Contractual Interpretation of Referenced Numerical Specifications
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court addressed a dispute involving multiple contractual agreements, specifically concerning the interpretation and application of various referenced standards or specifications within those agreements, which were identified by numerical codes. The core issue was whether the governing standards were those explicitly cited, or whether broader, later amendments or alternative standards, also referenced, superseded the initial designations. The court reasoned that the explicit, initial numerical references in the governing documents clearly controlled the interpretation of the relevant terms, and absent clear contractual language mandating the adoption of subsequent or alternative revisions, the initial specifications must govern the parties' obligations.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Interpretation of Referenced Numerical Specifications: The core issue was whether the governing standards were those explicitly cited, or whether broader, later amendments or alternative standards, also referenced, superseded the initial designations. The court reasoned that the explicit, initial numerical references in the governing documents clearly controlled the interpretation of the relevant terms, and absent clear contractual language mandating the adoption of subsequent or alternative revisions, the initial specifications must govern the parties' obligations.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe provision is cited in the final order concerning the allocation of costs for the Federal Supreme Court proceedings.
Testo completo
! !
"#$%&&&&&&&&&& !! "#!!$###%& #!'##"( ()*# !!! !' () ** !
**!!
+,-./+
!
.( 3#44444444445#+ 67#88%##*!9*###! :&(
,( ! !#;*!#) %#* < $!! # ,22. 5#+ 6 7 =9) $# #$ ># #88(
?( !#$#,22.+)3(4444444444$$##;! #8 ! #+*@* # .1AB) ## &( C#$$ #' $#D# !# $#) $# ) 8#;./(.2+.7
+ ##*#7 E=,F02/F12/(+
+=-''#'7 E=G2F./1(+
+=- CD$#%#7 E=?/FABB(+
0( %*### $# 5#+ 67 % = 9 *#& *#*)*#!#CD$#%# E= ?/FABB(+ : E= ,1F?.A(+( % $$ $ % * E= BF/0A(+ 5 E= ?/FABB(+ + E= BF/0A(+ H E= ,1F?.A(+9 3# 4444444444) >##) ID# ! ##!# : ++( $)># #88:!#)* #!!* #'7
J 7#'>#
** E=BF222(+
=#
'#!8 E=.,2(+
"+ E=BF.,2(+
G)BK E=0?A)02
$ E=B%/0A)02L
&:$!#!D*>#!! #! $#* #* E=BF/22(+ 3(4444444444:3(4444444444),/ >#,22.(
-,01/-,22/ +?-./+
8 !$###$ #$ : %#* < $!! # ,22. ! .. '#,22?(
/( # ., *# ,22?) 3( 4444444444 ! ! !*# 6% = )& #;; $ 3( 4444444444);#%'# !!*#)#%#>#!# ## ; $#!##!:$ !':%#?,#!, # $!! %#* < $!! #) .0 !*8 .112 5= M " B0,(..9(:;%8#$##$* !!* ##!(
B( .A!*8,22?)% = !*#!#! *## %#* ## 3( 4444444444) ;% $#D# 8#$#!..'#,22?(
G( ./ >'# ,220) 3( 4444444444 ! ! 6 ## %#* < $!! # 5#+ 67 ## 9( : %*## '# : % = 8 ' &#) ##; ; $ 3(4444444444%* E=BF/0A)02'#@*#!# '#* 8($#'#D*#'7
+"!D##5(BG1BA0 #'## .2!*812G5 "+",.29D*8 # ## 8#9) C; #!# % 8# #8## '# %8#D# % %#(
