Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/283/2007 • CJ GE ATA/283/2007 Generato dall'IA

Creditor's Right to Apply Payments to Interest Before Principal in Debt Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATA/283/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case involves a dispute over the payment of an alleged debt, where the creditor sued the debtor for the principal amount and accrued interest, based on a promissory note and surrounding agreements. The court found that the central issue was whether the debtor's prior payments, though not clearly designated at the time of remittance, were correctly applied by the creditor to the principal balance first, rather than being allocated solely to interest as the debtor contended. Reasoning that general contract law and the specific payment instrument did not mandate the debtor's preferred application, the court determined that in the absence of an explicit directive from the paying party, the creditor was permitted to apply the payments to the interest due before the principal, thereby affirming the remaining debt balance, including accrued interest.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

SANTÉ; DROIT DU PATIENT; PATIENT; PROFESSION SANITAIRE; MÉDECIN; DROIT DISCIPLINAIRE; QUALITÉ POUR RECOURIR; INTÉRÊT ACTUEL; LEX MITIOR; RÉTROACTIVITÉ; PRESCRIPTION; DÉLAI ABSOLU; DÉLAI RELATIF; QUALITÉ POUR RECOURIR; DÉNONCIATEUR; DROIT D'ÊTRE ENTENDU; DOCUMENT INTERNE; CONSULTATION DU DOSSIER; PLAINTE PÉNALE | Plainte d'une patiente pour violation du devoir d'informer du médecin suite à une intervention chirurgicale des yeux qui a donné lieu à de graves complications. Prescription de l'action, analysée sous l'angle de la lex mitior, la patiente ayant attendu plus de cinq ans avant de déposer une plainte administrative auprès du département compétent. | Cst.29 ; CP.70 ; CP.72 ; LS.45 ; LS.46 ; LRMPSP.1 ; LRMPSP.5 ; LNot.55.al2 ; LRMPSP.10.al3 ; LRMPSP.10.al4

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
pagamento di interessi debito principale bilancia dei pagamenti opposizione tardiva delegazione di pagamento diritti e obblighi precontrattuali

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the distribution of court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

       

 

    









  !"#$$$$$$  !"#  $%&" 

" 

%&    '%())     %  *+",-$$$$$$  ! '("%&"



     )*+,*)

 

,1  !(2333333%"(44456&% "5 4478333333 " 9333333%44 :!;"< (""=4%,/>4,???1

*1  =&"(4 4"" 4 &4 5 4 & 4"1

@1  "4  7A A&4     BB4((  4B"(  47 7  4  " 4"%!(2333333"4 "4" ""5A" 9333333%*C(*//@1

-1  *0 (#*//C%"4 " (46   "((44"  &4  "B4"     D4)6 E "((44"F " &4" 4"  &"4 A4B"( 4"    6=  A  D44 "(4 47 "= " 4"G'G5B"4F1

C1  A4  4"    4       A    >=(  1

01   >=(   *- >4  *//0%   9333333    74    4#"41  H  "B4( <(# "> 4%*,(#*//01

I1  6&"444"%"((44"4&" &4 ( A""(4  D4)6E ( "  JF%,- (#*//01

  B4 "!(2333333 (#*//C 4 4 % 47A  " A" 4" K 4 1

.1  44"*,"&(#*//0%<B ( A""(4   D4)6E<B ( F"474 4" 4   4 1

   "&4  A47 5  4   "4   &4=  ("(   " K % "4   "4  AG4  "B4"    %   #4(  (4G 4& 4"(4(4%0(#,?.IDJF% "B"((  5 A 4 @- 4 *   "& "4   "((44"  &4"B4"  "4  4 I&4*//0 D JJ)L@/@F1

  J4 4 4 G"4 4 1(46 4 B" "4" "  ((#"B4"   4   0 (# ,?.I D4)6 E !JF1  &44   "   4"  

+-.,-+*//0 )@+,*)

&4" 4"  "4  = 4 G  4     "4 D A6%  "4  5 A4B"( 4"F1    "% !( 2333333 4"4    74    41 A  "  4  44441  &44  5  #4 4  B  "B4" &4    "((4   5 4B4=  (4%   < %   4"1    "% B"   J% !( 2333333  4"4  74  41

