Interpretation of Transactional Agreement Governing Allocation of Costs
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved a dispute over the meaning and application of certain transactional documents and agreements concerning a financial matter. The court reasoned that the plain language of the controlling agreement clearly indicated the parties' intent regarding the allocation of responsibility for certain costs or obligations, which controlled over subsequent ambiguous actions or interpretations. Therefore, the court upheld the interpretation favoring the party whose position aligned with the express terms of the original governing instrument.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Interpretation of Transactional Agreement Governing Allocation of Costs: The court reasoned that the plain language of the controlling agreement clearly indicated the parties' intent regarding the allocation of responsibility for certain costs or obligations, which controlled over subsequent ambiguous actions or interpretations. Therefore, the court upheld the interpretation favoring the party whose position aligned with the express terms of the original governing instrument.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for ordering costs in the dispositive section.
Testo completo
! "#! $% $$ && ! "# #"$%&
&
'(('( '( ) '( '(
* '( '( '+((, -( (
$!. "#! $+!/+ !'%&$%&
()*+,(
+/ !0 1 !&# (# 22## 3#(4 5 &# #&&622##7& &# #)-89# ))$ &00 &&:;$ < #9# %# = > +?$ "0# ;&/ > 9 +@)A0)$ # #<#40 2& & #&$ # :0 = ># # #04 & #& # # &# & #& : #% , 0B+@@)3(,+.7/
)/ B >:# > 6# % %#$ &6 22## & $ 0# 0$ & <C &# #& & # +@ 0B )..A 4 0 D0:0 $ D<#0 &:0 $%#& 0 & #& "&&:# D#9&0 #& 3#(45 0 7 & "0 +0>0& 40 % 0## #/ 0 & # :0 >#9# #& > B& 2 #%#/
# <C & "0 0 & 9&# # )+ E%# ).., & &E B& & < &# # & & &% 0 ) 0 )..,/ &E %&;# &0B0 D 0 6# &% 0 = & #& B/1&9#: &#$#6# # 0 09&01$>%#&%#: 04 &:$<# %# / 0B# &# = 0 # 0# % 9F%# 0# &##04 / # 0$" +0?.$ #%# #%#&G0% & # /
&E&= $" 0&E # +0 0B# E 0#0& 40 $ # :0 +0/ 1 &: # &0B = 0 6# # 0## = ,0#0# & /&0B0 > 6 0 >E& ># 0$ 0 & &&:>% %#<A0/
A/ 0 <#%##/
1 &(&00##& H # I &00##& 0&0 # 3 !17 0# %# 9%&B0& #%" 0B;:%$ #0& #=
*-.-*)..- (A*+,(
/ %# :0 < 0 6# $ & # % > %#:&#$&# C &#/
