Appeal of Contract Breach and Misrepresentation Damages Denial
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigant appealed a decision that denied their claim for damages based on an alleged breach of contract and misrepresentation concerning an investment, arguing the lower court improperly limited the scope of evidence regarding the investment's profitability and the counterparty's intent. The court affirmed the judgment, reasoning that the trial court did not abuse its discretion by excluding certain financial projections and communications because they were deemed irrelevant to the breach of contract claim or cumulative, and the jury was provided sufficient evidence to find that the defendant did not breach the contract or misrepresent material facts regarding the investment's terms and potential.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeDROIT FONCIER RURAL; ACQUISITION; EXECUTION FORCEE; IMMEUBLE AGRICOLE; AUTORISATION; JUSTE MOTIF; EXPLOITANT A TITRE PERSONNEL | Acquisition d'un terrain agricole soumis à la LDFR par un non-exploitant à titre personnel lors d'une vente aux enchères organisée par l'office des faillites. Demande d'autorisation d'acquérir refusée par la commission foncière agricole. Décision confirmée par le Tribunal administratif. | LDFR.61 al.1; LDFR.67 al.1; LDFR.61 al.2; LDFR.63 al.1 litt.a; LDFR.64 al.1 litt.g
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive for ordering the costs of the federal appeal proceedings.
Testo completo
!"#$$$$$$$$$$ !"#$"%&#
#
%&&&%' (%&
'()*('
*. /// /// % "" 0" 1#"% (* #223# "# 45 '6 &78.
/// % 6 # *-,9 2(% #2# 6 4:" "#*;<2(%62( 6:5 "2 (-2(."8 "=#0"#%6 > "?#"1#" 1#" +# #:*;;*@ABC(.+*(.D.
///%6# E,-(2(% # " 642 ++;- 2( 6 '>" FF*( 2(. " =# 0"# > "?A.
G "&""#///%#& #22""# 1#"H 0"# @"'HI A D (; >" *;;9 8" " "" "2 #" "#"1!2//////////.
(. /// " 0&00"22#:"""& I
*D 2" 0% 43# 4" 6 & #2" JA ,--K---.' 1& 6"# :8 " C. . @"'HI CD ? # JA*K-+-K---.'L
(D G"H2 0% 43# 4" 6 & #2" JA,--K---.'1&8 #H&@"'HI D? # JA*K<-EK--9%9-L
FD #""H2 0% 43# 4" 6 & #2" JA*--K---.'1&6C?# JA*(*K,(*%FF.
F. :" "# *E 2: (--F% 6#11" 1"" @"'HI 6#11"D#2"& #(F# #:(--F/// "2? JA,;-K---.' /// "2? JA9(K+*9.'.
G &" 7 & 2 . 4" " "1 G "#" "# 0 # 68"" "# 6"22:=#0"#.2 "#"6&" # ". &" 7 11 272 286"" "# 1 #" .
+. !2 !#"//////////@"'HI#G//////////D # # #" M#" "# & "22#:""H G 4HN "&?& 2 "#. #2 "" # 22 6 "#
)+(,)(--+ 'F)*('
1 8%?##" (F%1" 8/// " #2"? A 86" " ?48>" " M"0"'272 H # #" N.
<. *+ # #: (--F% #G ////////// # "0 #& "# "# . 6" 0" :8 ? 60 "# 1 !2 ////////// " 1 G #G //////////&00 #"%# ""43# 4" JA*K*<-K---.'"%0& G"H20///.
# ""#%#G//////////600" ?3 ? 2" 2# : JA *F-K---.'. "G #22 " " 6# >? & &" 1# "# 8 43# 4H#":?6"& G4HI
*D >" "#G"#"#"G"1"? JA*K(--K---.'L
(D >" "#?# "#"G"1"? JA*K(--K---.'L
FD >" "# G "#" # "G 0 # " ? JA*K(--K---.'L
+D >" "# ? # " # "G 0 # " ? JA*K(--K---.'L
6 "# "" 8 8 43# 4H #" 6 " ///%#" G/// ///.
9. #"(*# #:(--F% "1#26#11""# .
E. #& G4H(,# #:(--F%G# >0 G #G //////////% /// # "G JA*KF(<K---.' ///#"G JA*--K---.'.
8" # & # % 6#" "# M !////////// //////////0" N4">86? JA*<K---.'% # 8 !#" //////////% #1"# :5 "2 % 4" >86? JA;<K---.'.
,. (E # #: (--F% #G ////////// # 8" A 6 #" "#68"///.
" 8 6GO #2" 0"#% !. ////////// &# !2 ////////// " " 2P "0% #" "# &" 7 "&0?8" "'00" 6 "
)+(,)(--+ '+)*('
9+"* 0A. # %6"22:1"" 6#:> 6:"? 122726" " G#" ?:""!.//////////%0" .