+%#?,#!,= !'I#;$#!#:%# #8 #'!; !##88!#!#8'( '# ## ; %*8 ! $# #!# % *#$*##)!#:%#8#I'#:!*## '#') #@!#+#(
+ $$## JI %C8##L C#$$ , ;## #! & #!# % * '# !# $** #$$! *# ##'# ' !# .%,22 *, * ( ##)%#* #'##$ '#'(
A( ,A*#,220)% = ! >#+#( 6'# !;%#,.#!.8=!##* 8 '#'#8 #%#8#88 !'# %D # # #!! % # ># 8 : # D#) !! %# ?, #! , = #$ :
-,01/-,22/ +0-./+
!#$#!#:%##8 #'!$#'# & ###'7
+ # $# %# !#8 $#* % # C#;) *# # !*#;) N # #8)%*##%!N#'#;%#!!;# *#6:#''%D###(
+ " @ #8 *###$ =#8D 5' $# .,-,222 (A2B+A2G9) % ; ; *!D* &!# *#6 #D#$##' $#&# ' #' ;%# % # #!%*!#% #! %# >#(
+ ;## J' #'L) ' $$## JI %C8##L)#6 *!D*&!#!!* !*# $#&#'#'(
+ % = * !#) %D# % '# ! #!#) $# #' #! : %# >#7 ! # <) # !) # C# 8#D#) # 8 8#D# 58 '# 8#; CO '##9) $# >## '& *#!( # !# %8#D# $# & #!# $* & # # !D # #'! # 8# 8# #8##( % ## #8%*!#%#* ;$#%#>#(
+ ) #$#'&J '#!L E= .,2(+ ## ! #'! %### ' 5! #!9);# !# $#%#%#8(
+ ;#%'$)#8#; J# >#L E= BF222(+) # *# %!8# ;%# %D## $$#'* $# %# ; & *# % = ( ) ## D!!**#*#6$#)##*8#:#;# !# : %&# % $# : !# : #*# $# % ' !;%!C 'P %) '%'# !! !(
1( A ># ,22/) ## 5#+ 67 ## 9 *# #* 3( 4444444444( *## !;%#.#!.% $##$ #'!!#8%#* <$!! # 5"B0,(..B(,9 !*!# # *8 $# %# !#8(
-,01/-,22/ +/-./+
##*!;'&>##'# 8% %# ># %#8 #88( J$#7 '#!L #:$#!#*## ' %D ># * 6 * !#8 P ) #' #'* $#8 * $! $#*# ;#$## ! %# #88 : #( $Q D!!) # #$ $! %!# #* #8 ' I %* $# %# ># %#8 ! ' $# ' 8* !# E=,F02,F12/(+( ! DD! %'# ## $##! %D*'%#8# '(
6'# !># #':%*###%$$# $# # %# ,, # ! *###' ., *8.1A/5 + /.29)'#8# #) ## ) ; #88 %'# # ;% !! #! #*$ * E=BF/22(+) #!!;!#! %#># %!,22. ##*#!: E=BF/22(+(
$# ! * E= /22(+ #88 : # ! (
!##!!#$#!.G>#,22/:% = (
.2( ., ># ,22/) % = ## #8 *###$ % !####( :%# !##$#'#& ##D*#'7
+" ## D!!**#*#6$#)##*8#: #;# !:%&#%$#:!#:#*# $# % ' !; %!C '( ##)#88;##$#'#$#%# %#8'#>#:!#$# #6>#$##' !!#!$#(
+ % = ! ># $#8D# !>: #! ! ! ' %#! #$!# 5 ) ( 19) ;# !$6:## !#*#6$# R#C(
+8'#'!#'!D#!#* #!###%!# #8%*!# %#* ; $# %# >#) ; ' $# %#8#$$#!'!(
-,01/-,22/ +B-./+
+##'#*#!#$#%# ##D#& *! # 6D $ ') # %'# !! !*!;$#DD!'# #;8*##' %#8(
+ % = ! $# %# % #*#! E= /22(+ : # ! #88P * # ## 8##) *##88%'#! !;%? DP ) #88 # # % $*# *# !;#' : *#%'# *!%#%#*#!(
..( . *8,22/)3(4444444444! P# !8*% = *#$;%#!#$* ## #! #8#'#* $#%# ;# # #88()$##D# #*#J#' >#L(
.,( %#* # #%;@ G '*8 ,22/) 3( 4444444444) ID#) !! ;#! !*#( & ! ;%# '# $$#'* * # '& *# * ,22. ># %#8 ##D#&P # %D## #C#8)%#8%!'!8#( '#)#%D## '&#: ' '&8(
#8!*#!*#$;%#'#!8# ,/>#,22.("#) :C E=BF222(+ # : %# # % * E= .,2(+ : !*#(
.?( .G'*8,22/)% = %!*#!( *#!#) %D# % '# ! #!#) $# #! : ! #<):%#!):#8#D#C# 8 ## ;%& '& >## #! & SC !#!( '& '# '# ;%: %# %#8 : *##%!N#!#;###( % 6)* E=.,2(+! ! #88%!# !#8 #;%#%D##) !*#) '( :%###&* E=BF222(+)# *#%!8#'#;%#%D###! '& %#( T) $ ' #*8# #88( "# #8 *# $# ; # $# '#@*#!#)#%I'# #*% = &$# !)'##*& ! #;'## #88 # ' !#! $# ;%# !D#';@! #8(
-,01/-,22/ +G-./+
.0( A!*8,22/)%##*!'!;% = *#!# #C#8("##!#;$#%'# !! !8#) # # # ;# ;% #*# !# ;@( # #*8# $# $# !) #;% *# !# % # *# $# #88(
./( 1!*8,22/) #!!#$*!;!#D!: >D(
,, $!'# ,22B $#) %*### $!! #8# :%*##% = P,G*@**#)! !! !:# #(
!
