Environmental Investigation Costs vs. Pollution Exclusion Coverage
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involved a dispute over whether a party was entitled to recover under a commercial general liability policy for costs associated with investigations and remediation following an environmental contamination notice, despite the policy excluding coverage for pollution-related damages. The court reasoned that since the claim primarily sought recovery for costs incurred *after* the notice of loss—specifically investigation and compliance costs—rather than damages arising from the actual release or property damage covered by the exclusion, the claim was not barred by the pollution exclusion, and coverage was available based on the general insuring agreement.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Environmental Investigation Costs vs. Pollution Exclusion Coverage: The court reasoned that since the claim primarily sought recovery for costs incurred *after* the notice of loss—specifically investigation and compliance costs—rather than damages arising from the actual release or property damage covered by the exclusion, the claim was not barred by the pollution exclusion, and coverage was available based on the general insuring agreement.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive section regarding the cost allocation for the proceedings.
Testo completo
!"# $ %&'%()** !"#$%& '($
$ + )* ) * ),**# -* *
)**) * )* . )* ) *
%&'/%'0*1
&0($ %&',%' %2*1*3
)*+,-)
,1 !2 3$4% % !$% % $5$ % $ $% % 6788'5%,/$22 %9:';<,77'$ $1 % % $) 6 78=' $% !2$>$(%1 )$ ?%)5$ %@' $( 6 78.' $% !$% ! % % %' A% <(% A%!1)!$>1
$%$ % >$9%$'%)% B>CD 52 : (% %5%' 5A < 49' A% $ % %%*//*1
*1 !1 $5$ % !2 % $ 4 ; !1 )
!$>',EE81 ( <%%'49 % % %1
-1 0 2 *//7' !1 $5$ % !2 % $ $ @ 2 <292 ' <A%2 $92 ' ( % $ 2 $ %$ 4$$9% <%5$2 %$ F%)
@G 2 $ H 2 5%% %( < $% %$ $ % (% ; $ %$ 49 @ %% I ?$ 1 3$ $' >))4 2% 9 % %(%%?91J% B(KC(% L $ $% 1 5#$) % 2%A $ $% %A5L 1: % K$ %K5L 5#1
$ <% %$ AL ' (% %( $ %%G
1 $22%%$ 2$2 ' % F%)@G !3H(%5($?2 ,*2%'EM% *,M% *//7'2$ %5 A$M < % $5$2;>$ A?$%< % 2%1
?1 *= 2% *//7' (% <9% < $$ 5($?2 ' $ ( 9% 492 <55 %$ ?N %2 1 2 %$M (% %%AA49 % M;55 ;I ( <%% A<%% 2L29@$ %$1
