Property Owners v. Unit Owner Regarding Equitable Division of Maintenance Responsibilities
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed a dispute concerning the proper interpretation of governing documents related to the division of common areas among property owners. The central issue involved determining the method for calculating the proportional share of maintenance responsibilities when the original formula yielded disproportionate results under changing circumstances, specifically regarding a significant enlargement of one unit's exclusive use area without a corresponding change in the ownership structure. The court reasoned that the controlling documents, read in conjunction with their stated purpose of achieving equitable sharing, supported an interpretation that required recalculating the proportionate interests based on the actual exclusive use areas to ensure fairness, overriding a strict adherence to the outdated initial allocation when equity demanded adjustment due to the subsequent alteration in the physical premises.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; IMPÔT À LA SOURCE ; COMMUNICATION ; OPPOSITION(PROCÉDURE) ; DÉLAI ; RETARD ; PRINCIPE DE LA BONNE FOI | Impôt à la source : notification d'attestations-quittances à la recourante. La contestation des montants prélevés est tardive car formée un an après réception des attestations. La seule absence du pays ne saurait justifier le retard d'une réclamation tardive, l'intéressée qui devait s'attendre à une communication devait prendre les mesures nécessaires à la sauvegarde de ses droits. | LIS.23.al2 ; LIS.27A ; LPFisc.41.al3
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for allocating the costs of the proceedings.
Testo completo
!!! ! "!# $%
! !
!"#
!
'( )*++++++,--.*-/*-0.1-*, .. *---. 23 '4 1 !&&' 5& 3*1 !&&5(
!( /.-'63-!&3-!&&!,)*++++++3-. /-..++++++7( (
)*++++++.8*3-./9++++++7( (':6- ': 6- !&&!, !: 6- '; 1 !&&! !' 1 5' .*1!&&!(
5( )* ++++++ .. -*/. < - 90 /= 0.!&&!(
7>- 9-.'463-!&&5, ?@#&!,;& ?@'A4#;,$%.. < -/= /29++++++7( (
7- 9-%B.3-!&&5, ?@%#%,'& ..<-/=/2-..++++++7( (
$( '; *- !&&%, )* ++++++ B*. .*- /2 0*--- B- C- /2D @ E, 3 / * *1*-.8*<-0-*/F/.3.<( >. < 9G > - 9- .1- / 9++++++7( (,.'463-!&&5(
%( 5H!&&%,0 @ ...*--31()*++++++ I=-2- 9-%B.3-!&&5,.*-.- -3(
#( !& H !&&%, )* ++++++ .-- .*- 0 @ /2 -- *-2 0-*/FC- /2D )E( 3-9G*1* 0-*/F/.3.<-03-=- 9- 9++++++7( (9!%*-!&&$(
4( .-- # 3*1 !&&#, ) 6. )*++++++ / -3. .*-( )* ++++++ 0-39-*-B.->/6-B-(
"$#%$"!&&# 5"#
;( % .*1 !&&#, )* ++++++ /2 -1 *---B.-- )( /--/.. >/-- -, */.. 9 -3. .*- 3- G >. / - 01 /I( )* ++++++ /.3-0-$'-.5-/.B-$1!&&' C@- 5'4E-3-9-.7-/-!$63-!&&5( .8-.8*90- 9-%B.3-!&&503-6*-.. /-*-<0 @ -B-J(
*1*0-0-*/F<(
:( ./';63-!&&4,0 @ -9)*++++++ /3- -8 3- 3-. / -.. ++++++ 7( ( !&&!( .9, - - -*1- *- .*- '; *- !&&%(0- 9-*-/-..*--%B.3-!&&5 *-( 4 B.3- !&&5 - -.. *- < 0*--- B- - ./--3 / 0. !&&! 9 B-8-)*++++++(
0 @ /.--9)*++++++..*---.7- '4 1 !&&' 5& 3*1 !&&5 < B-K- 0BB- //-C- /2D E(
0 @ 6 < B-*- .-- 9.(
'&( ':63-!&&4, )/--.-/--B .--(
''( -!$63-!&&4,/- ..-B*.9 .-8.<68(
!
