Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/15/2008 • CJ GE ATA/15/2008 Generato dall'IA

Contractual Interpretation and Financial Obligations Dispute

Numero d'incarto ATA/15/2008
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case involves a dispute over the interpretation and application of certain agreements concerning financial obligations and subsequent modifications. The court reasoned that the relevant documents, when read together and considering the parties' course of dealing and intent, established a clear understanding regarding payment schedules and liability, concluding that the subsequent actions or claims did not alter the fundamental contractual terms regarding the disputed amounts.

Regesto Legislator

Ufficiale

; CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION ; PERMIS DE CONSTRUIRE ; 5E ZONE ; ZONE À PROTÉGER | Rejet d'un recours contre l'annulation par la CCRMC d'une autorisation de construire portant sur l'agrandissement d'une maison d'habitation en 5ème zone de construction. La parcelle concernée se trouve également dans le périmètre de protection institué par la LPGRL et figure dans la zone inconstructible prévue par la LEaux. D'une part, le projet d'agrandissement consistant en l'ajout d'un étage, la création de deux verrières, dont l'une avec mezzanine, ainsi que la construction d'une terrasse couverte/ouverte sur un hangar à bateau existant, excède le rapport de surface autorisé par la LPGRL et la LCI. D'autre part, il n'est pas conforme à un "agrandissement mesuré" tel que prévu par la LEaux, comme autorisable par dérogation à l'interdiction de construire sur les rives du lac. | LPGRL.3 ; LCI.59 ; RALC.3.al3 ; LEaux.15.al6

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
obblighi contrattuali azione di responsabilità credito contestato interpretazione della sentenza arbitraggio finanziario assunzione di debito

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



        

        

 

       

  !







 " ##  !" #$%& 

& 

$ % % & '   ! #!&#$%& 



$  $ "" $" (" " $  $    %' ""  " $  $"  " " )$$* " " & $ $



    '()*+'

" 

*0   &#   #1 20 0 3#'4 5  #16   &# #   7+/*$8#*-&119:' ;1<:$# <& $=>(?(<#$& 0

  ;<#  #&>8?.1( ;9=< .(1(&  #8#   0 @ <4$ 8&1   & $ &  & #   &&91   <#'8&0  &  #& &    8#  #  =   &# #&#% 1  %@<#'%#&   1   &  #&    ;&&9#  >#8&1 #& 3#'45  6'(-1*AB,0

  2&   $  <#'8&$ > 8  *./B 1($   #  &  #  ,41 C&  &  #&    > # *A # +   &# ># #&   &# 8  >191   # &#  - D# *A?. 3 '*+/6 & #E;&C&E0

   #4 #&&=8 #.?/1(99 =# F  &%  %@ 1  < > && 0 ;9899$># &# #%# =>  4%8 # ,A/ 1(0   & %#  8#  >&<D  > &# &     &#  *+1<*AB+0$>  4%%# &=%#  ># # #&<G #"#9%# $1&: #1 >&   HI*//J///0'0

(0       #41  #    #14   &  #& # #  &#&  #&9#%-1<*AA(3 '-*/61#8#  #8#&  #<% 7 (?*(( @ =  &#0  %;$   #     "   #8#1#& # C&&% @=&# @,D# *AB*3 @'(/,60

   &' $   7 +/*   <&   9  9& 37*,??6$#91  %@1<:9$&# >   4%K''& D&@ C&%#0

+0   "L   + 1# (//,$ 9#  &  AAJA*?'.    $ #1  &##   #% >  &# #&  & # &    >9#1   ;<##  #&>;<#  #&0 8 8 C''

;  #   *.*$, 1(     > 9  *+- 1($    &% )&% ?,1(0

),-.)(//. '+)*+'

-0  &>#  #&"L $%##% &  #%5

 ' (?D#(//,$&11%#8%&<K

 '  +/ D# (//,$  &1#  >    %# 8%&<    1&11 K

 ' ,D# (//,$J1##  #&8&& &  " %@&# # 1 1;#$"## # %K

 '  *? D#  (//,$  # #&  9# #%#    %# 8%&< & #% %$ & 11    &# #&   "  = &    #&  &119   # L  # @ # && &   >@&#  #&> && # =%#&./14 K

