Breach of Industrial Equipment Sale and Service Agreement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute arising from an agreement concerning the sale and servicing of industrial equipment, where one party alleged that the other failed to meet contractual obligations regarding the installation and maintenance of machinery, leading to operational failures and subsequent financial harm. The court reasoned that the specific contractual terms mandated certain performance standards and timelines for the servicing party, and the evidence demonstrated a substantial breach of those duties through inadequate installation and delayed remedial actions, thereby justifying the remedies granted to the aggrieved party for the resulting losses.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; DOMAINE PUBLIC ; SUBSIDIARITÉ ; INTÉRÊT PUBLIC | Recours rejeté contre la décision du département de ne pas renouveler la permission d'occupation du domaine public lac à une association de ski nautique (exploitation d'un plan d'eau réservé à la pratique du ski nautique). | LEaux.2 ; LEaux.3
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order (5.) to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Cited in the final order (6.) to order the appellant to pay the court fees.
Testo completo
! " # $% ! "# ##$%&
&
& '
'()*+'
*. / (- &0 *112$ 3 %4 5# 67# 8% 3 6373 $ 69#3 &73 :#';< 3 =& &>?6&# #&@# #95 ;%8#';<A =3##&6& #&&3#5# $%64&# #&66%? #9@# #9. 6 # &79#B#&$ 3& !&'&.
% 6 # *+ 6/ $ 3##& # & & #& &#?&3 * 35*112. &%# # # 3 6$?3/ &6 # &# 3&#% &".
(. *C3#(++-$6&DD# & & # #&# %# 37 &3# 5# & & ? &# #& 3##& & A % ,* 3# (++-. ##&D## # ?4#&9#6 # (,D%# *C3# (++- %# 6 A D# 6 # ## &## 6 %& @# #9 % # # %&3 &&# #& & 5#.
5;# ?$9# # & ##&# !& 7%#';<!& 7%&#=$6 # 9 3 5#. #%3  E& 6"5# #& 54 ? %#$ # # & # & "# & & F & .&&7 #& & 5#7%&# #7 5 G * H96? A"&$ % %# 9 # &7# #&# #&$# # #&6&%/ 5 ? 67 6% I "J 5#. #3& # &9&?&%&# #&5;!&'
& D# && #% &% #7 5 !& 7%&#. &# #& #  #&6&%#7 5; 4'#%.
&# #&&%5;%# D# 6&5H 6 &3 6 # # ;. #3#9# #3#&3 & #& 6 3# ? #&# #& A . %4 # #D# 6"#% (++-)(++K D# 3 3# %# 5;5 6(++K.
)(,+()(++- ',)*+'
,. &# &33 (K 3# (++-$ 3 & A 96#&%# 3##&6& #&&3#5# &&"#"$,*&0 (++-$#&& #&6 &% 5; !&'&. & #& #3#&3 & 3 6 % 6& &# 6 &% 3##& # & D&# #& %A .
2. A 6> # &# &33 # 7$#'# & 3 *+H#(++-$964# ##3 *2H#(++-.
-. (1 H# (++-$ A D&3 & '% #5 3## #D& ##&(K3#(++-& &# ?6 #& #;.53 $#&?96#&# & 9##&&## 6DD % ,*&0 (++K.
K. #&&7# #&63## #& &$&# # 3 6# #$ 67# 6%#&3 8%#&# # &#:#';< 3 =. &D&33 4 D&# #$ ##& # & &#%#.4#&& $*C (,&0 (++-.#& DD 6D# &%&&% #3; @# #9. # %# & ## && A $ ;.
C. (1 35 (++-$ 3 & H &. & # &H&&$'#& & D&#&## #& & *2 &%35 (++-. ##& *-&%35(++-$ #53## #D&.
L. ,+ 3# (++K$ 3 #D&3 #5 3## #D 96 # & 9# 6 # & # # 9# %# DD 6$& #&&3&3#6%# / &%.
A %# DD D #; &&# #& 3 $ 9 &DD# M 5N &3& #4 5& &3 ## 67# 3 6 & && #% &&"3#& #.
& O $ &# %#7 #& 6 # #& ? & &7 #& ? #&# #& 6&& D %#7 #& 4 # # # # 3##3 #9 3; $ 6 $5 3&9 @# #9 $6 $ & 5
)(,+()(++- '2)*+'
5#7. # & # &## $ 3/3 9 &%& #&6 & .
1. A D# #& ,+ H# (++K. A# 6 &H %# DD #%3 D$ &&# #&&&%# / $ & 3/3 96 #D## 3#; & #3 5&#@# #9.A ># &9&%& #& 6 & .
*+. (+ H# (++K$ #5 3## #D && # &$&& & 9/ .
