Contract Breach Over Intellectual Property Usage Restrictions
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe case concerns a dispute over the validity of a contract involving an entity and the rights associated with various intellectual property and proprietary subject matter, where the contract stipulated certain usage restrictions. The court reasoned that the contract's language clearly defined the scope and limitations of the rights granted, and found that the actions taken constituted a material breach of those express terms, leading to the conclusion that the contract was unenforceable as applied to the subject matter in dispute.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach Over Intellectual Property Usage Restrictions: The court reasoned that the contract's language clearly defined the scope and limitations of the rights granted, and found that the actions taken constituted a material breach of those express terms, leading to the conclusion that the contract was unenforceable as applied to the subject matter in dispute.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the final order to rule on the costs of the appeal.
Testo completo
!!"#$$$$$$ !" #$$%&$
$
% &
' (
'()*'
'
/0 # 1222222% 222222/*3*% !% !##! 4 5!&!6&!5#!7(...'(../%!!8 !$$#!7$!9!'6:8;<!=! =!$5!0
(0 ! $ #! > 5 9$ $##; 4 !$ 5?#5$#(../0
?!6# > $#!% &! $<! = $ 5!! $$<(..+0
@0 ?8#!$5$#(..@%$" 6 ? !!!$ 4 !=#% # 1222222 #$! !=4!?!$%$$!!$%!$8!75 &! 7! *. ! ! */% $# $ !!$ !!6%!!75!8!#!0
! $! 4 5!! $!!6# 8$! 4 5!=# A$$#!!!B0!!=#?#7! 5$<!$!!8!?4!$5$$<(..+0
-0 # 1222222 "8 ? 8 # !$ 5$#(..-%$#C##$!8%4&$!"6?!!!$4 !=#0
D $$!!$% !!$ 5?!$ 8$! $ &% & $#<!E4$<0
! 4 $& $! 4 5!! $!!6# 8$! 4 ? !=#A$F=!$BA#"$!!7B%$!$ !8!7#8& !!6% !5$<!$!#8!?4$$<(..+0
+0 !!$(/$$<(..+% #1222222$&? 8% $E$ $ #C# #$!8 5 " 6 ? !!!$ 4 !=#%$!$A"$!$!!7BA#"$!!7B0
,0 5$$!!$ 8$# # 1222222 E $> 8//E&!(..,%#$!8$8!#%75E$! $#< ! !88!% 5< $ ##$! !% !!75"!5$<!$!60
)+,-)(.., '@)*'
30 /@8&!(..,% #1222222!E$6 $##!!$$5!&!9 ;0
$ $ #!7% 5&! 7 !!$ ! $ ! 4 !< $$#!7 &!$ !! $$!$!% 5 75 $ $<6# % 7 $ <&! 4 <$! 8!!% 8$ $ !% 5<$!!&!%!$8$#D40
!#$75!?!!=!!# !!!48&6(..+%$&6=#(..+'(.., #5$$!<!&!!4!/G.!%75 5$E4$#<!!740 $%&!%4C $!4!68$!$!?#755! 4$&$!$!$##$!!5!!8!(..,%<!!!#47 $!&$>45!&!6&$$&!!$0
G0 5!&!5$$$0
5 4 E ! 7 # 1222222 !#! 8 !!$ 6=# 7 $#!% 5 75 E4 =#<8!!$=!$!0
$<6#75!&!75$> $! $ $!!8 !$ ?!$ E!8! $&$=!$0
58!7!$5!>6#$&! $ $$= $ $$ !!$ 5!#!!$ 8$#!$ <$! 4 !% $ 75! ?! !$!!$!$!!7!!C!=$!!# !E!!70
/0 !!=$!!$$$!!$//E&!(..,!E !=8$#!65$!$#%$ &<90,($!5!&!(,#!/*3@'H /@.I0G3 6=#5!&!3#</*GG'H /@.0.,I0(,(3 6=# ! !8 ? $ 5$$!!$ $ (+ 8&!/*33';0
(0 5! ,@ ! @ &$! 7 $!!$ 5!#!!$ !!$8!?6=#5!&!0
)+,-)(.., '-)*'