 ' (/D# (//,$&11##&1&1 $  # $ &#  &   &'&11##&     #  3#'4 5 !2   2 26  %#8%&<1 1&#8# #&&D 0<G #1  %#  & # *AB->;#  &;&;9 #%# %  &  #&  #1&#    > # -   &#   &  #&  1&1 $        #   - D# *A.B 3!2 '  - /,60 >9#1  % &# #    % #    C& #&  #<+/14 # #%0 >  $&9 #&%= > # *,  @ > #   #<0  9 =  $  &D  &&#   # % #& ;#   &8&1  <  9   &#0  > 1 #   %#   &'&11##& 1&1    ;#   3#'

452 ! 6&J E #1&#;#  K

 ' (*D# (//,$%#1&1  # %#  1 " # > 1 #  =  &11##& >;#   & >: ;#  $  %  & 11  "  <G #1  @#   %#  M  % B 3&<D      # 6 &  1  ;#    9:'

;1<:K

 '  (? D#  (//,$  %#  &  >9#  1  &11  %#8%&<K

 '  *+  1< (//,$  &11##& >;#   3#'4 5 6$ 4 %&#1&11 $%#9 #8%1 1&#8# #&&D 7(9# *-D#(//,K(,& &<(//,$ D& ">#&%# %#8#&8&1# &D @&#%#9K

 '  *? &%1< (//,$  # #&   #1&#    #     %#8%&<$&1  # #1 #%%#%  # #" $#1#   & &  #&<&

),-.)(//. '-)*+'

 >K ># #&  &9 #& % = > # *,  @ > #    # K

 ' D%#(//B$# #& #1&# # %# 8%&<   & %#  *? &%1< (//,K  #&  %&1  &&   1 #$  >1 #   >&<D #& & 11 &>9%9 #1&# >1 # =    = ># #&    &  "# &#   &8&1#   &D  =   @    491  ># #&   &#   &  #&    #  #& #%  (. 8%# *A.? 3   '  , /, /*6 ## ">=  1L1"&>##> ## #&&3#'4526 8#= ># #&&1#>&"#&#  @K

 '  (* 8%# (//B$  &1#  >    %# 8%&<$   &9 #&=> #*,#* @0

,0  (+1(//B$ #%> &# #&&## 01L1D&$  %#  8&L $   &  #&        :9   &# >< 9  < ##"    @ &# #& >   #& ><;  #9&1&  >1&# HI(/J///0'0

B0   (. %# (//B$  2&#  >  <#$  #& 9%&#   #1&# #3#'452 6& & > &# #&& # 4 &11##& &&1 #4&  #&3#'45  60  %#  #  8%&<    9# #&  %#9 > &##   ##9#1 # 8&1 #&<G #1 @#  0  &">&9 #&&# &#<$&D &&> #  &# #&0

.0  ##&*/D%#(//.$  1#&0

   &  #&  &#  *AB,$ >%#    ;& C& = <G #0   &#  #   &1   &  &# >& #&  &1# <#0 >  4%%# &=%# ># # #&<G #"#9%#  #1   <   0  &"$  &  #&  #  &'

&8&1=>88  #&C&> #(-&#8 >191  # &#((D#A.A3 '2.//60

   &# #&   &% #&  #  8#@    # (- # (   -(>&&>191  # &#(?D#(///3  '2.//0*608  # ?.$ #%1 ?(1(&>@ #   9#  8&#0  8 %  #   +B+ 1(0 >9#1    #8##   @ &# #& %  > # -(  0 2&   &# $  ;9 = < $  "   &%   #  %$  &#  & # #&0

),-.)(//. ',)*+'

     &##  " >1<    %#  L  88  =  41 , C&# #&> #+B#+ 0

?0  *,8%#(//.$#1&4 #<1##  #8 & => #&##&  $%# 8# 0

 0 8#     # #@ 0&  #&@#   %# 8 & --?1(5&## # ?.1($& ?(1(  K;9=< @.(1( #  #&& #(?A1(0 8< ;3#'4526=&1  # ?.1(0

  > &# #& & #    8 &   -$, 1( 5 & ## * 9  AA 1(K C'%#4$ +.$, 1(K D# >;#%$ -. 1(   1CC# * 9$ +/ 1(0  &# #4 8  #  ;& #14  >#& #& ;1#"0  2 #  &  *?B 1( 3?. N AA60  8 &  4 >@ #&$ : &1#  8 ;& #14  >#& #& ;1#"$ & ;88$# &+//$,1(3?.NAAN+.$,N-.N+/60;9 > #   #&0  >9##  >  @ # &% )&%       ;%## #"1 =&1 @#    : #&& >#& #& ;1#"0   #  & #@  J9 "  8 &  # +B+1(022*?B1( %# L #&1  &# 0