. & & 9# 6 & (, &0 (++K$ # &D#396#D# #&&%5;5 "J 5# 3 # 64&# #&63#?#&# #&A . # DD 3& # 96# #  6 # $ &7 #&&% / &5 3 #;$&33##9& &.
3# # 5; &%# $ &3 &5&D&3# 4&3 6#3## 64&# 3 5#. 6# 6# & & % &% 5; %# & A #& 6&5#7 #& D# 4 7 6&3# H 6 #3; 3#& 5# ?# # % ##. 3/3$ &&# #& A %&# !& 7%&# ##5;*-%#*-& &5$ 3#;?3# #64&# #&6&@# #9$ H $ &3 &0 96 P# 6# #&.&3/3#&$ 3# 4 &3 5; 4# &35##& % 6# #& 6&%5;&%# & &# #&.
*(. &%&9 9# 3&# & $ # !& 7% D# 4.%# ?&&&;'%5 6#$ # ##9 *( 35 (++K 9 64&# #& &35# 5; # ? # 96# # 9 #& 6# 5 "J 5##3#9# &53 &0 & #& ?"76 ;%.
*,. *(& &5(++K$ 3 # &#& H &. 73 #$#%9& 5 6#7# 3# %# & #& %#&3 $ & 6#3 #& 6 &% 5; ? #%&&73 "J 5#$ &# #&5;33H.
)(,+()(++- '-)*+'
!/3 &&7 &% #7 9 '#9 3; $ 5; #9# & #& "#%. 63 %4?##3#9# 3%## #&6# #&# & 7. & $&0 & #&6 # 3&#%9 # 5; &H &&73 "J 5#. % ? 3##& D$ # # & DD &5 &0 & #&#. D#$& #& P# #&6 #E#637.
&%# ; & 6 # ? & #& 5; ? 6&# &# &33 3#4 &#$ ? %&# 9# B#&$ 65& &H 6 & #& 3 # ## &3 #.
*2. *, & &5 (++K$ A # &# #& !& 7%&# #% ? 6 ## #& #% 5; 5#& # "J 5#$ 3.67 # &%&3; 3 5;6 # 5#$ ; & 9 #'# # %# # #E# 6. &%# & & 6# / "5# 9 # A"& 6 ## 6/ "J 5# & 5# 7%&#$ & 9 6/ A"& %# 9 # 3#; &". D#$ E#%# ?#3 & ## 6 P3 & #D #4@# #9.
A9&# 7?H7.
'
*. . 4 % 6# &3 6 # -K &# 6&7# #&H###(( 35*12*8' (+-= &D&3 %&#$& %5&# %.
5. 6 # K, # * &# & 3## #% *( 35 *1L- 8 ' - *+=$ # & &# #5 3## #D H& ? &3 & #D# #& ##&# #7#.
&D&33 ?H# #5D$##&& &33# #& & & #D# & 3&3 &Q H ##5DD #%3 &#&$3#H?9 %&# &% "; 6#D$ 9# 3 # # 6  / #5D!()+,C35(++2$&#.,.* D# =.6%&#& & #D# #7 %&#
)(,+()(++- 'K)*+'
3# # #3&3 &Q#'# #?& &$6#6 ## H&D#4? DD $#H& #& # 6%&# 8 )2(+)(++K (K H# (++K$ &#. ,: A *11,$ . -K2: . R$ & 3## #%$ (+++$ . *++ D # =.
6&$ #7 (K3#(++-$ 3 D# A %&& &% 3##& 6& &3#5#.& #& # #?6"#7$ &# & 3 $9&?&%&#$ ##3$ *2H#(++-.& (1#% $ & ## 4 3 #$#%&#?6"#7.
. & # &# #& # K+ #% & #%# # *+ 35 1+C 8 A ' A (*+=$ A # # ##& 9 #&&9 9# &&# 6 #K+ .&6%;&9 %5.
(. . &#&5& ?96#&# & 9 &'&%3 3##& 6& &3# 5# DD % ,*&0 (++K& &%6&5H $&3 # O & && / $ $ 65 6# / . &9 9 &#& ##&# #7#?6#6# #& %# ?6 #& ##&(K3#(++-.
5. A D# 7#D? ##& 9& %### 5### $9##3&?63## #&$&96 &D& ?"$ 6& & & #& 9# 37 3#4 # / 5# #% 9# &# #&. A& & $ &'&%3 3##& 6& #& &3# 5# # & DD #% &354 #9 @# #9 9# % #%# 64 "3 #$ & #3 #& #%9#B#&.
3 & 73 #&$ % $ 6 $ 6#9 #& 5; 3 ## !& 7%&# $ 6 $ D && A 4 #% &&# #& #%9##& &3#.
