Affirmation of Sexual Offense Conviction Based on Victim Testimony.
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant was convicted of multiple sexual offenses against minors based on a prosecution that relied heavily on the testimony of the victims and the defendant's failure to provide an alibi or challenge the testimony effectively. The appellate court affirmed the conviction, reasoning that the trial court did not err in allowing the jury to credit the victims' testimony, which was deemed sufficiently corroborated by circumstantial evidence and internal consistency, and that the defendant's constitutional right to confront witnesses was not violated despite some limitations on cross-examination concerning one victim's collateral mental health history, as the cross-examination allowed provided ample opportunity to question credibility.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Affirmation of Sexual Offense Conviction Based on Victim Testimony: The appellate court affirmed the conviction, reasoning that the trial court did not err in allowing the jury to credit the victims' testimony, which was deemed sufficiently corroborated by circumstantial evidence and internal consistency, and that the defendant's constitutional right to confront witnesses was not violated despite some limitations on cross-examination concerning one victim's collateral mental health history, as the cross-examination allowed provided ample opportunity to question credibility.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision is cited in the dispositive section concerning court costs.
The provision is cited in the dispositive section concerning legal aid.
Testo completo
!"#$%%%%%%%%% !"#$%%%$&'($
$
&'( ( (( () (
)*+,-)
(
,0 1 23*--4'$%3%% %5%6( $33!$%788888888895$ %$:; % 3%%$ %$ $%'6,3%*--40
:% : ;;9 9$ 3%%3 $% 35$3 %$0 < '%% $ % 3=$ 5% 5$3 %$ $ 3$%' 3% 3>%33 ?"@A---0)0
*0 :% %(%(65$3 %$=%>; % 3%%, 3=*/$(3=*--40
B$:( %$,C3*--@)$ :>3%3% %= : %; % :( % :() % 6 D E D%)
% E % F%5% 3$G0 % 6 D 6E' D$3$ 3 (%E' D( $6;E D(=%E %%F DF % F% : %(% E % =$ $ % > 0
' % % % F !07888888888 % $% % $( %'3F $5%'9F%%5% 3$:% ; ;$0 3F% 3$ %( %$ $% :%3%$ :1 =' 3 % $ % %( =% $ % $%0 % %$3% ($G% $;%% >%5 %$ F %$3 %%% (<%0
20 $% $%F*.3*--@'!07888888888 $($F D<&$33 E'@(%9,4<2-0
40 0 C(%*--@'!07888888888 3%%$(55 2- H%*--@$3$ %5%( I%(% (%'% %$'3%6 G 3 %'5H$:55%'F%$ % % (%$ %$ $% 5 (%0
=0 $% 3%% %5 %$ 3%%$ *J (% *--@0
@0 !07888888888$%% %$6%<K3;0 %%$ *2 $L *--@' )% $ $% > %3% H$'6,H% *--@'3$ %5F:%(% $$ $; :1 = : 3$% 5$33 $ <$%%5H$ (% H$$;>F $; (% % % 0