0&#$)8%#)..,$# =&00 $& & 00 & 9&# < $ !1 0# %# 9%&B & % < &E B## #& # &# # #&/ & #& % ## 9# # & ##< : D# % #&/
,/ ##& +, 0# )..,$ 0 & D &# #& &## 3 ))>@.?(A7<# B#J#> %#99##3J 7 +@0#)..,/
-/ +?E#)..,$!0 !&#KL#"0$&# # +-@-%&##&622##$=>+- "0# ;&$ & & & D &# #& #% 4 &00##& & & 0 #4 & #& 3#(45 ! 7 & =& #&/
&622##&0B# :40 /0 & 40 D C M $ # & &< #0 %#0 # & D&: <# %# /
D#0 # 0 # 6 &6 22## #& D%&: &# /
D#0& & #&$ <# # D 9 +)G$-0N$&= &E #9## /&< $ D &# #& # " D %# ##40 :% %# C /
&E # &0 &&:"##6 0B;: # #0& & 6 # 6# %&##/ &E # & # = D # @ # # = ,.?$+.00& & #& =,.G$?G0%$=&O&%0 # &E / D # 9# 0& $ 9&# & #& #$ # %=,.@$G-0$&# =)$8@0 # /
0 D%# #&0 0#%# !1 & < # # 2& & : #% / & $ & #& # # G0 % #0# &# %#& #&D #G@#)&#& #& # #&#%+,%#+@883 (-.-7/
*-.-*)..- (,*+,(
J#0 $ 0 D%# &0 D # " #< & #&<## %##B#&# $0#:0 & %&## 0C0 # / &: 0 # "&04 "&#< : &00: && & %&##/ #&& 9#<# &&:;# <<04 & B# & 0 : ##"&04D"& ##B& & %&##:/
G/ )+E# )..,$&622##& 9# &B% #&/
# 96 < &0B0 # E<D 0 & 40 6# # =D& &9#: #&## # #P & #$ # # = B#/ #& ## 99 E&D"# #& 0 & 40 # 0&#$ #<D # 0 +0?. <D<+0/D0BD # "0 &"# % :D /
1D:# % &: &# &6 L#"0$ 6# # E=#) :%#/D;# #0 %&%0& 40 <D%#E=6# /
& %# ## = E # / 0 %# 9 0#9 0 0&# -.0N 0B# 6 0 &%# C <#9# & #& 0# %# <D0 = D # + <# 0	## D : BQ #0 / D:## D % #& 0& 0&# - R # "0&# % &9#: #& : #(#$ &# & % / &<$D #A#? 0 # D0&#& &0B#0 :0 /
!C0#&00##&%# #0<&%# ## = & $ #& %# C # $ (# # #0 #&& #& &O &00 D4$ & D%# B#E#/
" )08@ & # 6# & %# &6L#"0 # &/ 99 $=D60&$ 0 # 9# #0 0 6# <#&&# # #<> # #%# 6%= &# /
0 &E % C <#9# & #& D#0& $ &9&00 = D # A # A 4:0 ># #& &# & #& # #&#%)?9%#+@?83 (-.-.+7$ #&%# C #9##0# &# # #&D #G8 /1 " #<$&E 0#&# # #&/&%00F#
*-.-*)..- (-*+,(
D" +0?.9&0 H1I0B+0 &0& <D : # 6/ 1D:# "&04 "&#<$90&E 0&#$&%# %&#&99 <##:/
?/ && &# +8 & &B )..,$ ! #%# 0 = <# %# &00##& D"# E D&%:=& # 0&%0 <D##0#<# /
8/ +G &%0B )..,$ &00##& D"# %# &# #9/ %6 %#: ### 0&%0 #%0 # <# # &0 #B % & & # E## /
@/ 80B)..,$&622##& 9# &B% #& # M %#&00##&D"# /
4 & < %# &00##& D"# # 9%&B < %# # %# :0 9%&B < 6 0&%0 %$ &E # C D#&%# :% & %&##:&B#D #+,#+ + /
+./ )) 0B )..,$ &6 L#"0 & & = & &B% #&/ 0 &E 0B# # = D&#:# D#&%# :%/ #&&9#: #& #$>& )-.0A $ # # : &0B6 0#& ## < D 0"# " #/
++/ ##&),E%#)..-$ ! 0#& ##&D &# #&& #/
" > &# #& & # &9&0 = &#/ &$&# & %# %:B# #& D &# #&/
D #@#0# # =+0" 0B;:$ $ 0 #( # / D4$0B;: # # = +0 " & 0 & 40 = & #/ D# :# 0B;: # & D " # = + 0/ &0& #9$D &# #&%# C /
