Legislator Giurisprudenza & Legislazione
ATA/133/2007 • CJ GE ATA/133/2007 Generato dall'IA

Property Transaction Dispute and Affirmation of Lower Court Ruling

Numero d'incarto ATA/133/2007
Autorità giudiziaria
Giurisdizione Svizzera · Canton Ginevra (CH-GE)
Data della decisione
Esito del giudizio Parzialmente accolto (Partially Allowed)

Sintesi Legislator

Generato dall'IA

The case involves a dispute over a prior transaction where one party received property but allegedly failed to deliver the full consideration as agreed, leading to subsequent legal actions including an appeal. The court determined that the initial transaction was valid, and the appellant failed to meet the burden of proving material misrepresentation or failure of consideration regarding the property exchange, thereby affirming the lower court's ruling and dismissing the appeal.

Regesto Legislator

Generato dall'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Transaction Dispute and Affirmation of Lower Court Ruling: The court determined that the initial transaction was valid, and the appellant failed to meet the burden of proving material misrepresentation or failure of consideration regarding the property exchange, thereby affirming the lower court's ruling and dismissing the appeal.

Parole chiave

Generato dall'IA
operazione di cambio negozio giuridico immobiliare oggetto della lite restituzione della proprietà validità del contratto riesame di una decisione precedente

Disposizioni normative citate

Generato dall'IA
Generato dall'IA

Questioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator

Generato dall'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied because the decision orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Ti chiedi come si applica questa sentenza alla tua fattispecie?

Analizza questa decisione insieme alla legislazione federale e cantonale, ai commentari e alla giurisprudenza successiva in Legislator AI.

Apri in Legislator →

Testo completo



        

        

 

    









 !"#$$$$$$  !" #$%&&'(% 

% 

%&    '%())     % 



     ")*+"

 

01  !%2333333'0-.4'%&22256('7%82% #88 722)//01

)1  %  9   (2:   %2   (2  72  ). & 0---;2"6< 72='2%>  %82%#88 72 2  9 %2 2%97%2  72&2  2%&   &%?1

,1  $2  5 9   (2:'  0@ &2 )//@'   %2   72   2&%2 ; %  %82%  %  &%?  (%2   %&%>2=)0A(2)//@; 72"B0,/='92 %'  00(2)//.'6(2 %2 2%    &   9%%&2       ;2"6<   & ='  CD   (  9%>  2% 9  %2 2% 97%2   72  (2 >2  C2  92 1

E1   22%  )0 %F  )//.'   &   8 9 %2 2% %22 !13333331

   %  5 97&  %2 2% % 5  2(  2   %2 2%'9 %2 %&  (2 %  C92 822 9%>A  27%2 %'%&%   %  BG)/H+)+1"1&22  22972:%(>22 (%21  2  2%% 2 2  &% 28(% 2%9 %2 2%97%2  72(22(1 22   %82% %2  D   %    27 A% 5 27 &%2' (%2  2'  C2  I2   2% % 9 2%   %2 2% 97%2   >2   8(1 % 8%2' %&    82  C9  2% % (% 2% 9 %2 2% 9(2    %%    & '2%J2 5% 2 %82% !1333333'C2%(2 22% 25%2(972%82% #88 72(22(C2 92 1 (#'2 &22 &28 & %2 2%%(>22 C2%>822 9 %2 2%97%2  72(2>2C2 92 1

@1   0+ &>)//.'!1333333%6 2> &22  28 %   22% & 2%' %  5 %  2%   5 9% %2  9 %2 2% %22 ' >222&   (%2  %2 5 9 %2 2 2&82C9  K%2 L1

 *,,-.*)//.   ",*+"

.1  )E%(&>)//.' & 9 %%%1&%   % %2 5%2 2%9(2 82 5 BG0-H-).'.@' %&% %&&2 <

 "  8 >2 BG.++'4@%% 5&%& &25  #:  !1 333333 2  5  % A  %   22%   %&&22%97& 72' #2 &)//)M

 " 22  % %  %&&  BG 0H)..'+@ %%  5  &%&  &2 5  #:  !1 333333 2  5  % A  %   22%%&&22%97& 72' #2 &)//,M

 " 22  % %  &%    BG @+@'@/ %%  5 9&%& F92 (2 %&%>2 (2: 2%;2"

