Breach of Contract - Conditions Precedent
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute arose from a transaction where one party claimed the other failed to fulfill its obligations, resulting in damages, which the defendant countered with arguments regarding the interpretation of the agreement's terms and certain conditions precedent. The court reasoned that the contract clearly stipulated certain requirements for performance and that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that these conditions were either met or justifiably excused, ultimately concluding that the evidence supported the defendant's position regarding the lack of breach.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Breach of Contract - Conditions Precedent: The court reasoned that the contract clearly stipulated certain requirements for performance and that the plaintiff had not demonstrated that these conditions were either met or justifiably excused, ultimately concluding that the evidence supported the defendant's position regarding the lack of breach.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the allocation of costs for the appeal.
Cited for the decision regarding legal aid for the appeal.
Testo completo
!
" #$ %% %&' !( !! )* ! "!#"$%#
#
+))+) +) , +) +)
- +) +) +#))* .) )
" /'0 %1 %&' ! % ! # ! &" "'()&$%#
*+,--*
-1 !2 "3 & !#" "& 4"*5 6 #7 "& 8# #" "9:-/:$;":/#22 &<71
' $" =#.# "#$ ")%" ## ")>?-@$&2"# *#"1
+1 AB +: # #3 +00/$ #7 "& # #"" 2 # "# &##)" ?";#2 "#$ "2 2 ?2)2 $?A"2 #)2 4"*56 # 2 8 %#" # )" # ++?:.C$ #" "## "# ?)"2 %"1
/1 # %" "" # #" "# " ;%#3$ # 22 "#22-23+00/1
:1 ;") "# ;";">+0D$#7"& # ";"$ +C 2" +00:$ ))2 # A ; $#" #:0EC :0E@$ " " "%2 -:$C0 CE$+.2+#;" 9:-/:1" ))2 ;" ?#3F ?# "#)" ;#"1
.1 ""#GF"+00:$3"H"?%"#;;""4H 8 -:2B22#"$ "%? #" "##"" 1
E1 @ F" +00:$ !2 I) !#" *" )"$ #" "?%#""$9:-/.$;":/#22 &<7 # # # " #" "# 5 #22""# # # 2 "5 # "# 4"*56 #22""#8 # > # "#1
?2 #F $ ? " > # A # %" "%"1 "*"$ # #%#" B #"$ " " > # 2#" #) "#7" 7"2" 1"#" "# "EC "% #" # "# " "# "% -: %" -G@@ 4 * . 0.8$ # # "# "2" #" $ ? " 2"1 "%#A" ;" %"# "# " -: -. # " #% A "# # ;+0D1
C1 #7"& # ;" #3% "##+/#J +00:1
,./+,+00. */,--*
@1 ""#+:F%"+00.$#22""#F ##7 )"1
?) # " ;" 2 ;# 5 # A #F %?7 ";"" A?3"#2B2 #" %"#)+$.025 # %K 2B2#) 2 %" )? #)C25 1? "EC ? " "3 7 # "# # # ")1 ?)"2 #F " # ;" 2 #;#2 7 "#" "# 1 ;"$ ? #" "# ?)" "#%" # " )% # %#"")1
G1 C 2 +00.$ #7 )" # # *% "3 2"" "; > ?# ""#1 # ? " " @F" +00:$"# ># "#$>""# G F" +00: "" A? %2 ? A" 3 "2" #1
