Contract Interpretation: Minimum Quantity Per Batch vs. Cumulative Total
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe dispute concerned the interpretation of contractual language regarding the provision of a service, specifically whether a minimum quantity requirement was satisfied by the cumulative total of delivered components or if it applied to each batch separately, with the lower court finding in favor of the service provider based on the cumulative interpretation. The appellate court reversed, reasoning that the plain language of the contract, read as a whole, dictated that the minimum quantity condition applied to each distinct delivery or batch, not the overall aggregate, thereby entitling the component supplier to relief as the service provider had failed to meet the staggered minimums.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Interpretation: Minimum Quantity Per Batch vs. Cumulative Total: The appellate court reversed, reasoning that the plain language of the contract, read as a whole, dictated that the minimum quantity condition applied to each distinct delivery or batch, not the overall aggregate, thereby entitling the component supplier to relief as the service provider had failed to meet the staggered minimums.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited for the allocation of costs in the final orders.
Testo completo
! " # $ ! !""#$%
%
#
%&'()* !$"& #$%
'()*'
./ !%"0000000000# 123%42 "%0000000005 6$# 6 $%" # 2 7" 3" % "$ % %" 8 % 2($".*,9: ';((./((*/.</
(/ ;%"" $"% "$5" =">%? .@ %$ 3" 3" "%"2 2" : <#"$%"/
+/ (.A".#2" "3" "$" "$5" 3% 2 " 0000000000;/ //".*A"(,,,#" 3%46 2 "0000000000;/ //
-/ 2 " 0000000000 ;/ / 33= &3= 4" 3 "=%" 8 "%4" %B:"'6C D;< " 5 " %$ "% % "$ $" 3 " =E "3 ) %'F$ 1" $%" 2%="7 "% 3%4 2"" 5 2 % 2%#5$%"$%"#7%3 ! 2G/
@/ 2" "3 3"$6$%"#=8"" "" % ' 2'3" % "$ 7" % D; % $"=E "3 )%'F$/
H/ (H% %=.>%$3=(,,(#2" "3 "" $" "% 2 8% 7"/ % # 1" 3" 3 $" 8 $ "3" A%"6 %"" # " &7 2"" $" % # 6 % 12" 27"" 288 "% 1%1$" 8%"33 "%/ % 8%"# "# % %" (- 8$" (,,- 4" " E "3 :"'6C ;< 1 2" 2 " =% 3"% "$=E "3 /
>/ (H3(,,-#2" "38%3$ "= % %" "% % "% %" 3 "3 52% $%"#% 5% "% 12" " %A% '" % ' 7" % %D;# ="""3 51" 7 "%5% %" %%6.A$"(,,-/
)((++)(,,- '+)*'
9/ %.A"(,,-#% %52"$="" 3# "3 12 " ? I " %" $ "= 3"6" /
*/ "1(A" (,,-#2" "3" %"%/
.,/ "1+,%? (,,-#% 73 " %"%/
../ I (( 3=(,,-: ;)>++)(,,-<# "= % %" 3"%3 %%J " "7%% "/
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
.+/ ( 3= (,,-# 2" "3 % %=$ "% 1 " 8" $%" %3 "= % %" % %J " "7%% " % 5%8"3 "%2I "= %%"(( 3=(,,-#=% 3 $%" 5 %3 "% $%" 5 %/ 2"%"%#2" "3"$%1 B 7 1" 3 2" "% "# $%% 7" $%" A"" "% "1# %8%3" %" 8 8"
)((++)(,,- '-)*'
""62 7"$%$ "%% "$1" A "8" % %3""% "= %%"/
./ % " "%="1 %6$(-3".9->: / 7/ ' ( ,,< " " "= : / .+. / 7/<# &7 & 1 "% %3 A"" "% 3"" "$ 2 # A"" "%"$"%2 : /@H</
2 " @H " . # % " %" 6 "= %8" % ""% "6 " % 2 A"" "% 3 "% 5 2 " @HG " . # %1 A"" "% 3" %3 1 % 67 1 " "7% " 52 %A"" "%/
"%" "% "$ "= 3"" "8 "= %8" % 8" 2%=A 23% "% $"7.3(,,(/ 2 " @HG # 1" %" = %3%" "% "= %8" # $ 2 " @H / 7" 7$%" % 8%" %3" 2 $%" % %$ " @H # " =" 8 5 2 " @HG " . # % 1 "%" "% % 3 %"" "%$ "=3"" "8/$%"52 " @HG " . %" %1 I %3" %33 $%" 5 2 " @H " . : I "= 8 @/+9()(,,-)3" .@ 3= (,,-</
