Material Breach of Supply Contract Leading to Construction Delays
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA party alleged that the other breached a contract by failing to deliver certain required materials by specified dates, resulting in delays and increased costs for the claiming party's construction project, while the defendant counterclaimed that the plaintiff's actions caused the delays and financial losses. The court found that the defendant materially breached the contract by failing to timely supply materials as required by the delivery schedules, concluding that the defendant's failures were the proximate cause of the delays and damages suffered by the plaintiff, and therefore, the defendant was liable for breach of contract.
Regesto Legislator
Ufficiale; INSTITUTION UNIVERSITAIRE ; ÉTUDIANT ; EXCLUSION(EN GÉNÉRAL) ; CIRCONSTANCE EXTRAORDINAIRE | Élimination. Circonstances exceptionnelles. Recours admis en raison de l'existence d''une interprétation discutable d'une disposition du règlement d'études applicable, d'une apparente inégalité de traitement en matière de délai de soutenance de mémoire et d'un accident cardiaque survenu au père du recourant - lui-même atteint dans sa santé - à la veille du premier examen qu'il devait repasser. | LU.63D.al3; RU.22.al.2; RIOR.14
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order to dismiss the appeal.
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!
"#$! %%%%%% !"#$%&'
'
& '
( )
()*+,(
(
+. '" //////% //////+010% "'" 2'"&"% "$$" 3 4"&" 5& 6"(57 4"&"8 " 4 $"9 ),,,(),,+% "" : " ''$"9 '" 6"(57 :8% ' " 5(" ''$"9 '""' ''$""9.
'2"'$),,;.
). &%"4"""'<$$"=$4':'" 6 8''$"%"$2),,;'& 4'2"'"".
>. ?"& '$" "<$ % . ////// 4 & @:""';$),,A'4B34 @$"'4C"&),,;(),,A9"""".
;. :'$''""'+-$),,A%@"9&'"':: &"' '2 <"9 D' 4@$. ?4<" 4 ::"'C'"9%""'"$"$"4&"D< " ' ":" $"% " &" '$" 3 5<$94"""'""24""3"'<& "94"$""'.
A. ""')$"),,A% '"D4''""'.
$'"5<$'&"&2$B"&'9. 2"D":" :":"$"'""3':"$"' ""' 4@"'% '$ ' $&" '2 @@@$@9"4".
5 " " & '"5 @ '"' "& '$ $"@% 'E : ':'" & ""' 4@"' )1 $" ),,A% 42 ""$"'$"''$$D":".
-. '"'4 ),,A% . //////4""39@$% 94"'".
1. $"'4'$<% . //////C: @ : >+ ''2 ),,A% ' &'" C' @ '" @$"'4C"&94"&"3'&.
*)+,+*),,- (>*+,(
"' '25$ % F$ ":" ' $"@% ""' 4@"' '& & 'E:%"4'2"' '$:"@3 :&"),,-.
:: 2" 9 . ////// ':: 4 C" C" '&'9:@'<"9.
G. EC'""&"4@$%""3 . ////// @ " @$ $ 4C"&% '" H''$" $'5 '"<"'I""9H$"'''$"I%@9"&" 3"'4C"&),,A(),,-.
0. 4'2 9 ' "::" ) >% . ////// 4 3 '&'&@:%'""'+,$),,-.
+,. :'$''""'$"%@"994'25$ "$ "&'9% " &" ":'$ C' D' $"@@$94"&":"9'5&"& '"&" &" 4B &""$ 4 ": 94 " : 4" @.
'::'"$" 95' $" +) :&" ),,- 4" C" ""& C'"" J ' E'$ ''" "< '$"' C'$2'$'".
'$'::"'% . //////&"5' $" "% 9" 4&" ' " ' '"' 9 )1:&".'"""'9'""'""'".
++. ""'+,$"),,-%'E:D4''""'.
. ////// &" D3 2:"" @ '<"'% " &" C' 3 @ "<$ C" 9 '$ "=$. '% " 4&" 'D'''$$'"5'"$4.
+). E'"&'% . //////"D'5 GD"),,-.
:"&'"9$"5@"'''3''%9 'C4&'"'3$'$$'""=$'":'. &'$$'&94""' ""92:""'""'2"":::&'2 :.
*)+,+*),,- (;*+,(
:" &$ 9" 4" '" ' " &" 2" " &"B''$$"'@"'.
''"34"'""'+,$" ),,-3&'"""'"3@@$""<"@' "'4'$),,-3'"'$$'"4""3:"'&$2),,-.
'""'""'4::":.
+>. 4"&"4'''.
&$ . ////// &" 4$BC " @ @$ 9" " " ' $$'" 3 $% 494"&"D32:""@'<"'".
" ' '""5$ '<"' &"" 3 :&'" 4 $"5@"&<""4<""$& ".