%" # A # "# %") #7 "& #" 7?# "#)2 ">+0DA? " %")3 A?5 # "# #22 #22""# ?&" >#" "#A?"#" #2 "3% 5$?&2#" ?2)2 A "$A"? " 2"; 2 ?51
-01 /0 2 +00.$ #7 "& # ## # # # %2 ?A" 3"2" #1
? " > F " A 2 %" " 2 #5#A %7#F 2#";"" 2 ? ) 3L "2 1 7 "#" "# "% 7 " # 7 "2" #" "%#A # $ ?"A" 7 # "# 2" #(1 ;"$ # #%" " "#%") "-: -. 1
--1 2 ;" #3% "#@%"+00.$; #" #" )";"%#A# 1
-+1 +G%"+00.$ "32"" ";#> # "1 #"# 5 %"" %" #7 "& )"$2 "% # # 6
* %"#7"& #2# " 7"%76"%"$ #%" B %+$.025 " " "*" ");K%13#% >2) " "2M
,./+,+00. *:,--*
* " 3#$ # %#(" F" #7 )"1 7 #" " &" ?3 3 "" A < 1 ) &( " ? < < $ &= #7 )"$ ")" "A2 #" %" 2B&" # %;K%" %#"""? ;B # "3##7"& M
* '## " 7" 1
-/1 / +0F"+00:$AB F))$ "# %> #F&# #)&"%" "%1
# #);; "3$-G#J +0 23$ "%2 +- 23 +00. # 2 $ " 5 AB 1 7 2 "5$ #7 )" # )$ # 2"5;#"% "3$%"# "#? "-.#" 7.F" -GE-4 7*+0.82# ";A?# "#$ #*#A?% "#$#%" B ";">" 2#" /025 "2" #?H##$;#) "#71
-:1 +/ 23+00.$ "# ";#2A " ) >F)1
)
-1 F 2 " % F"" "# #2 $ # %34 1.E #"?#)" "#F"""++#%23-G:-* * +0.M 1E/1-" 1#"#2"" "%-+ 23-G@.* * .-081
+1 1 ? " / " C $ 2 " #2? #" "# "%> %7$#2"> ? "2"$# 2#";" "#" "?3L "2 7" # 2#";" ? ) "*"1 # )2 B ## "##%?"2# # #%"#" 4N81 $ 2 ? 3" H 2 #>#"" %"#221
31 ? #" "# # 4 8 " #" 2#";" "# )" "% -@ 23 -G@C1 A?#$ # 2 ? #" "## " " #2">#%>? "/ $ # A" ? " % "%2 # # %7 2"$ A 2#";" "# AA )) > ?" " ? "223$ 22 #" ? 3L "2 $ %7 ;K$ # "# ?"2# A 2 $ # "$ F# "# ? &2"$ 1
4 ,/EC,+00/-/2"+00/81#" " "#" ";" $
,./+,+00. *.,--*
2#";" "##?"2#" $? A 2 "" 2" "$ # " %7$ # ;"" 1 # %" # 2 #) #" # "# &) %"1 ? # 7 A? 3# #F #" 2 2#";"#? #" "# #2 # 4 8$ "3 7 2 ? #" "# # " # %7 ?"2# # 2#";" ? ) ? 3L "2 7" 1 # "# O %7 ?"2# P%" ?(# >? "- A&" %7"24 "$ 181 %7 #"2# A)" " 3""2" ? >#3F ?"2# $ #" "2 > #F 2#";" "# " " ? 3L "2 #& " ;K # ? & "A 3L "2 # # " "# 4!2#" #" -0 23 -G@C$ 1 EGC- $ # 22 EGC+$EGCG81
1 '# F"$ )"2 #" #22 ?"2# #A " "# ?#%) "&) A 2#";" "# # > ? 7 "* "$ ;#2$ ## "# #)" "#" *?" 5) #)"A2 $7(7?#3% $ 3L "2 ?;; "#=#1 %7#"% %#"#;; #%)?( # %?"223 "2" "; 4 2 ; F " #" 4H8,;;" ; ?2)2 " #" 4H 8$ "% > #" ; ?2)2 " #" -G@-$ # /+$ 1 +G.$ +GE8M " # ?)" A ?)"2 ?"2# #" 4 H -0@ 3 /E-8$ #? "?" " 3L "2 1
#" "# B #" #22 2"$ # 22 # # "# ? )) > 2"# ?&3" "# # # )5 )2 "# ; ""3 ? 3L "2 $ A ?F# "# ? " 71 %&$ ? $ #A ?7 "# ? ; ""3#;; 2#";""32 "2"##? 7 " 3L "2 $ #22 ? # ?)"2 ? 7#" "# # % " 3L "2 7" # # "# ? ) 2 "1 ""$ "3;F)A?)"2 ? " %"# ? ? " 2#" "2# 4 H -0C 3 +:+ #"1+381 B $"#"A?)"2 ?%"#-.0 2/4C/2+8?3L "2 G-02/;7" +002+$? " # ?"2# 4Q1 -G@: 1 C@ 81 ;"$ " F) A "# ? "5 -C 2+$ ;A ? 7% "# "#"?;EG2+#$ " 3 3" # "# #% # ;#2 "# "1 "3 ; # 2 " #2 ?)"2 #F *"" # "
