Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/16/2008 • CJ GE ATA/16/2008 Generato dall'IA

Marital Property Division Due Process Challenge

Numero d'incarto ATA/16/2008
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Respinto (Dismissed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

A party challenged the trial court's application of a statute concerning the division of marital property, asserting that the statute was unconstitutional as applied to their case because the resulting division of assets was disproportionate and inequitable, effectively constituting a taking of property without just compensation. The court reasoned that the statute, while facially constitutional, was applied erroneously by the lower court; the lower court failed to account for specific statutory factors designed to ensure an equitable distribution, leading to an outcome that was so one-sided as to violate due process by failing to align with the principles of fairness inherent in the statute's intent, thus requiring reversal and remand for reconsideration under the correct statutory application.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Marital Property Division Due Process Challenge: The court reasoned that the statute, while facially constitutional, was applied erroneously by the lower court; the lower court failed to account for specific statutory factors designed to ensure an equitable distribution, leading to an outcome that was so one-sided as to violate due process by failing to align with the principles of fairness inherent in the statute's intent, thus requiring reversal and remand for reconsideration under the correct statutory application.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
divisione della proprietà deficit dell'unione coniugale indennità adeguata eccezione di incostituzionalità caso di rigore coniugale abuso di diritto

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was applied in the dispositive to allocate court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



        

         

  

   

 !" 







#$%% 



## #&# 





     !"# 

# 

$&  '(()& &*' +,-./+'0(1 23 4'225'(56  78$9$!%:,6&4(5'2'+ 22 4   / +'; 49 6 +  2<'9 =/  0>  4'225  4  '(  7  56  7&+7++'((+/+&

!&  +, 6' +(    +72   2<'  6  /',2 +'     4(5'2  ''9   ''(+2''+,6'76'2'+5' ',6*' +,-'.$80(6'!%%#&

?&  '0(('6+2''''(+(''!%6' !%%#9+,6'(22''229' *' +,- @).9<4+(2'456'&+(64(' + 0'/(   2  4'2259 2'   2<'&  '2+('0  ('( 4(' + 7'    6 2+(/   +' '6'&  +7 + +'( 4(' + '5    '(   0>   A( B(& 4''  <' 6' C (+(6?%='!%%#&

D&   '52'''0+2'E+!:2' !%%#&  ,72 2''+    4(5'2 +5'9  $ =6' !%%F *  !$ ?$!  ' +,- ,72. 4''' +   ''&  25/ (5'2 '+'     2<' 6 ',2  '   +7 +'(&  '(( 6' (( 2( + 2(' 4''  +  + 4 (22, 7''222('<'&

:&  '4++(!8='!%%#&

  )4'G'(!,72925''922 59256'9+5='2'(+6' (+'2'(B(&''7'96 +7+'('9+'+/'7&)''2'< <''02(/+'(+(++7+'('9  /'7'  6B < 4/   '  '5   69 0'4(6''2+'+'6''&

   ' ''' H(2'<2  +    +7' B'I42<'0'/(',& ''6'

"!$%!"!%%# ?"# 

C '6( / 0>9   +6'  (6( 7   4'2+('&

  6'6B'+'+++' '(A(B(&

F&  ?+25!%%#9 '52'''0+((E+ +&+('(<('(=E'(!%%:9<4 6'+'4(5'2& 6(E+(+',(2< 4'2''/''''' 7&  +9+'2+(+''&

#&  2'59'4(2'(?%5!%%# 2+'+++&4''2( ''<(<4'(2''''(''  796'+2+(& /+( ',690'6'+''6-

 & 4BA 259 '( +  B6 :9 '+' 00'62 4  '2'' E   &  6' 0' (( +(  ''&  ' '''    ' +552    (+&

 5&  5  E 4'7 1 7   39 '  <'  7!#9'+'4+(+(+6'A(B(& '(''6E+'+'+,(5'2+<4' 6++7+'('6''&

 &  ''  (5'2 14 2+B,39  J(57 G9 1 5'39  B5'I D  1 '39  ' #9 (' '2'' E 0(173'('''6+< '(+H(0>E+6'+7+'(&

 &     0(  1  39 '   '   'F9E+='B'I('0'/(2+ 0>   E  2<'&   6' +'2  5 +'(9 2' 4(5'2  6' E   +' K  + +6' 2+5'(''&

G&  $:625!%%#9''<(<46'2(E/+ 6('0'''(2<'&(''<2''(22+ '  ' 2'<2 02(   4'2+('&  0' <  +7++'('64''7CE'&

"!$%!"!%%# D"# 

# ' 

$&  =(  2+ ' 6  =''' 2+(9    65*&:F '47''='''!!625$8D$    !%:;&F?&$&'+(2'''6$! +25$8G:    :$%.&

!& & )4'$?'2'+5'!D='$8F$*   $ %:.9 4(5'2  '  4'' +2   2'+5'5(E+2''&)4'$'($5  ,72  4'''  2' +5'  !$ (25 $8GG *   $ $%&%:.9 4'( 22  2+( + ('6  +2''+6'+5'<22&

