Settlement Offer Enforceability After Offeror's Bankruptcy Filing
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed whether a party's post-offer conduct, specifically the filing of a voluntary petition for bankruptcy, extinguished a previously made settlement offer, thereby precluding enforcement of the settlement agreement. The court reasoned that a settlement offer, an invitation to contract, remains open and enforceable until revoked, rejected, or terminated by operation of law, but a voluntary bankruptcy filing by the offeror does not automatically constitute revocation of a prior, unconditional offer, and thus, acceptance of the offer after the bankruptcy filing but before revocation resulted in a binding contract.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Settlement Offer Enforceability After Offeror's Bankruptcy Filing: The court reasoned that a settlement offer, an invitation to contract, remains open and enforceable until revoked, rejected, or terminated by operation of law, but a voluntary bankruptcy filing by the offeror does not automatically constitute revocation of a prior, unconditional offer, and thus, acceptance of the offer after the bankruptcy filing but before revocation resulted in a binding contract.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs.
Testo completo
!"!#$" %# !&' ( ! "#$%&
&
) ) )( (( )( *( ( ) ) +% (( ( ) )( ( ( ,))' ( ( - ) ) $" !. ) ( !!&$%&
'()'
(
*/ !0"1" !&""# 02"'34&5 '
06& &&" "7(.882,9+0(6$(.8:2+(0(6 +*8: 29.90(6&00 #;5$<=*9 $%#3/ >"'?& & " 930 @& & "&/ 7 +*8: ?&0"&7(.8+ (.8A/
&)&' 7(.88$ &%7(.8-$&B "?" %" & &" "$ !0 C !&" "D "2"'34&5 "6/
(/ (- 0 (..9$ !/ 0 &"" 3 0 =010 $ =E"0 &10 $ % " & 0 & "& #&&1" ="?&0 "& 2"'34 0 6 = &" "& & " 5 %" & "1F % 11 ""/ #??" >"" &'&" &00 ">"#%"/
-/ :0"(..9$&5 "& ""E 0 E 7(.8* " &" &5 0/G" &)&' 7+*8: <= )' 7(.8-$%" 5 = "" "&&.$-<.$,/H%" " "&0 =0> ?0" 0&&??"" = "" "&& & %& "&E "/" &I " 10 " < &" &"J " &0> &'& = " #>" >$0"%&K 01/&I %&H" & 1 "00>"" "& & " "0 1 "? ="0 "& # "E/ "3 >"" 0&"?" "&$ E"&" %&"""&" &5 "/&I " &0 " # "E$& 00 "&&1>" "< " %" %"& $ 0" " & " " &> & &5 ""% =&"0 %/ <""$ " &"&&/
,/ & =" "& EK $ &00""& =#" &&&<=& &"=&1 "&<= "9:&"&'
"& " "& "% *, %" *:88 2 ' 9 .96 & & ?(9L$0 =&>% "&/ &00 0" %" ?%&>$ & E =& &" = &1 "& 5 & ? " "/ %" & 1&&1" 0" %" ?%&>$ % % & =" "& & 1& #0"E
