United States v. Leon (Good Faith Exception to Exclusionary Rule)
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether evidence obtained from searches, conducted under warrants that were later determined to be invalid due to technical errors in their description of the premises, should be suppressed in a criminal trial. The appellate court reasoned that suppression was not required because the searching officers acted in objective good faith reliance on the warrants, as the errors were minor and did not prejudice the defendant by misidentifying the location to be searched or the items to be seized; thus, the evidence was admissible under the good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; United States v. Leon (Good Faith Exception to Exclusionary Rule): The appellate court reasoned that suppression was not required because the searching officers acted in objective good faith reliance on the warrants, as the errors were minor and did not prejudice the defendant by misidentifying the location to be searched or the items to be seized; thus, the evidence was admissible under the good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision governs the allocation of costs, which is explicitly ordered in the dispositive.
Testo completo
! " #$$% % !"#$%&'#
#
&%%%&' !( &%!
()*+(
!
/1 !#$ $# 2#$ # 3$(45 !1 2#$ #6 7$ !#$ !$# 2#$ # 3$(45 !1 2#$ # 461 $ #$ $ 8.+-- #99 : $"%& $ ;# "$#& < # $7$ 9$# 2=>$ $# ? >@ $9 "$#1
)1 /. 9 )00.& !1 2#$ # # 4 #99$$# 7#$4"$# #4'3$(45#99$$## A 6 <B # $# <$ 2?#$ C $ # 2 $D#$7#$ 7#$E# #>/DD/3A( : )//1E/)1//6& ' 2<$ 8.F+0& # $"G C 8.+--1
,1 ## #$ ), 9$ )00.& #99$$# $'$ H$ C #$ $# 7$ # < $4 1
E1 /I$)00.&2$ #'#4# >$C 79 # 8.+--1 : $99> "$#& #$ >"$ ="& $ 7791
-1 /EI$ )00.C#99$$#&!12#$ #$ < $#7$7$$ 2 $'$ "$#<2$'$ #%C 9 $ C $ "$?I<29>)00-1 2 $ <2C &$#2$'$$ #4 "@"$($& <2$'$ $9$4# 2 $'$ 2 $79$$1'$ #"9 #= 9$$##9#$""$ 9 )00.1
.1 )+ #J )00.& #99$$# 7 C !1 2#$ # <$ 2?#$ C $ #& 9# $7 <2$ 2 $ $ $ 2 $K9 #9$"$#1'$ 77 7#9 $#9$$ '$ '$C$ 9#""$ ' 9$$##,/9 )00.1
9$$# 7$$ $ C $$# #99$$# /,9> )00-& #7$9 $> 9$$ $7 ), 9$ )00.& 7 C # 4 <$ 2?#$ C $ # # ? $#5 2 &2($'$$ $'$ #"2$'$$ CF/L ) '$ )00/ & 2 & $ '$ ? $'$ C )-L 42 $'$ $ I<2,0#'9>)00-1
*,-./*)00. (,*+(
7$& >@ $9 "$# $7$ 8.+-- $ " $#'$$'#$ < 1
F1 )+ 9> )00.& !1 2#$ # # 4 $> 9$$ $7 # $$# $ # C # $#1 9$$ # #$ $#$9 '#$#M <$ 2?#$ C $ # '$ B #$ C <$ 8.+F01 $ 7 < $#& #99$$# $$ # $' >$$ 2?#$ $#79$$1
