Statutory Interpretation of Property Rights
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case involves a dispute concerning the application and interpretation of various statutory provisions related to property rights and obligations, as evidenced by multiple cross-references to different sections and amendments across the controlling legislation. The court analyzed the text of the controlling statutes, considering the context of legislative intent as suggested by the structure and evolution of the codified law, ultimately concluding that the specific factual scenario fit within the scope of one set of provisions while being excluded from another, thereby resolving the conflict in favor of one party's asserted rights based on the precise language of the applicable section.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Property Rights: The court analyzed the text of the controlling statutes, considering the context of legislative intent as suggested by the structure and evolution of the codified law, ultimately concluding that the specific factual scenario fit within the scope of one set of provisions while being excluded from another, thereby resolving the conflict in favor of one party's asserted rights based on the precise language of the applicable section.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAApplied for ordering the appellant to pay the appeal costs.
Testo completo
!" ##########
$ %% % &%' (&%% $& $
!"#
%
%( )* ++++++++++,* -./0*11234***1 .5( **1 -6* * ** 0 -4*017*4(
!( %%7!&&'30-*1*1++++++++++3++++++++++ 5 4-++++++++++89,* -./++++++++++23**1 1-4 :*3 -* 1*1 ,* -./ 82 ** * 7 04-; 0*11 44 6 1*1( 1* 0<* * :*** -* 9 0--* => = 0*110;?*6*-(
@( !A 7 !&&'3 -* :*** -15*1 1?574 4-1*134*?=0*111*5*-*- ??*3 1 %BBC3 %BB#3 %BBB !&&&3 1* 04 ?*3****.31*04**,9 0>2-<.7*(-3-:64 *7-* !$:*!&&%30*115*11419C4*04-*45 *-@3*1*-*4-=0*5**?*61 9*@&:5*!&&&(
'( >1%C547!&&'38?10****13 4*?=0*115*?*07:4*-1*1( 3 -* 5* 14* -15* 16*?( 0*11 0??* 1= - 6* 0D7**13 5** 0* B *1 % -* 1*1 %# 7 %BBA , ! %' E 2(
$( *#147!&&'3F6?? *74***? %& 147 !&&'3 0*11 1** 8( * = 1** *:( ??3 * 05* 11 41 =09 -*-763=0*05*--5=1(84.0153* 5* G 44 9 5* 9 0H6 %A * 05* - - *5 01 44 9 = * 01* **( 5* 06 1*1-1*-*7--*505*(