;. (, #&2: (--F% 6: # A % #G //////////# #&87 .
*-. *9 2: (--F% #># #& A % " " # 1" &"#&#".
64 /// ///&" 2# "&M#4" &" #" " 6 2"# &"0#" " N # 3 4:" &1 .#" 62: ///% #" 6 " G /// /// . 2"% " 6&" 2#" " "# " # "# "22#:""H. !. ////////// &" 2"1 #" 7 ?G#" ///.&" # & " # :" ? 12% " :" 8 " "# " 6 " 2 2#"1". 1"% /// /// 1#2" # . 00"22#:""0&" M# "&2 N. #002 ##2"8"2# 86"&" "62:///%" "0" #0 "& A .
. (->&"(--+% A ""#0 "&.
#& (F# #:(--F%006 " " /// /// . 2# 00 0& /// 6 " ".
# % #G ////////// 6 " MG#" ? " #N."#*+# #:(--F&" # : 2"2"///# #":"" 68"8" "'00" . 0H2%"&" 6#" &" #22":#" .
!. ////////// &" " #0. &" #1"2 G#" " ///"*;;<.6 " :1"6:"?12 3" 120 0 . G " # 1#" # " >#" &G 6 "% # 6#11" &" "1#2"#22*;# #:(---.
*(. F 2 (--+% #G ////////// # # H ": 2"" "1.
""# A 6 " &: 1#22 . 6 " 11"22 2# "&. #" 67 6&" I " 6&" " A %"6&" ""?62"" "# &. 8" "'00" %" " : :":1"
)+(,)(--+ '<)*('
6G "#6 "9+"* 0A 6&" #8 " H0 A%"#22"6: #" . 1"%"&" 7 2" :1" > 2# "1 6 " 9+ " * 1 A "86" &" 8" /// # 86 #11 :"8 &" 1" ? "G8"6 " 1" 8626&" 1" G#" ? " #.
*F. # 22#"'# F- &" (--+% A " 272 02 "# 8 &# ""# " #" :# 2 # . # % #"0" 8 6 " 9+ " * 1 " "":6H.
*+. " #2 "# # " & ": 2"" "1(*2"(--+.
# &" " 6G" 12 " /// 4" 8" &"" # 22 ##223. &" # " " % " 44" #02 # G'
272 1 & Q ""8#2H!.//////////8"% 2%&" 4:" &G.
6 " ?6#11" 2:(--F &" "#" "&""#%""8#:2 "8#" 1#".
6 " 8 " 86" &" " 8 6C " "'00" . 6C 6 " " & 0 ? 0. "#4" " 4 . '"&" "&" # ?1"#11.
2#68"" "#86"&" 1"2 #& &" 2 "" ? M2 0N ? & G 4H # 8 6# " #O# :8 &#" 1&#".&" #"#&#"8"/// # "& ? # "# "22#:""H /// . :0 " 6" "2" . H 6>" "# G % " &" " # &!.//////////1"86""# "? &"///.
A # 8 # " " ///:"& & G4H. H6>" "# /// %"&" ""?& ///8"&" 1"2 ">0.&" &## 1&#" O 272" "#8"&" ""'272G4H.
A &" 40 "81"(--F."#%6##" G "#8"&" #: %6G "#1#%1&#" "'00" "2 G#" 0"#. 6#%
)+(,)(--+ '9)*('
"# " " & > & & &" "2 # #:> "1 1&#" # . "8 " 8"" "# "22#:""H "2#": # 0" . #" ""# 3% # # # % &" A #& "8 &" ? 6&". "&""# " &" 1" &" 60" " R 7 4& & & G 4H 2"H?2 02 " "#00.
" *,>"(--+ 1"GG " ## # "H "%# # 22 # A G"H""#" &402 "8.
# &" 2" " 6"" ; >" (--+% A 3 #":"" "8>86F->" (--+.
*<. F>"(--+% A 1" &" ":2"" "1 G "H ""# "& ? # 402 "8 @ A )*+F)-FD.611" 6" 2 & >"" "# . H &"1" "#% &" # 8 6 1" 6 ""#6 " " "86H.
*9. *, >" (--+% #" # 2" ": 2"" "1 #" 6 #" 86" &"  G #" 6" "# A # "% 45 A":#0 2 ""#6" "# # "16 " 9+"* 1A.
C# #" &" 45 #"%6 "9+"* 1 A " 02 ":" "#1#.G"0" ?6#11:"8 " & G4H.
*E. (F >" (--+% #" # 2" ": 2"" "1# ! ////////// 0" M? " # # 8" " 6 #" 1#"H #1":#0#"N.