1 *, M% *//7' $22 2% (% 5($?1 @ 9%$49< % A %(% <:% 1 2$: 2' ?N %2 $% L 5$2 $92 ' ( $( (1
+.,+*//0 )-+,-)
1 $22$(%5($?2 8 2?*//7G $M $$% $M$;499%$'( $9$2? 5L <K% % %'A% % % %1
1 (% (% < K%2 5($?2 *7 2? *//71 ?N %2 %% <(% 5% <$?M < $% %$492 <55 %$1$M % : % % $A$($%%91
71 $ (%'!1 $5$ % !2 % $ 2$%5% $M 1 $ %2 <% 9% B(KC $ $( 2L2 $2?5L A%K% ( <%%1
4% A $ $5%2A<( <%%'?N %2 (% $92 %% %' A%' 2 ' (% %$22%%$5$%@9%$,EE71
01 (% *//7' !2 $> $(% !1 $> $ 5$2 $?( %$ @ 2 1
!1 $5$ % % ?$ !2 % ' :4$$9D % <K)
#% < %(% 9%$1 % A<% (% A% 49' $ 55 %$ (% 2$%5%G < % ( I ?$ 1 $2?(4% 4 (% $;<$A1
.1 ,8 $ $? *//7' 2 5 < $% %$ $%% 1 <55 %$49; %(% %<(% M2% $%1 $M !1 $5$ % !2 % < % $5$2 ; >$ 9%$ $%2 %$< % %2$; $% 1
=1 3%% < $ !1 $5$ % !2 % ' $22%%$ $ $ 2 %@ $ %$ F%)@G $22%%$H < M $5%2 %% %%$ 2 */ 2% *//01 <55 %$?N %2 (% 2$%5% $% %$? ,EE/1 $( 55 %$ < % $5$2 ; >$1 @ $' $ %$49$(% L $%$ %*7 %( $%5O292 % $%M%E=EF )3=//H' *= %( $% O% %$ $% 5 O292 % $% 7 M% ,E8= F ) , -/H 7* <$$ O292 % $% *8 M% */// F ) 3 =//1,H1 $% %$ $<%5% %$<$($ %$< % 2%1
81 $ *=M%*//0'!1 $5$ % !2 % $ % M $ @ %? 2%% %5 ; <$ %%$ $22%%$1
+.,+*//0 )7+,-)
5 % %9%K % $ % %% <9% % 2 ' !1$>)A%< % 9% ): $? < $% %$%K 2 52 %%1 52 (% $ 2 ($ %$ 9%$' A% (% 2% $22%%$ 5$%@ 9%$' %%!1$>',EE71492 <55 %$49% PL $%'% %$< %*7 ' $ (% ?5%% 9 %% %$A%F 1*71* H1
%%9 %$% $$ %$% % (%$ 5 $%$% M% 5%% %2$ 1 %(% A%$2$ J"-*/O///1)5%< %%49 $22 I D 5' ( % < % 9%$' $% J".<=.81); J"81)2*1
E1 1 !2 $> $(% $ $M$% A !1 $>' $% % 52($%%'$ $$$',- *0M% *//01
3 % % <% 52 (% 29 $92 @ <%%1 $92 29 K% % ( (2 1 % ;<(%$2 %%K %(% $ % ?% 1 <55 %$ 49 (% 2$%5% 292 %('$ 22 2%$K %%$ $% %$2 5% 1(% $ A M%5%% 9!1 $5$ %1
?1 - $P *//0' 2 < 92 $$ $1 <55 %$ %$M % $ %;>$ $% %$<$ $% < $9 %$ < % %1 49 ?5%%% 9 % % %$ A%' % % < % *7 % * ' 492 <55 %$<: %$5$22 $% %? ; <$A1 <% $ $%' <4:$ 4@ $Q 49 <% % 1
%%$ $22%%$ 5$%@ 9%$ 2$%5%% % % %$1
2 < % %$ 2% %' 2 (% $% $ %$ @ %% K 2 ($%%G $M % $%?'$ %2 ;%M$<4%% %9%K1
,/1 M99;<% %$$; $ ,E 2?*//01
$%$'%$ AB>C % $ % <9 $ 52' %% A < 2%$' % ) 1 %@ % $ !2 $> $(%1 9 ?N %2 % '
+.,+*//0 )0+,-)
$2$% %% )$ ';52%% %A%<$% 1< 2$% % ?N %2 $(' $) ' % ; !2 $> $(% A% $% ; %1 $) ?N %2 $(% ; !1 $5$ % ;!2 % 1:?% % 5? $ AA 21!1 $5$ %%%AA<%%% $ %49% %A;% A%K% % 1 %%% $2 ?N %2 $: $R2 % $$22?$ 1