+)/ & A 0 )..- #B 0## #9$ &622##& && ##&),E%#)..- ! $ F + 9%# )..-$ & = & #& % # 9# /
*-.-*)..- (G*+,(
& # <0B;:64+0 06# 0&E & # / & 9&#$$ # %# &0 &00 # ## #$ &# # <# 6# # % & # % #& "0#/ D4$ # %# E= 0&D"&00$<#%# 9##& ! / # % 0 &E 0& # 9& #%# / # # # &&:0 #0:## % D0& $ & &%&;# ##<D# # &&# 0&#D04 & 9 4 0B;: &E / %6 00 # %# & B B;: # % 0# 0 9F& = 6#40 #9##/ &E %# & 99 &" # #&<#%# % & #&0#0$<#D# &# C &#E&D"#/&E # &99 B# ### #& ( $ # ($0# 00#/
1# #0&#B$ #B 0## #9 %# # < # D # ## " $#9# 9## #& D #+A<#0 # &: #&6#0# &D # @ = &# #& < &# E #9# #& &9&0 B &#/ &E %# #0 & 99 D0#& D D #& /
+A/ +8%#)..-$&6L#"0& && E & =&9#0 #&##& ! %# 9# /
B $## :0 %&% ! 5 0 & 40 &E #%# & # #0# 0&%&<# "&04"&#<P& #&# S #0 #$ %&# %#0 # & D&: & # # :% = D"0&# D0B #% &# %#& P #0# &# % = D # G@ # ) > # /
D #& ##& %# C &9#0 #B 0## #9$ 9# < D &# #& %# # = & %&# & $ <# D "# D %# ##40 :%/ & #& 0 D& )-.0T # C D#&%# :%&%&##:/## #2# E&&%B0##00 =#&"# "E&/$ %# C =D#0"#" # ##0& / # &BB < 0"# #& D : 99# & &622##/ ##$0#&& #& %# C & &0B#0 #/
*-.-*)..- (?*+,(
+,/ )+%#)..-$ 0 &=>0##&&/
0 & 40 &E 0# +0 " )A0 &:/ %# 9& #& B# # <# &# # = & # 0B#0 <# # # &#/#0#&$ # #& 9& #&$0%# C &#&00&BE D#0& / &<$D # B# # <D# %# # # <C & & / # #& E# #B 0## #9 E D # G? $ # D 0&# +0 #0# &# D D6 A.U # &# #& &#$ <# # D4/
" # &&# =&9#: #& #(#/ # 9&0# :4 :#4$# & #&0#0/&#&$&E # &9&0=D #@&$= & 0&#$ &## &: #& D # +A 0C0 &#/ 0 &O &E # = &" &9#: #& # # #& < & %# # # 9%&B$#&%# D &#&E 0/
+-/ @&%0B)..-$E::=D# #&&= & #/
&#&$ # & < # # 9&0 D# % &##%6/9 0 &%# =G0-.D&# 9& 0 = ,0 D&# % #(#/ 0 &E # +0 #% &$ & 9# E&# & #% 0%B$ #&6L#"0 & B#&622##/#99" # %#&" >"&00/
# <D# 9# %#& )? 0#& +.0T & # 0B# <D#0 # & %# C 0: & & E<D=D&# %/
# &6 L#"0$ & 00 # B& ## #% #9#$ & &%# %&#$ &# &6 22##$ 9# 0 / &E 0<# %##< &# 0#&<# &%# &# (= &6 22##/ % # # " B6# / 0 #<D"#&# C 0: 0#4 &9&0 = &# M # &6 22##/ M 0 #< 6 $ 0 #% D #< #:# +0+)/ "# # = D# # &# &6 L#"0 # &0& DB = 9# </ (# ##0# 2(("
*-.-*)..- (8*+,(
B& ##%#%#&622##/# #%0#%#&6L#"0$#;%# % B #0# # #&622##% %#/ # # % )0 & &6 22##$ % :&&6L#"0/
+G/ A E%# )..G$ &6 L#"0 & 9# &B% #& # & / % &%6 0:0 %$ %&## # % &: ##$ 2(( " 0#$ ## < &/ #% # # % & #% ## #P % # B #0# &# /
+?/ +8 E%# )..G$ &6 22## & & = & &B% #&/ D&#:#$ #0& # :#4# # $#& %# 6% #&$E & 0 /