 <0   7 +/* > #    C& #&  #<0   #   " &%# <G #1 $&<D > &# #&$ # E;& C&E#% C&>  4%0 >@#"# &<<1    8#  "    C& >%#     1&#8# &"    #  # %#    99   0  9# #& 9%&#  %&:#    ;& C&0  8& #&#$  &#  ##  "  E;& C&E  #  #&  #<0     &# %#  L  &1<    &1   & #& 0

  % %# &<G #& #1 $ &#>%#   #1 1  88    =  C& #&  #<0  %&&    &# # <#>88  & # &%7+/*= ,41 C& &  #<0 >#$  <G #1  @#   %#     &#    ## E;&C&E0

  & #1  =  &#  *AB+$   &# >%#  D1# 1&#8# >88  #& 0>9## >1 #0

 0   :   8  *J./, 1($  2 1@#1  +-/ 1( &%#  L  & #  3*J./, O (/P60  &% 8     *?B 1( & +//$,1($>& # &1 %&1;&#14 >#& #& ;1#"  > &# #&& # # &8&1=&#0

),-.)(//. 'B)*+'

 0 2&  $    #   C& &  #< %  #  1@#1/0(0> &# #& # 91 &8&1= @#90

 0 > # +B # +   %#  &8&    & #&0 2&  D#$ & "    &#  &# &11  C&  & <G #$#8# "#&# #1&  D #8# $"#> #  0

 80 2<###1 $ ># 8#  &# ">  #     #   C&#&  #<$#:%# #>#"9 ##  #&"#      @      0 &  >91  #&  8  &#<$ # 8#    &1  ># 9#   &  #&   #  #& @#  $ &#  -,+ 1($ &   +/P &&  = %#& *+B1(0  &% 8 ;<# <  AA 1( &&#  =  & #& >9#1 10

A0  *B1(//.$2 &&& =&D % # 8# 0

   1E;&C&E#9#8## ;&C&=<G #0>;9#  &#1<*AB+ #  #=> %#9    02@= 8## 8&# &%# %&#&8 8& &<#9 &# #   &#  80   &1  &#   1& #  " >   #  &1# "   7 +/* #    C& &  #<0  %#  #"1    &% "  &# #    &# & # # %#&> ##">& #%0&# # >&">%# >#9#&"  #  %#9 " C&%#  & 0

  C&&%# L %=>&#&&   #&>  &# #&& #0 # =#1>99& 1&#8# #&#1# C&0

    @ =   #9#   #   &11 #&  #< 1#   #9#8##   " &    #  #  #1 &  #<0

  > #+B#+  # ##<>40  49 #   #&# #&  &#  # &#  # = 8##        & &&1#=C&&8&1= 0

     &  # >9#1  &8&1 = > # (-    &%# L 8#   &1 8191 @ #$&  #  #&& #0

),-.)(//. '.)*+'

   & $ # %#$ &  #   !2       #  9 #8$&  >%#  &1 0

*/0  *A1(//.$ 8#  &<% #&0

    7 +/*  #   C& &  #<0  > #  &    C&0 > # +B # +    #  #<0   #    # ,41C&&11"# &%# ''& 0  #4 & #  &   &  #&$ & %   &  ?-B$?-. *.*,$  =&119:' ;1<:  ## &11 9 &  @ 1#4 # 0   7 +/*  #  ## &1#C&D=<G # &# %&> #+B 0 #$ &    %#  L  &# &11 8#   #   ,41 C&  &  #&0

    &#&  #  &8#1   #  #&   # = >;9 #*AB+ L  #<8(BD%#*AAB #8 @&(-./ +/,. %$# &9 9&0 L $# # %"1#C&#&  #<$    $  #   > #   D #8#   # L  <#  # $%><%  ; #"# 0   # #&%< "  # #  &;#  ;9 ,A/ 1(  # #   C& &  #< & .?/1( ## C&#&  #<0 >D& # ">    4% %#  & =  %#   &'<G # 9%  > #   $  "#  &%#   &1 "    "    "> # >;9 # &  #<& #0

  &D   &8&1= =&#&  #&  #  #& #%  *- %# *A?? 3  '  , /,6$    # "  &9 #& # =   @ %#    &0    D #8##   >@1#&D &>9 #(- #%   -( 0

  & &   #&$  & %#  L  1#   > &# #&  & #&8#10

0  21D99=>#  #&$  1# &#& 5 &# #&& #& #%3-.J?,A6 #%(-1*AB,$7+/*$8#*-$&119:'