!1$>%%AA((% $;$A%% %2%A 5% 5% % A %(% 9% ?$ 2$(2 1 !1 $5$ % %%A L $ 2$(2 1 !2$> $(% ( A ($2 ?N %2 $M 2?% %2$ $ I ?$ 1 $ ' <55 %$ ( % % %9% 2 $Q 49 % ; <9% $% 5% 2 L $%1 !1 $5$ % $?( A!1$>(% $(9?N %2 A%$% 55 ;<9% 1
%% $ $ $$ A<;<%@ >))4 %?N %2 $(M$K %!1 $5$ %' %K% % I A $(% 55 $$ %1 , 9'% : (% 9($2'(5L ;$?(% 9 2%@ >% 41!1 $> %%A A<%< % % < (K ' $ $<% 1
,,1 M99$K %% %,7$ $?*//0$ 2%$@)(?1
1 0 $ $? *//0' !1 $> % A<% : (% 2%@ >% 41 ' % < % $% % ?N %2 $(% (%9 (K 1
?1 ,, $ $? *//0' % A< 49 % ; <9% $% L $ % A %2% ( $% 5 $1
1 ,7 $ $? *//0' !1 $5$ % %% 5% A<% < % $ 5% 5% 91 $ $ ' !2 % %)2L2 (% $ 22 $ A $% (% $? A :K<4 <5$% % 1 $ % %%L $ 5$2($24?% %$1
,*1 ,/ (% *//.' ; <%(% %$ %?' 2 $% $% %5;< $% %$%(;!1$>@<%%521
+.,+*//0 ).+,-)
(%%% 2 <% %$ 2(% $ 5($?G
) $ '$ %$ % $5$2;< %7* D
) $ 2 % $% F%)@G H' %2 ' $M $% % $ %$ @ %% K $92 'A <K#% $5%$<9% %@A%> ' ?N %2 ( %% <(% <55 %$ 9%$ $M % % 2%2 %<%9%$F 1*7 7, 7* HD
) (% $ <( %$ < ; 2% % (D
) (%% ?% (%5($?;$% %$A 42%$'$L %4559'%%A %% $% % $ % %( < B %$ 42%)
ACD
) $22 %9:(%5($?%%$D
) !3 2 2$%5% %$ $M A% (% $ 22 %2% 2K%22 % M$ $% D (% $ L %9$$% %$%55 2 %K<($D
) % %$9%%(%< 5($M ;$% %$A A <992 $; $ %$$229 % L % K % $$ A% $% $ <K$% %$ < $$ ,% ;$K%2% $ %$$%D
,-1 %$ %5$2,-(%*//.<$ $%; $1
*
,1 M 2 % ( M%% %$ $2 ' $ (?F 10. $%O$9% %$M%%%$(2?,E7,) ) */0D 1.-1, 1$%$2%% %(,* 2?,E80) ) 0,/H1
*1 1 3$ < % , % , ' $5 %$' $ $22(% ; %% %$2$1
+.,+*//0 )=+,-)
<55 %$@9 2$< %% %$$ %2% >$;?N %'>$9%$ >$;$ 9F 1,7 H1
?1 >$9%$( ;9 %?<$(%%$2 : ;$9 2';(9:9 2 ; <A%%?$$9%AD< $A$%'(% L 2% A $%? %? $ $ %$1 >$ $2 ' < ' % A% L ; <K$% %$ 9%$ $ ; <4$ % $ % $ % ; <$2%2 %55 N4 ($ ; <9% ' < ' % A%' <% L 9' $%( L K$% <9% F 1,.1, H1
%$$ 5$2 %$<$ %$$<% %$ >$ 9%$ $2% ; $% %$ F 1 1 , H1 %@ %(%$ %$$<% %$ $5$2;<55 %$>$ F 1 1 * % 1 H1 >$ 9%$' % 5 A< $% $5$2 ; <55 %$ >$ 9%$1 < 2' $% L % ; <K$% %$ 9%$ $ ; <4$ % $ % $ (% ; $ ($2 % F 1,.%, * H1
-1 2$%5% $(K %%,'*.'*=;*= $ (%9*72%*//-1 ( %%$) $ %(% ' O$%A'492 @9$% '%$% %$(%9 $% %$O 5% A%$% L %M%%A2 $A% $A M%%A F " 8E+/, ,E 2 *//*D " ,*. ,.. $%17?',*-,-0$%1*?',*,,//$%1, M%% D 1!'$% 2%% %5G $ I' $2*'*//*'1 ,=8D 1 S ' % $% 2%% %5' N 7@2 1 ,EE,' 1 ,,.H1 $ 5$%' 2 %@ < $% %$' M% 2 A< <? %$% %$9'< $% $%A$2(%9M$ $Q 1<% %$%22% $($% %%M %5% % L ?%$ F ",1-07+*//*-,$ $?*//*'$%1 01*D " ,,E ? ,==D 1 !' $1 % 1' 1,=7),=0D 1 S ' $1 % 1' 1 ,,8H1 % < 292 % $% $4 2% % >$9%$M %5% % %$%22% $(% %$1