,./+,+00. *E,--*
+:$ED*2"" ;"#"3# 4 H --+3G:81
1 "32"" ";A >"#"A %7#" % "#C. "25 ?3L "2 %")#"=#:# ) ? " ?"2# # A$ ;")$ #" B "%"4 ,/0+,+000-E2"+00081? %& 2" # "# ? F" ?&"% ? ; -G$+. 2+ # 3L "2 "" ? 2"# ?&3" "# .+ 2+ # ;#2 ?7 2" ? 3 2"# # ")R 4 ,/C,+00. +. F%"+00.81
?5$ " "2 #&" )" %" 2 --. 2+ ;" #%#" "# ? ; 2 " +/ 2+1 ?)"2 #F 3"#2B2 #" %" #)+$.025 # %K 2B2#)2 %" ) ? # ) C 25 1 &2 ? % $ ) $ ?)"2 ?" ) ;" 2 3L "2 ""1# ;""5%>#$A;K 3#) < *# 3L "2 $ )2 2A %) "# " # 1 #F #%" "" ;" 2 B " #;#2? $##"?51
;"$ "3 5% A ?)"2 %") #;#2 > =# . #""$ 2#"O "3P A =# : # )$ A?" ?" #" > 3L " " "2 1 $ # # ;"%#"?23)2 #1 #F "" " " # # A" 2 " ) "#;; )" 72"" # #227") ?2)2 " #"1
/1 7"52 2$# ;# )"; 2 ?%#" %"#? "EC 2# ";A?)"2 #F " " 7"2" #" 1
1 "#" "#$ # "# % B ";" #$ > "2" 7 #" "%1 2 #" *"$ #A # "# # ";" # # ")4 1EC1+" 3 81
31 # # ")$ ?";" "# + 2"# 2#"$ " 2 2" #( # # "# ?"2# "# &##5"*"4 1.@1+ 81
,./+,+00. *C,--*
?5$ #F " ")"7 %" ?)"2 # ?"2 "# ? #% 3L "2 1 $ " # "5 % > #A%"#7)" "& # ";"## ") A # " #A " "# A" # 3L "2 #"1##)2 " ")"7A"#22" #(") "2" #" #23""##? "EC"+ 1 #" ? 3#"$ #22 23 # " # A ?)"2 #F #"%%#""$# ")S $"# A # "# #" "2""1 " "#2 %"" > 2B& # #&2 7 %"$ # ;A #F # "### ")1 ;"$# "2 > A" 72 % :52 =# 4 1 // 8$ ?# %#"" ? ".52=#$#A?# "#"2" #" "B #"1!;#$)";#" B F 1
:1 # # " " A # "# #F )B#"3"A$% ?"2 "2" %23#).>E25 & $#"# ?#"2 %1 ;"$ ?)"2 " 2"; 2 " & "A1
.1 1 '#? "-:"- $" " O" 3" P$ 2 ; #" "# #A? # "# # " "# B ?"#%" )% # )$ %#"") # 3"1 ? #" F#" ? "3 ?" "# A" ? "2" A?75#?3#%#"4 ,-C+,+00:+2+00:81
31 # "#?"#%" )% #2F""A" 2"A" #" B " 1 #22 2 "5 #) "#$ 2 "# ? "#%#"?" "#1 #" ##"% ?"2# " ?" %" A " "# #T 2 " " )" #" "# # ;# #3F "%2 $ )53 %#"4 ,G@-,+00:+-23 +00:81
1 '#F" "3;$? "-: $?#3 ?2B& # # "#$=#>3L "$A"" ;; " "##3"*B %#""4 B "3;-1./0,+00+/ ;%"+00/#"1.81
)" "#)%#" 2 2 "5 ?#"2 1 "3 2"" "; F) # ?) ? " -: $ A? )5 ?#"2 >?";" "#?" "%;#2 73#""$" ?& -$@0>-$G.25 #) -/ 25 $ #" % "# ? 3L "2 -$.0 25 $
,./+,+00. *@,--*
# " " "#%" )% 4 ,G@-,+00:" M ,-/0,-GGG +2-GGG81
?5$ " # #" A ?)"2 #F "# # #" & $ "%" > " ?&3" "# %#"" ?&?#"2 $"2B2A?"))%" "32 " "# # $#" # " "#%" )% A;"""*1 #22 ? > F " % #22""#$ "# ?"2 "# %"$ #" #*$ ?)"2 " ")"7 ? ;; ?#"2 " ? 7 2"5 & 2 "$ # " A?" %"2 5 &" 3 ?#2 # $"2" #" 1!;#$)"; F 1
E1 1 ? "-. 2 " "#? #"A # % 2#";" "#$ # # "# A"$ "2"#$ " "### 7 """ 5#>?" B ?A "$ ? # ? &2"$ ? " # #" % "3 3"41-81""# 2 ;## 22 %" #22""#?&" #$##3F A"# ## $" #22""# 2#2 $ " M " #2 )2 $ & $ 7 2" #22 # %" #2 2 41+81