+;. ""' "" )0 D" ),,-% $ ""' 4::":%"'$$$'&""'%D.
+. ""<'""'''""'+,$"),,-"D " < :'$ " 5 4'" '$% ' &26.-)'"4"&")-$"+01>(K +>,L.G1 5<$4"&"1$2+0GG(K +>,.,-L.)-)1 5<$ " ": @ ' 4''""' ' )A:&"+011(8.
). . . ////// '$" 5<$ 4 : ": "=$ 4 ':'" 6 8% &"< + ''2 +00G +''2),,,6"(57 8%9$"'""'4"$""' "9"2"@$$" ":"@%'"->">))")2.
2. "5<$&'"9'<$$44@$ $""$$'"$$@"$$.'D$'":&" '$$""' "=$ '% 'E : '" " 9" :" $ " 3 ''< 4% &'"@$$"$@"$$6.A>.+) 8.
*)+,+*),,- (A*+,(
' '2" "=$% 4" '" " @$ "<$ 9" ' & 4 2"<% :: & 5&@9"%"<'"$$'"6.A;.+ 8.
@$ "=$ ' " 3 :" $ 4C"& ' @$"<$"&"$4C"&%3"':" $4'@$"<$"&"$4. " "" "=$ '"& "$"&$ @ "' 4@$9""&$""'@"=$6.AA.) 8.
'9 ' ":" 3 ;% 4" '"2"" 4""3@$<6.A-.+ 8.
:""$" '4"9"7
. 4 @ @ "' 4@$ "& ' $""'@"=$L
2. <" C :""": @ @$ ' 3 ' $$'"L
. 4'2"=$"4:"@34"A>.
4"$""' '' 'E : &" '$$""'"=$6.-+ 8.
. " 9 ' ) > 3 "' <% @ @$ H''$" $'5 '"<"'I H$"'''$"I% . ////// '&" ""' 4"$""' :.
>. . '4E'"%'"&'9'$$$"$'E:"9 ""'4@"';$),,A"3''"4":'.
M'$" '25$ % " :" &'" 943 5<$ "=$%"B"$"94"4@@ "'"&'$""''$3@$4"'% 9':"$4">-"+.
2. "'""'<4"5$""45 "'""'6""'"8.?""""'@ ''"2%D<CC&"2''$<< "' & 4 "'""' ' '@ 6""' E$"98%2'"&"%"<"5$4"B'<6""' ''<"98%""9&'''94''$$ &@'"6""'C"'"986 N) .)-*),,A%+;D"
*)+,+*),,- (-*+,(
),,A% N ).-0*),,) )> 'F ),,)% N +.)+*),,+ 0 :&" ),,+% *>0*),,A8.
4D' 9 "" 2' :'"% ' "& " ':"%"$'94$"""'42"''$'$'3 ""4$""%"""<$<"6:..0 '""': ':"'"+G&"+000( .(? +,+L N).+>;*),,>-$2),,;%. ''%'"$""":%+00;% .;>A8.
. "< @% 4" ' '" "$"&$ @ "' 4@$ '"& 3 ' $""' @ "=$6.AA%.) 8%4"$""'''4"4 @@"'"&$""'6.-+%.+. 8.
"4''9@'99" "'""'% 9" & ::"&$ ' " 3 @ ""'"::.
5<$"=$""<5<$: ? ?9'&2<<"'&6.))%.) 8.
"@944">-%"9" 3"''9"""'3&'9" '&'9'"'$$EC'.
?' 5<$ 9"'% " 9" 4'2" ' ; 4"" 3 @$ < 6. A-% . +% C'$" &""'4''">;6.AA%.A 88.
. 9"59:9"'&34'"<"@ ""$" " "$' " &" 94 $$"4"24$''&""'.
"'"%'@9":":""3 9 " "' ' $'" 4 "' < 6:. ' "..1%.- 8.
;. . @"5$$'E'& . //////'4@""'" ''$$'""=$.
" 4$2 & 3 < 9 4@"' 6 "$ 4"$""'8'4D":":"9 . //////4&" '''$$'"3$'$(3.
*)+,+*),,- (1*+,(
$"&'9'E:'D":"D 4''""':'$'.
2. "9"""$"3 . //////':"C" :&" ),,-. " 4'2"' < ' " " 9" &" :"@ """$%"'$$'".
' 9 4" 3 % . ////// '.
:" &C &'" 94" &" D3 "< &" EC5% " 3 '" 4" C'"@ D $$'" "=$% ' 9 " &" '2 ' A% 94" " 'D' "' & ': //////% C< &" ' $$'" "=$% 2" 9 4E '"" :'$$ ''<"'% ""&"'$$"994"4"'$"C2""3'".
D' :" 9 ' :" 5< < 9"5$ $4%34"4"9"%$22"'% 4" & ' " '"". $B$ "% @ :% ' '$$ '% ' 4B 3 @$ 9 " " ""%'$'":<$%4"&93""$$"$ "<:%'39"'"34< "4"$B$''.