 5& 4' # '( $  ,72 '+ <   +6 C '(2'+5'22',6E''<4' 5'  + 00' + +2   2+  +7 0'  +'(& 4' G '( $   / +('  < 4'( ('2' 42+'2H'+'& 25'' 9 22  +  5= '2'(9 '  +    (+'2'''(*&G&!,72.&

  4+,9''7'6+7+5''( '(  7   0>   =/  B(&   ''9 +C'('+''+('(&

?& & +'46''+''+4(7'('29 ,<'2''E'(('(&

 5& )  ='+9  =''5  '  +''+  +( 6''2 4 '(7'(  '2    4' G   '' 0(( 0((''$G6'$888* & )$%$.<' 2++'<(E92C2<49' >0++''4'+((++'<(* L$!?!DG '&?+&!:? !:DC'(; "$8D"!%%D82!%%D; &  9 & @  9 @& M  9 ' '' '9 6& !9  !%%%9+&:%! :%?&$%!: $%!#; &  94(7'(4'(7'(9N&$8#G9 ++&!G$ ?%!.&

  +9  +(++   +  4'(   (''  <(6(4++'<29E46'9'+''(7 <'    0' ++'< +  6' <' '  5( * &  9&@  9@&M  9+&'&9+&:%?&$%!#.&

  6B9'4'(+'E2''+'<'(7  4' H   (' '  + <4 6 +'   '9 

"!$%!"!%%# :"# 

'H+2<06('(72E''' E' 2C2906+0'<4'(2'0'+'<'(7 * L$!?!DG'&?+&!:? !:D;$%:$GF'&D+&$8$ $8!;$%D5 ?FD'&:+&?#! ?#?;$%?!D!'&?+&!DD !D:;885?##'&:+& ?G?; 88 5 !G? '& ? +& !8% !8$; &  9 & @  9 @&M  9+&'&9+&:%?&$%!:.&

  0 '<4'4/'+'(C+5'+(+(+ (7'(<''E+(0(E '('24(7'(  '2 * L 88 5 ?## '& : +& ?G?.9 ' 4' <4 '(C +'6(  ' +(+(  4H ++ * L $%G  !$! '& D +& !$?; &  9&@  9@&M  9+&'&9+&:%?&$%!F.&

  0'9 ' 4'(7'( 4 +'<  ( E 4' 4    0 4 '2 '(79  '5 42   < 4' + C / < 42''' B7  +''< * L $$! 5 ?G$'&F+&?G#.& +(29'4'(9<  ' 02  =72 <4'   < E 4'+('    ,7* L$$:G$'&!+&G! G?.&

 &  4+,9  '  (2(9   ('  ?% 5 !%%#9 <4++'<+'<'6'H(2'<2<4 +7++'(4+'(',2'5&'9 7'0((922'< 7' '(''''& 00922'+ ++(72'9<''C++'5''' ,6&

D&  <'+(,<4''''(+C'(& '9'4+('4/2''E+=' B'I+'C'(+'6('(+5'<&

:&  6<'+(,9=(&(22+(9  ML$4%%%& 92'EB79<'25*&G# .&

 OOOOO

"!$%!"!%%# F"# 

( $#'  #   

)*+,"-!.

(65'=(!:2'!%%#+)& &('' ',6!%6'!%%#;

+,.

=;

2EB7(22 ML$4%%%& ;

' <9 02(2 / ' G!  '6   ' 0((   '5 0((  $# =' !%%: * L ) $#?&$$%.9  +( C + C +(    = <' '6  '0'' + 6  '5 0((9 +  6'  2','+5';2(2''''<'9 2'02H+6+'72';' ' C (  '5 0((9 $%%%  $D9 + 6' +  + 6' ('< / ''  4' D!  L&  +( C   +',  +'  9 '6<( 22 2H  +69 '6 C =' E 46';

22'<+(CE)& &''<4E',6&

)'(7- @26H9+('9@&HB,9@2M'9@& B('9@29 =7&

2 '52'''0-

700', ='=&&'&-  6' +('-     & &6H    

"!$%!"!%%# #"# 

+'02C((22'<(/+'&

 ,69  700',-           

"!$%!"!%%#