.( >! * # ' >### * !) '85(/B #FD##>###,,'*8.10.+ + ,2/P(B?(.#( 9(
,( ;#;# % 6#:!*## !# $ >## * E= BF/22(+ *##8(#88%I $#)#*##!# : * *&#* E= B%/22(+ 5*D! $ E= BF/0A)029 % !(
?( ( "%#,/=)'!$; ' #* 8 !# D!! $# *#! & # ,B:??(
"%#?,#!,.6 C=)#88;# 6 #8 #'! !# $# !# : #) #* %#':#8$#%*### #(
% # $!! !# $# #$ & #8 #'! %#* < $!! # ,0 U .11, 5"B0,(..B9 ):#.#!..6 C)&%#?, #!,.6 C=>;$#;#88#DD #; *#6 ! # #!! '* ;# ;# '# !! * >;%## #!# !! !'!5(.(.,6* C9(
" 8 = # $!!) %*### $!! #8# !) ,0 U .11, !D*)
-,01/-,22/ +A-./+
$# #$ & #8 #'! !#8 %#* < $!! # 5" B0,(..B(,9) %# . #'7 J." ##!#8$##'7 ($#%#7 .(! &! #&!'#)# %T D*#'%#8) ,(VWX) ?( $# %& ##7 #8# !##; %6'* *!D6 5*# #8# !'! ## + I9) %! # &) %!#D ID P %# P & #8##6 ! #* < !P !#8# #DP $# %# %!#D #6 ##! ) %) () * N #!#*P 8( #*%7VWX ($#%*###7VWX
, !#8$#%##'7 (! ;%#88DD)'*! #8 '* ;# ;# '# !! * #!# !!) !#MD!!#; *#6 !M;##%;###5 #; #8$!!*#6 $# 6%;###9P 8(#8##;)&;*# #!#) ) #) 8D) ## #) & * : ' ##) ! # &) DO) !##!))!!'##!!!)(P (VWX (VWX ?[…]L(
" %# ?0 =) ' @ !# $# ! ) ##) $# %;###) # %*!## %!!*$(
!##&!D;$#%#'#:*## ' % #8 !#8) # ! ;# D*#'#+#(
8( #@.1G?)># #8$!!#6; ;% 8S#* !'! ' #!# 6 %C) $# '& ## #! ! $# %*!## 8# $# %# 8S#*) !#8'85 =118?B,#(?8 (?B/+?BB9(
-,01/-,22/ +1-./+
.11G) ># !! !#!( #8 $!! ! ;+#'# 8%%!D#!$#% %;! % #8 *'# ! : 8 #&) ;# # !'# #+#)% )%;!%#88! #& !'!)8#!'#(!D* !#!;%='# 8 %%!D#!#888 #!#8#'5 = .,?,.A#(.8 (,,.)$#*!%@ #8$!!..># .111)#7 C#'#$#G2-,22. (.//#? (./19( #8 $!! # &*#! ;# M % : ; !# !## ># M 8# #8##) ;# '# !! * ; #!# '# $# %# ' : *## ' 8#) *# ;# M : * M ## $$#'* : D*#'(#!!;) #* #; .1G? >#$##) N U %# #8'*;#8! '#@!#8);%# %D##%#5 =.,?,.A#(. (,,,+,,?9(
># !#! #8$!! !J*+&#L #8$!!#+*@*@!# #(
># #8 $!! % #' & $# !#8 5" B0,(..B(,9 !#8##! $# !'# 6 %;### % 8# #8## 5 @ #8 $!! , (0A2-,220,$!'#,22/)#(,(.:,(?P, (?A1-,22?.2*,220) #(,(.,(,9;#% ###* 5 @ #8$!!, (//B-,220,*,22/)#(,(,(,9(%I %@ #8$!! 8#!#$:!#$#>#D 8% !#!(
( ;# '! ! *!# # ' ># 8#!>7
+!#### !# R#C.A$!'#.1??5R??-.1?0 (.A1(AB9)%;# $# %# 8S#* ;# !! &*#!P ' ) ## 6 8#6'* ##;! ; $# %# ># '# @ !# ; * N # !# * % !## ' %#8( # 8# ! ! 6 #8$!!!##!!>!A>#.1??(
+!#### !# R#C.>#.1?15R?1-.102 (?2(./9)#!!#!!;$# %#>#!#!#8)*N#'## #$# 8# ) ;% *# !# D$ !#!##! ##6
-,01/-,22/ +.2-./+
>#( % 6) $# %# % D ># ' *6*)#) D)C*#%6) D'#)C*#>#)88#'#!!*#( 'C)$# '# !&$) D& 8$## *#(