'( 6. */ - 3 6--- */., 31C(%# -08--6---!!3*1':$' !&%L(#5('-(-/.*---3'! /*1':;% %'&E(
!( 7 0- !5 -. ! - 0-*/-- < / /KI-9 * !5 /*1 '::$ C7 5 !&E, -119-*<9--B-/ ./ .*- .- *-3. /2 ./* D E - 0--9-..*-3-6*-
"$#%$"!&&# $"#
B.3- 0. 9- - / 9 0-*/F .. D 690 5' **G* .L1E-0- ..*-.-*D 5&69--3*-,*-/5'.*10. 9--/90-*/F..(
..-6,.*--30319- -11 .1- 9, / - 3- *---, 3- -3-, *-,01/I/0*-B.->,-..*/GK. /..*-*/-90-0./.5&6/2 B-0*/GK*C($'(5@-//-1/3-0(!4 7E(
5( .-.*-B->./--/-- -*/.-3 - /1-( , /--/, / /-1 0G /8.C('#(''2/K E,-./,-0/ .8-- *G*( --,-9-08-/.-/-B .--9-B1-8-C "'$!"!&&4!&*!&&4 .B.-.L "%4&"!&'1!&&#E(
B*6.3.C('#('!2*/K E( .8, - I - /.- 9 *1 - .3.* >---*/.3--19-3-K/K20-3-. 0-.. 9- 0-*/ < - 0>.- B= -.--1 C "'$!"!&&4 !& * !&&4 .B. -. L "%4&"!&&# 5' 1!&&#E(
$( 0/2, - 9- '4 63- !&&5, .3..*-';*-!&&%(
7 6-/ , - 9- - 0 < 3- -- BB-- / * .- < 38-( --,B-3<0.8/*/ 90 .- 0-*/-1--. -9 3 7- C "4$:"!&&'!43*1!&&'.B.-.E(
896-B-./-01/I C($'(5@-E( --9G/-7-!$63-!&&5(7 B-K- 0 , -.*---.7-6905& 3*1!&&5( -2B-B-,1-9-/.*- 3 .- .- ( 8 - 0/2, - /* - 90- - .- -*/-1 /. .*-*/-,B-./<0.8(
"$#%$"!&&# %"#
)G*-0-<9--93-=- 9-, - !% *- !&&$, .*- .. *- 3 (@9.*-.-.-3(
%( 0<6-9.*-,0 @ ,/- ) , -.. 9 0-.. 3- 8- -3* 9 .*-.----31(
#( 708-0- 9-%B.3-!&&5,- 6*-03-=-J(
4( /--/1B--*/G/.//-, 0 < -/0-.9/0*--.( -9-30>- 0.----88--F-/--/1 B-C "4$:"!&&'!43*1!&&'.B.-.E(
;( 0- 9-9-*-%B.3-!&&5 *-(9.-*---.7-< *-.( 23<1-0 @ ./'; 63- !&&4, /3- -8 3- 3-. / -.. ++++++7( (!&&!( B-80--./--3-.. . 4 B.3- !&&5 0. >- !&&!( B-, - - 3 9 0 * C ?@ %#%,'&E 3-9 *1* < 0- /2 -1 *---B /.-.* - 0-*/F < B-8 0- 9-%B.3-!&&5(
:( )B.,6.(
.** ?@ %&&( *- < K8 9- *1C(;4 E( MMMMM
$! !
&'()*+
.31-6.%.*1!&&#/)*++++++ .----*-20-*/F#3*1 !&&#L
"$#%$"!&&# #"#
(),+
6L
*<K8.** ?@%&&( L
- 9, B*.* > - ;! -3 - B.. -1 B.. '4 6- !&&% C @ 7 '45(''&E, /. G / G /. 6 9- -3 -B-- / 3 -1 B.., / 3- *-2-/1-L*.*----9-, *-B*I/3/-8*-L- - G . -1 B.., '&&& '$, / 3- / / 3- .-9 > -- 0- $! @( /. G /-2 /- , -39. *I /3, -3 G 6- < 03-L
-9/.G<)*++++++--90<-- *-20-*/F<0*---B-(
7-.8D )(IK2,/.-,)*3I?-,)( K.-,)*, 68(
* -1*---BD
8BB-2 6-D /.-D (- 7-8- @(IK2
/-B*G..-9.>/-(
23, 8BB-2D
"$#%$"!&&#