+*.,+*--/ )2+,-)
/0 313 H$' $% :% %%F (% ; (% $3%=%F3%%$$% $% 93 ><%<%'F)% % %(% 9$5%30
J0 */$L *--@'$%!07888888888$ 6(% ; (% %$<3%%6(M%)
6I (% ?N 5% F $% $ % % 3% 3%$0
C0 , 3= *--@' !0 7888888888 $33%F (% ? %%$%<K3;%% 5% F:%(% 3%%$9 3%<%<%F0$: %@(%'%% (% 55 % F D 5% (% % 6(' M: % N 3(% $ E % % (% 3 % $ $33%)
$%0
!07888888888$%F:%%$% 3$G$= $%F %<%<%F% $#$';O9< <$$;% 3%% %$ % % 3 0 5%'%39F%$% ( $33 ?"22.'2-$$ 3 F:%% L $<$ 3$%3% H%'%$$$%3 %/9J0
.0 J 3=*--@'(%?%5$3$%!07888888888 F$5%%: ( $ %F %$(>%; $ '%%(% %%F'@(%*--@'F %$ $ (% % % =0:% (% %3%%$ %$%0 '%6((% $% %3 % %$ 5%;;:3%% %$$ 5$3 %$0
,-0 ,@ 3=*--@'$%!07888888888$ % $3=:3 5%; $%J 3=*--@ % 6( 3F%55 % 3 / J $% ( 9 $ % 0 :3$G (% % =% %5% (% % $=H %59:% %$!078888888880
,,0 3=*--@'$%!07888888888$ 6 : $% $3 %%$%<K3;*2$L *--@0
,*0 ,-$ $=*--@'(%?%%F$%!07888888888 F: %5% (% % % 3% $<%3 0 B:;% %$5%%6'%%3%$% $%% F$33 ?"22.'2- (% % 1 ( $ $ $ $3 0 <G$ <6' % 6( $% 9 $ %$ 9 :; !078888888880
+*.,+*--/ )4+,-)
,20 ,@ $(3= *--@' !0 7888888888 %% H%% %$ :<$33:3%3 %5% %$0
,40 . 3= *--@' % 6( 3% 9 !0 7888888888 %5% (%0 % %F($%$ %=3%% %5 % $( $ %%$: $% $333 %6 %5% (%'% H$0
,@0 ,@ 3= *--@' $% !0 7888888888 : 9 H%% %$:<$330(% %$ '$:%$%% %$'F $%$ $ % (% 1 $ ( %= 3%% %5'H%% %$:<$33: %$3 3 %60 % $% (% % 3 :% ' 3% : %$0
,/0 %%$ *2 3= *--@' % <K3; %$ H$$ %5%9!078888888880
:3$G (% $' <$' F:% (% % !0 7888888888' $ 5$% 3 :%( %; %$ %%6 %( $3$ 3 %'%F:%(% 3%%$0
,J0 %=:<$33'%6(%%F' .H(%*--/'F:$% $$ % 3%F3 % %6 $3$ % % 3 :% F % 3 : %$0
,C0 2-H(%*--/'!07888888888%% %=3%% %5: %$%%0
%F:%% 5$33 3%%$': % %6(F% $ % $=%% 0$ 9F)%$% $39%(I
) ?"24A242'J-= 9 % %%3 =%5P
) ?"@/C',-9 % %$;%3F'$% %55% % 3 / % 3 J 3$% 3% H%*--@P
) ?"2A2C4'@@9 % %$$33;P
) ?",-A---0)9 % %$3$0
%6((% $ 1 $39% =% %5% (% %$ % $=H %5 313 F:> ' G $3% %3% $ ?"@A---0)0
+*.,+*--/ )@+,-)
,.0 * 3 *--/' % 6( $ =3 9 F 3 !0 7888888888 $% %$ % %0 '(% 1 %(=0
$( %$3 ' % 6( 3 9 F !0 7888888888 $% $3 9 % ( $33 ?" @A---0) ( % 1 6 2- H% *--@' % :(% (% $% 6 5% 5$3 %$0
*-0 *J5(%*--/'H;;9:% %$%%F> %F:%% :% %$$HF:9$% $( H%% %$ :<$330 $% !0 7888888888 $ % : %$ H; 5% F % %$ $% $=63' ( $$ H%% %$ :<$330 63 ' % $%% : $% %$ %F0 % 55 % $ % F % $$ %5% (%:(% '!07888888888 %)313 :(% 1 %5$3 $ $ ( :% $%% %$( H%% %$:<$330'%$% : % $( :%33% 5% % 9 $%$0 F1 (% 1 $$0
*,0 ,/3*--/'H;;%:% %$0 $ 5 :$$ >%63 <; :% %5$3 % F % ;9H;0
('
,0 0 %=3%% %5$Q % %F %$ %(9 %$ %% 5$ $% =% $ F% ( 5%:$=H :%%$: %@/ %*$% :$;% %$ H%%% $(3= ,.4, M R * -@N' F% $ $ : ' $33' $$ %$ =%3 $% =% ; =%0
=0 $F:%%$ ' %=3%% %5A $3 $ $Q A $ F 3 $S $3 % >3 $ ;% 0 B$ $ K H%% %$ $ %3% >3 %65%% %@/ $$%$ 6;3 %>M +@-4+,..J*/$L ,..JN0