5!((!!$$!(75!#!5! 7!"$4?#$4!$5?#?7! &6=#590;%$7!<!?# #!!8!?6=#590<;0
!!$5!#!!$!$>890@;0
@0 0 # 1222222 $#! 6=# 8 (...'(../% &!=!/$$</+9!'6: ;%!<4$! 7!$##6$&!=90/,0/I/30/ ;0
D5=!?!6#>!7$&! #1222222 #$#$!#!!$%?#!!!$<!$ =$!4-90/-0(;0 5"$!$$!!% 5!4!$5$#0
5"4!$5$#%5!!!$ 8$!#?!##0
<! 8! ! ! 7! 7! (-. ! $% > $#!!88#!>90/-0(I-4, ;0
5!<!8!"8!!!8?!6#>!#! 8$75!5%:
' 7!#$!@.!5I
' 7! #$! /,. ! 9> $#! ! 7! #! >;6?5?!6#>I
' $< ! $$ 6 ? !!!$ 4 !=#I
' 7! #$! (-. ! 9> $#! ! 7! #! >;6!754$#<90/+0/ 04 ;0
<0 56%!5!$<!$7 #1222222$ #$! "$ 6 ?!!!$ 4 5?# A"$! $!!7 B 6 $!!!!$4!!!A#"$!!7B0
!$!!$ &!% $&! !!$ 5!#!!$80
5E$ 7 $ ! =# !< &$! !#! $ ? #$!8% $! 5&$! ! !#! $
)+,-)(.., '+)*'
5$<!$!%8!?4$$<(..+%5>!!$ $##$!!4%5&$!$<7(/.!! (-.!!6=#6!750
-0 $&$!$!#!!$!4!<$$#!7 &!$!$ !! $$!$!% $ !C !& 4 $<! $=!$ ?!$ & 5!C <! 5!&! 4 8! $6=#540
0 D! !< $$#!7 90 (3 80; =! $! "$!! 5? !<# !&! !& !&% !< "$!? !#!7 !#!8$#!$$8!$0
$8$!% "# #! !< $$#!7 8# $!5648$#!$!$!!&!=#!9 J /(+/3@%$!0@I/(/(($!0(I0KJ %!<$$#!7 ! 8 $! $% "6 6&% (..+% 0 +G;0 $% !< 5 <$ $&% & 5! @, ! / 4 @ $!!$8%$#!4!!$7!$!&$< =%CE!8!!C<!$C$$!$9 0 % 0 % 0 K % $! $!!$ ! % ( 0%(..,%0---IL0'J0 %0 K%!$##! $!!$8%(..@%00/*$3%0(3%$3I J(0(+()(..- /($$<(..-;0
$!#!7$$7"<!!=!4 &$! <!! 6=# 8 $!!$ 5!#!!$ !8!55=!!#&!47! $$!=#!$"&0
<0 $! E! $ $E$ $ ! $&$! M!!$4M#!!!$M$$!$=!$9 J/*3,0/(-I 0 % $! #!!!8% &$0 % % (6# 0% /-% "0 -0/0@0@I 0 K %$=!$$!<!:6=$?!$N! = 0D %"O%/*G@%0++3'+,,I$!$$&$!M?#:80 J/ 0/,G)(..+/E!(..,%$!0(0(//*<-./%$!0+<!8!;0 M$!5M$$=!$7$P?=M> $<!=?#$!#!!#%$$$7$=!$E!8! !$!!6%7$##$?<=? $!&!$!%7M$##M!C<!$!C !& 7 M$$ !C <! $ M !C !& $% $ $ $7M ?!= !! M=! !#%C$!4!C<!9 J//3/-,'/-3%$!0- //3</@-%$!0,;0
)+,-)(.., ',)*'
C#?#"<!!48!%M$!M M$ $=!$% 8 ! 8 ! " M<!! 9 J -3/%$!0@IDL/*G3@*3'@*GI 03#</@IK0//# /*G3!;%!!!&#$#$=$!4 #!6 < !$!!$ $=$! '#C# $ !CE9 J/*G/0-(-;9 J//3</@-%$!0,I %$0!0 0 @((I 0KQ)0 10 K % R=""=% =S=<% /.% $ @3 ;0 E! $ ! 7 $=!$ &! 8$## 4 &! M?C# % #$!!$!!$?!$0
0 56%!!$ #1222222=#!$# !75<8!!?$=!$!>#!5!!$! 8$!4!=#0
$!!$% ! 8! =!8 4 5$! !&!!5&$!<$$&$!5!!$8$!!6# $=!$#% 7!&!!4$!4$4 $!6#8$!4#C#?#9A#"$!!7B;%#C#! ! < ? ? #!6 !$ 9 )/-*)(..@ /+ #< (..@I ),()(..+/+#<(..+;0
0 5 4 $ 8! 7 !6 !# 7 !!$ 5!#!!$ !4$$&!$!!$$!$!9 )+()(..,(( E!(..,;0
!! $$!$! $ 8$!$ !! ! 5=!<5!!$0
$# 6= 57!$ 7! ?!= 7 #$> "$!! $! $ 4 ! < 8!?% #! ! 6= !% 7! !#$ 75!#$>$!"$!!!7!$#$!!? !C !& 9 % % K % $0 !0% 0 /.3 I 0 D K % 0 T % =#! R="% ( 0% (..+%0/-@;0
5$$7$!!45$!"$!?!&# 7!6""'#C#7#75 "<!! 4 !! 90 % $0 !0% /-% 0-/3I )(-+)(..,*#!(.., J(033)(..+(,$U(..+;0
0 56%=!$!!75!7! $!!$$6=#5&5$<!$! $!#!90,@0@%((0(;0
8!%!5!#=#V&45$!#!70
)+,-)(.., '3)*'
$ 7 !6% !! 7 $! $% $! $#!C!&"7!%!! 4 5 $ $<!=!$ 5!!$ 5$! #!7 7! $!! !# 4 #! 5=! !# !% 7! 5 $&< 98 % )-*)(..+ //$U(..+%$!0/.;0