26# % % %3 "% 3 " "= %%" 1"'"2 % I (( 3=(,,-/ "31" "72%% 52" "36$ %3 "=3"6" / " "% "@H 5 @H # "= "" %3 % %J " "7/
(/ / ;% 2 "@H $"7A12+.A" (,,+# "=3"" "8%"" #1" "= % #" %"1C
M<% "%$52 "9H%"8.93.- 2'3"#""1 "$B%33 " 2 ".(#"(#" %"M/
)((++)(,,- '@)*'
2 "+>"(%"2" "%%"82'
3"(*3".>: !'+,@<# $"7A12 +.%? (,,+#"%" 1"" C
M ; %3 : < 2 73 B % "% 4 " B %33 ": /.(#/(# !</M
5 2 " .( " ( %" 8 K'3" .93 .- : ! ' ; 9+(/.,< 1 8"" 8 B "%" "%#"3 "%1"" C
M " 3" % %" "1# 2'3" %" %"#%33 "N$ 73 "1 2 =& 2 B %" "% "3" 8"B %"8/M
2 "+>"( !$" $52%17" 7$%" % " B "%$" " 5 $%" %" # " " ! # % 1 " "7 % "" 5 2'3" %" % B %33 "/ "%" "% $%4 B3 B"" 3 5 2 " .( " ( !# "= 3"" "8 $" A7 12" $" %3 % %J " "7 3 "62'3"%33 ""13 #%1"6 " "1%"# 1 8""52 ".( !/ "=3"" "82 6% "3%3 1% 1 %33 " 8 "1 " 3" % "$ %"5 "12'3"%"/;"2 " #% "%$" I % $ "=3"6 " /
=/ . %? (,,+# 7" 7$%" " " "= % %" 1" %3" %3 3 "6 2'3" %"/ B 3 %$ " @H " . 8"" %3 %$ "=# "= % %"%J " "1C
O< % "% "$ B %33 " 5 2'
3" %" $ %" 8 2'3" .9 3 .- 5 2'" %="7 %" $ %" 8 2'" (,3.*9./M
3I3 #2 "+> !1"$%4" 52 ".(" ( ! "3#I 3 "%" "%7/
""#%17" 7$%"" " %$ "= % %"#"B"" 3 # "%$
)((++)(,,- 'H)*'
%33 "# % 8 5 2 " .( " ( !# 1 %" "% 2 " +> !# 1 2= 5 2 " @H " . % $%" 5 3I3 " .( " ( !/ 2 3# % 1 % 2" %" %33 " $ %3 "=3"" "8 " 8""8 52 ".("( !# "3" "%B"" 3 =% 7" 7$%"8"" "%%3 %$ "= %%"/
/ 3%"8" "% B 2 3 8% " C"B"3 $%% 7" 7$%""3" %3 "=B %" =" B %33 " %88 " 3" % " " "% 2 "$ %" 2%88" 8 %"# 3" 2 '" 73 B %33 " %88 " " "% 2 "$ % %"# "8" ""3 "6$%"%"%"=B/
$%% 7" 18 52 "@H". % " $B %" "852 "@H" . /
;"2B%3% "88" 8 "=3"" "8# " 8" 1# 3%3 "%# " 2 " % 1 "% "=" " #3" P &3= %" " "= 3"" "8/ 7" " $ 1 "% 2%7" "% A"""# 3" %3 A"" "%8% "% 1 "= %#% 1 $B7" "8 %"7 % $/
# % $B %"# 2 " @H " . 2%=A "8 8%3$"" M53"%" "%1"# " "7 $ "$ % "% %33 " 5 2'3" %" % 5 2'" %="7 %"# %% %3" "" "= 3"" "8/ ""# %=63 %=3 $%" % / "# =8""% 2 % % 3"6 " "3 1A7 =" 2%88"8" #""=3 $ 7 " 3 / 73 %B % 23= % "B 3 "6 2 %33 " % " " 12 "3 %%73 2 "->"( +%"8(+A".*>9 $"" " "%2"$:; <1""3%A5 % $%"%"3#" 7 " %% "% "$ B %33 " 5 2'3" %"/M : 9H+H# B%3% "8#7((</
)((++)(,,- '>)*'
$B %""" ""8" 18%3%= "3 4 63 $%" %" / "# %1 2B%3% "8865Q"3%%73 2 "->"( + ; R# 7" B% $%% "3"8" 2&3%" % 8" 1 '" %" "3 " 1 2 =8""2B32%88"8" A7""17 " /
$%=A "8%"$"7" #"A "8"#""1 2 8" "= % %" % I (( 3=(,,-#2" %$ "@H". 3"6 7 1 2$" 8" "= 3"" "8 I "852" "@H 2 %3 "= % %" 5 23= % "% "$ B %33 "1'"%" %88 "3"% "$/
2 " %"7 1 "% %3 3 "6 2 %33 " 6 2 %" A""" 8" 3 %8%35A" "=81"A5A71 %3"2'3"#%" 82"3%B % 2 "=% "B$ "$3 %" "$ %" =" 5A"" "%" " : D.(@/-H+"8"</
+/ " 273 ="""#% 8" $%"12 7" %$ "$ I %" %33 %33 " 5 2'3" %"/ 73 "% I "$"/ 7" 3"# 3I3 %3" B "%" "% # "" =3 %" %33 %33 "52'3"%"#""1A"2A5 =":;(,,.(,*</2 2"% 12 7" " I "1 " 3"# 1" %8"3 %3""% %33 "52 "@H". / %3 %=A "8%"$"7" %2% "% %$"%" "% 1"'#"2 88 %"= 23 1 " "7 %" %3" % % 5 A"" "% "" "= % %" % 1 2 &%"" %" "$%"3"/
-/ %1 $1"6#2I "= % %" (( 3= (,,- %" I %8"3 " "7/
)((++)(,,- '9)*'
2"" "7#3%3 GD(K.,,/'3"5&7 $%"#%37"2$"/"3" % GD(K,,,/'%5!%"00000000005&7% / SSSSS
#
+,-).(/
$=%" A (9% %=(,,- $%"#%37" 2 $" % 2I "= % %" (( 3=(,,-N
-%/
A N
=% $%"# %37" 2 $"# % % % " %"%N
3 5&7$%"#%37"2$"#3%3 GD(K.,,/'N
%"3" %5!%"0000000000 GD(K,,,/'5&7 % N
%33"1 I 5!""#$% % #5!$" & #$% !%"0000000000""12 "= % %"/
;"7 C !/7"#" #!3; #!/ &"#A7/
%3 "=%8" C
788"6'A" C " C /"%';"7" /7"
)((++)(,,- '*)*'
%"%8%3 I %33"1B "/
6$# 788"6C
)((++)(,,-