Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/194/2005 • CJ GE ATA/194/2005 Generato dall'IA

Witness List Challenge Denial Affirmed Due to Lack of Diligence

Numero d'incarto ATA/194/2005
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Accolto (Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The court reviewed an appeal concerning the application of a procedural rule related to the filing of a motion challenging the adequacy of a witness list, where the movant argued they could not have discovered the necessary facts earlier due to the opposing party's lack of cooperation. The court determined that the movant failed to demonstrate sufficient diligence in seeking the required information or establish the requisite exceptional circumstances justifying the untimely filing, thus affirming the lower court's denial of the motion because the procedural rule requires demonstrating that the failure to timely assert the claim was due to a cause beyond the movant's reasonable control.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

TAXI; COMPORTEMENT; POLITESSE; VOIE PUBLIQUE; OBLIGATION JURIDIQUE; AMENDE ADMINISTRATIVE | Chauffeur de taxis condamné au paiement d'une amende de CHF 300.- suite au dépôt d'une plainte pénale d'une cliente à son encontre. Classement de la procédure pénale compte tenu des versions contradictoires des personnes en cause. Amende annulée par le TA pour les mêmes motifs. | RLST.26 al.1; LST.31 al.1; LST.29 al.1; LST.21 al.1; LPA.19

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
insinuazione del credito controllo della procedura mancanza di prova circostanze eccezionali procedimento pregiudiziale d'urgenza interrogatorio formale di testimoni

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs for the federal procedure.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs to the partially successful party.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo

        

        

  

   



 !"#"$%&'





&'#"((((((((((  ! ""#$%# 

# 

)  ** * +*, -+** )+  ) 





     &'()&

* 

-.  !#"  //////////$   -0+' 1"&23 !. ////////// #  # 4$#5"""//////////$-',+2%$6$"-7%" -00+$#7"#877 6"."'9#%5:',,*$"; %  #";6#7"#<" 877" %5"   "#5 %5#=.

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

B.  !. //////////        >5"  #%"  '- 5" ',,*.  %"  77 "%5  "  "   -* 5" ',,* 6  #  5"" ##"?#"6. 5#5 =$&""%" " <;" "5<"  @A',.&."%" 5""#:C > " 5 <;  # ;>  5< $ 5"  " %"  # <; ;%" #7""."%" ##;% " " # $  <; %"  7.  " %"  # "  <;" "   #". E  5#5 $" %" #% # %#"    # "%8". %" 5"#:  # #;5F8 ".A"5 $" ;%"  " # "   %#" .   "      "  #  % ;"55:.%" C#"8."%" 5"""     #"  # %  ;"55:   " %"    --G. 2 <<5" $# "  8 $;"<"  <"

('*+*(',,* &B()&

 " $ " " %"  6"< <;"  "  ;F  =.   #  "  #88 @A-,.&5< .%" 7" <" ?" $ #" " "  ".;%" 88?7"=;  <"  "  @A-).&.

*.  #"#  "# " #">7"  " #  '+#H ',,*.

+.   "7" $ 5 C "$#" " 1"&23  5 4  "7#5 !. //////////$  #"  ''  5: ',,*$ <;"%" 5<%#"># #""%"  <;";%"  "%<" #H5 5". 7" $"%" %"#  " '9 " -   B' " *  2>5  ;6 "#   #"   %"  6"  ) 5: -000 1 6" I @ - B,.,-4.   5  %">" ##55""  "%" "#; "B- "-#"%" 6"'95-0001 6"I@-B,4  "5 "" ?!.//////////"--# #:',,*#7"%#" #:% "#.

9.  !. ////////// ;   5"  '0  5: ',,*.  ;%"   #%";"" %" -*5"',,*.;%" C5"7 5 J?" .

G.   ""#  * #%5: ',,*$   5   "7"> ? !. //////////55""  "% @AB,,.&.

).  !. //////////  ""  ": 5""  "7 ; # #   ""#"  '5:',,*.

   #   #" %"     :"      <  %"#   " $ "#5 ". "7 "#<"" " #8 ; " 7#.% " 5 ##5    %"# # " #"  #     #  <  "> ;%" #.

  ;%"   #7"#.

  # ?; "#""#<.

0.  #B-C%"',,+$ 5 ; ###. ##:  5 ## " " ## # $ "%" 5"7 5 # %?#%#"># #"". 5#    ;5  @A B,,.&  8 "    ""   ## "#" .

('*+*(',,* &*()&

-,.   ": 5""  "7     "77  # >#"     77"05',,+.

 .  5#" D//////////  #7"5 <  -* 5" ',,*$ 6 %"#  5"" $#<; " ;#"55:$%" %%#"" <" " "  %  8#55 <; #""    #  # .  " %"  5 "  %"  :#" ;"$   %"  #   <; ;%"   ;" :". &" " %"  #  ;77"5 "%    ; "  5"?. #5 <;"5<"  @A-,.&?%#""#> # <877 6"%#" "5# 8K# 88;#" $%" ##877 %" < !5 ////////// 5# "  88 ;>  5< . "&" %"  7. %" #7" "## @A-,.&5< .  %" #5>%#""C<;?# 5 &" " "<. #%" #?< "#%#""#"%"   5#5 7" . ;%"   #% "#  877  6"    %#"". < C#  $ &" " %"  "  <;%" #" # 877.