+@0>#.1A0) #8*###$ CS &*#! !# $# %# % #8 5 = .1A0 (?1BP"'-'$#.1A/ (B.,9P#!*! &@O#C# !#!#!!;>#) %# ## # /22 $ #O #$$!) !# ># %D!*) ; $ I #' %!# !#85 =.1A0 (?1G#(09(
+ #8 *###$ S+ * D &*#! *@* ;#@.G!*8.11G5"C#.111,/(B ??9($#*! #;##*#6 %#* < ;# %*# !# $# %# ># ; ; ># '# !! # #!# !*# ' %#8( %) %'# !! ) ; >### % &*#! !# $# %#( @ B!*8 .111) #8 $!! $#*! ## # 5"C#,22.,/(B009(
+ .,*#,222) #8*###$=#8D# # &*#! ;# $# %# ># 5 "C# ,22. = ,/(B 0,P " ' - ' $# ,222 (A2BP = ,222 (.GA9( ! ; %# ## *#6 %#* <) J;% #8 ! #!#) ! !D#6 %# ># ' @ !# ; # >##D*#6#D#$##'$#&# '#'( %$$*#;%# ># *## ' %D %#8 ! #!#( 'C) ! %# *!D* &!# ;# !D# ! #'! #!# !#8V'!$!X( ##)U *#6 #)C D6 %D!*) %# >#D) %D#) ! #! & *#6 *# %*!D* &!#)! *8##>###;#;##) %D C8#) : CD # !#8( VWX 'C);'#' * *#6#D#$##' *!D*&!#)! #8) '#' ! !8#D) ) ' @ !# 5!$!9( VWX ## ## %#! ##*! $ !#
-,01/-,22/ +..-./+
! %# *!D* &!# % ##8 # ' ># !#+#'*$#&#'#' =#8D( VWX( *) ' #' #$!#* *!D*&!#);%#% ) D ' !*#) # #! %* #! %#*!D*&!#L(
( 'DD!!&#*#6$## $# %# >#P ># #8 $!! 5J*+ &#L9 5Y(Z" -()!##$##5#* <#9) 06* !() ,22,) (.AA+.A1 ( 00P [( ") # $# #) ,6*!()S,22,) (.0?+.00(,?09%&# # $!! I ! 5 ( 3 " - ( E ) "I* C\#O#C"C)B6*!()R#C,22,) (,/.(,09(
# ## $# ; #; #8 $!! !'! % # C#; : # !*#; $# %# D5(RY E )#73(RY = -( E "5!(9)]O* C\#O#C "C) - , DO ^8 # #_ 59) (.+A,)R#C,222)(.,(?,=P(+3( )#$# #7%#* ##'$),6*!().11A) (002P (" )%#* ##'#').1AA) (.,2+.,.9(
### # $# %# #) !#8) ! %#'#* ! %*!##) !#8)!D* !5 (E`E-(Y )"C) ) " 8# *aD) \8b#D_#) C*) D) #CD) 16* !() ,22,) (.0G ( A2P ) (#() (00.P (" ) (#() (.,,P(RY E ) (#(5,2229)(.2(?, =P '# # =( E - Y( = - "( ] =3 ) ] O* C*## R^C "DO) R#C .111) ( ,/ ( ?2 "-RE) %(?2(,"DOO#C#A>#.11GV"-REB?.(.(XI *88:%(?,(,=9(
##* 6###& #;; !*# # ! 6' %# # # #'#*' +')#$ **%;###% 8# #8## $#& ' %D ###P '& * ''%D%#8!#8)# '&D*'%#85 ( 3 )$#%# %#8 #'! # $#) - ,220 (.?1P 3( " ) R #C 8OD$bC#D_# ] #DC$C) "C\#O Cb-%& * 8#.1AA (.AP(= 3 ) # #C CD #DC$C_) " ' - ' $# .1AB (0//+0B2) !#* (0/B9( ;$#) #
-,01/-,22/ +.,-./+
'& *@* * 6 %# 6 %#'#*7#$! #&!D#5 (E`E- (Y ) (#() (.0A(A?+A0P % !## #! D'# ! .1A2) '# 8 !! = 3 ) (#() (0/G9(
$#%#6!P#%D#$# '& #)!$# ##)!'## $Q * * ) $@ ) * *%## %*@*'5 ( 3 ) (#( (.?19(*#$#%*!##!#8 #%## %%#8)%*!D**8)* ! &) # % ># %C#' % DD 5 ( 3 ) (#( (.0.9( *#6 >#) $# #$ & 8) & 8# & C# !#8 5 ( E`E - (Y ) (#() (.0G(A29(