%A5% $% $( *72%*//-' M9$%$% %$$($% 1
71 1 3$ < % */ % , ' >$ 9%$ % ; <K$% %$ 9%$ $ 4$ %$' $ A $ %$ % %$ % ?2 ; %(% K $ <K# ; % %%'A% :9' A% $% %$5%K %-7 %( ( :L $%1
+.,+*//0 )8+,-)
?1 O $% %$ $ % L %( AO; $% %$ A $ %$ $% $5$2 ; >$ F 1 1 * % 1 H $ AO % ?5%%O$9 %$F 1*7 D *= H1$ %$$ $5$2;>$9%$$AO$ %;OK$% %$9%$ $$A<( ($2 % O %(% $5$2F 1,. D 1*/ H1
<@'%< $ A$ %$49< %; %(% 9%$1 '%)% L $%$22 $ %$$5$2;<55 %$>$9%$1
01 $(% @ $ <K2% % ?N %2 L $% ; % $9 $%< %*7 '$22<%($A $ 1
1 @9 9 %( K BK %$ ( 4$ >$ ; ?N %C$ 2$%5%$($%*/2,EE8' (%9 ,M(%*///F$(K %*7;*7 -E;7- H1 9' $($% 5% %2 % % %$ $($ %$ 5$2 %$F +E=/+*//7,72?*//7H1
?1 3$ O % *7 % , ' $ %$ % %$ % 4$ >$ ; ?N % A% ( L %% $5$22 ; % %$'2%A%$ $5$2;O55 %$>$?5%% %%9 %% %$A%1
O $% $2 $%$( %$ $ %$ % %$' 5$2 %$ %' 9%2 2 $ $ %$' $ A ?N %2 % %9 $ 5$2 92 F 1*71* H1
%$% %$ %?K$ %$ % %$A%$ %9 $ 5$2 $5$22 $% 2 % (%9 ; O$A' 2% A% $ ( $ % ; O55 %$ >$ ; % O 2$%5% %$9% %$$O292 F 17, H1
<@'%$ %@$%A49'$ <55 %$ % 9%$' $ % B( 9C1< <%9A %<% %92 1'%<:2$%5% %$$%% <292 A% % 49 9%2 >$ $ $ $A A< 49 ; 55 %$ 9%$ $% $% >$ 9%$1 ' < ; % < 2$%5% %$ 5% ' % ( $% %$'A49 ($ %;<55 %$>$9%$1 $A ' % % ?5%% 9 % % %$ A% < %*7 1
+.,+*//0 )E+,-)
.1 $22 $ ( ($% $ %$ % %$ A%' < $ <9 < % *7 %5 K $( $ %$4$>$;?N %A$% L 4A %$<$ $% < $% %$ $ % F " *//*' 1 ,,7D "1! T 3 "" ' >$ 9%$' %G $ % $% $ %$ *//,' 1 78D +E=/+*//7,72?*//7H1
1 3$ < % *7 ' $% %$ ( L %( $ $($ %$$% %$$$ $ 492 <55 %$% <%2 %$ $ %$ $ % %$ 4$ >$ ; ?N % %2$ % %$F 1H %% L $ <:$$ F 1?H1 $% %$$ 2 %(F L %?5, 1*.+*//- (%*//-'$%10H1
?1 3$ M%' $ A< $ %$ $% %2$ % %$'%5 $M$A%$$?M %(U 4%A'$$2%A $ $ $5%9 %$ $ U M %5% % %$ <$(9 $M ; <22 (1 <: % $2 %$?M %($$% %$$($ $ F ",*-7EE1-?+10/8D +70*+*//**=$P *//*D +*/8E+*//-,72?*//7H
<@'$ $ 9% 1$M $% $ %$<49; % %$< %(% %'$ 22 ( I < ?$ 1 %? $% $ $ ( < $% % %2 A $ %$ < I ?$ 4$ >$ ; ?N % < %2$ % %$< %*7 1
$A ' <% L %( $ ; %$ < I ?$ % %2 5 ; <% L ?% (% <292 $ A% %2 '%5% %$'<(% 9%9 % < %% %$2$F +*/8E+*//-,72?*//7H1
=1 '$ $ <% %$$22%%$$ A492 <55 %$?N %2 55 ( ( <% (%2??2 $%<%(% 5% <$?M <21
9%5 %' @ $ A<% <9% A < 4:$ 4@'$%<@1
81 $ ( (%$ %$ %% <9% % 2 5% ($%A% %A' $% $ %$@%%K$92 1
1 %%$ (%$ %% <9% % 2 $A< ?% % % %$ M%%A A% M %5% 2$ %5 %$?