A( 1-@%:5*!&&$38:( 5* **4 71 ==0 5 9 * 0 *D.=3 * 9 *4- 1D6 57( ?*3 4*?4 653 ?* 4* 4*1( * *1*1**?*-D1=0*5* .7*=<*-<*( 1=34-4
"!$%!"!&&' @"#
1* *4-*7 5 -D. 0*5*1 5*61 0* B *1 % 3 * 0<** - * 4* ***5 = 0*** 0. 9 -?* 06 1*13 1 1=0*5*44**?*9*<-*(
C( *?*-**5/
2 %C 4* %BBC3 0*11 ?* 07: 0 -- -* * 9 **04?*(
72 %! 147 %BBC3 * ?* 07: 0 -- -* * 9 ??*5******.(
2 !4*%BB#3*?*07:05*-1*0 4**3*90>(
2 !C 4 %BBB3 * ?* 07: 0 5* - 5* 5;61 *-5*?*7*<.(
2 %C :* !&&&3 * 11 41 9 5* - <. 7*3?*-5*0-4(
?2 !$:*!&&%3*11419C4*04-*45* - @ 3 - 1* - *4- **3 - :64 *7-*, "#!%"!&&%2(I*0*D.=3-.*1 13 * 5* ** *41 5 *( 5* * 1-700<*5*1-?* 90*51-*3-**;5*1(
% (
%( :1 4- * 5 :*** 4-13 57,($A *J6**:***!!547%B'% !&$K(A@(%*(* -14***5%! -47%B#$ $%&2(
!( 80*A&7 3=*1-*- =* D1 *4 - 1** *1> *6 -*9=0*14*?*1(0*1>97*:64 ?57*>-3*3*441*, "!"!&&!#:5* !&&! 1?1 *12( 806* 0*1> 3 * ? 047*=061*1=*=*0**0<0* --.4(
"!$%!"!&&' '"#
??3**1**=1*: 11 - *( *7 4***? 4* =*1 - * ??**4**3=04-;=105*- , "A$#"!&&'!'G!&&'1?1*12(
@( 114*?*1-5*-15**3 @:*!&&@,* -./5*2( *-13%%:* !&&'3*315*6%-47!&&'34*?** !147%BBB,* !%'(&2( <* *0 9D195*(
I J* J* * -?* J6 1*1 -*51 %$ 4 %B#$3 - 7 ?*< .6 44 16* J*5*1 -* 1*1 6 J 5**1 * ** 1 - ,( ! K) 3%BBB3L3-(B&$%2(
0* * B *1 % -15;* = J** J66 - J1* 1 = * J6 1*1 J5* - 11 413 *< -11 =>3 - *4-*75-D.J*5*1-?*5*61(
*-**=**4***7.9-?*J61*1 ****9*7114*=?4*19J*@A *1 ! ** ?11 %# 5* %BBB ,8 %&%2 5* 1:9 11 4*-*71, "AB$"!&&%A547!&&%2(
J<-1 4*? 4-6 -: JD1* 9 -4*. 5*3*5*11**=1=*5*3J7 ?* 5 4-*3 - <4-3 47 *?* :61 *4-*7 5 -D. J*5*1 -?* 5*61 ,) 3 %BB#3 3-($%BC2(
8* 9 15** 3 0* B *1 % 4* 53=/
M N(
8 0<-1 4*? 4-6 -: *3 5 <*60D7**13*.?*61:90*16**65* -*1*135*-40<4**4-4 0*111*4-*750*5*10**1*=*3 4>4 * * 1 05* - 11 41 -14
"!$%!"!&&' $"#
,D-""OOO(65(D"6*"44*""$$&@&B"'#"$$&@&B+'#+-*$( -B147!&&'2(
'( :*-13 *74***?*11= 15 **-* * :*** *5 9 1* 44* - *5 0471 > *1 44 * 1* *13 0 9 *=0*1**415*-;5*.3150 -1,(@A%@A@(' -1*!%147 %B@C 8@%%(K "%%"!&&$%%:5*!&&$K "A#"!&&'!& :5*!&&'2(
*7 4***? *11 =0 - H61 !% 3 = 8 5* 1 =* 5* 11 413 =0 1* 4*3 - *7 :3 9 = -*3 - 5 ;43*<3534469--*115**4****= 4-**17*66-5*>*1144D7 7-*=-?*061*1, "A#"!&&'-1*12(
> - 1 , "!!B"!&&' %A 4 !&&'23 *7 4***? 4* 0 : D44 H61 !& =* 5* ?* 07:-*---*?*76*=0*1* 4*3-35*5?**3--**< 0*1 5* ?* ** = 4( 0*11 5* 710-7*44**?*9*?114 4**30144-14-*6;1*93=0*5* 4*1( ?* 1*5*1*9< :64 :*** 4-1 P*76 9 -1 :6 0**( ; * ?* = 0*11 5* 1:9 7 0** **13 = 0*1 **41 **3=0*5*5*19*?*4-;(