+1 $'$4# 2$ 7$" #$5
1 /E I'$ )00.& %$ 2'" 9 > $ 4' <# $ 99> $7$/D+D1 4'#$' 9# #N> N&$'$ # 4/DD.#N#" 2# N1 '" $ $ " #79$$?$ 1
>1 )0 I'$ )00.& !#$ !$O P>$O& 9#% # I<29)00.&<$'$ >7$$2=#$# #" # #% $7$ $#& 7$ $ 9 2? # $'$ "$#">#$2?#$ $#79$$1
1 9$: $"%#7$9)F7'$)00.<# # 4?#$ $ $#9>'"9# # #$ $#$#=>1
1 )/ I$ )00.& %$ $ < !12#$ # '$ $9# $?>>$ >$N#"2# N1
1 #J )00.& ?#$ #9$ '$ $# #9 "<# '$ $C2?#$ $# '$" &'#4&$(9B99#%C ?2 $'$ )-L$ /D-D1# '$ # $#4C'9# # $ #9$1 2$ $ 7$ 9 $ " C 2?#$ $# 9 $#1
71 $ )) )D 9> )00.& #99$$# 7#9 $# #7$# "$# 2#$ $# "#9 #"$ $# #92"$ 3 6#7$9$$ $## C 7#9 $## $"$ # #$ ?$9 $ 1 7#9 $# 2$ ? # $K9 # # >7$$ $9 $ & 9$ >7$ 2 A # 2 <$' #7$#& <$ '$ '$" ($< 9$$99 2?$#7$#9#9 ?91
*,-./*)00. (E*+(
"1 #'$ :1 1 $7$<2$ $ 99>Q=>(>##O #'$R$/D+D1
D1 .#'9>)00.c$$#$ $$# # I #1
/01 // 9> )00.& $> 9$$ $7 #"$ # 1
I""# <?$99>"$# 9$# 2=>$ $# $ $7$ 8.+--1 : # $"G 8.F+0& #'$ $>@ $9 &$# $#77 #2 &<$ $ C2$#$ $1
2 $99> "$# >$ $ >1 2$ $& #'$ "# $'#$ #> $ #1 2 2 ? $ % '$ ? @ " $ C # $# & #& $< $ 9# # > $# $>1 !1 2#$ # ?# <2$ #$ # 2 9#( # #' $<$9$C$#$ $#'#$$1
# $ ' < ?$49 $99> "$# '$ B #'##'#$$$>B 1 &$2'$ #99 K ## $#'#$ #99 $9$<1 2 & $99>2 $ ?#$ >$%'$ 29$ 91 $ $## $<$$<>7#$ $ #># >@ $9 1
#$$49>@ $9 >$ $ $$$<'7#$ $1'#$ $ $# $2$99>1
# ?# <2$ $ # )02000 94 C 2 : $"% /02000 94 C #$"%1 "? $ '#$ ## $##$ #>#=$1#=$ $ "$ # 7$ 2 # $ 7$$49 & $# # < $ '#$ <$ 8.F+01 '$ "" '? 9 # ##$ # 2 4& $# C #$ 1 '? '$ & $ '#$ #$' )" $ # #)1
: < $# I"& # #7$9 <2$ 2'$ A 2"$ 1 '=&$'$ #I# '$C79' 1 :# A 9$$ #$ $ 4 $# $'$ "$#& $$$'$ 7<99 #C $ $#1 '$ '$ $; & C '#$ I<2 9$ )00.& < 9$$42 #>$ ? $ ""1 /D+D&
*,-./*)00. (-*+(
$2 $ 2'"9# # &$9$)00.&$'$ ' $' # # "$ <$ 2 $ >7$ 2 7#9 $#&<$$9 $ 2#> $$K9< $#1
//1 :<#$&277$ "CI"1
! %
/1 I 9 $ ' I$$ $# #9 & # '>3 1-. #$2#"$ $#I$$$))#'9>/DE/( ( )0-S 1.,1/$ 1#$#9$$ $'/) 9>/D+-( ( -/0S 1/,#$2$ $##$7 #$ 7#$/.9>/DD,(A(!//061
)1 $>799 2 $ $#$#$ $#$ C <$ 2?#$ C $ # 2 $ D A 3 B $>7- 1/F*)00.)/9>)00.61
$$&$<$ <$$99>"$# =9 2$ $#A3 1) .A6# $"$#3 1F + A6 #$ #> $ #$ $# 3 1 ./ 1 / A61 ($ # #<2$ 2?$ 9# $7 7 3 1 ./ 1 ) A61 :# 2 $ ., $/ A&2<$$ $#2 $#2$99>"$# 7& # 99 #< 2< 2 ?#$ C $ #3 B $>7- 1/F*)00.$ 61
# $ $## $#2?#$ C $ ## #$ >$ 4' # $$ #9 9 $ #$ 9$$ $'&# 99 $>9$$ $71 7$2#>I 2 $$## $#2 $+EA3 *)++*)00.),9$ )00.61
24&# #<B 4#99$$# ' 2<$ 8.F+01 $$# # # $<9 2?$ <$ 2?#$ 1
,1 1 :# 2 $ D A& ?#$ C $ # <$#< $' $(9B9 "$# & 2$ 2"$ 2 $ "$#& $$" #9 ($ 31 /61 > 2?#$ C $ # <$#< $ 9 <$ 2"$ # % # $' $(9B9 "$# $$" #9 $"$#31)61
