Appeal Regarding Damages Award Sufficiency
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court reviewed multiple appeals stemming from various related proceedings concerning damages awards, affirming most but vacating and remanding one specific award where the calculations were deemed insufficiently supported by the evidence presented. The court reasoned that while the general methodology for calculating damages was appropriate, the specific evidence and factual findings underlying one particular damage component—an award related to a specific prior period—lacked the necessary evidentiary foundation to meet the required standard of proof, necessitating a reconsideration of that particular element of recovery by the lower tribunal.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Regarding Damages Award Sufficiency: The court reasoned that while the general methodology for calculating damages was appropriate, the specific evidence and factual findings underlying one particular damage component—an award related to a specific prior period—lacked the necessary evidentiary foundation to meet the required standard of proof, necessitating a reconsideration of that particular element of recovery by the lower tribunal.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for the allocation of procedural costs.
Testo completo
!"#$%&'(
(
! "" "#!$%%"" " !
)*+,-)
"
,/ !0 1222222 " " 3 "4" " " 0 35(" %"0 %"",67*/
6 0% ,668& 0 9 "& (" " ) (0 : "( 4 0 3((0" ;")<= 0 > 3 (" ? 5(" 4) @ A222222B&"?222222&( (" "/,79"*..8& (" ? 5(" 4) ? 3"C @ D222222B& " ?222222&(" (" E222222#/ / 4"&*7( (% *..F& 0 3 ("?5(" 4) @G222222B&? 222222&( "(" "/
*/ "' "(0"" "'( "4"C?!01222222&(" =
) 0 1E,../) ,7 0% ,667 ( '(" C" ( 3 %"0 @ A222222B& * 9" ,667H
) 0 1E8../)*-'"*..8/C "( @D222222B&C" (3'" I ( ,.9'" *..8 "" ((00" <3$40 (H
) 0 1E*../)*.0"*..8("0 "(0"( ("?@D222222B0*..8H
) 0 1E *../) ,J 9" *..F ( '(" 3$40 @D222222B&*69'"*..F/
8/ *('0%*..F&" 3" ( '" (")
"( ( "C ( (" "( ( @ A222222B @G222222B/
/ &!01222222""KI (" " 5(" @ A222222B/ '" : 0C ? 0"" ' 0< 3(" (0 %"" & $ " '"/ 9(& 4"" K & 0" " ("/ )0I0 3(" "/ (00 (" " 44 $4 "" %("(!/ 222222&K" " " 3 %"0 $4'"/ "CC" (/ " <(' &0I0$( $("/(0 %"" " 4"""/
+-+*..- )8+,-)