)+,-)(..+ '-)'
% "/ &" & "& &I $ " =H %" = & "& 1&0">"/
&%""" " ?%&>&I /
9/ 0 0 $ !/ 0 E &" "" 1" ?&"?" E= &" "&& ""%&&" < 5= "" "&&& " " &" "<(9L/
+/ ""&>"C"=%"&??"": 0>(..9$ 0 "%= &" "&&"" /
A/ & &>(..9$&5 "& &3&00""& &&0 "3& "&2"'34&00""&6/='
&" "& "% %"" 5 0"& & "1F$ 0" 0"& &'
" 5 @& =#>" "&$ " "> % "0 $ & 5 = "'
" "&&&%" K "<(.L/"E?&'& ?M "&0 $"%" " "<""0&" #0>/
? 11 %" K " & ?$ " = " 0& " " " >N "0 =#>" "&/ " "& "" O=1 (*P$ ="00>"" "& & "" &I " &1/
= # "E 1>" &I " =#0&"E "/
$ =%" "1 0 " &?"&0 E"?"/
8/ : &%0> (..9$ &5 0 & && &$ & < & I / 0 $ " " & &" "&$ % E'"&" &>30 ""/
:/ &0 "&&(,&%0>(..9$ "& 0&" "&/
*./ *+I%"(..+$&00""&I &/
%" "10 "&?"&0 E"?"/ 1"? "? 3 #" 1>" & "&$ & 0& "%$ " "%>/ & ?"" ? < "&" "&1E"&" " ="00>"" "&&'
&/
)+,-)(..+ ',)'
11 " & "& ="0& %" " & "1FJ = " < I " E 0 %" & &1 "& 0 5=& "&&(9L/
/ (.?%"(..+$&5 "& "" ">0"" "? =??"/
= " < & E&00""&%" "1"?&? 0& "% "&/ &I = " & " 5 0"&$ 0" = / &" "& 0 0 & < &" "&?11= " 0"/$"?"" 8L?7+*8:/
& & 10 "1"? "?<="00>"" "& &'&$ 3#" 1>" &I /
*(/ (.0(..+$&5 0& &&&$& E&I " " 0 &?&05"&" "&1">/ 0 ?" 0K0$(-0(..+/
*-/ (,%"(..+$I11<=" "&&"&< & /
/ !/ " &"1 E 0I&" %" E " " %$%=5" =# "E/& "&&I $ :03 # $=#0&"" %>N "0 5" /"1" 10 E?"?&0 %"& %5$< # "E/
!/ 0" E&I %" # 8$A903 < >"3/
>/ &01 &3'%> "1$ &5 " & & " E E %" =% #3 &0& " 5 1 @''#/ > %" > $ >" E = &" "&=> 1?M ?&/
/ ((0"(..+$&5 0& &I& E%"5" &I %" # <>"3:$(903 / &0& " @''#%$ 1 &0>%>& /
( )
*/ I 0 " % I"" "& &0 $ & %>2 /9+ &"Q&1" "&I"""((&%0>*:,*'
)+,-)(..+ '9)'
' ( .9J / +- / * " / &" & 0"" "% *( 0>*:89' ' 9*.6/
(/ Q " (( " * &" ? Q010 " &" ((I" :A: 2 ' G A..6 %&" EQ & "& & " "& K & ?&0 Q &" "& &1 &0 / &" "& "% " & "& & Q" "& &?&0 < Q?? "&@& " " E"2 /((/( / > 6/ &" ? &" & % & &" "& 0 " < % 5 " * ( "&" "& " / Q EQ ?" 1" 1%&"" /
-/ #" + 2 /98<A:6?"5&0"?"E< &&%&""?">N "0 $&00Q Q3$930@& 2 / *: / - &" Q" "& &" ? Q010 " &",I"*:8A2 '*-.6/
/ 930 @&$ #E & "& &0& $ ""$ E &10 2 /A9/* 6/
"&" "&$%"1"*,I%"*::,$ " &" & 0 0&" "EQ "" "&I""& & "?" "&@&& ">2!0&" &"$ *::-$/,*(:6/
>/ G& Q " 9: " * $ ? & "& 930 @&$ 5"00(#$&" 5(.L?/ & ?&"$3& "&&00 &00""&Q#" $ 0 &"$&&I & "&&& "1$ ?#(9L$""& I "?" " 0 &0 ">% 3$Q#0&" Q010 E "2 /9:/, / 6/
