Damages Calculation Misapplication of Liquidated Damages Statute
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe petitioner challenged a ruling concerning the calculation of damages, specifically involving the inclusion of a specific element of cost, where the court applied a statutory provision regarding liquidated damages clauses to a situation that was determined not to be such a clause, as the agreed amount represented a genuine pre-estimate of loss rather than a penalty. The reviewing court found that the lower court erred by mechanically applying the liquidated damages statute, reasoning that because the provision in question lacked the requisite contractual elements to be considered a true liquidated damages clause, the proper measure of damages should be the actual loss sustained, not the fixed amount dictated by the statute, thus reversing the decision and remanding for recalculation of damages based on demonstrable harm.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF, Art. 93 al. 1 LTF; Damages Calculation Misapplication of Liquidated Damages Statute: The reviewing court found that the lower court erred by mechanically applying the liquidated damages statute, reasoning that because the provision in question lacked the requisite contractual elements to be considered a true liquidated damages clause, the proper measure of damages should be the actual loss sustained, not the fixed amount dictated by the statute, thus reversing the decision and remanding for recalculation of damages based on demonstrable harm.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the second respondent.
Cited in the final order to declare the appeal inadmissible.
Testo completo
!"
## $%%%%%%%%%%
&
' (
!"#
'
$% &' %(((((((((() * (((((((((( $+#$) ,-.- .-*) ,-''-*/,-0-*10'-,2!334% 2-.- -.-,5-516*-*'-7 -8- 5196*:%
!% ; ;' 7, 5** / - 6*0- ' !33<) &' %(((((((((( 23%=--7522--* ) 4%!= -.- .**) 4 - 2-.- ) 3%>= *'-,5-4'52--*6--1 )-'? - !%$% - ,** !33<) 5** 5 ;') -3!%=%
4% !3@-!33<)25',-0-**-/ ,66- 55- 5 55? ' ,-- 0- &' %(((((((((() 7- 0- 0* '5- '5- *5' A'- &-. 10) !B @- != 5'2!33<)/-4=A5'-%
<% '. *-7 !3 5'2 !33<) &' %(((((((((( ,*/&' %(((((((((()-1;*6*) 0,2-C 0%--!45'2% 6-A D- *2- / -) 7 ,*- 6-'* / -7,5*-;'/-5.7-0- *2)2*D2-'?.***.5*-/4%
=% ,- - D' !33<) '? .** 2 ,'2;'5'-1*,*0*/$%B=)- 34%!=%'?*-5*-,**<)6* -6-* / &' %(((((((((() $= 2 !33<) *-- ,*-'--6*)55--,%$4E$21.',*%
B% 51 0- 5- - *) &' %(((((((((( --* - 0 -1 ; *) 7- - !! 2 !33<% -) 6- 5 / &' %(((((((((( 521' 5 7D 0- * / - D -5- 5--1%
>% -. $$ 0'2 !33<) ,*- 6'* 55-- *--,*-'--'*/50-6-5'-1* ,*% '-'-!33<) 0-**-5*'-125 . 6-1 @,---5'-- .-*%
4"#
*0*''-7--7521'**5 D** D0- '5FA* -0 02' * 5*5 ;' ;5-7- '0- * 2% 5- - '2 ') '' *-- -2 '---6 !3 G !33<) -6- '*- !3 G !33<) -- 7, - -5?A.-7,-0-*108- 519 :)!> 2!33<)6-*521'5?A.-7*%
#% *-- $ 6*0- !33=) ? 6* -6'* &' %(((((((((( 7 - * 0- @* 55--) '-67'0-*2*-*-/,-5-5 . 6-17,-;---55-6.66- ,'5,*A;;'%
+% '-/54'!33=)&' %((((((((((-@* *--0''--,-0-*8- 519 :% 5 2 .' *055* 55--)/0-'-'2-/-,-5-5--1 '- '- !33< 521' * * ,** !33<) *0*' ;5-7 ,*A 2- ; ;' - @- ,2!33<%