!01222222(5(K3'" $ 33?L / 0" 0&'" '(C"@A222222B&"'" " ( %"0 " & @G222222B/ '5 " ( " : '" ( (00" "( 5 %"0 / 35(" "( @ G222222B 3'" ( (00/ '" " " ? !/ 222222 '" " (' " ' "' 3 (" "(/ ")" '" %( 30" C(& M %: & " " "' K3" 3: " / : '" " 0C ' 0<(K@A222222B44"$" (0 /
!01222222(""KK33(" '0 " (&0"KC "($C(""(0%" (0 %/
(C 9 @ D222222B& !0 1222222 K3 '"" ( ( / 4"" " $C(0 %"" /""'" 4"(( %"0 ( 3:0C?0""/ :" C"<0 ("&<40 @ A222222B/ !(" !222222 3(" @ D222222B& ( " " (" "& CC" (/
!0 1222222 "0 K3 C" (0 44 "'0 @ A222222B/ ? @ D222222B& 4"" ( 0"5& 0" 3 " (" "/
%/ !/ 222222 ""K K3" '"" ? @ A222222B/ !0 1222222 " ( ""C" 3 %"0 /0N" (K33 " ?& 4"" '"& 3(" (00 %("( " ,,$..?,F$.. ,-$8.?40 /!012222223(" " (0 %"" & (K3 " K3" 3: '" " & "" 40((3 %"0 /
3 " ? ( K3" " C" ? 3(44" ( ( "( K" " /#(" " 1E8O-../)% &K"" " ' !01222222/ )" " C 5? ("$9(/ 3'" 3$("4"5&( "0 ?"/
(' "3 %"0 3 " 0"/ " "'K " 3" %(K@A222222B " 0"&0" " /
!0 1222222 " (% @ A222222B K3 C" 44 "'0 (0 / " ""( "(" 3" "((C "(3 %"0 (%&"'" (" K3 0 "</ " C0 ($
+-+*..- )F+,-)
" <$%" &(K!012222223(" ' C%K C(/
/ " ( "K3 ,0%*..8 ,( (% *..F&"3 " ? "M"?@A222222B/'"" '" " ,.$-- ,J$8-/ !0 1222222 " ? (" "H ? K "&('" " K3'" "(K3" 9(H?"5"& " % /
F/ 0I0" ( "C&*P('0%*..F&( ()
3 %"0 @D222222B/
/ "(!01222222 " 0I0K5( *('0%*..F( @A222222B @G222222B/
%/ !/!222222""KK3" " (%%(0$ )
H " 4"" $ (" ( 0"/ " %4" 3 ?-.Q/
3 %"0 " (" (" E222222 #/ /& ( " " 0(:/'" CC(0 %3 %"0 &'"" )
( " 3(" (00/!01222222$C" "< R$ (K3" " % / 3 " (0" ? $(" "" " %(3$3 %"0 /
!0 1222222 5(" " 3 %"0 / " ' 0""& (0 " 9( (" (("(0 %/ " &" " (C/ '" "("& $($ 0" 4"" 40 '"/
!0 1222222 ($" (00 1E J../) 0("& K" " " '(0 %/'" 3"3C"" 30( % ( /
" ( ( ( K 3 %"0 3(44" $("5 ("%("(((?"5"4"5%("((("K& ? K("!/!222222(K '" "C0" /
C '" " K"'" '"' ( ?"44 0 $4(( % ' 0 S(S/
" 5 K*7 0%*..F&"0 "(0"(4(0 S(S'" "/0(: " /'" " 5C0 K3"" 03 (" "(/
+-+*..- )-+,-)
C0 '" ""K ? ( K3" 3: '" C" (= " '" & K3" '" 0( 5 4( 3(/ (%<0&"" !01222222(("/
" 5 K3" " ? <(' &0""C" 3 %"0 / 4"" L '"&(%'" K"" /C "(( 44 "'3 %"0 '" (%"" !01222222 ")0I0/
" ()"C " %" '" 4" ? !0 1222222 ' (0 %/ 3C"" 3 0"& K3" ("" " (C 0& < ( K3" "'" ("( ? @ A222222B / ($" 1E ,O-../) 0(" "(" 3 0"( / (: ( "( " C0 :/
E222222 #/ / " 0"" 4< !0 1222222& !(" 222222/" K!01222222'" "((" /