/ & %5 &"Q "*(:&"& "& " "& "% (9 0 *:+* 2"'3 4 6$ & &&E=" 10 <Q "9: $" %E$&%" ""& & "& 1"1 " & < >N " @&%"$" " &#" >E &" $ ">"?"" 0&H " "&$ " &" & "& %" & & "1 % "" Q "" "& & % E Q " Q" &"/ & %" >" "& 5"% @& %"$ E&"" <" "&H 0 "E& "&&& "1$ ""0& " E " "&&" &0"<" 3>""0" / @&%"%" &?&%,30@&$E" " %< " "00>Q#>" "&2!0&"$*:8-$/,(86/
)+,-)(..+ '+)'
""$ "> &" E %5 &"$ E Q& &" Q &1 "& ?% Q "" Q "" "& (9L &0" < "&" "&/
&0> '" ?"1 Q5"1 E &I & "& &" "?"&& "1/
,/ && "1Q"?" "&50"&0&"$" 0 0" &H & & "& Q"0& "& #&&3"'"2 /98/( 6$<%&"= " 0K0"%2 " &> $" "&"#> "E &1"E 1?R"$*:+A$/*-*96/
/ G& I" & "> ?$ &" Q" 3 0" " & / & ?&"$ " 5 Q >&0 "$ " "" "&"'"& &">$"? &##E %" > & &0$ 11 & 0 < &"$&" & 00 > 31$&" $""E% E&/EQ&& 5 10 "0& 2 C:(,8$A--* K " 6/
>/ %51" "?<Q&"1"Q "*(8"( $& 5 "<Q "98"( &?"0 Q" "&" / ?? $ " & &"1 E Q" Q3 "'" &%" I "?" "& ?"" "&0K00"&""%"$E""0"E" Q5" Q & Q / & "&$ @& %"$ Q >N "0 & "&10 0" &">$<&" "&EQ""&Q3&0'
0 5 &10 / & " 0" " Q0 Q3 "'"$ & %" E$ 0"& ""%"$ & < ?&0 #" && % 15 " >N "0 @&, , 2!0&"$*:8+$/,,((6/
/ =3$ &I & 5 5"1 "'/ & " 5 %"$ 0 & "1S / ?" E " &5 #"E$ E #??"$ >" =>"$ & ">"#%"0&"?""/ & "0 < E & " & $ &">"" = %" < = %0 "E="=1" =&10 / 1"?3 & /
9/ / ?#"&" "&& ?$ " ? ? > # & " & "&#&'&2 /9:/* ( 6/
)+,-)(..+ 'A)'
>/ &E "& I "?" E 0 &0 "> % 3$ =#0&" =010 E "$ 0 & < &" "&$ & ?$ ? # &0>$ &E %" = 1 "?" < ($,.
03 & "%" ?T "3 2 /9:/- / 6& &E&0>& ="0& $"00 %"= 1 2 /9:/- /> 6&?11"0"&0& 2 /9: /- / 6/
&5& # &%&"%1& I % %"<=#>" "&2 /A+/* 6/
/ "> 0"" "? &T &%&" =" "& 0 $E" && " = "9:"*$ - , &15""15&BO"& I "?" P &B &0 ">% 3$=#0&" =01'
0 E " 2 )A88)*::A (- 0> *::A ? " 6/ "&0> & ?&" < =0"" "&$ &0 &%&"$ & #E<&"1" K /"& ?%&> < &1 "& & "0& $ 0 &" ?" % /&%" & 00 ?"" "&&%&" "% % "" =1" " 0 2/ U $ " &" 0""'
"?$N*::*$/-97*+96/
/ =3$ 0 Q& ?(9L/& " " &1 "&=?? "&= &">/ 1 $& "0 <E& " & $& " " ? &'&$ "#>" > &"$ &00 "'/ = $ & =& "$ & "> 0"" "?$ 1"? & ? &0>/
+/ &%" " 0""11&I & "& Q"0& /
/ Q "-"-310 Q" "&&"& "& " "& "% (A ?%" *:A8 2 ' 9 .9 .*6 "% 4
VG& & "&="0& $<&" "&E= % "<=#>" "&$"<=5"= "%" &00"$"'
" & "$ & ? =53 9. 0( E" =""% 1>" "0" 4
/ "1% "& # =53($9.03 J
)+,-)(..+ '8)'
>/ "1&>"E?" %=#&"@& &00 "1 % "1-.J
/ "1#&"@& ?T 1" <,$9.03 &05"00/
&$? & & "&="0& &" 58L? 05"00*..0(V/