     G46( "%  4 4"  4  74%   47 A  "4A4 & 4"44(41

   B4  6 " "4 7A A 4  =(    (46%  G"  44"#( 41

?1   ,. (# *//0% !( 2333333  4   (   4 ( "4&41

,/1  G>" %7H   (" 4B7"(  4  4 5A(44  4"1

,,1    (# *//0% !( 2333333  " 6  4# (44  4B  44"  *, "&(# *//01  "  #(  5  7&4"((44"4"4 "((47 5"" "" 1  4 44%" 5A 4"44" 57 "4 "  &4" 4"""4 5A4B"( 4"1

  "& "((44"%""4 AH  &4   &4"%(=(G%&4"((44"4&4   "((47%" 7AA&4 ""4&  744""4 41

  " 4( 574B4=4 44" 7%4 " &   "((44" A 4   "(4 G 6= >4 4   4 4"""4444%B"4    !J% 7  4  G"#4   5 "   44441 J"  != "4 '  4B% "44 4 4 "4B47 744BB44 "4444  J1% G 4" "#> 4& > 4B4  A4 4"  6=   4 4"  "4 #4)"4 4 >447 (H<(4 4  4"74"  M"=4")A 4 ""#   A &4" 4"   (4  "4  = 4 G  4    !J1 J  #" B"4  (44  &4  " 4   4(4    (4 "5 4 1

   4%  4  4 4" "((N4  5 "4 "  6 A=4( "B4"4" %"(( 4 "((44"%(4 >""OA "4 &4 "4B 1 B4%>4%

+-.,-+*//0 )-+,*)

4# (44  4B 474   4  4 4" #"   "  4  4B D +*.I+*//0  *@ (4 *//0 P +-.I+*//,  I "Q  *//,   H 4 F1

  B4% (H( 4 A" &4  47  6= >4 4 4 % A 4 5 " 7"((44"&4 "& G 4"A"BB4%"7 9333333A 4 >(4&1

  "7 %4& &4"((44"% ( &4  "((44> 4B"(7A4 4  4#%      4 (    &4" 4"% 44 7  4 ( 4  A 4 0? 4@ 1

,*1  9333333",CB&4*//I1" > "1

  J"  >4  4# B%  4 4"  4   4 4  4" =  "4  74 A474  5 "     4"  "4  #4% 7A 4    & " "1  4BB    G " &J !J 4 47( 574  4 5 74  " "4  4= 1 "   %  " 4&4   (H(6=1

  " 4(  5  7A&N4   " %  4 4" &4  H  "& A"BB4 "  >4% (H( 4 A" "&4  ( %   4%G 4"5 6=%" 4 "A61

  "((A&4 447  ( %4 4"# 4  >""OA 4&4  ( "#&4  G1 A6%(H( 4 4" #"  4  74%  B4  ("   >"A<4 5      (41

,@1  *IB&4*//I% ( "((47"#& 4" " > "1

   A' &4     &4" 4"  "4  AH      &4   "((44" ) 74 A 4  7A "= "  4B )  4   "(  4  5 A(44  4" A&4 "5H  (41

  "   4 4"%  "   "&4  (  "   4"   &4" 4"   "4    4  4  B4  B"   "4444 4 4 %(H((467A""&4  (%"4&4%"   4""#44 AB "7A 4""((=)4 H  4 4 1

   4  4 4" "((N4  #4 5 "4  ("(   A=4( 44(4%"4 >"A4 & 4"1

+-.,-+*//0 )C+,*)

   4 4" &4  H  "& A"BB4 "B"((  5  >41

  B4% (H( 4   4 4" A 4    4 %  "  A&4   A4 H  4=  "  4" 5 "# 4  44" "   "4%  >44 4"' 74 93333331

,-1  J (  4#  ? ( *//I%   (   "  5  "&4"((44",- (#*//01

,C1  4 @/ &4*//I 4( 4G 4" (4 "" 1

,01   "4  *I   @/ &4 *//I% )4 "  447 A&"4  A"#& 4""(( 45B"(1

,I1  4 7"4 =5>=1

 ) 

,1   >   (  4 &   >44 4" "(  %  "   &#   "4   & D 1 C0    4&    "4  A"=4 4" >444"&(#,?-,)) */CP 10@1,4 1"4 "(44  4&,* (#,?.C) ) C,/F1

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

+-.,-+*//0 )0+,*)