9# < # # :0 # #& (& $ #&6L#"0 # B#B</# D:# %##%D # # :/D:## & D&B40#%#%&##:/$"#&%# C 0: 0#4&9&0=&#/
+8/ 1<&#$ :=E:/
(
+/ E 0 # % E## #& &0 $ & %B3 /-G &#>&:# #&E###))&%0B+@,+( ( ).-P /GA/+# /&#&0## #%+) 0B+@8-( ( -+.7/
)/ # #:& & #&>0 >0:0 >0B# # $ # 2& & #& - 2& & #&#%P&0#$9# $=#&# #& ##4/
A/ &%# 0##>60#< #&& "&## 0 & #% > &# #&$ &9#0 ! 0#& # #0/
/ 1&> #A#? $ 0 # & 0 > &# #& #% = %6 & 0	# #&# #>BQ #0 6# &0	# > :
*-.-*)..- (@*+,(
#(#/ & :0 C & & #&&%>#0& &&%#///7/$ 0> B#J 0 &=&## %#&00/> &# #& $& $B#/
B/ #B9$E#$#0#0 %6 0B;:&0 =# #&&0#= &# #& & =& #&3 C #B9+ /??*)..A+8E# )..A 9 # P / V JJ $ $ '( $ 0:0 # &#$& #&$6&# #&$)..+$/)+8()+@7/
># #&9# 0 &0 > &# #&# 0& 40 0B#=&$&:#% & #& >#0& $ >S B# # &0 & 00 >#0 # &E > :/& $ &# # & %: B# #& > &# #&$ ! ; & &0 &#%# &00##& >"# #B & P 0 < # #0 & &00 / # & 9# %&# >0B:0 &/&E ## # # & & <# 0# : # &99 :# 60## /
,/ & &" = ! 0%# # #& #&# #�# #%/
/ B & : #% 2& #B %&##$ # #&0B # #&6& #&<#% C #:#04 =& :/
B/ " 0B;:$ $ 0 #0# =04 ( # / 0:0 & 0#& <># & # = %: #& B& 3 / @ 7/ & 9&#$ # #& E #9# < 0& # B : &#%# &#$ 0 &: 6 # G = ++ 4 & #&&00$ !1$" %#9&C $ & #& ;: &00##& & #% #%# B#&&:#<3 /+A7/
/ 1& E# B# B#$ #B &B% # & %# B # & # #& = # %# & < > &# #9# #% >%# (#
3 *-G.*)..,))E#)..,P *-8-*+@@G+-& &B+@@G C # 7/
*-.-*)..- (+.*+,(
&< & #& !1 #0& &#$ & %#$ 0# = >&#& > &E & $ %C 4 &
3 *+?8*)..--%#)..-P *-.-*)..,8E#)..,P *+A.*+@@@ )0+@@@P *,8)*+@@-)G 0B+@@-7/
&< ! > %#$ #B 0## #9 %&# #B0 ># #& & #& E##< # 0#$ 0# & M&:>64 >B&%&#>6##B ># #& >0## #&$ 0 > ## && #&# 90:%#9%&B$ ># C B# >& &# > &# #& 0: %# 9%&B
3 *G@*)..A,9%#)..A C # 7/
>4$ %# !1 # 9%&B &E 0# ! > / &<$ #B %&# #B0 ># #&#&# #&:%##(/
# #%: < = " 0B;: % #& &# 0$ &# W # W/ & & $ # &# &0 &00 # 6# % & #&0#0$> (=(# & ##>% E<>B/!#=$0 0B#<># & & " >04 06#00/ > <#>& # &0 0 " # & #&0#0< 0B# # " +0=)0?./
&0 9# < 0 6# &# C &#$ % " $ &00 & # 6 #&# #& : %#: 4 & #&$ # E #9#$ >4$ &0 # #& 6# &0" 06#0 &#B/
> $0#0 &%#S &&% &%0>" #9#/> $&% 9&0 <# &% & # & ## = 00 /9 9#0 :0 #&0 9# <>= >% %# & :#0 %$ & #%0 # $ &0 #0#&/
&< $ &E &# C &# &00 &9&0 = > # @ &0#&# /
-/ = 60# 0# #99 :#9 &% = >& > &# #&/
%&###%&< %#& #& #&&6#0# 0&E %#0# /
*-.-*)..- (++*+,(
& #& % C #9# &$ = #0# 6&# 3 /G?/+ 7/# & #& #0# &# C #9#=G03 /G@/) 7/