>/ "> 0" E " Q0K#" &" " Q E&E$ " & 0&H$ QE" & "1F & &%&"10 ?& ">&" J Q"&%" E" &%> $"&%" "$0K0> $& & "&E"&" " <&%"%&" "%&""E" 0 < "&" "&$ & ? & ">$ ? " E" Q%" I< %" < & >N "0 5" / 0"3?" " 0"&" "$0K0"&" "&5$ Q " E ? %&"" 0" < & "> "& & ? & "> " %" "0 < $ E" "0"E" "E0 EQ&" 1%Q%" &>N "&?" & "%" 2 )+9-)(..," ?" 6/
0 & ""> &E=" =1" 0" *..L ?<&0 &%&"">N "0 ="0& /
/ =&$ 11 %$ = ? ,: 0($ K &"&00 ="0& E"? "< &0 1 & " < +*($9 0( 2,:)85*..6/ =3$? & %"&I *=.(-0(/
% E" 3$ &I "&" "& 1 & & ?/
A/ / <50"E "&&0 ">"" &I &"% 3$ =#0&" =010 E " E" & " = # "E$ &1 < & < = " *9 ?" < & "&I""E"0"&" 0"/& & "&%" & & "& >I "% " E" " 3 & "& #EQ3J& "&" <Q &" " " I10 / &EQ # "E 0 E 0 &" &" "&& && " Q& &" Q &" "&& "E& ?Q53(.L2 / *9/* 9:/* 6$1" ?" Q # "E&" "& ""> & &" &1 "& & ? (.L
2 )+A.)(..9& &>(..9J )+,)(..*-.I%"(..*6/
)+,-)(..+ ':)'
"&" "&1 ?0 = # "E$& I"'
"> " E= & " & "& I""E " 0"$" "&%&"=" "&<=0"" "&$'
" = "0" E =53 & => &%&" =" "&
2 )+.:)(..,9&M (..,J )9:)(..,(.I%"(..,J /G $ " &" 0"" "?$ #N $ *:8,$ / --('---J / U $ &/ " /$ /-,'-+$ 7 *+.'*+:6/ H 30 $ %" & %" &00$ 0 &1"0 " =& E= 3 & "?$ ? "&" "& & " 5 &"/ &E= %" &>"1 &"$"&%" 0""0"2 )+.:)(..," 6/
>/ #E ?&" E = &" 0"" "% " %" &00""& & "%$ = &" & &" ="0& " $ ?& "& & " < # " "1 2 )*(:)(..- 0 (..-J / '
$" K %I10"" "?" /'/ /! $ 1&> " K $ &" =%"&0 010 " &"$N C?& '''!"$*::+$/(.*6/ &" & "0" <50"" 0 = 0& "?& M0 >" %" = &" #"E & "%$ &0& "" /
/ =3$ =0> %" "" ?%&> &I / 3 &$ "> 0"" "?$ ="0& % E" " "&0> 0 "3 = # "E & "&$ E & E= & = &"'
"& & "$ 0 = " > & &%&" =" "& " 5"'"/ = ""<I " E&00""&&?"0= &"'
"& &$ & E 1"? & < 1 %" " K /
8/ " "$ & &# &I = T & 1 "00>"" "& & "E & & >N "'
0 /
/ >1=" " 31& ="00>"" "& &/
>/ G& "" 15 &" $ " Q " < Q0"" "& Q"00"&?" &" "%&% Q% E && / 1" "& 1%&" 0 "3 &" & "& &> Q&?&0" &I %" "& 0 "3& "& Q010 " " 5 ">N "0 " "&/ %#$ Q & &>I %" &" 2 /-/+ J )+9-)(..,(,&M (..,6/
/ 1"?&"% "K /
)+,-)(..+ '*.)'
:/ &&" 0?&$&I /
0&0 WC -=.../' 0" < #1 & $ " &I&" 0 &""0 / 5'" & &0$ &I&" 0 &""0 $<%<Q" "0"0" & WC(Q9../'/2 / 8A 6/
% () (
/01$ 2
%> & " I (. ?%" (..+ !0 C !&" "D "& ""&&00""& && 0 "3& "&*+I%"(..+J
1$2
I J
0 < #1 & $ " &I&" 0 &""0 $ 0&0 WC-Q.../'J
&<!&""# 0"0" & WC(Q9../'$< #1& $"&I&" 0 &""0 J
&00"E K < ! "#$ %& & $ < &00""& &&0 "3& "&$""E= 0 & "& #&&1"="?&0 "& <!!&$%& !&""# 0/
G"1 4 !/H#3$" $!0&%H W"$!/ #"$!0&$ I1/
&0 ">0"" "?4
1??"3'I" 4 " 4 /"&'G"1" C/H#3
)+,-)(..+ ')'
&"&?&0 K &00"E5 "/
3%$ 1??"34
)+,-)(..+