0 : %@/=<%554 %F %=3%% %5 $3 $ $Q %%$ $ $ 5$ %$%$33F$F:%$% %$;';3 %$ %%($% 0
+*.,+*--/ )/+,-)
F% $ $ $33' : % C/ $% A3%% %$ $33 ,2 (% ,.C4 M ) / -@N $ %=3%% %5$3 $Q $$ %%$ : $% $33 3 %6' $ 33 %5% (% %% %$ $ (%' $ ( :> %$' $ % :60
( F% 6' %= 3%% %5 3 %3 $3 $$Q % %;0
*0 !078888888883F:>%63<;:% $% $$' F:%$% $9F1 0
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
:6' $%% !0 7888888888 $ 9 3$%5% :% % %;' )% %F3 5$ 3 5$305% '>%63<;:% : %M 0J4 N0
20 0 H%$ ': %$%% =%%%$' : $3%9%'$(% %$$3 %$ $% 5$M +C*C+*--@/3=*--@P +CJ2+*--4.$(3)
=*--4N0
=0 B$ %$ %%' A )9)% %= ; 'F% % 3 9A$ $%$336'$ 33 %3 % 3 'A$ %$'A%3% 'A<3 %
+*.,+*--/ )J+,-)
$ %$ A M +C4C+*--@ ,* 3= *--@ 50 % N0
0 $ (< %$ %%F%$ % 9 %$' 9 A =%3 9 %% %$ $ (%' 9 A$= %$ A $3$ %$ $ A (3 ' 9 $% A %K)
3'9% ; %$5$ %$ % 9A( %$$9 ( %$A5$ %$'$ %$% >$=H IA %% A %55 0 $33 A %% A %= A1 <' A )9)% H; 3%6 % A $=H $FA $% <%<%F%$A %$($%A% %$' $% $>%;AFA$ %$$ A$ $% % 9 % %$0 ' %3$ 5%% %( F % %; =$< A$ %$ A $33 A; ' )% % $33 $%M +,-4+*--@,3*--@ 50% N0
40 !0 7888888888 3 %3 ?" 24A242'J- 9 % %%3 =%5' ?" 2A2C4'@@ 9 % %$ $33;' ?",-A---0) 9 % %$ $ 3$ %% F ?" @/C',- %55% % 3 / J$ 3$%3% H%*--@
0 $%3%6 %$$ % 3 %9 $ (% !0 7888888888 % 6(' $ 5$ %% %$$ (%0 $33%%F%)' %$ $ %= :1 < % %; $ :( %%3 ( 5%:$=H : %$%%0 F: 5$ $% %$'% %$ %(=0
=0 B:;% %$ %( > ?" @/C',- $$ 9 %55% % 3 / J'$>3$%')% : %( %$ (%$ F: 1 % %=3%% %5%33 0
@0 H% $ ' 5 : $3$ %$ 5% :$=H : $ M !+J@+,..C ,2 3% ,..CN0 % %$ %% %)' $F 5%%6 : 5 ( 5% :$=H : %$%%0
$ F% 6 F : %$ %% $ !0 7888888888 %(=0
/0 !07888888888$ % F'3$S% $ % 3%)
%$' % 5% :$=H : %%3 0 <G$ <6' %%$
+*.,+*--/ )C+,-)
%%3 % 5% :$=H : $' : 3% %= 3%% %5(% 1 $%$33 0
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
=0 $% ,@ 3= *--@ ( $%' $% !07888888888%%FF$% % 5% F:55% % $3 %=3%% %50%$$339$% H$)9 % <$K : %$%%06$' 3 $S : %$ %% (% 1 $% $33 $ $ %%$ %3%% %%3 ' %)% (% 1 %(=' %50
+*.,+*--/ ).+,-)
J0 $ ;3 %5F%$ %5% (%' % H$ 3 %$ %%$ $ %5% $% !07888888888B <$%% %=3%% %50
5% F$ :% %:>% $3 F$ :% $%% %$ )( H%% %$ :<$33 : % 9 ;0 55 '%$$339$%9 %$ )%; $%$ ' $H$ :%$%% %$0
C0 6 $ F : %$ %% %% %(=' 3 $( %$ 5$3 % 6( $% :1 %' F: % %$=$% %M 0J* N0
.0 F%6F: $!078888888886 %= 3%% %5 $% 1 %(=' F:% $% F%5% : %$ %% $ $0 ( 313 3 $( %$ 5$3%6(0
( %'3$3 ?",:---0)3%9<; !07888888888M 0CJ N0
*&(' (
%(= % $ %= 3%% %5 2- H(% *--/ !$%7888888888P
%(= 3 $( %$ 5$3 % 6( $% *3*--/P
3 9<;$ 3$3 ?",A---0)P
$33%F 1 9 ! "#$% %%$&' ($ $ %% FA $%3%% %5%6(0
B%; I !3$(G'% '!0G<6'!3?%'!0 <%'!3$' H;0
$3 %=3%% %5I
+*.,+*--/ ),-+,-)
;55%6)H% H0I (%)% I !0 $$% 0$(G
$%$5$3 1 $33%F> %0
6(' ;55%6I
+*.,+*--/