+++>?!>.4+!&&' 2.+.16+2)? 6 . ?C3 4+ E 4+ !&&E) 4A- ?+>+ (# 419!&&E?.+6.+.<+4+.6+6+96 .6 4.A+ 2 ?B- 1+ @1+ >A+ +: 9A +)?:6++4++>+.H-?+D+4+-+ 64+ ?4+ 4 >> 1I4) 2 .++4
8 4+16-+6.+.H?4++4+..+>+.3 -+63H?+C..+-H?+?4+.) 66.2 6- +9 6+ ?4+ 9A+ 66 6+) ++. >+ H?+ .+ 1 6C 3: ++-6+H?+C A++-+?4+@1+>+?9@? 1 1+++4) 8 6 6>+- + 4+ 9+ 4.A+626>+1)
"$%&"!&&' %"#
') 6+..16+6(%1!&&')
) *)*,,,,,,>+1.)H+.+?C34+- + 4+ ... 6 4+ 6 J) 2 +>+ +4 .61 ? >+ 4.A+ - + C6.H?+++>+:A-+.2?B)4+ 4>3A91.-4+::.>++ 3 H?+ 4+ 6 >+- >A+ +: 9A +) H +K+136+-++.+24C>+ ?.+2H?+4+..+6.6:1)
866>+-+>++66+:?16+AK L,,,,,,) 4+ 9+ 4.A+ 6 - H+ ?.+ 6 9+ 4+ 6 9- + 4+ 2 +) >+- . 4+ 14+ .6+ H < + 4+ >+?9@?+61+!&&$-1++4+ ?1H++4+..+>+.63H?+C..+) +9 6+ 4+ 9. 1@+. :+> - 6++ ?C3 4+-+:-)
9) 8 6+. .++- 6.+ H . + +..+C1+6.C34+?..)8 ?..-+..H1+) 2.1++16.46 6+>+F6-.++1+)
) @: ..:. +>1. 6+ H?+ 1+ ?66 2 6. + +. 6 +9 6+) 6+ 6+3 6+ + 1+ 8 .+ + + . 6 .1+)
#) .@:1(/619!&&EH +96+4+ +..11.+.?+>++21>+4.A+2 ?B) 4A-+4+..4++6.++>>+- :166?.66..2?+-.6+? 4+9>1)*)*,,,,,,4+..H+.C A> ?+ 9..>+ 51 MN !5&E&) 4+ .. .+ 2 MN %&&) - O .: C > .1 11+P- +/&A+>>( -$0A+>>(! -!(/+4 )
0) 4+.2.1+@:16.-8 1+.++ (( 4+ !&&') ?.. 4+ B 2 A:- +. 6. ?F64.><+4+>>..69 ?4+1.6+>+4.A+2?B4+.6. 1:. 6. ? +: ++ 1I4) 8 4.H?+?4+4-*)*,,,,,,+6++ +91+++>
"$%&"!&&' $"#
++:-H?+?4+6>+-1B1H4+>+:+ ?B.!#@+!&&$)
/) 8H+-?>>+..:.2@:)
' )
() @. 16 + 4 @+++ 16.- 49;)E' +5:++@+++!!419(/$( !&EQ)'%)(+)+ 6.1+++4(! 619(/0E E(&=)
!) 5 4.A+ 19+ + 4+ +>+: 11+++464++3:++H5+.9+- 2 +>+ +- H5+ >>+41 11+ 5+>+ H+ + 6A.)5+.66>+11 H + H+ 4++ H 5+.. >+ 3: ++)
?63-2>+?..H8 .++4?+>+(#419!&&E+2.64.A+ .6+6.+:C++1I4)
. @:1 6. H +9 6+ H+. *)*,,,,,,C+>++424++6.2+ +>>+-+.H4++6>+) 6-+?.. 69?4+1.>+4.A+2?B-H?2@ +H8 ..)