*,-./*)00. (.*+(
>1 < #$ 9$ #$ $# # ? $ 2 $ D A # '#$ <$ 2?#$ C $ #
3 *EE-*)00.,/#J )00.61
$ # $#2 $DA7$$ '# I$ $> 7 3 B $> 7 - 1 /F*)00. $ 6#29$2$#$ #%1
1 <$ 2?#$ ?$"$<2$#9$#& 7T#> $& '?$= C#9$"$# <2$$$" 2 $1 ?9& $ "$# ?#$ C $ 9 ' < I#*=#99 '$ & 2?#$ C $ # #$ '$ # 2 $ 2?#$ $# "$#1 #$ B B C ># $'$ $$ =# "$ 1 # 7#$& $'$ 2 ?&C#$ $# #$3 *EE-*)00.$ 61
1 $ 2?#$ C $ # # 9#% <$ #7$# < 9# =%$< <$& 24 " # C 2"$ # $# #& # <$ # ?#$ #'>9 #9$ "$#1 $ 2?$ & 4" "& < $ 2$ 7< # 2"$ 3 B $> 7
- 1/F*)00.$ 61
1 &#' 2 $DA&<$ '$$# ). I$ /DD+ 3 /DD+ ,00D ,00/& AA /DD. /6& '#$ < <$#< $' $(9B9 $99> "$#& < $ # $ # 7 $ 2 $ "$#& $ #$ #99 ?#$ C $ #3 B $>7- 1D*)00/,0I$ )00/61
'$$# '$ C #> $ $ $# $7#9 #$ & 9#U $ #&$<$ C 2$$#$ $#<$ 7$ <2C 2 $ "$# #$$ #99 ?#$ C $ # #$ $#2<$$ $#2$99>"$#& < $ <$ $$"$ IC #9 $ "$# 3 B $>7- 1D*)00/$ 61
'$$##$ $$9 C%9 2<$ $& ?9 # ' 9# #1 & $ <$ #$$ 2 #$ $# 2<$ $99> "$# #$ #I# >$ <2$ > $' $(9B9 < $#& 9B9 $ 2# '$99 ?$" "$ ?T $'$ #$$ <2$ $ $'$ 7#9 $# "$# #94 1 $$& # # $&?#$ $#C $ # 9$#<< #' <2$7#9 $#"$#< #?#$ 2$99>"$#<2$
*,-./*)00. (F*+(
<$ # <2$ ?#$ 4" 2 $99> #9>3 B $>7- 1D*)00/$ 61
24&$%$#$<# $#$ &9#9 #U$$# $&<$ 2?#$ C $ #1 77 &>$ <2$ 2$ 7#9 $# $7$< #9$ "$#& $ #M >$ $'$ & # #992'> $&#'#$? # '$79$&<2 >$ $'$47$" #$1 4 C #7$# 9$$& $ #I# # # 4 '? "$#1 $ 2$'$$ $ $# # @"& # # $'$ $'#9 $>& # $49 C 2?#$ $# "$# 79$$ # " $ '$1 # $<&$"$#= #=$ <$'#$$& <$ $ 9 2"9 >$$ # $ 2 '77$ 1
& 7$ <2$ #$ $ $ A 2"$ & $ 7$ #> C $ 2?#$ C $ # $ "$#1 # ?K #4$' I#2=$#$ ?$<$ B #$<$' C7#9 $#"$#< 1 $&9 #$9 # '## 2? 2 $'$ "$# C $ $$1 2 #" # $# '$$ '#$ ="2 C9#$7$ $ $#1
E1 ' <$ 4& $> 9$$ $7 #$4 < # 9$ #$ $#2?#$ C $ #1 &# 9$ $$##99$$#1 H77$'#% C A ##'$$#3 1.D1, 61
-1 9#9 VA /20001( 9$ C =" #99$$# 3 1+F 61 $9$ # #% # & <$ 2% # 1 WWWWW
$ &!% !
*+,- ./
'> # $ I )+ 9> )00. !#$ $# 2#$ ## $$##99$$#7#$4"$#)+#J )00.S
*,-./*)00. (+*+(
,-/
29 S
'#$C#99$$#7#$4"$###'$$#S
$$##99$$#7#$4"$# #4'S
9 C="#99$$#7#$4"$# #4'9#9 VA/20001(S
$ <2$2 #2$9$ S
$ <& #7#99 ? $ +) $' #$ 7 $> 7 /F I$ )00- 3 A(: /F,1//06& B B # I# <$ $' # $7$ $# (' $> 7& '#$ #9 $4#$ >$S99#$##$ $$<#$#& 9# $7 9#%' # $" # ##9 $S$ #$ B $> 7& /000 /E& '#$ # # '#$ #$< ? #$ $# 2 $ E) A1 B $4 #$# # & $'#< #99 9#% '& #$' B I#$ C 2'#$S
#99$< B C ! "#$ %& '# # & $$ <2C #99$$#7#$4"$# C2#77$7I $1
:$" 5 !1%=4&$ &!9#'% V$&!1 =$&!9#& I"1
#9 $>9$$ $75
"77$4(I$ 5 $ 5 1$#(:$"$ A1%=4 #$#7#9 B #99$<? $1
4'&"77$45
*,-./*)00.