/ !0 #222222 C0 / '" CC !01222222 '" '"" 0" ?@D222222B 9'" 9"*..F/ 3(K& " :(0 %/3 %"0 " C!/!222222/!01222222" (9(4"("('(" " ( " %"/ 3: '" 3"0 "( 0" ? 3(K(T: '"" /!/!222222 " '*.$..((? 40 ("(" '" K 3$ /1(0" 0&" " (9( 3 %"0 /
/ !0 222222 5 " K3 " ' 3 %"0 "4'"*..F/ '" CC!/!222222 ( '" '" "C "/ (0 % " '" ( "/!012222223(" C "(3 %"0 / "" ( '" ? 0""& "" K3? ""/ !/ !222222 3(" (00& "C& C" 3 %"0 / (%<0& " 3(3 /( " ("/
-/ 7 '" *..-& 0 " !0 1222222& !/ !222222 ""KE222222#/ /&4"K3"" 5(" 3I /
(" *7 '" *..-& !0 1222222 " K3 " (" " 5(" @A222222B",67J/" (K& " $K (" ( %"0 / 4"" " C"<0 3(' 0 " ( ' ( (C 0" (/
#((04"C" ( 3 3 %"0 '" '" UI 0/"&K3'" &"'" ((
+-+*..- )P+,-)
0"? " "(/0I0&3 %"0 (44" "*,9"*..F ("%("(((?"5"4"5%("((("K/
!I0 " C" ( " & " 5" " '" 0"54 K3" " /
#3C" @ D222222B& " 35(" 3(" $ &3$:C"<&"C&'"(K " " C "( ( ""& "0 4 & / #( $(" " 45"%&0" " (9( ?0""&40"/ :" C0 ("/
3 (" "3 %"0 &C" 0"5&0" 3 " (%"K4""/ 3'" '"I )(0 3 " 0 ( 4( "(0 3 %"0 / '" '"( " "&"((0" ""( !/!222222/ "'" '" 89'"*..-/
K" (" @ G222222B&" " 5 K!/ 222222 '" ("0"? ""(' 3(' (44""/'" ( ( / 4(" 3 (" "( (& '" (0 5(" 3 )
%"0 /
3" ( C(%0 ($K"" " /
P/ / ""( *, 0" *..-& 0 "4" " !0 1222222 "5 0(" " "4"C 0 1E8O-../)/ '" (' 5(" @G222222B 3 (")
"( 0 35(" " (0 44 "'0 @ A222222B/ 3'" ( ( (0 ( @ A222222B 3: (44" (" %("( (( ? "5 "4" 5 %("( (("K/ 4"& 35(" " (0 44 "'0 @ D222222B&0"'" I )(0?!/!222222/ %"0 3(44" $("5 (" %("( (( ? "5 "4" 5 %("( (("K C" ( 3 " ? 9(/ 4"& !01222222 3'" "4(0M L '" (" "( 4" ( "'" /
%/ 0I0 9(& 0 1E ,O-../) "4"C ? !/ !222222& K 0 ($ 3( @ D222222B& ( K !01222222 " 35(" / )" ($" (00 1E J../) (0"?"(" "(( "4" " /
/ 4"& (9( *, 0" *..-& 0 "4"C 0 1E,O-../)?3 "E222222#/ /?K" " ($3'("(4" 35(" "( @ D222222B?!/!222222&(K!01222222 "
+-+*..- )J+,-)
"C(0035(" 3I ("'("K"5(" " 0 %"0 /
J/ ,.9"*..-&!012222220 0 (" ""(& 0 5((%' "(/ 0 4(?50(",-9"*..-/
7/ *8 9" *..-& !0 1222222 "" "% 0"" "4 3 (& '( C0 4"C ("*7'" / 0 3'" (0 0K 3 " "K0 4( ( " & " 4$0 5/
( ""0 ?3 "(""( &%"""0 & K3(" "(K(4 C<&K'" 0 "00" 0 ("C/
6/ *P 9" *..-& 0 3 (( (& '( 0 4"C ""(" "C"/
,./ ,6 0% *..-& "" K 8. 9'" - 0 *..P& 9C C " " (0 "( ( " (?KI /
/ !0 1222222 ""K K3 5(" " @ A222222B @ G222222B& 0" K3 3(" ( @ D222222B/ (K3 " C %"0 &:" K (9(& 0I0"0$&(" ?0""&(" <40 @A222222B/ "" 0 (" %"0 """ (" 5 (00/ 0 "< 3CC0 (& ""( 4" " " C0 /
@ D222222B& ($" 1E J../) 0("H " 3C"" 3(000("K&C?(C30" "'!/!222222/ " "'?""C( 30(:&0""'" "00" 0 ""KK (C "'" " '/