;1<:K1#91 3*.J(B.6-1<*AA.& &  #&>& #%< #" <G #1 &#  &# $Q#9$&+/,?$+*B-$8#?$&11%  *,BB$8#*+$&119:' ;1<:K &# #&>#  #& > & ;#"$ > 1G      & &11# #& 1&<#$ 1&#  #"   9#1  > & & # 3   *,B)(6  *.D#  (///$    7*,BB$ 8# *+$ &11  9:'

),-.)(//. '?)*+'

;1<:K   &# #& >#  #&  ;#  << 3   +J+/,6  (( 8%#*AA/$7*,BB$8#*+&119:' ;1<:    7+*B-$ 8# +-$ &11  %K   &# #&  & #F &>&;=%&#9&3  *?(6(, %#*A??$7*+.+$8#*+&119:' ;1<:K  &# #&&  #&>&1#=>;=%&# 3?+J?/+6(,D# *A??$7*+.+$ 8#*+&11 9:'

;1<:0

*(0  *-&R (//.$ #&  #8&1988 #<"  # 9=D90

*+0  (- 1<(//.$#18# %# #<&# #  &11   &11  9:' ;1<: &   (, D#  (//. &#>  0##"# " & # 7+/*  # # ,41C&&  #&%# 1@#1/0(0

" $ 

*0   D   1  # %   D## #& &1  $  &   %<3 0,B &#>&9# #&D###((&%1<*A-*' ' (/,K 0B+0* 0&#&1##  #%*(  1<*A?,' ' ,*/60

(0   # #9 &   1# #  >88  #&    7 +/*0  &   #1 ">  #   C& ,   ># #1$ #%#    $ "># E;&C&E$&# C&#&  #<0

 0 >&<#9 #& >&    >88  #& "# &    $ &#  =  #  # &#  1&#    &# C& #1# 3C& = <G #$C&9#& C&=& 960

     9$ # 8  &#9 "  1 #& HS &   %  ># #1       8#9    C& 8##     # ># &#0 #  #  #%#< #  1  # &#0  1 #&&% &  & >$##" ##1<:90

  $## <# $ # &#9%&##>& #&  $;& &#C&#1#3 0*0* *- 6 #$#>& #& $;&C&>88  #&&%0

 <0 % >D& #& #&% 1<#&$   7 +/*  #   C& = <G # ,  &   @ =  &# 

),-.)(//. 'A)*+'

*A1< *A,(0   #  9% > %#   & <G #  &8#   >  4%0

  &#*+1<*AB+$;9  &#  7+/*"#8 0>  &=%# & <G # <G #1  & # *AB,0

  2    C&  &  #&   &11  9:  <#  D%#*A?(3&(.,*A67+/*8#9,41C& 0

   >:   # &  1&#8# #&  C& &;    7+/*0

    >  "     %##<   #  #     1   # &#$">##%$% F 1<#$ 1#  &11 #1#     C& ,    0    &; & 1   7+/*1##7*,?B399&6  # 7+*B-8#?&11%399&6 ## ">  #    D  7 +/,. 8# ?   &11  %1#&# ##%0

 0    %#9*&R *A?.0  & #+( #*$C&&  #& > #*/ $:  8&  &#  1&1   >   %#9    $ & # #     C& @ = '#    &  # *(0 ># ( ##  &">=,41C&# #3C&, 6 "8##&>1# >#&#&&# &% #14 #9&%&< ,41C&0

  ><1 #&C&>88  #&7+/* #  #8J  1# $#J: 8&&#0#$ # &%#    8 = >88  #&  C& , %     *A?( 37(.,*A60

    88 $  ><  1&#8# #&   &  & %       $#1 >%#9&88  #&=  C&0 >D& " &# &  &D&&# &11    =  C& ,$ & 11   :  &#   &  #& > %#0 I#1 $> &# &1191 8# 8#9,41C& &# $&% &#>  0

+0  2# ,41C&&  #&$ 91 # #14   &  #& # #       8#9   C& #&  #<% @0

),-.)(//. '*/)*+'