# "#"2"" 4H%# 22 :" "#% # " " #11 :"8 11" 6 " 9+ "* 1A%":"8 "#" "# " 02 ": 6G "#1#.
*,. # # 2";>" (--+.
2" " #"#. 402 "8 A " # . 8" "'00" &" 7 # #8 6 "9+"* 0A6"8" .1?#" #&" 7 %1 # A 6&#"2# ? "1 "#6" "#
)+(,)(--+ 'E)*('
1# .6H " "11 A )*+F)-F 2 & ":2"" "1.&" 1"7 2" :1"6G "#6 "9+"* 1A.
*;. 6 #" " "2 "8 F- >" (--+. " " #"#.
(-. C8#" 0?>0.
&
*. > 2 " & >"" "# #2 % # &:@ .<9 #"K#0" "#>"""((#&2:*;+*' ' (-<L .9F.*" .#" #2"" "&*( 2:*;,<' ' <*-D.
(. 6#:> # # G"&2 1 A 6 #" # ?8"///%/// 6 #2"? A.
F. # # " 8 6 #" " "2 &"# #" 67 .""# "6 2 "11"22 2# "&%2" # 6# " "# # A %"6# "" ?62"" "#&.
. #" 67 0 " 1#2 @ 7 ": 1 (.(<9)(--* (+ >&" (--( #". ( 7 " L )*E()(--+(2(--+D.C# 2"2"" #" #@ .+* #"#2"" "&*( 2: *;,<B B F*-D #" 2"" "1"@ 7 ":A *.E+()*;;;*<1&"(---#".FL A*(++;#".F.<* 7 " L 7 ": 1 *( #&2: *;;, :" " A *;;;;E#".<.*-FD.C"# "#&#" "11" % # H02""2" # " "#1@ BC*-*D 8" 6"8 @ 7 ": 1 (.(<9)(--* (+ >&" (--( #".(:L 7 ":1*.<+<)(---*+2:(---#". ( 7 " L. S%#2"" "&%(---%.*;,D.
86" 0 " 6 " (; " ( .% #" 67 #2#" # "1"&#"#" && 86 ""##" "%1#"&8 G1" ?"1 ""#%6&#"H#"% ""?62"" "#&% 6 #" 2" ? ## @ 7 ": 1(.EE)(--F;>" (--F#".(.* 7 " L )*E()(--+
)+(,)(--+ ',)*('
(2(--+ 7 " D.#" 67 " #K"2"8 " "# # K" % "'" & "22 "# K#"# 2"2 #?"1K" @ . +* L 7 ": 1 *.9<*)(--( *- 1&" (--( #".+.F 7 " D.
>"2 "H#" # " "# ":1 02 " #" 67 #" 6#: """#2# "&. 6 #" 6 # 1#" #" "# # 2#3 "L "2" G8 "#""&. 11" %#" &% 8 "" #2 # ""#"? 0 %4 %#"# #"@ 7 ": 1 *.E(;)(--F (< 2 (--+ #". ( L *.<F*)(--( (E 2(--F#".(.* 7 " L )<9-)(---*+ 2:(---D.
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
:. 6H%6 #" " "2> "1"""# 1" 86#" 2"H11"22 G"" #8# " #2 #" # #".
# # 02 # #"" ""?62"" "# &""86G"2##"(E # #:%(,#&2: *92:(--F. " "##6 " H# ".
# %#22#" 6"# G'
272% # & &"# "##" 67 & ": 2"" "1 8" "# 272 #&#" 6G2 8 6 #"
)+(,)(--+ ';)*('
" "2. # # " >"" "# 2"" "&%"# 6G"2:""6406" G8 "# >#" #2 &?"#" "#.
""# "6 #8 &""1#22 . # # :# #" .
+. A # : K#0 #" 1#"H % ""% 2" " " 12"" #22 1#2 K # "# 1# K 0" # "& #" & G#" "# : # @ . * . 1 AL V V% "8 >" #" 1#" *;;+'*;;,% . *;(% W +;E 1 " D.
<. 68"" "# 6 " # 6 "22: 0"# #2" ? #" "#@ .9*.*AD. 68"" "#6"22:0"# &#" " "# 1#% 6>" " & 2 6 #" "# 68"" "22:"G>#8""& 6>" "#@ .9E. *AD% "8 #" "# #># " # "2 ? K>" "# # K #" "# K " 9+ A @ A*(F+-9L )E,+)(--*(E#&2:(--*D.
6H% # # 8" 6 #" "# 68" ///"&? 11 .
9. 6 #" "# # 6" 6G" 2# "1 1 @ . 9* . ( AD. 1" # 68 7 G#" ? " # # " 62# "1@ .9F.* .AD.