2?+>+(#419!&&E-+92C1+ +.+.-61+>C6.+ 63)
%) A+6+:C1H6+++:C >+C4+1C+1;)!#)( Q)('!!5 +:+++3E619(/#/ 8 8#$()!(Q N(&0'!=)
5+.+ +.- 4+ 1C+1 :.. 4.A+ 6 + E& G1"A- H ++ - ++ 4++9++.>495+$+.(5 3: ++ +3 (% 419 (/'! ; 8 #$()((Q N (!( (!#- (//E ''$=) 8 5+. E 1B1 +6++- +:C 64 ++H 5 4+ 1C+1- + . 66+9 +6+1++:..4+)
8 @+6 +9 >.. 1+3 5C3 4+ 2 5+.+5+.-.614+1C+1+.E2
"$%&"!&&' E"#
!&G1"A+6:4+.H+@+>++164+1 5+('+.% ; N(!!%#- (//##%%-+)(-6) #%#=-.4+6++3; N(!%(&'- (//##!E- +)!9-66)#!0 #!/.>)+)=)
.61 !( 2 !$ G1"A +- H 2 +- +>+ 1F1:4+16+H3::..+61+ 5+('9 )
4A- .61 !E G1"A 6 R 6++6 +9+:+61++->1+>C6+64@+>+ 5C34+C>519++-4:4+.1+ : H5+ 64H) + - @+6 +3 H 11+4++:+353:>1 ;)(')())/&A)! Q N(!%(&'- (//##!E- +)!-6)#%(.>)+)Q N(!%%#-+)(-66)$& $(-8(//#66) E!# E!0Q )('@+(//0=)
+6++666+9H+++++ >49 H .. >+> + 9 14+) 5:+- >>- 1+3- 5 .+. + >4+H6+95.:+.+1@++9; N((/9 (E'Q8(//%6)E%EQ N((0(/&Q(&09'#Q(&$9E(=)
563- .61 4+ +.- 1 .-..%'G1"A-63.+1:.+.)?:+? +>+ ++ 6 ?+ (' +. ( - H+ +16+H + 9+:+61++)
$) >+C . +- +4 > +4 B 6+ +.+-11?+2.+.+3-:4+.>- .. H ++ H .+. 6>+ +4.A+ 19+) .1++1+6>+ B.+)
63 +>+ :4- 61+ + +. 6 + 1+1++11H?6?..;)(')!) =)
?63-8 6.++C1+-> :4+.C+>+6A.?..)
+9 1+++> 34 H? H+ ?+>+ . (# 419 !&&E- 8 ++H.- 16+ 66+-H1B1+?.+691
"$%&"!&&' '"#
?C34+E4+!&&E-.++..+C1+ +.++4)
E) .++8 .+1>12@+66.+. 1++11 .: 6+ 6 5+ (# +. ( .++4-6BH>+1.)
') @.)
5+ ++:- .11 MN $&&) 1+ 2 A: -H+19;)0# =)
+ ') '
,-./$% 0
.49+@.'>.4+!&&'6*+*,,,,,, .++4+19+4+:+/@4+!&&'++ 61++6+C1+Q
./$0
@Q
12A:.11 MN$&&) Q
+ H- >1.1 C + /# +4 + >.. 5:++ @+++-6.B6B6.-64++1+++>- @ 3 +>++- 6 4 +9 >..Q 1.1+ +++H+-1+>1F646+: 1+Q++B.+C16+1+ +9 >..- (&&& ($Q 6. B 6+3 6+ -+4H.111F64-+4B@+254+Q
11+H6.B2*+*,,,,,,++H54+19+ 4+:+25>>+>..2)
8+.:< *14F-6.+-)FA3 A.+-@:)
"$%&"!&&' #"#
1 +91+++><
:>>+3 @+@)< 4+ 6.+< *) + )4F
6+>1B..11+H.C6+)
34- :>>+3<
"$%&"!&&'