Contractual Asset Division Dispute and Offset Claim Denial
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute involved the proper division of proceeds from the sale of certain assets following a contractual relationship breakdown, centering on whether certain obligations had been fully discharged or whether an offset was due. The court reasoned that the language of the governing agreement clearly established a formula for distribution which did not account for the specific offsetting claim being raised, finding that the claim was either waived, inapplicable under the agreement's terms, or superseded by subsequent actions and settlements, thus upholding the original distribution method and denying the claimed offset.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Asset Division Dispute and Offset Claim Denial: The court reasoned that the language of the governing agreement clearly established a formula for distribution which did not account for the specific offsetting claim being raised, finding that the claim was either waived, inapplicable under the agreement's terms, or superseded by subsequent actions and settlements, thus upholding the original distribution method and denying the claimed offset.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision was cited in the dispositive section regarding the costs of the federal proceedings.
Testo completo
! "#$%
& '(((((((((( !!""##$%&"
"
)** +*,,
'()*'
*
-. $$"/ $(+"&01(,,(%23$"&$ 4 " "$ 4$ "$ % $1 3$ 4" $"$ ""00 $1 "0 $ 50#% $$ 6!7 89$ $ 89" 9$% " /0$ !0 ::::::::::. $$ """ -*"&01(,,;%3 $1 0$/ $.</ ""00$ /3 $"3$ $&$ "0$=
!0 :::::::::: "44 "1 89$3 < $" $4 0"8 $" / "% " "1 "0 "4"0 ""/ % 50# >"$#$ "$" </ $ 0$ $$$$$ ! -- &$ (,,-. " 50#% !0 :::::::::: "44$ </$ 0$4 0" &9$. "1 $ $$ 3 & <$ ->$ -??@ $'$&$ $0" 0$ 90 "1A0 89$3 $" " A $$A0 $0$" . "# $ 0 0$ $44$ $'$ $ "2 B "189$3%" "/$.
<<&$ < 89$ $3& <$ . $ "1 "$ $ "0" 0 % <$" $4 3< &$ " $ $" / " $ / 0$0 3< &$ $ 2 <$ "1 < $ 89"#A. "1 89$3 $ " $ $ 3 & <$ . $" "1 /$/ < $4% $ &$!0:::::::::: $ C,D 3& <$$ &$< $ $2< $&$ "4$"'0E0. <8&$ $ 0 "$"0$"" .
(. F $"" %"$" &3</ ""G$ 2 3 !0 :::::::::: $ "$ "00 2 &$2C,D $3<'$&$$ &$ 4$/ -"H -??I.
</ " $&$ ># # 2 $ "$ . "$ * >&$ (,,C% $ $$3 3 !0 :::::::::: $ J $$ &$2C,D$-"H -??IK.
@. $" 0$</ $% $&0 (->&$ -C4&$(,,C.
)(+,)(,,- '@)*'
. " !0 ::::::::::% <$ " &$ &$ $0 $ #&$ 0"8 $$ 3 $1 &$ >2 >#. $ $ $'$ "1 89$3 $ ". "00 "# $ 0 0 $ <0 3$$ 3 &/'$< $ #0 . "3%""&$ E 0$ $ 5. .L$'A=$M"02$&=
' $0$ >"$A "00 $ L (, 2 -,, DM - 0 -??*@->$ -??IN
' $0$ >"$A "00 $ L (, 2 C, DM - "H -??I@-0$(,,,N
' $$ 3< <$&$$ % "00 $ 2 &$ <'$&$$ 4% " $&$$ 2 C, D A - >$ (,,,.
4$%$&$ $&" 76@IO+?-%+,% #$ - >&$ -??@ @- >&$ -??? A $" $">2G<'$&$$ <$ $0.
1. $$ " &"1 2</ $50#4 / "1& $" 3< &$ "$$ (* >&$ (,,C " $ 3$ &$ / $!0::::::::::-??C.
" $" 0=J$8" $ & $" $50#" $&$ "< .5$&$ %$$ H$""4$ <$ E "11K.
2 $% 0% "00 " $% 3< "& / $$$$$$"$ "". &$ >2$ "$" & $143$<&$ $&$.
;. 5" 0 " "$% !0 :::::::::: &$&0 $ $3 $ " $% J0$" P9/$&< "$# $ %0$" 4&K.
C. >##"$"3<$$ !0::::::::::& &"$"4$0$$"</ $% 50#"(@0(,,C3<$&$ 44 $&0 &$2<"44$ " <'$&$$ " A& L$'A= M 01-??I 201-???. $"%$&$ &(,,, "$.<&$ >0$< $& $$ $ $0"$1 <$ &$ & "$ </ $ . "3<$ &$ G $10$$"</ $%$<&$ "&$ " $"%$$ 40 .
)(+,)(,,- ';)*'
"$ 0$/ $ #2>#.
*'
-. &1$$ ">2 0$$$" / $ (+"&01(,,(.
(. . "$0"$4$ "$O"#$ $">$$$-;"&01(,,(% 3 $1 " "$% &$# - "H (,,@. A % $1 0$$ $4 4" $" "00 $1 " . % & O $ @ $($ "$%$ "$ & $10$$ $4& O &$#"$" $ $ ># >$$ $".