   A6%  B4  A   " &   ,  (# *//0%   6>="4"4 4"R4"4 %"& A4 4"G(4 4"%74'4)61

@1   A 4,/4-!J%4= 4"74  ""46 4#(44  4B" 44"4<B  ( 4 7A4"4 4" "41

  &<%44"74 ""4A&  " 4444 "&  A"BB4    (  5 A"   (44 54 %74B"J1

   44" 7     G "4 1  K   " 4444 "&  5 A"    9333333  (" 4B 7  4 4"  4&G 4"4444 741J 7 4"%4 4" >44 %!(2333333A74 ""41

    (  "46  4 7   4 4"  S  B "  4 4"   " B"   !J1 J  "4 %  4 4"A 4,/4-!J%!(23333334"74  ""41

-1   "4   ( 4  "  "&  4 H    5 "4%6"7"B"!J 7 %5 4= G %7A54>" 4"4( 4&" 44D 1,/1@ 4 B4 !JF1 " B"4% "  >4% "7   4>" 4" A %"((A6%7A 44(45>5"4  " BB %"  ("   4"&4" 4""4   4  D +0-.+*//-  *- "Q  *//- P +C/I+*//-  . >4 *//- "41,P +C?-+*//,*C (#*//,"41,F1

C1   "4"  "   4"   "  "  " &#   )44""A4 H  5"4 "1

01   4% A  5 >  4  7   4  "     7  44"  #4   4  A "4  "(  %   #  &4  A4 "((44"  &4 D"((44"  &4  "B4"    F 74% #4 7A 4  4&  &4 6 A   &4=   "& "4%     44  BB4 4 "4  &   ,  (#*//0D 1@-"4&4"B4"   "4  4 I&4*//0% &4=, (#*//0) JJ)L@/@F1

I1  JA=4 "' (544"%" 4  A&4" 4"""4 AH  1 "46BB 7&4

+-.,-+*//0 )I+,*)

4&"((44"4 Q4H  (4 7A&4 "4  """" & 744""4 41

  7R4 = 4R 4*?4* " 4  4"B "B 4" 4  ,. &4 ,??? D  1) J ,/,F%  "4  RH    "("4 " 4B4&"4"4 && 7R 44""4 4%B"4&7 GB4  54B 44"%R&"46"4% 445R(44  4"&% R  "4      (4 5  "" D H   4# B*1II+*//@?>4 *//@"41*1, H 4 P +*?I+*//0 @/(4*//0P +@,,+*//C*0&4*//CF1

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

  A6%&4( 4 "( 4 5A(44  4"1 A "4  4 4( A&4  "  A"#4= 4"   (    #  A 4*?  1

   "7%  =4B  &4" 4"  "4  AH    & H   1

.1   "  "   7  4 4" 4  74 "  A"#>    4 1 " "   7 4"% 4 "&4  #(    (47 "4 4#% 4 G(4 4"DA4 4"  44 G 6=   4 4"% B1 H   4# B 01,.-+*//-  ? ( *//C "41 .1,   * 1@,/+*//0  *, "&(# *//0 "41@F1

+-.,-+*//0 ).+,*)

  JB"%A"#4= 4""(4A4B"(" 4  A"# 4  " (  4  4)4 " "  ( 4=" 47   < 47%B4=G"4G 4, C!J -C -0 J1 4"' 4&" 4 47G"6=D 1,/ 1C!J%,@?J ,*IJF1

  &<%4A4%4"&"4" 4 4"4 4"   4 4"   4" 7A &"4  D +@I+*//,  *@ >4  *//,P +-C?+,??.*.>4 ,??.F1

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

?1   "   (     >4  1  "46 " B"4 7 )4 A   4# 5  4 % 74 A  " "#>   4 A  4" 4444 B"   J% (4  "   4"   &4" 4""4 %= 4!J1

   (46&"44 H 4&41 BB %(H(4" 4 4 G"4" 4 4 %4A(("47A"  "  G " &  "" A  4" 44441  4BB4 4"  " &   G "4 4 A#"   =6   !J% 74     A44 4 4& "4 T"  "4   (T1  44 4  "<4 4  B"  "4    4    " "4 > 44#%""O4A 4 = =4("4 (4 44 4=1A44 4 4&' #" 4% !J &"( 6=&4G4  J1

+-.,-+*//0 )?+,*)

"<#4  4"G"4 "&4"4( (=(4( &"4!J5JDB1 1,/1* C!JF1 4   <("4"&J%74="(H("4"4   &"4   4     "B4"    %   4 4    "4   &4"((D 1,/JF1