. ?' %'E:'""9":" $ " 3 ''< 4 ' @ $ $"$@"$$%D$'":6.A>%.) 8.
. //////'"3'C<'' 'E:4"9"'%'''4$2 $"5 " 2' ' "% 9" 9 $ "% $'"& " "' 4 C 3 @ @$3"'4'$),,A%'"'$$'"&" '>,'&$2),,-.
. "" 4<" "$ &"' '94 ""' 2" """' D""9 9" D":" $'": "'2 < ""' :" 3 <$ ' '94 '$ :" """'9"4"$'&"'%4(3("'99" $224"$"5""99""$224 $"5"::6 N) .+1;*),,-)>D"),,-8.
42'$""'4"&"'"% "$'$'""2<":42'$$'"
*)+,+*),,- (G*+,(
' 9 "9 O B '% "" 9 5<$ 44E'".
@ ""& A $ +000 ' $$'" ? ''$"% $ '5< ':% " 2" "2E"'94"9'$$'"'"&'"" " & 5<$ 4 '"% % 3 :" '""5$ "$4P6.>8.
A. ' "&'9 :" 4@" "' @"' '$$'""5$$'E.M'$"'25$D3&'9%4" "9&3'5%'"":'$""D'& $" @$ 94" &" :"% '" "'% 9" 'O<<&'::"'.
4" )) " > % " '" B " '$ ""'@"''4""'4"$""'.
. ?'D"' % 4@"'9 ""'9"""5$<&'4".'9"' @"''%""'&B5@"'9 "::2'F$'&'.4@$ "' @"'% 'E ' " 4' "' 4 <'&'"4""'9""':5'"2""C'""" '"'. %:"%2"'""'3 '" $"9 "$" 3 &":" 9 (" 4 2 '&'" 4""' 9" " ':" 6 *;G*),,- +A D" ),,-% *AG*),,->,D"),,-8.
' 9 5 4 'C " <'""'@"'6 *G1*),,;>,'F),,;8% $B$ 94 D< 9 4" <& 2" 'C 2 4 "'4@$"3:'"@"''3'2"' "' @$ 4" 6""' . *1,*0G>&"+00G8.
2. 45% 4"&" ' '25$ 9" ' " 5 '% $" "$ 9 ""' &" $BC"(""@$49'25$' &" D3 " '$% E 2:"" @ '<"' @"'% 9 " ' '""5$ &"" 3 :&'" $ @"& < 4<" "$ & ".
*)+,+*),,- (0*+,(
. <$ D< 9 "$ :" : "' @"' $'": 9 4" &" D3 $" 2:" 4 '<"' 4 2. ' " 4" E " 9":"""'4@"'%4'"'"""@$"4$2 "' "" 9" ' & 4".4''""4'<"''"94$3 '""'':'""'.4$""'"' @"' "' ' "& 3 4" 6 @$ ' "&""8 9 "' :" 3 4'"<"4"$""'6 *>>*),,-+0&"),,-8.
% '"9% " & "( 6. > % 8 9 $"5""'4"$""'''' . //////&4B& 5''""'%B"'$'":3""9.
-. 4""' "'""' "2 45% "::"$"@"9""94"$&""2E: 5 ' " "' 4@$ ' "% '" :"4$9:'&".
:'9"59'2D"'94"&":'$ ' 4'' @ '"' ' ' ' $ $"% $" " " " " '$ 4$2 "' '&'" 4""' 9" ". E 'Q%$""'"<":42"".
'9 ' $". ':'"% "$" '"& B :"@:"4&"9"""'@"''":&'" $"5"D":"2:""4'""%"$'<
6 *;-*),,;);$"),,; *>>*),,-+0&"),,-8.
. ////// 2:"" "" 4 "$ " C 3 'C" "'"'"@@$9""'"'$$'" &5.'&''<"'':' '25$$"@'''9"''"34$""' '.
1. 4"""<%"4E"&'" $'$.'E"'"'&":"% '$$ MN*"'3"4"$"4" G1") .
RRRRR
*)+,+*),,- (+,*+,(
+ (,
-./0 1!2
&2 ' "D G D" ),,- '" ////// ' ""':"''$"9'"+,$"),,-L
/0"2
4$L
""'''L
&'" '" 3 : " ''$"9 '" ' '& ""''"L
"9S"SQS$'$L
' ' "$" ' MN +4,,,.( 3 C< 4"&"5&L
'$$"9""'3 !"#$%&''%3 : " ''$"9 '"% &" D""9 4"&" 5&%""94$4""'2"9.
?"<7 $'&E%"L "?CC C'%$$2
'$'$$""''4"&"7
<::"57 "7 . "C"' .'&E
'"':'$""''$$"9@".
5&% <::"57
*)+,+*),,-