+.,+*//0 ),/+,-)
9 % %$ 5% ; 92 $ $A< $2 5% % % %$A%<%2$ (%$ '< );)%$AA% 2??< % 2%@% %A $AA% %2?? < 2%@ %55 F 1 ' 1 ! ' !1J '$% $ % %$%'$% 5$2 K'$2 ' *///' 6 ,/,7),/-,' 1 7E=)0/.D " ,-/ ,8 $%1 01*D ,*= *00$%1-?D,*.0*$%1-?H1
3$ M%' M %%? % %% (% %2<%9% % 2 %$% %$% $A $% $ 2 %A;$'$2L2A< ' % #5% %$$<% %A $ F ",,0 E-D,,-?-,-D +8-*+*//7*.$ $?*//7H1
' $ < $% $ %%$ A($$ <%A$ 2 ;<(%%$% %$9 A %$ 5% %A (% A% % $ ?$$ F 1 '<9% <%9% '&1,E=8'1*8,'*E/H1
(4'%< $% % ;2% % %A$%9 $ <% : % %$ A< ( % )%' % $: 2A5($%92 ; %$% % ;%)2L2' 5( 5%$A< $% 2$%5% %A%9 F ",/0,E*D,/7?-=-DEE?-8-D +=//+*//0*0$ $?*//0H1
$5 )%AO%OK% % L ?%$ 9% A%$%;$5;)% %2 O9% % 2 F " EE ? -87H' % O% AO % L %( % $ O:$$F ",/8*,-'*,7D1S '$1% 1'417E,1 ,/7D1S ' $$% 2%% %5',EE7'417E,17*'7-H1
$ ' %? 5 % AO% % % A O $% O% $%' $ %$' % 2L2 % ' 2% $ %A $ A )% 5 ($% AO; O(% 92 $%13%O $% $ % % %$'%:%O2 AO%( %A$5$2; $%F ",,08,D +0E+*//7*/M(%*//7'$%10D +=8E+*//, *=$(2?*//,'$%1EH1
?1 $ <$ $% < $9 %$' %% ( L $%92 ?%' 5% <(% $( $5$ ; K %$ % K %$ F1 !' $1 % 1' 1 -*7H1 % 2 A<$2<9% % 2 $KA% $( % %$ % %A?5%% $2 %A2 <$9 %$1 55 '$(%% %% ; 5% <K %$ @9' ; (% $% %( $
+.,+*//0 ),,+,-)
9%@ ; <% L ?%A%2$ %(<$ %$$%1 ' <% L ?% $%(% $% %% 9% $%( <2$ %%<9% % 2 F +=0*+*//*- 2?*//*D "*//*17=7D1S '$1% 1'1*E-H1
<@' %?2%% %5$ '$ $ ' A <% 52' 92 % <%%' (% $ % $2$ % K$92 $55 ;<9% 1 ($% %5; < $% %$%(;!1$>$ $ %$' %?$ A )%(% $? %*7 7, 7* '$% ($%$9 $%1'%$ (%%%$<% %$ A B?N %2 ( %%<(% <55 %$9%$C1 $ $ 2$% $ A <% 52 <(% $ 5% <$?M < A$A $% %$ 492 <55 %$1 $ <% $9 $5$2% % $% %$ K %$% %$ 91 $% A<% $% ' 5$ $ A < $% %$ %( $ % %$1 2 $%2 % %A $ 2 ; $% 9%2 $9 %$1 % %9 2$ %2 ($$ 2 (% ; % %$ % %$% %$92 %@1!L2% %? (% ;$ <%9% %%$< $% %$$9 $% %(; $ %$<%52'$ $% $2 <9% $? % 2L2 ?5% %9 $ < $ $5% ( %1 % %$'9% <2$ <9% 1