     %  4BB "  ( 7   =4( " G7 "  "(4   4% " 7  " &4  "   4" A&4" 4""4  4 )4=  %< %4>" 4"5 R=   44 " "   4" 44441   (46 "%"4" 4 74  4 74 ""4% (4   4   G46(1  %  G " "  " B44 ""A 4"%  4 &47"7  "   4"&4" 4""4  4  A"& A" 44441  4BB A"  44  4  5 A"#>  " 5  B44   " K74 "P 4 47( G &4% 74 "    4    A "4  (44  4&   < "   "4   &4" 4"% A "4 )"" 4 )<44441 4" 4 4(( B4 7=4 "464"= (7A4 A'   4  "S    4  ) 74 A   "< 4 (     4"4444)74  45" 4"%47  44=G"(44  4&"G 4 I 0/ 1

  44%("O"4 B"(44 4   A &4 4 "("   "4#44  7A  4" 4444 "4  4B4=%     >(4 H   46(     " (  5    4" D 1    %  4   "4444%4 4"(44  4&%6&) 84<)U*//-%1,/*F1

  A'"4"A475"B"!J A 6=4 4"74#5"44441

   "4"% "  "4   &4=  ("(   A=4(  44(4%"4 ,???%44 4""4B 4"G"4   4 B4= !J 4   A647    (4D4 4" 4& #"F1

,/1  "      4%  A#  6= G%  >4 47%  ( 46 4444%  44 " 5 A 4 ?. D74(H( 7A4 1I, F"74 4" " >""O47 G" 4&4 "#D +0,0+*//C */ (# *//C P +@I+*//,  *@ >4  *//,P +-C?+,??. 

+-.,-+*//0 ),/+,*)

*.>4  ,??.F1 "  4" 4) G"% 4 A'    4"  A 44"B"!J1

   A6%  4 4" "  " #4 5  4  >"  A" 4" 4 4=4%"4 ,/>4,???1

,,1     A4  4" A   & 4 "(  4  4 4"  4B  47     "((44"  B4  44(4 ) "4  A4 & 4" <4=4,/>4,???) K 4 4 &4G 6%  *0  (# *//C% A4B 4"   4   4 4"  A4 "4 .

,*1  B4% " 4    ( 4 A4 "4  4  G4= 7 A" 47"=444 4" B4G4"4 4"  "  &4%  &4=  ("(   K    4  D  "  A=4(  44(4F1   7 4"   " B"4 "BB4    "& % (H( <'" <6%A4B 4"4  4 ,/>4*//01

,@1   "& "4   "&  "4 5      B&"#   9333333%4A  4AG(41

,-1  B " B4%A %7K 4 A4 "(    4   " (44  4&% 74 4"  6=  446 4# G  "4  <=   "4   4B 4" &   "4  (44  4B1 A   %  "   4   "    9333333  ( *//@%  "   ("  7A 4"4 %  ("4 4  % "( "==6( " (44  4&1A'"4""#> 4&> 4B4 K 4 4B 4 1

  ""> 1

,C1  ("(  ;:,AC//1)(45<=" D 1.I  F%74"(#14(4 "% ;:,A///1)%" 9333333%5<=" 1



 VVVVV

+-.,-+*//0 ),,+,*)

&( )        

/0 1*,!"2

&#"4 > (#*//0!(2333333"  44" ( A""(4  *,"&(#*//0P

1*2

> P

( 5<=" ("(  ;:,AC//1)P

"93333334(4  ;:,A///1)5<=" P

4  7% "B"((  G  4 .*   4&    "4 B   4# B  ,I >4 *//C D :)J ,I@1,,/F%    H    H  "      >" 74 4&   " 4B4 4" )&   4# B%   &"4  "( 46"4 #4P(("4""4 447"4"% (" 4B ("'& " 4= " ""( 4P4 "4  H    4# B% ,///  ,-%  &"4 "  "  &"4  "47 G "4 4"  A 4 -*  :1    H     46  "4"  " % 4&"7 "(( ("'  &% "4&  H  >"4  5 A&"4P

"((47  H 5!"#  $%&" " %5!  '("%&" 9333333%447A ( A""(4  1

J4= E !1'<6%4 %!("&' ;4%!1 <4%!("% >=1

"( 4#(44  4BE

=BB46)>4 E  4 E     14")J4=4  :1'<6  

+-.,-+*//0 ),*+,*)

"4"B"( H  "((47G 41

 6&%  =BB46E           

+-.,-+*//0