$3% -*4'!33<)&'%(((((((((()-- 51 -0-- '---0 - *-) *- / 5 6- 5 5-) ,.- @ ,55-- 6'* 5 *-- ,*-'-- 6*) '5 -66-* * 5 D*- 5 ;-1' 5- D* *'-7%
$$% 0-* / *5) ,-0-* ) *'-- > 0- !33=) @ / 6-'- *-- 7*% 5** '' 20- -1 ; *) 7- 5*-- 0-***5)55'-16-)7- 5. ,' 0- ''% ,- -) ,0-6-5-,-5-55--521' *%*-0A7-';-'--*6-,2- '? .** *. 5*- / 4) 7- - 5'- / &' %((((((((((6-,*%
*5 ,-0-*) '5.* 5-1 5-) ** ''-7*5 /$!0-!33=,66- **.*/@.%
<"#
$% --.**--55--$6*0-!33=-@* *-*.6'5-51,-*'5*) 028%B!-,-0-*!B'-$+>4 H $43I%#> 1.',-0-*>5'2$+## H $43%3BI%!B!> 1.' - -6 ; 5* ,55-- != 6*0-$+>> :%
!% -- D*-'-- *- 6-;* 5 1.' D-0-* 8% B4 % 4 :% ,% !! -* ! -5 7 D*- 7- *A / ;' / - ,;' ;7 - 5 5 5*01.',*8%:7-2-5;' '-5**-6-;*51.'D*8%2:) *-'-*% ,51) &' %(((((((((( '- 1.' ,* 6* - *'-7 - ,2 !334 8- 519 :%
4% ; ' ,% > '2-* 0 ,% $! ) .-* A7 * - - ,;') ; --) 5-'5 **) - ;--) - 5.) '% *- *- ,;'),*--2-'?5*-*./<) -F-6*-/4%,%$!A-66= 5*-7,,*A/ -,'),*-56-5'-1*57,-- 2'?5*-*./4%-);',%$4 A-66$2 )2-*A*6---65'-?*-'-* 6*,*-7-,52'5'-1*,* '?*.5*-/4%
<% ,51)5**-7;'/-DA-0!33<) ;**-*53%=3%>=% --- D**!33<)&' %((((((((((5**5'-1)*2 ?**-6*-/4% ,--,'!33<)'? .** ,*0- / $%B=) - 3 4%!=% 6'*' ; -5-- 5-) , / @ - 7 6* *-'-* '5'-1*,*%
=% / ;'- - ' ,-07 -;5-),-!!-*4%
B% % J@-5)D;5-7--7- 5--1' .0 5 D*-% ,;' - ;5-) ? 5*- ,* -5 , . 50- ,55*--7--615-2--*A--5--% 5)6-)2-5555*--/,-*
="#
*'-7 -'- / 0*-6- 7 - , 5 2* 50- ,55*-- 7- - ** 6-* 8 &"=3"!33! $> '- !33!I &"#"!33!=6*0-!33!I &"!4"!33<!<'!33<:% --@.*7.0521'*D*'D. -0- 0 1 .0 *5- 6'- D*- 0- F -**''--;5-)--6-7 66 52 - ** 50* 7D 55 -* - ** *'* 5 D*- 8 & $3!"!33< $! 2 !33< *6* -*:% 0A) -66-* 6--1 *'-7 5 66- 5 @-6- -- ;5-% 66) @ -** 7 -66-*) '' 6- D; -0-* -0 *) D*- 5 ;5-) 'F' - -- / D 5 - 8 &"!3"!33= > ' !33= -%=*6*-*:%
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
>% % ,51) 1. 0- ** -5* '-1 2 5. 6-1'-'-!33<% *0*'-/D-.- *A ; ;' @- 2 !33<% -'- '. ,55*--7--6**) 75.27D-
B"#
-) **' - 5 - ;5- @-5) - -* *0*' '0- * 2,?55F*2-% 66)*2;;' - -- ,A-0 !33<) - 0 D-5- 5 5-) *- .' -66-) '? 2 / - ,*0 / !%$% -)5-15-/D55-)/0--0- '2- 0-.-) *-- -2 '---6 - 5 .** - 7 -6'- 5' '---0) - 0 D--- 5'- - *. ) 5 D--* 0 D55*- D66 52 D-5- 5--1 2 *' *% 5--7''*0-,**D *;'-)/-4=A5'-)'-@-!33<) -51*0*''-'-)D6652; -50 --F-0-*%?--D207,56-5 521'/-1;*5'--0 *2-5.%
2% ;521'**07*)2/5- -6-'*---77D0-**'-;OL5-;-0-- 108O:$+G!33<5'-)F0-- '-?-***%
% 7-6-'*-)*-0*7 ;V- -0-* -0 / - 4= A 5 '-) - 5*--'-)*DA5---)- DF 0-% 5' -- 5 D55*- 7 ' 50- 5 *- 5 ;'% &' %(((((((((( D 5 0. 6- - 7 *2 D ;5--) - 55---)D.-'-66 7D-5-*/5*5;'ID--/@/ -1 ; *) ; - 7D 0 % - ) 5*- / *-- D*-'--) D - 5 0. / *.% 6-) -6- '*- 0 5 5*- D;' *-/ -)?*/D5*0-- 5.%
% 7- 5*1) -1 7 D-0-* D 5 5* 50- D55*-- 7 D0- 5 66-'' *2- - -* D-5- 5 5- '0- * 2) *5- D0- - ;5-'* 5 D- -5 %0'F'D.-521'*)- -* D? 5 5 F *2-) 0 D2 '51 D--- '--'52*'*%
>"#
#% 07-5*1)@*%
+% --.*''5V8%44:% WWWW
) '*
+,#-" .
*02-@*4'!33=5&' %(((((((((( *-- 55-- 6* - *'-7 - $ 6*0-!33=I
#-.
@I
-7D*''D5V--'-**I
''-75**--)5-)/&' %(((((((((()/6* - *'-7 -) 0- @--7 ,-0-*) -- 7, *5',--52-7%
J-*.9 &'0?)5*-I &' '--0-&'CC---CC-)''2
'''--,-0-*9
.66-19 5*-9 %&-A- %0?
5-6'*--**''-7*;5-%
10) .66-19
#"#