4"&5(K"3" 3'" '?@A222222B& 3 " K3" '" 3 %"0 (" 0 " < %( $&(" 3<)0""/
%/ 0 ' K "M ( L& !01222222 3 " K (" 4("/ 0 3'" I )(0 ( @ A222222B& 0" ("" K 35(" "( ( " "44" /
+-+*..- )7+,-)
/ !/ 222222I (00"?@A222222B"K / 3(" C "(3 %"0 /(00%("( " 4" (" !01222222&(" ")0I0&3% "</ !0 1222222 CC" ( 4"" (/ #3" 0K" (" & !/ 222222 " ")0I0 0C" K " ( 0/ 3 " " " K" ( L" "'"(& (K ( " % /
" " ? ("(K "&9 < !0 1222222/ "< "" ( $("& ( L" 3 "'" ( "" (K " "/
" 5 K((00 K" " 0"'" '" " ' ( (' / ( " 3 "< (%"" / ("" 0"5" <$%" K!01222222&0"3 " K" 3(" C(/ (C"" 4( "(0 @A222222B : " ("& 3 %"0 "" C( C"& CK3"("" /
/ !0222222K3 " '?@D222222B K3 '" CC !/ !222222/ ( :" '" " ? ( &K!/!222222'" "C/#("" " '( (0 %"(0 %3 %"0 /
!/ !222222 " (& 0" !0 1222222& K3 ("" & "(" " '" (/ " KK $& (" (&"" 0$3 " "" '" %("/ " K%("( " (00!/!222222/ 3 " C"<0 '!01222222&0"'" K("& ( K3('" "K"(" (?K"/ 3C ? @ D222222B& " " & " !0 1222222/ #" (%<0 " ("&" !/!222222/
/ !/ !222222 ""K K3" '"" ? @ D222222B " ( (' &*..*/ " "? -.Q ('" 4"344( /#( '" (" " ( ? 4" ( K ( %"/ '(:" !0 1222222 (9( "" " 0%(C00/""'" 4" KK (00""(/ !0 1222222 3(" ' C 30"" "(/ ( " CC (0 %& K" " 4 0(:?!01222222 ?")0I0H$("54"" "4 " ? !0 1222222/ 3 " (& 0" " " (00 5 0(:((% " /
3 " !01222222K""" $ (0(" "( 9(/ " ?'(""4N"/ " ""?@
+-+*..- )6+,-)
D222222B0 "& ,.$.. ,,$... : " 9K3?,F$8./ '" "(' ("/ ( "0 ?K"4"C" "(4" ? ("& !0 1222222 3(" ""0 (00/ " "&(" K30C" &(" K34"" (0 %"" &0" ( " 4"/ '" 4 3 %"0 0I0 " " 0(" K")0I0&C" 44 "'0 @D222222B/
( ' K3" '" K "C"4"" 0 @I )
(0B "" "(/ <K9C" 5"K 0&"""KK3 " !01222222?@D222222B/ '" " "( 44"&0"3'" 4" (&" " "0(0 (T""("'" ( "4"/
( 5( K3' 3(' E222222 #/ /& " 5(" " ("("? (" / " " "%" C"'" 0?K3"('/" " "'"C( '" (0 % <'(" $(?"('"4"K3" "4"/
4/ !0 #222222 5"K K3 " 0 $L0C/ '" 4" @5 B& ( 00 ? @ D222222B& (T '"" " 0" ("&!01222222&'K'" ( ( ( "4 ? (" "( 3CC0 / !0 1222222 " 0(0 $K9(&"" ( (" (0"5 5 / 3 " K""'" ("&"K"/
!/ !222222 3(" %( 0$ / "" 0 (00?4"(K3"0K" KK$(/
" %
,/ 9 0 " ' 9"" "( (0 & ( '%; /-P ("O(C" "(9"""('0%,6F,) ) *.-H /P8/," /("(0"" "',* 0%,67-) ) -,.>/
*/ / #(3 "F",(" "(&%" %("( O$%C0 ,J 0% ,67J ;1 ) * *,>& 35(" "( ( %"0 C" 1 (0" ? 3(% "( % 3 (" "("' 0 /3"* ""K (" "((" I K"($K$C0 35(" (0("4")
"((" "(3 (" "( "/ (" "( ( " 0""%; /,-/81>/
+-+*..- ),.+,-)