1. "$4 $#"$ "$+ " "1 (,,, L Q 5 I@,.-M &$# - >&$ (,,@ B0"$4$ $""01$"$ $"#"0$ "$. ""1 %OA #$$"$ $" % &$# >3< @- 01 (,,(. 44 % <A >$% #$ $" $1 9#0 A# "$ 3$ $ &$#"$ $"< 4$ 3$"$ E $>$$30 "3$"3>$$3L .I( N 6 -(*;+*"$.-N-(+-++"$.;1N )-C@)(,,@-I0(,,@M.
@. 3 $" 8 $ 2 $ 3 $$ 3< " </ $0$" #0 $$"/ $ (+ "&01 (,,(. " 00 " $ #&$ 0"8 3 " $1 4 % < $ A $ "0 A3 $$ $ $ 89$3$"00 "# $ 0 0$. $'$ < <A " . E 3$4$ $$A0 "#%<$ < "$ ->$ -??@ < ">""3.
;. "0$ "$% ># 4" $$"% 4 $"$ $" " $ "$ 4$ 3$% 4 <E 1$ 0$A $4 1% $ "00 &$011% < '2'$ 3$ #&$01" .44$ "3< 4$ $ E "$ 0 "00 98" 9A "$1. 0$ " 0 4$ #"&$#1%>#"$ %9 % $ /3$$$ "11L 6--?*"$.@).? 4$ M.
)(+,)(,,- 'C)*'
$$%>#< 0" $4$0$/"$" < / $ 0$ >$$$% P9 </ $0 0 "$$2$"$ $"> $4$<$ 0$/< 4$ ".5">$%& " $ $" < < / $ >$$$ 4$ 3 '$ " $ " $ $". " % "3 < $$ 0 "$$" " $% 2 0 $0 " $ $" </ % " /% " % $ $" $&# "$"$>#"%1"$%$ $" "00 $"4"0<"&/ $0$L 6--I(I+ "$.-1.((?N )+*I)(,,(-("&01(,,(M.
<A% </ $ 50# " 2 " "$ $" >$ $$'./0$</ $2 "$$ $ $ "$ "$ $# " $ " /3 $"3$$&$ "0$.< "" $ 3 % 3$ $ $"01 % 0$ 9# $ / "$"/$$ 3<$"%2&"$3!0::::::::::<&$ < 89$ $3& <$ %3< $ "1 "$ $ "1 "0" 0 % 3 <$" $4 " "44$ $ $30 $"/"" $&2<$ - >$ -??@. "1 89$3 $ $$ $ $ &<$ . 2$ &$% $ C,D 3 & $ - "H -??I. $" <$$ &$ "0A " $3<"" " 4""$ </ $50# " $1. 3 < $ $0 & & "00 $ % 3$ " .
C. <$ $0 99 2 0 " <$ <"1> $&$ </ 0$R& $14 " $3<&$ '
0E0 0 -??C 3$ &$ >2 " 2 $ < / $ $$$$$%23"$<$ $0" 2"&%31$0E0 1" "$ $1 4 . 50# 8 $0 4 "$ $" 98" 9A " $ " 3$$ "!0:::::::::: <"S$&$ &$2<'$&$$ %$<8$0 " "1$ 50#% $" " 3 $ <" 0 0 < "$"</ % $144"'
$.
$$ $0 1$ 3 "1 " "44 !0 :::::::::: 98$3389$3" $$
)(+,)(,,- '+)*'
3 & <$ $ $ 2 $ & $" 2<.
+. "3% " 0$. $$" ""$ $" -I 01 (,,, &"8 2 $ "$ .
*. $ $#% 0"0 0$ 2 9# " . 4$ </ $% 2 9 76 @O;II%;C " $ 2 9# < A&. $0$ " 76 (O,,,.' "2" %29#$.
TTTTT
-+*' . *
/$%0
0 "!0::::::::::N
$$"""$ $"$ 5. .-I01(,,,N
"0$ 5. .2&2!0::::::::::=
' "00 (,2-,,D$0$ >"$A-0-??* @->$ -??IN
' "00 (,2C,D$0$ >"$A-"H -??I @-0$(,,,N
' <$&$$ "00 $ 2 <'$&$$ 4 " /<$&$$ C,DA->$(,,,N
' "00 76 @IO+?-%+, & $ E 2 C D A @- >&$ -??? A $4$ $"'$0$ $"N
&"$"$2$ 5. .4$3<"A 0" $ N
$ 3O$O GO0"0 N
0 29#< A&4$</ $29 76@O;II%;CN
)(+,)(,,- '*)*'
" 2 !0 :::::::::: 2 9# $ 5. . $0$ " 76(O,,,.'N
$ 3% "4"00 / $ ?* $& "$ 4 O"#$ $" >$$$% E E " %&"$""$ 0$$ $4% >"A" $4$ $"%A $14.$ E ""#. 00"$ " % "$ /0$% $14%59U$V9"43$+%+,,;N
"00$3 E 2 ! !" "##$% &" " % 2 $ 5. .$$3<2<"44$4"$.
5$# = !.89A%$ %!07$%!. 9$%>#.
"0 $10$$ $4=
#44$A'>$ >.= $ = !. ""$ 6.89A
"$"4"0 E "00$3/ $.
A&% #44$A=
)(+,)(,,-