+0 8 $ ?#! ! # 1222222 ! 4 #C# 5!&$7 !!$?!$%5!((!@%7!!#$! $#!$!!65!#!!$0
0 D$ E! $% !!$ C 7!8! 5?!$$75!!6#=&!88!!$5!0 $7 !$ $ % !!$ &C 6 ?!$ 7 ! 88 < $ U# $& $0 E! $8$# !! 5!!$ 5$88!
9 )-/)(..+*E!(..-I )/@)(..+3#(..+;0$! 8! !$ 5 = $&$! 5!!$% $ 7 5< 9 )/)(..+ // E&! (..+I )/.()(..-/($$<(..-8!;0
<0 $#<$=!$$$>4$5 #! 5% > ! 4 ! ! 7 $ ! 5! > &! ! 7!8! !!$ 5?!$% 5$! &! ?#! 5#< !$ % 5$$! ! $=!$ $! 75 # $ ! 8! ! $#
9 )@@)(..,/*&!(..,I )--)/G@&!/G;0
0 #1222222$$$<6#4$!#!!$0
$! 4 8! $! !8! #!?0 ? #! $% #$!8%$!4!$$>?$=!$!&0
8 $8$! $ 7 $!!6# !8! #! 5# 75 $$! $!#! = A77 !88!B 7 ! !$&?#75$!<!0
$ <$ E! #!6% $## $$##$!!$45#!!$5!!$?!$7 $!!$ $ 5! $! =& 75 $ ! $!!#<!&5"!&!!9 )@G)(..,/*#!(..,;0
5#!8#560
0 5 & !88## 5=! 5!&! $> ! 6# 4 $ <&! 4 <$! 8!!0
)+,-)(.., 'G)*'
E!$% $E$$!78!5? !&! !& "$ % ! $!! !# $! #!% 5! ! =&% ! ?!$0 5! &! 5$=!#!675!!#8$!&! 67!!$!&9 )*3)(..@/-E!(..@;0
,0 # 1222222 !# 8! C # <8!! $& !$!!$ =#! ! 8$# $$=% $# 5=!!#0
=#5&<0
0 > !=! !# $7% #$!8 !?% ? !!$ $#?!!$8!#<<46=E!!7!88I !!$ $# $!& !# C !!7 $ $!%#!!#!!$!C<!7!$#8! !$!!$49 J/3.G)(..@(3E&!(..-;0
<0 8 5 $ 5 $& 6=# !$ 5!$!$ < !&!! #W! !&!! ! !$ $$=0 ! & 5! 6=# $ !##!0
5!(+6=#(..+'(..,8%!6=# 5!7 4 $ ! 7! $## 6 $ &!=%$!6/$$<(..+%!!75?!7!!!! #!6 5 / $$< (..- 90 /;0 ! > $## & / $$< (..- $#! 4 5! 6=#5%"$#!??!$%!!50
<! &! 7 $% !! 4 8 ! $$< (...% ! &!7% #! #C# !$!!$ =#! &!% !!$ ! #$! $& 6=#$$!C%!#!!5=! !#78%7!$8!4#!0
30 !6##8$%$$!CE0
!!=%#$#5X90@@;0
$7!$#<5$!490G30( ;0
YYYYY
)+,-)(.., '*)*'
) '*
+!,-."/
&<$!E/@8&!(.., #1222222$ !!$ $$!!$ 8 ! $$#!7 $! //E&!(..,I
!,-0/
EI
!7M!MXM#$#%!$5!#!I
$##!7!!$4 !" #$$%&$$%4 8!$$#!7$!%&!E!!75!&!%!! 75#5!!$<!70
D!=: #$&>%!I !D"" "$%##<
$#$##!!$$5!&!:
=88!6: !: 0 !"!$ 0$&>
$!$8$#!!$$##!7?!0
6&% =88!6:
)+,-)(..,