>3 *7 4***? 4* 0 4*9016=40*1*55*11**13-* =* 5* 11 -1 ?; - * 4*3 * 5 06 0 9 * -4* 51D* -1*1( 5* * 11 41-1*-*4-35**4**4469 --*1194*1*5*3- *7:( *7 1 *11 = 4-** ** 0D7**1=0*-5*<-?*061*13461 *?*=0*5*44*, "%%"!&&$-1*12(
5 :*-3 * :*?* - - *1* *?* 44* - - 4**13 4>4 * 9 4 15* . 6*? 4-4--<*(
"!$%!"!&&' A"#
$( 806* 0 5*3 * 0 *4-*7 5 -D. 0*5*1 5*61 * 0D7**1 ?* 07: > *5*71/
2 >%@547!&&%3<4**1* :***3 4* ' C 3 J - 1* - *4- J - 53 11 :61 *4-*7 5 J<* -?* J6 1*1 / J<* *5*13 * 41 9 557*47***447**J* -* > 1 44 5 1* , "C!%"!&&% %@ 547!&&%2(
72 B 147 !&&@3 *7 4***? ?*41 ? 1*5 ** 0664 =06 1*1 -*51 9 -=*5*11413*=51-Q=>**6*3 -1*-*4--1-=*5*?* 1*4 07: 0 -- -* - 5* ?--1 0 5** 9 0* 0 *-( *7 1 *41 = ?* -D1 1* *4-*7 5 -D. 0*5*1 5*61 - *=1-1**, "B&B"!&&@B 147!&&@2(
2 $ G !&&'3 4>4 *7 :1 1-1 - - =* 5* 711?**1 0 ** -5** 5* =06 1*1 -*51 4*? =0* 5* 11 41 *< -5 - 1* - *4- =0* 5* 1:9 <1 1*4 5*-1-(*=<**.=0*11 * 1 9 5 1 ** ?* - 5* *5*1-?*, "A%@"!&&'$G!&&'2(
2 !' G !&&'3 *7 1 ?*41 ? 1*5 0** 0664 =06 1*1 -*51 9 - 413 %& :* !&&&3 9 4 RP !&&( - 1* -*4-(5*5*44?--1D44=*05* 77*(4-41*-**.45*:*?** ?-1*1, "A$#"!&&'!'G!&&'2(
2 @% G !&&'3 *7 4***? - 0** 0664-11441*51961*1-1*< 4*4*?=0*5*3==%$4*-.1?*3?--1 5*64*H61%C4*-.1D6--1617 , "A#A"!&&'-1*12(
?2 !A 7 !&&'3 *7 4***? :61 = 1* -<1-1-9<-*:*?**
"!$%!"!&&' C"#
?0****1(*5*- *=0 -5*<*==0*11?G116-5* ** ?* =* -1* -?* 061*1, "#@B"!&&'!A7!&&'2(
** :*- *7 1 = ?* 445*:*?*.6611?0** 5*=*1061*1-*51*0**1:9 1*51( 8 * -**.3 44 *5*1 -?*-D4713-5-4 01.6(
0-.3 11 41 9 -* -* 4* 04-*45*-5*11-9* 9*0*4-5*3-.*11(1*H61 %# 4*( 0 0*= 4-4 *6 4-31*?*-0*4-11 44*-4:*1( =65=*1 -* 0 ( 1=3 * ; * * = 1- 9 ** ?* 4*. 5*3 0* 1* 41 9 < -?* 06 1*1( ? 1*5 0** **1?*41- *74***?(
A( 1** -*3 =* - 7 16 ??* :*- *7 1 ,?( ( "A#A"!&&' -1*123 *?*-*4-**---**13J*** J<-?*J61*119*75*13 **J1-=*--**0D7**1(
?*3 0* 9 *71 14*= 0*113 =* 0< - -?* 06 1*1 -*51 =* *7 047 -?*=** -4*9 **4>4;-3 ?*-*4-(
C( 4?1*>:1(
144 RP C$&( 4* 9 D6 ,( #C 2( SSSSS
&%( ' %
"!$%!"!&&' #"#
)*+",
1 57 *:1 # 147 !&&' - )* ++++++++++ 1**1-4:*3-*1*1%C547!&&'K
+ ,
:K
49D6144 RPC$&( K
44*= -1 > 9 )* ++++++++++ ** =J 1-4 :*3-*1*1(
8*16/ )(;D.3-1*3)45;3R*3)( D1*3)43:6(
4 *74***?/
6??*. :*/ -1*/ (* 8*6* P(;D.
-*?4>1144*=1<-*(
.53 6??*./
"!$%!"!&&'