Judicial Review of Agency Interpretation of Public Service Obligation Statute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe plaintiff brought suit seeking judicial review of a decision by an administrative agency concerning the interpretation and application of a regulation regarding public service obligations, specifically alleging the agency erred in its interpretation of statutory language governing the scope of such obligations and the calculation of associated costs. The court reasoned that the agency's interpretation, while deferentially considered under the applicable standard, was plainly contrary to the clear and unambiguous meaning of the statutory text and was therefore unreasonable, resulting in the reversal of the agency's determination and a remand for further proceedings consistent with the court's reading of the statute.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Judicial Review of Agency Interpretation of Public Service Obligation Statute: The court reasoned that the agency's interpretation, while deferentially considered under the applicable standard, was plainly contrary to the clear and unambiguous meaning of the statutory text and was therefore unreasonable, resulting in the reversal of the agency's determination and a remand for further proceedings consistent with the court's reading of the statute.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for ordering the appellant to pay the procedural costs.
Testo completo
!
"# $ %&'
'$ ! ((((((
) * )) ++ )) ) *, +
!"#
)
() *(+#&,-. //////0. 123-) //////4 5...* 6 78.) 9 28 1:. ;:: 11<.=8.0. 123 4)
..>15..*=.,?..***.8* !$ *5< (+@A, > 1 >** B . *<. 1 8.5<.8.=.0. 1237 4)
!) !! C. !''%, 1 DD , ?>. <.?. B =;, 8 <8 5 EFG .. ;1,8><51G,-) //////;* 1.* ==* 1= 1*=*) . *. <**:. 1; 8 :9 .., 55 -) //////, .= .= ..? :. 9 ?>. 8. :. 18 > 11..2) 128.**1..*B1.*,.>8.1 8)
:.5H8:.=>=-) //////< >*8.1.*,1=2<>*=25<*BI) . I 8*;., 8. 8 * 1..* B =1 181.8B:.<8.)
$) ((J!''%,7 .8.*>.**B:.=.>I ,?. .5.:1)
&) *..%15<!''%,7 .*15..B -) ////// 1 * . 5., 5.: 1. 55.. > .:. =8 9 2= .. .2) 51 <. 1:. >.** < **, 5 *.* 1
7 >*.15..55*=)
%) #<!''%,-) //////*..%15< !''%) 1. ;? C 1. . K.52 :. .,.8..?>:=8.*5G ..15..1*>5.5)
#) & 85< !''%, 1. ** . 51.13
) 7 8 1* 1*, -) ////// . *5. 51.1*5...855*1 1*) 8.. 5. 1 1 1. (+@A
"$%&!"!''% $"#
9 1. 9 5.) >8. C5. :. ><C > 5 5...8.7..E)-.*129: .*, . 8. 55 55 ;= 9 51, > 1 115 > 1 8*;. 1) 7. 5 5...8 8. I :.5*, . . 1 ..*, 5. <.. *. . 6E#'') 5..5515.)
<) B1*>.*..5*,**1. *..1.,8..?.8..51.?*1.*1= *.*) >.>.,.<1*1. 11.. >. (& . 1* 5...8 (! 15<(+@%0 %'%4)
A) (@C.!''#,.<1.*>.:5. 1*1*)
!AC.!''#,-) //////*1?>.8.*>5?. .8.**.:.=*(@C.!''#)
@) !(85<!''#, -) //////.:5*.<?>.8..* 11..B>5)
+) !A 85< !''#, .< .:5* 1. ? *. =*BC=)
) +
() C* 51 . 8 C... 51*, 8<0)%# .L=..C...!!85<(+&( !'%M)#$)().1*5...8(! 15<(+@% %('4)
!) ;:: 1:. 51G* 1 1. 1<.? ;=* 11,11*8.<.1:. .51, ?. ** 1 >.* ..5*, ? I* 5..55*=*5*)
75..=.?.8..55. :=8>.(#.*15..:** .. .2 (+ *5< (+%@ 0 7 A&()'(4, C.:. . > * . 5. >.* ! .1.. 1*.* >. 8. . ?> .:. 5G5 =8 >. (#< .* 15. , 8 ?.:..
"$%&!"!''% &"#
.B1?>.>*>5.>. (#<.*! )
$) >.$$ ,>8*;.5<.. :.. 9 1.* 8* ;* . 8 1 1..281=*8*B.) <.,..>I 1.1..*,?>.>G8*CB>G==)
91.*9 5I5,11..>.&+.*! , .<**:..1..*1=11.*,N5..81 >GB>.518.O)
:. ? 1.* 8* *. *CB =5 ==* 1=, ?> . . 1; >G I *B>.518.)**8:..1*1..* B =1 1.* 8 ; 1 .* ?>. >8. 1 5?*) 8. .:., B 5. 1.5, 8. 1..1?...5<11..>.$$ )
&) 7C.1.<*,:1..*B 1.* ?.:.* : =8 0 "(!+"!''# A 5 !''# "A("!''#A:*8.!''#,>51.8.4)
51 . >.:. ** *,.<1I5*1:.B*.* 5 . 5..55 *=, < *.. 7
0 "&&"!''#!&C8.!''#4)120 "%@!"!''&#C. !''&4,.<*?.:.*:5G5=8. :.3 8. ** =I* 1 =* 8*;. 9 .* PB 1= *.* ? 1 . ;M . .. 1 .B8.*.)
C>;...=.9,**1..*B =11.*1.8.B8.*.)1. 1;>8.8.*8.1)
:.B1I.:B1*>1.*.*. I .8.* = 515 C 8 ;) .<,:?>.55.5.=8?>:=** 1..*) 1I..?.:.*5G5=8)
%) 51 <. 1:., 9 ** . *.,*.15..5* B5.11..>.(#<.*15...?>.*! )
"$%&!"!''% %"#
#) 8.1*>5.15. .>*>9*15.)<...=.> 1B>?.:.1*,?.5.B;=>.* ..5*B. 6E&'') ) ,..B.5.* 1*>5 6E$'') B;=> 0)@A 4)
QQQQQ
- )+ )
./0'!# 1
*8<.C*#<!''%1-. ////// *..8.5<.8.=.%15<!''%.. 15..1*.5.M
0'1
>5M
*.*.15..B5.M
:.5*..?*11M
5B;=>..5**55 6E&'') M
,B;=> ,.5.*1* 6E$'') M
. ?, :5*5 9 . @! .8 . :** .< :** (A C. !''% 0 E 7 (A$)(('4, 1* I 1 I 1* C ?. .8 .:.. 1 8 .< :**, 1 8. 5.2.1<.M5*5....?., 5.:5G181.=5.M. . I * .< :**, (''' (&, 1 8. 1 1 8. *.? 9 .. L. &! E) 1* I 1.2 1. , .8?* 55 5G 18, .8 I C. B L8.M
55.?1*IB-. //////..?L8.5<. 8.=.BL::.:**B)
7.*=3 -58G,1*.,--)G;2 ;*.,C=)
"$%&!"!''% #"#
5 .<5...:3
*. C.3 8. 1*.3 7)6R F )8G
1.:5I**55.?*91.)
28, =::.23
"$%&!"!''%