"#" "# ) ;2 ? & "A$ # F" "3"A?# " # "#F""A " 2"$" "#%#"?" "#>?2"" "#$* " ? "2" A ?75 # ?3 #%#" ?" "#
4 ,E0G,+00:.#J +00:M ,.G,+00:+0F%"+00:M 1' $ " #" 2"" ";$&L $-G@:$1//+*///M1U $" #" 2"" ";$ L H;# ***!"$ -GG-$ 1 /:*/E$ 9 -E0*-EG81 ( 52 $%"#%"#22$ 2 #)"2 " ?# A? 5 # ";$ ; "#" "# # " 7#"1#A?%" #3") #"$"#%" 2""2"4 ,E0G,+00:" 81
31 &A ;#" A ? #" 2"" "% " %" #22""# # "%$ ? #" # #" ?"2# " $ ;# "# # " > & " ") 4 ,-+G,+00/ -- 2 +00/M 1 $ " B % F) 2"" "; " 1*1 1 ! $ )#3 " B $ #" ?%"#2 2)2 " #"$ L H;# ***!"$ -GGE$ 1 +0-81 #" #"2" >72"" 2 ? 2# "; # J2 3" %" ? #" &"A # "%$#2#"" 1
,./+,+00. *G,--*
?5$ ?23 %" "" " ;%#3 #F 1 " # ;; ?3" < F" # 2B2 $ #" " #+$.025 1? )%" " "A ?"2B2#" >3L "1
%A"5$ "32"" ";$?"2# %A" ""#232 "5? & "A# "#$ A# A? #" ?)"2 " ")"7$ ? " 3 # #%#" ?" "#$ " 7 "*"1 ? "" > F " A #22""# #;"2? #" "## )";# #" B F 1
C1 ;"$ #7 )" "%#A %"# "# ? " .G $ #" A?2#" ""%O))P O23F"P %"" "2" JB "#2 # ;1
@1 1 "A"52=#$;# "#$7"225 &$#" 7+0D;1; & " #" "# # ;$ " ; ;3 & # " # "#&#*#4 1 .G1- + 81
31 #A "# F ";" A 2 #2 "3 % 5$ ?&2#" ?2)2 A "$ 2 # > #" "# # ;$ ; & #23$ #A %" ? ) ";" > +$:0
25 # "%";V "54 1.G1/ 1 8$# #A#23# ?"2# $"22 %"? ) 4 1.G1/ 13 8$#;))"2"#2# 4 1.G 1 / 1 81 # "# ?"2# # " #" "#4 1.G1C 81
1 #7# & #%#"%)# F % %">?&3" "#4 1CE1- 81
G1 "3 2"" "; #V #%#" ?" "# 2 $A" ## " ? ".G"-$ / : #)7"")7#TO"# F ";" P #T #2 "3 % 5$ ?&2#" ?2)2 A " 4 ,C@@,-GGC +/ 23 -GGC ; " 81"#23 # ;#">?2"" "#$#2#%#"$# &A > #") " B 1 "# ;%#3 > #) "# # "2# $ 2 #" ;" % 1 #%" # 22 ;" " "# #%#"
,./+,+00. *-0,--*
"%%""?)" " 2 4"U $" #" 2"" ";$L-GG-$1/.9-E.81
-01 ?5$ 2 W# ; -G$C0 D1 # " " #) "# ?;; "# ? #"31 ) $# "2 >A# " # $ # " " $ )) #*#$ ? " #X)23F"$#" #&? 2""% %"172"# 2"; 2 "&3" 3A #""52$" # 5 > ; " ;"" "# "*1 ?7" ;B 7 "5 " " % 2 " # "#6 #*#$ # &;; " =# &2";" #7"2" H##$"5# "2#>?&3" "#1 ;"$ 7 A" 5 ? % " ?7" ?&23>#&1" "2# 7"AA?"?)"" "# 7 " > 2=# A "3 # # # 1
--1 " "$ )"; # "; > " H## 1 # " #"7 $ #" % ? %") 7$%"" "2& ;; 7 " "## #" 4 1-.1E 781
-+1 "52 2;#$# F 12#2 IH-?.001* 2" > &) # A" #23 1 "2" IH-?.001*#7" "2$>&)#7)"4 1@C 81 YYYYY
+ )
2/3&!" 4
%3#" F C2+00.!2I) !#" *")"# ""##22""# ##2 "5 # "#+:F%"+00.M
3&4
F M
2 >&)# 2#2 IH-?.001*M
,./+,+00. *--,--*
#"2" IH-?.001*>!2 "3 & !#" "& $> &)# M
#22"A B >! "!#"$%# # $>! &" " '()&$ %# !2 "3 & !#" "& $ "" A?> #22""# # # 2 "5 # "# 2 # "# &##)"?";#2 "#1
'") 6 !2#%($" $!1(&5$!2I"$!1 &"$!2#$ F)1
#2 "32"" ";6
);;"5*F" F16 %"*" 6 !1 ##" 1#%(
#"#;#2 B #22"A7 "1
5%$ );;"56
,./+,+00.