3 " - " , & "'0 1& "'3 (" "( %((?(" "(KK (" " " "4" " ( " ?C %")
0 (0" ? (" K "( K3" (44 ( C "& (0 ( 00 ("(0""(" "("%"" &3 5(" "(( 44 "'3 %"0 /
' 3 "*,",1&35(" C( %"0 4N(( 44 "'/
%/ #( 9" "% 0"" "4 ; +F76+*..- ,69" *..- 4" >&C "(44 "'(" " $C R$0"" "'"&3 &(;CC0 & "& $("& 00 & /> & 3 & ? %( 0$ 3 %"0 ;(00 0$"& 4"5 "( "5& (0(" "( 0&( L"&"' "& />/
/ 0 ($ ? ( '(" 5(" (0 @A222222B @D222222B/
3" "(?K "%0"" "4(0( K 3 " /!/ 222222&(00"@A222222B&5"KK !0 1222222 3(" )0I0 3CC0 ( C "(3 %"0 / " C"<0 3 %"0 & 3( ""C(' 0C("/
"(4" !02222229 L( C "(@D222222B'( 0I0/ & ( ""K (" K !/ !222222 " (& " K !0 1222222 " '" ( K" (" ( "" 0$ 3 "/ !/ !222222 & " "& (4"0 / ( 00 "K""(4"&(3CC0 (& " ? ( &0I0"")0I0 " 50(:(00 (& 4"3(% " /!01222222"" $ &(0(" "( 9( &45 "(&(00/
"(""" '" (" "( ( "(" &( " "('(( ' "% 0("&(4("0 /
( 4("& " ( " "( K K "( (( 4(0 30"<5 I00 " "'&4? (( ("C4N" "0" /
+-+*..- ),,+,-)
& !0 222222& K" '"" ( @ D222222B& "(4"0K3 " ( K"" $(" (4"5 & K""'" ("/
(K& 3 ? ( K3" ($ ? ( C(0 44 "'0 %"0 K "(/
8/ #( 3 " ,* 1& " " " " " 3 "4" " '"I )(0(35(" "(3 %"0 (0"? 1/ " " "('"?'"35(" "(3 %"0 ( K" (" ? (" "( " 3$((%"" %" 0"& ' ( K (0( (00 "K ( %" ; +F7P+*..**6(U *..*>/
0 ( "% 0"" "4 9? 0" K !0 1222222C" (0 44 "'0 @D222222B&3 ? ( K 0 "($'"( "(3 ",*1/
F/ 3 "F 1 (0 "(& $C0 C("& 3C"0 & 4(0 "(""K ( 0("4" "((" "( 3 (" "( 35(" "( " ? 3(% "( % 3 (" "( 0 /
3<&"3 ( K" " ((00 4) @ G222222B ' K 3 (" "( 0 " "'/ 0 (T " 0" K !0 1222222 C" (0 44 "'0 @A222222B '" K" (" "( " ( @ G222222B& " : " 30 K "4 "( "/
4" K30(:( &!/ 222222" ""KK3"'" "K0 "" 3 %"0 '5& ( K @ A222222B " 0"& ( " 0" ((00 ( (44" ' 0("4" "(00""(3"4 "(&0I0" 0 (" I "(0 K"(K( " "(?"4"C/
-/ O5(" (" ( 0I 04(" 0 5'"(" ("C0 "4?O" " &(0""& 5 % 4" OCC0 L 44 "4 ( ( "" ?O5(" "((?O"0 "(O %"0 /
( ""K K3 " C" 4" '( & 0"?9(4( "(0('0 (&K" (4(0? K " ( ( / ( 4("& 0( 4" 3 (4(0 ' 5"C 3 " *- 1& C" (
+-+*..- ),*+,-)
' ( 0 ( " 0(: '" 3 %"0 0(0 ( L&0""" 5K":( '" 3( K" /
"4 "( <("/
P/ %"0 K %("( (("K ( '" ("' (44"& ' ( %( "& $("5 (" %("( 0("& (0 0" & 9 4" %("( O((4"0 " (%9 & *P0",68P&?"5"4"&?K( " C&?"%("((("K 0("$</
3 "( ((00 (" I " (44 %("( ((/
('& ( ( 0 "4 "(& "K35"KK@D222222B(44" %("(((?"5 "4"?K( " C?"%"<& K94" 3 " 'K3? "5C<0 "?"%"</
?@D222222B!01222222""K'("$C84'" "5%("(&4" 3 "F7 1= "(" "(< ( '"(' $C0 /
J/ (" " O5(" ( 4" 4"C (0 ( O %"0 /