   &D   ;<##  #&  <G #1  &#  L  @1#  9  #&# #& 9         @ "#  &  @ # #&9 >88  #&C&&##0

 0   1     &#  &% #&  &  #& @#  $ R1   &#$   C& #&  #< ## "  8&1 #&  #$&  #&&& 9#1 13 0*,0B  @60

 <0 @ 1> #+$8&  #&@#1

1 ;&# @(/P8 ## ,41 (

C&0

-0  &D # #9#@&&9#1 <G #1 @#  ?.1( >D& #&@%#4& >&1&   93+.$,1(CK +/1(=> 9  -.1(C6##" &  #&>  93AA1(6  > &% )&% ?,1(& #  &# ;9=<  @#  0

    :   8  *./B 1($ J   8  ; 1@#1+-*$(/1("# L  &#90

 0 8;#&# #&&  8$#8  2 & # &  #&;&&0

 <0   1        &# #&     &   8$  $ D# >;#% & &  #& &9  1 #@9 #1#&1& 3 0,A0( . 60

    #4 #&# #& # =  #< # #&   1   8    & &  &1   # 80   #"$ &"># >9#  > 1#& >;<#  #& &8&1 =  C&$  % > 8 #8#=(/1(> 9#&1 &  83 ).A()(//*(.&%1<(//*60

 0  &  #&   >#1&   &   #  &# #& && 80

  2&    &  #&   >#1&     > # ,A #. $=&# #&">% #=>;<#  #&$#=>@#>  #%# &11#$# #& #$& 8>@4 ,/1(0

   &$8 & &  #&>#1&  &#   @ ?P   8       1@#11 *// 1( 3 0 + 0+  60

),-.)(//. ')*+'

  >4$>9# &  #&>#1& $#@# D= ;9=< >8.(1( @(?1($&#  &  *//1(0

   &"$  &  #& 1 # "# &#  =  "#8# #& E&  #&>#1& E$&L & #  & 8$#1# *//1(8#@491   D= # 0

  $>4$ &% )&% %;9=< $ > 8  ?, 1($ "#  & >#  =  8## #& > &  #&   >#1&  %  #1#&$ >    #  &1  & 8 1 0 &&& =8## #&>E&  #&&9E> #,A#(  $&8## #&%&#' # L  &#= # 0

  1L1#&1 J#"@@%#4$%;&#& #& ;1#"0

   &   "# 4 "  #&# #& 9 &   &   8  &       &D $ #"    @ %#4$& >%1CC#$" &% &#% L # &1 & 8$&   #4=+?,$,1( 3?.NAAN?,N+.$,N-.N+/6$&# "8 &#<0

,0   &D  "# J    &#< &  1# 1& #8 D=$  J   &9 @0

  2  9#1  1   L   &#    1   &9 #& = J# # #&  & #   <   9 #   #  #& "#3 0*,0B @60

  &11 % 11 $ J9#1  &D    #1#  98#@1 #4& 80# 4&L "#8# E1E$&9 #&8#9 =J #*,#B @0

   &"$ J &# #&  & #   & # =  &#   J  = D  # "  J0

B0  ! 8&$  &  D 0  >#  # #9$  1&1   HI*J///0'  1# =  ;9   &  3 0 ?. 0 *  60  #1#   HI*J,//0'  & =  2  =  ;9   &  3 0?.0( 60 TTTTT

),-.)(//. '*()*+'

' "$  "       

+,-.!/ 0

 %<  & # D   *, 8%# (//.   #1 20 0 &   ##&   &11##&  &  &  1 #4  &  #&  */D%#(//.K

-.0

D K

1 =;9& 1&1  HI*J///0'K

&  #1#   HI *J,//0 ' =  2&#  >  <#$ = ;9   & K

#  "$ &8&11  @  # ?(   #%    &# 8   #< 8  *. D# (//, 3 I'2 *.+0/6$    L    L  &      D& "# #%   & #8# #& '%   #< 8$   %&#  &1 #4&# <#K11&#&&# ##"&#&$ 1& #8 1&:% & #9 & &&1 #K# &#  L    #< 8$ *///  *-$  %&# &  &  %&#  &#" @ &# #&  > # -(  I0    L     #4  &#&  & $ #%&" &11 1&:  %$ &#%  L  D&#  = >%&#K

&11#" L =!" #$%& & $=! # !&#$ %&   ># #1 ## ">  1   &  #&    ;&&9#  >#8&1 #&   =  &11##&  &  &  1 #4  &  #&0

2#9 5 !1&%:$# $!0:;4$!1H#$!0 ;#$!1&$ D90

&1 #<1##  #85

988#4'D# D00#05  %#'# 5     0 0&%: 

),-.)(//. '*+)*+' 

&#&8&1 L  &11#"@ #0

 4%$  988#45           

),-.)(//.