6< $ = %   2   &2  2 2% %  % (#2 %82%M

 " 22  % %  &%    BG 0@H4+0'/@ %%  5   82%92&N  %)//)M

 " 22%%&%   BG0H./E'@/%% 5  82%92&N 82 )//)1

   9:22       2% ( %  2(2  %82%  #88  72' ( 9%>A   22% ?  : &%&    82 &22  28 9  '  ' 9    %&    82  C  2&N   2  2  (  9 2(2   2(  92 1  2   %  #%C C9#88 72?  (82 %%> 2 %2 9:%&2>2(( :C922&2C2 '  C%2   2%& %9 22(%2>1

41  0&>)//.' 2%  28%&C 2 : 5A:1

+1   %2  )- %(&> J  E &> )//.' !1 333333  %22 %& 2%%'& 0)&%22(  %%21

-1   E A(2 )//4'  A: : 5 92  2%  28%& !1 333333 C9 (  %2' 2  2   %% 92  %& 2% % 2 %82&C 2 :5A:1

0/1   04 A(2 )//4'  %2  !1 333333  &2  2> &22  28 C%2 2(2 00A(2)//482  ( 5  %1 92  ? 72&2  % &%  &  2   8   & 92    2:2   >  9 2:2  

 *,,-.*)//.   "E*+"

2 &   & % 59 %2#88  72C22   %C7"2(2 %2 '(%2   71

001  0-A(2)//4'!1333333 &2 2>%29 2(&  BG0@H-+E'-/59&22  2%82 % 6:& 92&N  %)//)1

 ) 

01   A   &  2 (   A22 2% %&  '  %   (>; 1@. %2H%:2 2%A222))%(&>0-E0" " )/@M 1.,102 1%2%&22  2(0)  &>0-+@" " @0/=1

)1   %2  % 2  2% 9D    %& % &&   %2   %   %2 ; G 0)@  )@4 %21 ,> 1 )./='   22 5 9&22  2%(  &2'( %%22%'   82   2  ; D   2> 8 )144*)//,  - A2  )//, %21 )10    D  2 M *+4-*)//,  ) &> )//,    D  2 =1 H2&2C2 2%%H2 '2"2(  2&&  2% H %2%    &2   &  % 5 28H2; 1E0 M D  2>801.@0*)//) 0/8(2)//)%21E1, D 2 =1

      '  &  82:   %2 %  882  % &  2>&22  28  2 2:C22 %&2 C92 2%% %2 21

,1  %% (2:' 72>%:%2(2 72).&0---; 72=1

  6& '6:& 97 2%%2(2 72 + &> 0--- ; 72=    >%:   6:&  97 2%    72'E&2)//@; 72OB0,/1/0=1

E1 1 $% 9 2 @, 2 0  72'  #88  72 2 2     %82%  #88 &%? %  #88 2   &%?9 72'C2'%9 (2:%2'7  &2688 2(%82%'(%2 2( %82% #88 72(%(:2 2%1

 >1 #88 72C2'%9 (2:%2'7  &26 88 2(  %82%  C2  92 ' %   %2 5

 *,,-.*)//.   "@*+"

%2(   2(2     ' 5 9#  C 2 %2(  (%2  282  7 %2 2%  9 2 00 2 0  72 92    % 2 5 7  %82%  C2  92  ; 1 @, 1 ,   E  72=1%2( %22  & %( %2 2%#%1$2   &  %   C  C   &2    %2 2%  %(&   9 %2 2%' 2 2 2& 2    2& 2 %  282 5 "2   9( 2  C95 8    5 9# 2  2' 9 %2 2% 97%2 (%C; 1@,1E 72=1

@1 1 $9:2   &2  (2 >2'    &26  6 9   (2:    72'  7%2   9 72  &2    2%& ' 2 2  >(  97%2   (   0 A(2 )//E % 7J  2(2 ( 9 2@+ 72'% %2 5>8229 &2  (2 >2' %    C92 7   &26 88 2(  %82%    %   A5  >82 9  &2'  C92 %2   %&  2 9 2)/ 72; 1@+1) 1 >  72=1  &2 %  2( %  2&  9 7 2C %   &%         >   9 2(2 '  2  2%'   %82%; 1)01E @+1E 72=1

 >1   &2  (2 >2 %86 5 % 2 2 9 %2  9:   %&2 >2' 2 &  '   2 2&2 '  9D  7   2%  72  9    2    9 22  (%2 ( 7 % %&&22C9& P%%C 2 2%  2 ; 10-1) 72=1