!01222222( K& ( KK9(&( (0 3 " ""K ( 3 @ A222222B& K3 3 9( ?" C3" / 5"KK'" ( 3 '" %" $C& K 3 (" " "0 ( /
"( & 3"4 "( "H " (0 "( (00""(4"5 "( "(/
7/ ( ( "(0"" "'K""( "4"C& ?'(""('"" ( "4" " ( "50(" 0 1E83-../)/
/ O"4 "( ? C" "( ( 5 (" "( ""< O (" "(& 0 & (0 C'" O"4 "( (" "(&(("(O (" "(O5(" ( ,. 9( ? P 0(" ( " O (" "( O5(" ; / J. 1>/ & ( 3 " J8 1& 0 (( "(&("5?'"C )K 0("&'"" "4"
+-+*..- ),8+,-)
" ( " " I )(0 ( 35(" "( 3 %"0 /
00 ((3 "('5 "J. ? J8 1& 0 "4"C 0 0"" "' 1E,../) ? 1EP.O.../) 3"4 "(? 1 ?"(" "( 3" "( "" K35 (" "( ""< (" "( K3 '(" /
%/ ( 4"5 0( "(& 30"" "( 9(" 3 C ('(" 3" "(/ 9"" "( K3 35</ 0 (" "( & C'" 4K "4 "( (00" "" (( "(" ;!0(" ("&,67-&/F*J->/
0 0"" "' ( & " < 0 " "C "0 0 ("" ( K (0 0"" "' 0"< " 0 " 5" ; +7,8+*..,F0%*..,H/!&(" 0"" "4= ( L& (0*&*..*&/,86),F,H/ #/ 1# & #$V"M"$# 4$ =C0"( MC# 4%S" & & P<0 " "(& G"$ *..F& / 8J>/ O " K K( " " 0"" "'(" I 4"5 (0 ""C5C" (" ; +7,8+*.., " >/ ' O " , " * (" C'(" *. 0% ,67, ; ) +8+,>& " : " 4" " "( "(" "( C ( ( " *,0% ,68J ; ) # 8,,/>& ( ' 5 "( ' C" (?O "*F/
"""K( ' " (00"4 &4U )( 4(0O"0C"C/#(""K"O( 0" &O0"" "((" 4"''" 4"O (" ; / # & " (" 0"" "4& '(/ *& $R & ,67F& / PFP)
PF7 H / *. 0% ,66F> 9(" O C ('(" O" "( ( "4"C 0 ; +*8F+*.., 8 '" *.., H +*-7+,666 F0",666""KI " >/9"" "(KO O5<; +,8,+,66J,74'",66J>/ 4"&O0(" ""(( "(" ; +FF8+,66J-(U ,66J>/
/ 3<& "% 0" K !0 1222222 5(" " (0 44 "'0 %"0 ( '" $C/ "( "4" " &4(3 "J81& ( K3I /
+-+*..- ),F+,-)
'$& "% 0" K !0 1222222 '" 5(" @ G222222B I %4" (" "("&K33'" C" ( %"0 (4(00 5 <C C&K33'" (%"C "(( "5' ("%("(((("& K&&((04"C" ( 3 %"0 /
C'" 35(" "( 0 @ G222222B (" I "'"&"K3"3C" K3( "(("((5& ( " "('" "((( ?(0(:/ ' 0I0 3C" 3% (0 ( & 3"4 "( 3: K < 0/
'$& 4" 0 (" %("( ( ((" ? "5 5"C ("& " C" ( (4(00 5 5"C (" I (" (00 C'&3 K( ?9? 0"?30(5"<0 "4 "(/
"( & "%"4"C?!012222220 1E,O.../)&""(" "C" (/
6/ 'K"<&( "0 0"/0(0 1E -../) 0" ? $C ( 0(0 0I0 0( ? $C 0 3((0" ; / 7J >/ "0" ( 1E,O.../) ( ? ( ? $C3 /
$"% "
&'()*+
'% ( " 9 *8 9" *..- !0 1222222 ( ""( 0 9 "&(" " *80"*..-H
(),+
30 "0 H
" 30? 1E,3.../)H
""( K(H
+-+*..- ),-+,-)
0 ?$C!012222220(0 1E-../)H
0 ?$C 0 3((0" 0(0 1E-../)H
(?!01222222"0" 1E,O.../)?$C3 H
(00"K I ? ! " #$%& '( ( "" KO 0 3((0" /
#"C = !0(':&" &!01"&!/ $"&!0(&9C& !/(&9C /
(0 "%0"" "4=
C44"<)9" 9/= '")" = !/ ((" /(':
("(4(0 I (00"K5 "/
<'& C44"<=
+-+*..-