 :. !5//////////   #7"5 "#?#". "<;%" 75 877 6"#  > ".  #%"    5 2 :"K    %#="    <;" #"   7" "   %"  .   # " < % ; "  5J   877$  ;%"   %# < "&" ;#5> ? #  5 . E  5$  877 " %"  5"     < 7">"   5#     #.    #%"   ;" = %"   ###  6".  %"  # "    #L   ###877.

 .   ? ;"$  #   6"< <;" %"  7 <  >25# 88;> 8K$" " "":<;#"  ? #<  #" "%" .  %"  ## ?  "   ;#5> % # # 5  ; "$5"&"%"  7 " "  <; ;%"   #7"  ". #   $ " %"  #%    %" "5   " $    <  >  "  88;> #=# %" .

   6 <;"%" 7 ;" " $"5 "  ;F =8 .#"<#"" "" 6877  6"  5  "2 ;" " .  %8$ " %"  5  8# # : 7" ;%#"  #:C  ; % " 5   ;F  #55>.D"" ; " %$"" # ?#"  "" 7" # "#.

  "" >#"" %"#7#"5#".

('*+*(',,* &+()&

   5#    ;5  "  "## "#$ # < "&5F5 ;%"  "5#  5# "" .

     5" ?  "  ; "    <" .  # "   ### %  5  ?  "     #% "  %"   #:25.

--.  D<#"$ >?C>.

* - 

-.   C   5  " %   C"" "# #5  $  #   %:1 .+9 #"M#>" "#C"""''#%5:-0*-& & ',+N .9B.-" .#"#5""  "%-'  5:-0)+& & +-,4.

'. .   6"  # :  ;  6"    #7"#    6#"  "#  6" #7#5 6 6">   "      5#"  :"< #=   "##55".

 :.  "'- '' 6"52 #:"> "#877  6#"  $ #   >   #" ;    #%#" 7"6  2>  #5# 5   #:"> "#8771 .'-.9 6"4.

 . D#; "'9"5" 6"$877 6"#   %#"># #""$# 55 ?;>> %"  #".  %#"  # #"" " "  # 55  6 # #     ## "# #"$ %#" >#".  ;>"  ; #:"> "# >$ #   C"  #7"5  %""  1 (9),(',,*  '* #H  ',,* 7" 4.

B.   #  #   %#" %"# # %#"  # #"" "" <  ;%#"5"<" H5 5".

    "#   "    5    ; :" %  "   #5   7" . ;  ;"  "#   %"# # " #"<" #!5. .

  %5 -*5"',,*;=  5#"" $ 7" ;"" 5     5"   %"5:  7" . E   >$  7"  <  #  "  :#8   ##  5  ;"5"<  "5  <;" ;= "   $      # $#5# 5 # "? 6".

*.    5 "2 5""  "%$  7"  #"%   "" F   :"

('*+*(',,* &9()&

M#77" $5#OM# "#:5 6">M #" <M #2? 88$2> " "#7% M"< .M55#"<$#<%7# 7 $ #"M# "#:5 6">M #" <M"$2>  M " )  # "%" "  -, 5: 0,G 1 D & D '-,4   ":  #>". #  7"  # "  "7 M #" $  7   % "#5: ? " <"    %#"   #"  1 A--' : 9GN .!$#" 5""  "73 5""  "7 # P$%#.$. -G)N . Q $ "  #"  5""  "7$ *25 .$ -00-$ # ','-N    7" 4.

  ;2$ #55%"&% $7" #8# M#   5#" " .   "  #  C> M :" 6&" ?  "  5#">># 55 #?<"6&"$M" " %$"  F  .C" ":7"#L ? > > #%#" M" "# 1 F   ": 7 '.9)(',,B  'B 5" ',,B$#".B.' F " 4.

+.    :";2<;"5<" ?>2#55 @A-,.& # >  #.  "$ "   >5   :"   # #   <  #   7 <  "  5#   ? #  5  #  ;> 5< .6" "#<;"##C "7"# " $  " "> $ #  ":   ;#   >" "55  #%#" <  877 6"" << "?<" <" "6 %#"<"  # " #.

     $ ;"  "#      ": 5""  "7 ;  # ;5 # 5   "<# " %"## %#"  # #"".  ": 5""  "7 2% <  #  6  #7"#""6$<;" ;C5" #?# #  <;";7" ;#:C ;55""  "%.

9.    ?  <"  "#52 $  #   6"< <  #5   "  "?5 ?>2 #%"%" #:25. #5# 77 "%5 5#  #$5#5 " 6"    ">   877.  #5    "  # :  "<;"  5" ;" "7"#5"" .

G.  %<"2$#5".

  ;"" ">$5#5 5"?8># . "5" # @A-M,,,.&"#$?8>;   2%1 .)G 4. RRRRR

('*+*(',,* &G()&



 +*- , *   



./&!"0

 %:#" C '5:',,*!#"////////// # ""# 5 C "$#" " *#%5:',,*N

/&'0

;5 N

""#*#%5:',,* 5 C "$#" " N

" <;"; J;5#5 N

#"5" # @A-M,,,.&# $?8>;   2%N

#55"<    F  ? !  " "#$ %#   #  "" <M  5 C "$#" " .

D"> 3 !5#%=$" $!!.=82$ 8"$C>.

#5 ":5""  "73

>77"2&C" C.3  %"&" 3     !. ##" .#%=   





('*+*(',,* &)()&





#"#7#5 F  #55"<6 ".

 2%$  >77"23           

('*+*(',,*