9%5$ 1
E1 ' $ %9 < (%$ %$ %% $$ %$% 1
1 %% $$ %$% $ 5$ %$ %% % <9%? <% %$1 %%'$A$%%;< $% 4$%K %(2' %$ $% <K%9<A %$; 5% <% L ?% A% $%(%1 %% %2% $ K% $($% %A' 2%@ A 2$: A<% 2 V( <$9%A <5$ %$2 ? % '2%% $% %$<2?%$ ':$2%% L $ $$22%% 1$2$ $%@9G< % ' % $$ %$% % $1 %%'$%%%$' < $% $% 4$%%2$:$; %? (% A%$ < % 2$%9(K% L %(1 5% '$% 2 ?9(% 55 24$%%% %$<% %2 $2 $% (<% L ?%F1!'$1% 1'601*'17,.)7*.H1
+.,+*//0 ),*+,-)
?1 2 %@ $ %$' %% <%A K %$ 2%% %(A< $% %5%9;<2%% A%(%$@9$% ' $ 22 $ %$ $% %$1 55 ' % 2 $ I 4$%K < $% % 2 F2' 2$% %$ $ $ %H$A<5% 9$$($%<% %$1
%% $$ %$% <%A 2 %@ %$ 2%% %('2%2 %@< $% %$$9 $%F +7*E+*//- 0$P *//7H$ A9%5 1
,/1 $ %9 $ 5% A %%$ 5 $ %$$ % ;9 %$% 1 9%5 K$?% ;<$?M % %9'%2% $ I$5$2% 2$% ?% <292 % $% <(%$2 12$% K$ A'M%$ ' % %$;9 % $% $ 2%%? $ A< $ ? 9' A< $% M %5% % L ?% 55% A< %% $$ %$% F +,=7+*//, ,- 2 *//,D +,8*-+*//7 *72%*//0H1
A%@A<<@ $ $% %$$ %1 @$'( % ;9 %$% '% % (' % 2%%?1
,,1 $$% 25$'$M 1
,*1 2$2 J",<0//1)2%$M$% 2 $%%2 ; 49$ F 18= H1
) *
4(5 '6
(? $% M *=M%*//0!$%% $5$ % !23$4% % $ %%$$22%%$ $$ 2 %@$ %$*/2%*//0D
5 %6
M D
2 ; 49 $ ' % $M$% 2 $%%2 ' 2$2 J",<0//1)D
+.,+*//0 ),-+,-)
% A' $5$22 K % E= %( $% 5 O$9% %$ M%%%' L L $ '($%$$% 2%% %5' M$ @ $ %5% %$' ( %? 5D 22$% $$% %%A$%$'2$ %5 2$:( $ %9 $ $$2 %D%$% L $%K2%2$% %? 5' ,/// ,7D L %@ $%$ $ '%($A$222$:('$%( L M$% ;O($%D
$22%A L ;! "#$% & '($ $ ';!$% )! $>' ; !2 !$% J% $> $(%' 2 $ %$ 4$$9% O%5$2 %$ %% A<; $22%%$ $$2 %@$ %$1
3%9 G !1:4@'% '!2$(:'!1 4%'!2$'M9' !1$'M9 1
$2 %?2%% %5G
955%@)M% G % G 1%$)3%9% "1:4@
$%$5$2 L $22%AK %1
@(' 955%@G
+.,+*//0