6 # 6# 8 # # G#" ? " #.
E. C"686 G#" ? " #%" 2#"7 #" ? 8" :" "22#:"" 0"# 6" #& 86" G" > 2# "16 "9+"*A.
86? 2#"1" "# (9 >" *;;,% &"0 * >&" *;;;% 6 " 9+ " * A " "G > "1" G "# "" 6G#" "# ? " #. #& *;;, ># "H2% ? &#" " "'00" 8" 8" 6 " # 6"22: 0"# # 6G "# 1# @ . 9+ . * . 0 AD. 2#"1" "# 6 # 1#" 40 "# 0" 6 " 9+ " * A > 8 ": 2"" "1 >? 6#"# & 8 " 86" # " 6 G4 "&. H #% 6 #" :1""6 " " >02 . #2 8 #": : #".#86 #" "#> "1"%"11" 8
)+(,)(--+ '*-)*('
6" "# " "# &"0 Q #8 # "0# 8 0" 6 &# @ )E,+)(--* (E #&2: (--*L )<F)*;;9F->&"*;;9 1" D.
# # : :""'00" 6H"86" # 1" *+2:(--F6" 0" & .
,. 2#"% " #&" 6G2" "% #22 611"2 6 #" " "2% 68"" "# # 8" "'00" 6 "9+"* 0A6 # " "&6:#" %&#" 61?#".
. 62"" #" : 6 1 8 " #1H #" 6 "" ?1"#86 &. 1" %"&"# #" 2" " 6 # " : 8" 6 "0 # "# @. X % " #" 2"" "1% *;;*% . *-E% Y <-E 1" D. :#" 1?#"" "" :#1#"@.!%#" 2"" "1%&#.*%*;;+%.+F+D.3:#" #8 6G" 6 #" :> "1 Q % # % 2"1 2 # " #" # #86 " " "# >""8 "" 2"1 2 ?6# 1"" #8 @ A*(< E;%.,*L )! )J %#" # " "#"%&#. %(---%.<+<%YF-D.6" " "#6:#" "2#G> "": G "?#6#:"0 "#6G#" " #3 @ A *(F (F* . (F,% A *(* F- . F,L )! )J % #. " .% Y (;D. 3 1 ? #" #8% 62#38"%#"% 2"%#&" 8"" #4":@.!%#." .%.+F<D.
:. 6H%2 "# 6 G4H& 12" "#64 G/// /// %#1#22 G " "#O2 8"%6 :2" #" "#6 "9+"* 0A% " ""6#: " 6 #" "# A 2#3 #. 11 %# 8"# 0#2"0"#%6&" "21"46#: " A 6 #" "#68"///."##: 2"" ? #:H2 "8 # #&" H # #"" #" "#& 8" "'00" .
6 "#2 "#" "2 86"# " /// 8///."# " " &2#" H6#&#":" "#& G4H2"2 *+>#& '".6#11"66" "1#2#"8(* # #: (--F% #" E ># & 4H. 1"% 6#11" &" #
)+(,)(--+ ')*('
:" "# 8 " & 2 8" "2"8" 8 # 6 " 2 #:"068"///272" /// &" >0.
#8 % & "#" % # # 68" "0"#2": A. 2#3 #": 86" " 7 ? "& " 6G" "" 4?6#" "#60" 6&"#" ".2Z& # "228:2 # " "& 6 1 ? #". 8 8 "# 6 & " "# 6H 6 " 9+ "* 1A #& %1?#"3 #11 8# # :# .
;. ##> .
2#2 JA(K---.'2"?40# @ .,E D. [[[[[
)% & *
+,-!.
&: # " > F 2 (--+ !2 !#" //////////# ""##22""#1#"H0"#(->&"(--+/
-!".
> L
2 ?40# 2#2 JA(K---.'/
" 8% #1#22 G " ;E "& #" 1 K#0" "# >"""% 7 7 # %&#"##" 2"" "1% >#H# "1" "#%& ":1L22#"# #" ""8 #"#% 2# "1 2#3 & # "0 # # # 2 "L " #" 7 #" G2" 2#" ": 1% *--- *+L 7 "H #"# # %"#222#3&%#"& 7 >#" ?K&#"L
#22"8 7 ?!"#$"%&# # ""8K? #22""#1#"H0"# ?K#11"1> "0
)+(,)(--+ '*()*('
C"0 I !.34H%" %!2#&3%J"%!. 4"%!2#%>0.
#2 ":2"" "1I
011"H'>" I " I ."#'C"0" A.34H
#"#1#2 7 #22"8G ".
H&% 011"HI
)+(,)(--+