# =) E #* ; !#*## $#%##'#*!#;#>#( ##) ! !D#6 %# * * ) *!## <)! #C*#*># $#%#P#*@*$# '&!D# !8ID)ID) DO) #$: ) $#!D*( 'C) *#6 #%8)8# ! $#%#5( E )]O* DO ^8 # #_ ) .( #) ( . M 0A ) C\# ,22.) ( ,A ( ?, =P '# # ( RY E ) # #_C#C CD ' #DC$) S .1AB) (..A+ ..19(
) ; #88 #+*@* #!!) # ## 8 * !# $# ; ># # !! # * '#'8##8##5( E ) (#()(,A (?, =P ( " ) (#() (.,,P ( RY E ) (#( 5.1AB9) (..1P ( ] ) D #D* #* #''*aD # "C\#O)#C$.1A?) (.BG9(
% 6) # ;# #' @ ! #'*7 # $ %8'!#$#%#%D# *#6 #%8)8# C#P#$#*#>#'#' %#8P # '# $# '# #) : ' ### %#8)'&$$! ''#;* :*##%!(
-,01/-,22/ +.?-./+
!# %#* <) *# ! #88 # .1AB( '& ##D#& ## ) ;@) *#6 #%8)8#C#); 6!#8# @&:(
"%D# ;#) % = # ; ;## J'#'L)'$$## JI %C8##L) * #!*!D*&!#!!*#! !*#'(
%&*;##J#!& #!#% * '#L5,0(22(2=B00,22.+9!*# % = !'6;'#' 8##8## !!##;# &#$$! I %C8##( %##;%*###'#' .%,22*, J$ L'#$$%##.)2/;% * #!! !D $$! $$## 2)A ;% *# ##'# ' *# .F,22*, # ' 2).( $*# * 8#; !#$#; !' >#( # $# $# #88 !; %8 $*# 8#; ) % ; $ );:) #* !*##$$##(
3@*%# !!*!*# $#&#' #'$*# !#!)*!D*!*# # * !*# ' #' 8# ##D#&) ;# * % 6 >#) ; !# $# %# # @(
$#) ;@ *# %!8# ; * E= BF222(+) * #$##D#) #:'&*##! #!!%##*!(
'# 6 %* ;% * E= BF222(+ @ !# #88#%#>#)D*! # ( 'C) # # #+*@* '& %*8#*):C E=.,2(+% 6(
0( %#! !## ## *#$;+#!#*#! !:%##*!(%I #%*#66!#: *#( "%D# ! !' %# .0/ =) # ' J # L !# : # ' ##)#8!% :%$$#! : #) :$#*%#%$$#! : #)6;%#%#! %#B0#! *##$!! !*###'
-,01/-,22/ +.0-./+
,2 !*8 .1BA 5 + " .G,(2,.9) % ## # @ *#&;%D#;(
$$# ; # #88 % + '##:%#%#*#! !( !####D#! #(
/( D#> *#)% :%# % #*#! ! +' #8 *###$( # !( "%D# $# !) # '# ;%& #%8# ##(>#$#6 *C:!** E=/22(+)I* #$# %;@( ccccc
( ! !
+,-"%7
! '8 #>! ., ># ,22/ %*### $# !####%#* <$!! #A>#,22/P
-"#7
* #*P
!## ## %#* <$!!# ;%'##:%*###$# '&# 8%*!#8 E=BF/22(+;%#*#! ! E=/22(+:%##*!P
'# # : ' !##) * !#8 ! $#&!: E=BF222(+ $#$$!:&'>!P
> P
*:CD%*###$#!** E=/22(+P
*:CD3#4444444444)!** E=/22(+P
# ;) $*!* & # 1G #' # $!! FD## >###) !@ @ !) '##*###$) > 6 #$##) ' #8 $!!P *!*#
-,01/-,22/ +./-./+
###;#)*#$*I ' #D *#P##@!#&* #*# #8 $!!) .222 .0P ! @ #6 # )#';!*I ')#'@>#:F'#P
#; ! @ : %*### $# ) : ## %#* < $!! #P : #!! $### %& # !'## "( () *# %##*!) ## ;%: %*### $!! #8#(
"#!D7 3(IC6) !#)3*'I)E#)3( C!#)>D)3() >D !(
* #8*###$7
D$$#6+>#7 !#7 (#+"#D# =(IC6
#$*@!!#;!& #(
6') D$$#67
-,01/-,22/