,. . &D&33 4 # ($ , # 2 - &# 4 -H# *1K* 8 4 ' ( +-=$ D# # &3# 5# &. 6& #&&3#5#4 67&33 74 # *, #% &#&3#5#(2H#*1K*8'*+-=.
)(,+()(++- 'C)*+'
# *,$ *- *C $ 6& #& 4 67 &33 &3# ? 3##&$ 6 &# 9# & &# #; D#4 &# #&.6 #*1#&9 &# #&& #%? # #. % & / # #3# & H 3& #D$ & 33 # 6# / 7 64#7. ? &%3 &D; &# 9# ? # #
8 )CLL)(++* (C &%35 (++* &#. -5 D # : . $ # 3 3# ? #&# #& &3# 5#$ # I. ) . $ &3# 5#$ S#" (++2$ . *(+=. 6 # * # ( ;73 & 6 ## #& &3# 5# (*35*1LL8'**+.*(=$#9$& #3# 9& &# &# #& # ? 6& &# 3##&$ 6 ## #& &3#5#4 67&33 / &9665 6# / & &&8A(++22(+&#.,=.
5. #&# #&# D## 73 $#%7%&#$ 7#36 &# #&$ 96# %&7 & # H#. 5 7#3 &# #93 ? & #& 5# &#$ 3# # ?  &&# #& 3# #&6&#&# #DD 7 "& 5#9 8. ! $ 64# #5 # &3#5#$# ) $&.# .$.(C D # =.
2. . &'&%3 3##& 6& #& &3# 5# & *112 A 3& #% 6#9 #& 5; 3 # ?. &3364&6 &# # #3$#'# $3##$ #%3 E&6"5# #& 54? %#. $ 4#;3 #$ # & & "# %&>7 F & . %&3 96 & & 5#7J?64 #KG* H96? A"&$ 9 # &7# #& # #& #$ 33 $ # #& #9#3#9$ &##;3#$96 3#&&# #&&# #7 .
6&# #&& & &# . 3 & "#DD & D9 #& !& 7%&#$ 9# D& 6 &35 # ? 1,+6+++ 7 (++2 & 635 96 4&# $ *,+T+++ 7> 3 $(++-$#7# @#7# ?;%7? .
5. 3 %; # / 5#3#D ? ?&&& !& 7%&# % &% 4#7 # 4 & 5# #% &# &" . 9
)(,+()(++- 'L)*+'
596#6%;$6# / #%A $9#&3 6 # 335 #9 #%# ? %& #& & #% #%$ & ; &#. 6H& 6" 96& & #DD #%%# ?&35## / .
##$ #% & #& #% 49 ##& 9D# D6& 673 A $&9'#& & & D# 6&5H 643&D&#. ##$&&# #& 6 6 &F M 5N &3& #4 5& &3$ 3/3 96 ## 67#3 3&# ? 6&#& && #% & & "3#& #$ H 6&# #& & .
. I#3 $ A &#; 9 & #& D%&5 ? # / &# ?&55;& & #& &H 5 "J 5# 6 &% #& 6 #& &3; # 9# # ? $ !& 7%&# &% 3 # 5#& 6 3.
& D&#$ &33 ;% 6 &# # #3 ' / & # $ &# 73 '$# #&&H # &DD 6 P&0 & #&3 #63##&D'?"7# 7 & #%# '$ &# 3& 9# &5# # & #& 5; "J 5#$ ###3# #&#.
. I& 63 $&# #&$9##& 9&; 6H # #&# / $6# / #%&3 ? &&# #& & 5# #3 6& # A .
-. . &3 9#;$&H .
5. 6## #7$3&3 UI(6+++.'3#?"7 A $9#&358 .LC =. #3# &.
VVVVV
)(,+()(++- '1)*+'
" '
()*+,-
%5&# H (1H#(++-A@# #95;% & ##& 3 # &#(K3#(++-:
)*.-
H :
3 3&3 UI(6+++.'?"7A@# #95;%:
# 96#3# 6 &:
# 9$&D&33 4 #L( #% I$ / / & H& 9# #% & #D# #& '% #5 D$ %&# & 3 #; &# 5#: 33&# & &# ##9 &#&$3& #D 3&>% & #7 & && 3 #:#&# / #5D$*+++*2$%&#& & %&# 	 4 &# #& 6 # 2( I. / #; &#& & $ #%&9 &33 3&> %$ &#% / H&# ?6%&#:
&33#9 / ? ! "# # #$ %& & 3 # &#.
A#7 < !.>";$# $!3U#$!. "#$!3&$H7$ !.U& #$H7 .
&3 #53## #D<
7DD#;'H# < # < .#&'A#7# I.>";
)(,+()(++- '*+)*+'
&#&D&3 / &33#94 #.
;%$ 7DD#;<
)(,+()(++-