Implied Covenant of Good Faith vs. Express Contract Terms on Termination
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose regarding whether a non-statutory, implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing could be used to modify the clear terms of a written agreement, specifically concerning the termination of that agreement. The court reasoned that when a contract's terms are unambiguous and fully integrated, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing cannot be invoked to override or contradict those express terms; such a covenant is meant only to prevent one party from acting in a way that deprives the other of the benefits of the contract, not to rewrite the contract's explicit provisions regarding termination rights.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Implied Covenant of Good Faith vs. Express Contract Terms on Termination: The court reasoned that when a contract's terms are unambiguous and fully integrated, the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing cannot be invoked to override or contradict those express terms; such a covenant is meant only to prevent one party from acting in a way that deprives the other of the benefits of the contract, not to rewrite the contract's explicit provisions regarding termination rights.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive to rule on the costs regarding the third respondent.
Testo completo
!"#$%%%%%%%%%%
& '' ' (') *('' &( &
!"#
'
&' &()*!%%+, -.)./.-(01, . 23+4,&!&5.6"3-,((/)7., /. (.( 8. /39 (/): ) ;.. . / 6 (.( / <.
&54!,)...(13-'
)/.. / .. ;@*..( )/), . )./(A((/(1;.9
). 4 7-. !%%! 6(( /(./.)/)).!5/)*!%%&;.( (.68)/.),.!:'
6(( !% 7-. !%%$ / -.. .)/ 36 .. .3 -.. -.
-,A/(/.-.-;;. 1/.8/./.-.-&%7,.$) C2&D%%%' :'
). 6(( $% * !%%$ / - ;.)/ ). 8 *. -. 6 *.;@.;.-:-..)..)).&5/)*!%%$
8 C2E%%' ;):'
$' F( $& 7-. !%%#, (/) B( ;..
)/), 6. ;@*..( /@3 ;.-.( /B. -.6( 8' 5 ' & ' /. (.(&4*&55E !&+:'
(../(.(/5B(-.!%%#'
B.).?..(./@((.G 7H,1/.;66.;@1?B. /./'
#' (/&+)!%%#,(/);//('
"$!!"!%%# $"#
;)* B. /@( .. ? (.(. .B.)).B.).3*.?I./I.' .? (..- (. ' ) (. B) /../ //..(..?;17./ .*)...B'
' *
&' 7( )/ . - 7... )/(, -*8'#E .D6..7...!!-)*&5+& !%#J'E$'&.'. /()...-&! /)*&54# #&%:'
!' @( / (.. ?(, ?.( / 6.' .* )...B ). ?.( BB. )**, ? ;)/A ?( ;-. / 8 "&&4"!%%# 4 ) !%%#(B(.(:'
$' (().B.(/-./(-.., $7.!%%$8. /39-.:' ./(,&&7. !%%+,.,(-.6&/)*!%%+,).B.. !()*&5558. !&+'%:' I. .; 1@(1-.'
;I.6;@*..(?.B.6.;.(6..6-. /. (.( (( /. , . 1 (-.. , ;.5.(&(-.-9
G;..;66/;(?.;6(.( 8K: BB / ((, / 3 )/) 6.;@*..(/@3;.-.(-.6(H'
+' ' . D .)/.* - /@3 D.-.( -.6( D@*..(B.(6.3)D*7DF .*)...B9
..((76(?;(..)/.*-.;@*..( .B.)..-9)./-.B.A . )) I ./ B).. 8 "5%5"!%%$ 5 ()* !%%$:, / * B. C2 ED%%%' 8 "4!#"!%%! # -)* !%%!:, / (. / .)/ 8 "54&"!%%& &$ -)*!%%&:,/.(;.-)6;(*.) B.8 ">!&"!%%&E-)*!%%&:,/*.L68 "+4%"!%%& > M !%%&:, / . 8 "E4"!%%& $% 7-. !%%&:, / -
8 "E&!"!%%%&%*!%%%:,/BI().668 "4$"&555! B(-. &555:, / (.. ). 8 "5#>"!%%+ > ()* !%%+:, / (. / 8/ : 1 . ; .)/ -./3.((8 "&&4"!%%#4)!%%#:'
"$!!"!%%# +"#
-@, (( .(( )) )/.* - . ;@*..(-1;(6)1!#.38 "5$#"!%%+ $%-)*!%%+:,-;A),))61//.(( )*.6 ; *.? -F) 6( 8 "E4"!%%+ !% 7-. !%%+:,-..)..))61//.(())./ ).E-(/N?F8 ">$5"!%%$>*!%%$:, ). / - ; /. //. (.? )). / ).
8 "&>E"!%%&&$)!%%&:,)/B((B)..
8 "E4$"!%%&$%-)*!%%&:'
*' ;/3, B. /@( ?. ( . 1 )./((()).?;.(.)7' ;/ I , . (( )( 1 . /., . 1 I /. /.-.- .*( 1 )' B. ?. . /@( () ? / )O. . )F)' , ; . ; ; 6(.(..(/@*'/B., B(.(-.*)1..B.B. ?. . /@( . 1 / ?;. A (/ ).3 -.' ;. ? B (.- ;.. ..( B.)( / .*)...B'
#' (.. /., ?. / * (6 BB. 7./ .* ( 8B' ' "&&4"!%%# 4 ) !%%# (B( .(:, .B. /.) /../ //..(, D... DI /B. D6 (.( ( 1 . * -.(, . . D( / ?. //..;@*..('
B., ;. 1 .*( ().? ;.((, ?. ;I / /B. ;6 (.( /.-( ?. .* ;)* /B.?.. /).1 ..)F)A/, B./.)/'
E' )B(.F7('
()) C2 >#%' ). 1 @6 8' 4> :'
PPPPP
"$!!"!%%# #"#
('* ) '
+, -#.
(..(/)7.,/.(.($&7-.!%%#
, !.
7J
)1@6()) C2>#%' J
7.,/.(.('
0.(69 <)-A,/(.,<'A@3,<)C.,<' @(.,<), 76'
) .*)...B9
6BB.3 7.7' -. /(.9 <' . '-A
/.B)F(()).?(I/.'
3-, 6BB.39
"$!!"!%%#