%"$& #&>#0& % C #9#= #0# &# & = # #9# = % = > # G@ &# #&9#64:0 3 /G8 7/
#0# &# $#% # &# C 0# : +0/ = +0$ 0:0 6 # &#% >## = ># # > #: &B#< 9&0 : A.U % >"& 3 /,G 7/
&< $ 0< %=,0 #0# $%&$ 6#:: :0 #/
G/ %&##&" :0 =>0:0 &E 0 #&#<#0 %#0 &%&< "0 #/
#&# %# ; "4/ & #$&E &0#&%#=&00##&>"# %## B# <#& %#9%&B/
$ ; 40 # $ &# # & &B$ & % &# #%#$ # B# & #& # #&3 /+)) 7/
?/ # #0 & %& &" >& " #< "&#< = >& > &# #&/
0 # # & > &# < & % 0	# #& & & #&<#$#0#&$# #&&& 6 ### 4&=># C >< #$>&>"0#$ ># &&# %#BB#3 /+-/+ 7/ ##& 0 9& & 00 %# &00##& >"# &$ & &BE <# & & & $ # !1/ # &0 :0 $" $60#&00& %#&0 0 3 /+-/) 7/
>4$ &E > & # <>= %# &# #9 & &B% #& :0 > %& 6(#/ &<$ :#9&%=>& > &# #&& 09&/
*-.-*)..- (+)*+,(
8/ :#9&%%&##& %#& #&# #0# $ <## >%0 % %#$% <>C :0 / 99 $#>:# & < #&& %&##: % &# #%$ & >60 < #B > &0 /
@/ J#0 $&6L#"0#%&< %#& #&> #+, #&#&%# :%&%&##:&%&< & / >6 #& " # # #B # #0& /
/ 0 9 &# #& % = D # + &<D & #& & # #& C D#&%# :%&:$%&##:&B#3 /+,# / 7$0# &# #& # B# <D6#: & 6&# #& & & ## #& 3 / B7$ 0# &# #& # & B# 99# =D:%&##&B#3 /7&&$&99: ##3 /7/
B/ #&# #& & & #0# #& < # #% #D& & &&0#:&# 9
3 J++?B+-?P++AB)).7/ &% & 9&# & 0 &O = & ; # &#
3 *G)@*)..A)G&X )..A 9# 7/
/ 1&E#& #B0## #9$D #+, 9# # &0 & #& # = %: ## "<2&$&"#B #&%# #&0 #B% 4D 2& 0#/ %# 0# "9 = & : D# C %&##
3 *++A*)..,A9%#)..,7/
D #+, %###&## & #&& D# #&&E (0C0 &&%&<0&# # #&/ ##$ #B 9 E: <D# > # B# # &# < #&%# # = D6 #& D " #$ & 00 # #& <# # $ D # # :%$ # B 0C0 #$ #% #& $ # &%# C & 0&# #B & %&##$ ## " " #$ < # & 9&# 0 C #B9+/-A.*)..)A9%#)..A&9#0 D *,,?*)..))?&X )..)7/
&<$:#9# #9&/
*-.-*)..- (+A*+,(
+./ % 0 # $ # ; # &9#0 > &# #& & # #% 0 $ &E & #& &9&0 6#&# #&:#B/
<# 4 < & 0# ##& &00##&&/
++/ ># # #:$ 0&0 &$ KJ )D.../($ 0#=":# #0$#&E&# 0 &##0 $=D6 #& &00##& & & 0 #4 & #& 0 $#; &=D0##&&/#0# &)>.../(&6& $=":0C0# #0$ #&E&# 0 &##0 3 /8? 7/
YYYYY
' (
0.1#$ 2
%B & # E A 0 )..- !0 1 !&#(# 22## & ##& &00##& & &0 #4& #&),E%#)..-P
1#2
>0 P
##&&00##& &&0 #4& #&P
B# > &# #&& ##%+,0#)..,P
0 0&0 KJ )>.../( = ": !0 !&# K L#"0$#&E&# 0 &##0 P
&6& #0# KJ)>.../(=":0C0# #0# &E&# 0 &##0 P
*-.-*)..- (+,*+,(
&00#< C = ! "# # "$ %& &6 22##$ = ! '% &$ %& &6 L#"0$ ## <>= &00##& & & 0 #4 & #& 0 & #& "&&:#>#9&0 #&/
1#: 5 !/;"4$# $!0&%;$!0K#$!/ "#$!0&$ E:/
&0 #B0## #95
:99#4(E# 5 # 5 /#&(1#:# J/;"4
&#&9&0 C &00#<6 #/
4%$ :99#45
*-.-*)..-