Contractual Performance and Breach Dispute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose regarding a contractual obligation involving a specific performance, leading to litigation over whether the claimed performance had been duly tendered or if a material breach had occurred due to an alleged failure in that regard. The court reasoned that the existence and sufficiency of the tender were matters of factual determination, and upon review of the evidence presented by both parties, it found that the claimant failed to establish the required performance, thus affirming the lower court's finding of breach, while also addressing and rejecting various affirmative defenses raised by the breaching party, including arguments related to waiver and cure.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Performance and Breach Dispute: The court reasoned that the existence and sufficiency of the tender were matters of factual determination, and upon review of the evidence presented by both parties, it found that the claimant failed to establish the required performance, thus affirming the lower court's finding of breach, while also addressing and rejecting various affirmative defenses raised by the breaching party, including arguments related to waiver and cure.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order concerning the distribution of court costs.
Testo completo
! "#$%
$%! &&&&&& ' ( '' )) '' ' (* )
!"#
'
() *+ ,,,,,,- .+++/ 0 *1+- ++ 2 3.+ ++3+3+/)
!) ('4+!&�&$5%!-+++6+1+ +++/72+8+2942:6+)+ 0(&(;."576+3+/+#&;."5) 3</+ .=/+/-/3.88+8++>%;."5)
6+6/8+++6((46+!&&')
>) *),,,,,,3//96+!%46+!&&'8+6+ 72+6++5?@,,,,,,+++6/5+43 2+0223+)47+-+6+330 /.++/+)216+3A5A7+26+ ++/ 0 3 6+) 3+- + 6+ B . A/A 7+ + 6+ 6+B-2372+6+9+6/5+36+)
C) /++ (! 8/6+ !&&'- 6+ .9+ 6+=+D+ 3<EF G3/+3.+2/+ .+ 3 .++.. /=- +/ 72+ 2=++ 2 +8+ =6 H <= ++ +< 2+ (# +/ ( +8//+++<(!/.9($%ID F'C()&(G)
%) 3/(&.!&&'-*),,,,,,/++ 3< +9.+++8)2H<6+7++/+35/2/+ 36+/32+(# )+6+.+=/+/ 2 =) 3- 2 ++ +< .++7?5+/-+.++6+/+8+H/0 I&;."5)2H<6+72+6+..+6+J7(%;."5 >% ;."5) 8+- + +=+ 72+ 26+ //- 7 /++33.+<+8+/+HJ../6<72+6+3+ +8..+)
4+=+2. KL#%&) 72+6+B0724+ /.. KL#&) +2/+7+/)
#) 3+ // 2 + .3+ 3!&6+!&&') 3+/H3++)
"$%!"!&&' >"#
) 8+6+72+6+9+3.++3 2+02@,,,,,,0<6.+/=.0+ )
9) 3/F 3+//++7/-8. .++../=)
') F7+-//=/04=)
' )
() 4/ .3 + 6 4+++ .3/- 69D)%# +M=++4+++!!6.9($C( !&%N)#>)(+)+3/.+++6(! 3.9($I% %(&G)
!) K+/-6+.H+.=//6/5+3+ I&;."5-7++-++6++9++/ 869 M+ C +/ ( M <= +++<(>6.9($#!D F'C()((N L(!( (!'- ($$%##CG)FM+/%.J.+3++-+=H36 ++7 M 6+ .H+.- + / 33+9 + 3 +.++=//6+)
F 4+3 +9 8// .+< MH< 6+ 0 MH/+M+/-+++7+M35//3/- /3.6+.H+.+/%0!%;."5+ 3 =6+/ 7+ 4+8+ +.3 6+. M+ (# +/ > D L (!> (&#- ($$' '!%- +) !9- 33) '!I '!$ /8) +)G) M+8+ 3++<. /=<- + / 0 . .+++6D)(#)C G)
7/3.+!#!$;."5-8=6+/ .1D L(!C !%$G+.3+7<= =//+3.+ M+(#9+/!08 NM+/+8+ +3 MH.+ + M3<- + 36+ +9. + 7M+ M/+ 3 3 0 M+/+ M +/) H. + + 7MH3+. 4= M.+++ 0 + 3.+ + D L (!# CI +)!3)%(G)
65- /3. >& ;."5 3 O 3++3 + 9+=+ 3.+ + 8 .+8 H3+ 36 4+8+ MH< 6+ H 8 M.9++ +
"$%!"!&&' C"#
9+=+ 3.+ +- 6 =6+/ .+ = 7M+ 367) + - 4+3 +< 7 ..+6++=+<M<=8.D) (#)!)08 N)$&5)! N L(!> (&#- ($$' '!%- +)!-3)'>(/8)+)N L(!>>'-+)(-33)C& C(-F($$'33) %!' %!IN "'>%"!&&%(6.9!&&%G)
+3++333+97+++++ 869 7 // 8+8 + 9 .6+) M=+- 88- .+<- M /+/ + 86+73+9M/=+/+.4++9D L(($9 (%#NF($$>3)%>%N L((I($&N(&I9#'N(&C9%(G)
>) 8./. 0 2+ C +/ % 2 <= ++ +< (> 6.9 ($#! F 'C()((G- A7 +=H++726+.H+.- +33+9+ 3+.++=//6+A)
23<-6+/++++.+/0#&;."53I&;."5) /72H<6+>%;."5)
C) +H3/-H<6+++8+ =6 2+ (# +/ ( 3+72 ++- 3+ +7 . = /+/ 2+) .+ = 9+ 88+ D "!%#"!&&# $ .+ !&&#G) F + < 3++< 36 + 0 +/ 7 ++ 2=9+/+H23+8+D "'!&"!&&%!%9 !&&%G.++3/+/23<)
%) 7+9+38+/=/3-H +363.8+H.+8/+.++../= 7+9+230JH.+/D L(>!!>C-+)!)>3)!>' 588H+G)
#) 3+.8/-4/)
/.. KL C&&) .+ 0 5= D) I' G)
"$%!"!&&' %"#
+ ') '
,-.$ /
/69+4/(&.!&&'3*+,,,,,, /++6+.9+6+=+(!8/6+!&&'++ 3.++3/+.+N
.$%/
4N
.05=/.. KLC&&) N
+ 7- 8./. H + I! +6 + 8// +9 8// (' 4+ !&&% D L F ('>)((&G- 3/ J 3 J 3/ 4 7+ +6 +8++ 3 6 +9 8//- 3 6+ .+<+39+N./.++++7+- .+8.1363+=.+N+ + J / +9 8//- (&&& (C- 3 6+ 3 3 6+ /+7 H ++ M+ C! L) 3/ J 3+< 3+ - +67/ .. .1 36- +6 J 4+ 0 M6+N
..+73/J0*+,,,,,,-6+.9+ 6+=+++720M88+8//0)
F+/=E *)15<-3/+-*.K+-4=)
. +9.+++8E
=88+< 4+E 3/+E )+ F+=+ L)15<
"$%!"!&&' #"#
3+8.J//..+7/H3+)
<6- =88+<E
"$%!"!&&'