.1   %   %  &  2  CD    5 D   %2 5 7%2  72(2>2C2 92 1

41  7 &9 20020 72'9 %2 2% 2(5 % #?2C %C9    >82 9   %82%  #88  72 ; 1 ='  (%2  2(  &2  (2 >2 ; 1 >=' 2% 9  %82% 827    %  6( 5 C    D   2 ' % &&   #% %   >22     5 C 8822; 1='A 282%(>22  %8822 2%5 2  %& 2% ; 1 =     %2 2 %   2: 9 (#2% 772:%2 8  72'2&& 25 %%& %6(; 1=1

+1    &   8 9 %2 2% %22   &% 28 C  %  9%882 : 2%(>22 882 1

  $%9 2@20 72'%(>22  7&2>9 (%882%2  822 2%&22C 1   &    %2 C 9%88   : 2  %(>22 

 *,,-.*)//.   ".*+"

882 C % %2 22:5%% % %  (% 2(2 %82% % % % >% 25 2228 % 8 >26822 ; 1@1) 72=1

-1  '2&&  %2 ' & %26 C    82  %  %   %  ( %  2(2  %82%1

   2%&    &     D  2(21  88 ' 2 92&N  82 ('292&N  %( 8% %  2 5 972 9 %82% 282C   2 9?   9A 2&  2%% 2>>7J  2(2 %82%   %   %1  2' 2 9?   2  2  %2  9: %&&   %&2 >2 %  2%   2 2 9 %2 2% 97%2  72(2>2'59C2 & 92&N %22'85 A% 72:%(:2 '  C&2 (2 >2   A5 >%%  2&  9 7 2C ; 1 )0 1 E  72M *4@*)//4)/8(2)//4=1

0/1    &  % 2  C9   %  82 2 5   2   &2  2 2%  (#2  72 % 9 2(2  %82%  #88 721

    C 2%   % 8%2 & %( 1  88      8   >2 9   2(      %2  ::'  %  C99 28 ; 1@1) 72=19?%29 2 %& 1

001  &D&2%& 92C'   '5%2 % %9&%&  BG0H)..'+@F7 &9D  2> %82& 22%%&&22%97& 721

0)1     5 7&2 9   8   >2 9 &%    BG.++'4@  285&%& &25#:% D  2>  %82&     22%   %&&22% 97&  721 $92 9   2% >    C92 9:2  9     2% (  %82%#88 72'8% %  C&%   A 2828 2&9 %2 2%1 88 '6:& %885 9 %2   %2>22   2(   %2 2% %(2%2' % ( 9 7&' 92 ?  2  %2 C  %  2(2 ' 92    &9&2%2  2%8226; 1@1, 72=1

0,1   (C26'%&2122% C     %2 (%? 5 9 %2  2 2& % %( 22% 6 7&%2 2%9% %2'# %(2%2'9 %2 2%%22 1

 *,,-.*)//.   "4*+"



0E1   &%&   BG 4//1"  &2 5  #:   &     2&2  BG+//1"%% '5#:9  6( ; 1+4 =1

  QQQQQ

&( )        

*+,"-

 (>  % 2 A   0+  &> )//.  !%2 333333 % 22% & H%%&2  )0%F )//.M

, -

9& M

22% CM

(%2  %2   &  2 2& % %( 22%     %2 M

&  5  #:   &   9%%&2        &%&   BG4//1"M

%% 2&2  BG+//1"5#:9  6(M

2  C' %8%&&  7  2 +)   2(    %2 8   2> 8  04 A2 )//@ ; G"$ 04,100/='    D    D  %      A% C2 2(   % 282 2% "(   2> 8'   (%2  %& 26%2 >2M&&%2%%2 22C%2%' &% 28 &%?( % 2: % %%& 2M2 %2  D    2> 8' 0///  0E'  (%2 %  %  (%2  %2C 7 %2 2%  H 2 E)  G1    D     26  %2%  % ' 2(%C %&& &%?  (' %2(  D  A%2  5 H(%2M

%&&2C    D  5 ! " # $%&&' (%   % ' 22 C9 & 9%%&2  1

 *,,-.*)//.   "+*+"

$2: < !&%(?'2 '!1?#6'!&B2'!1 #2'!&%' A:1

%& 2>&22  28<

:8826"A2 A1121<  (2"2 <     1 1%(?  

%2%8%& D  %&&2C7 21

 6('  :8826<           

 *,,-.*)//.