Contractual Right to Unilateral Fund Withdrawal Upheld
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe litigation arose from a dispute concerning the payment and application of certain financial instruments, specifically revolving around whether an agreement permitted the unilateral withdrawal of funds without further notification or justification. The court reasoned that the plain language of the contract clearly granted the right to withdraw the funds under the specified conditions, and absent evidence of fraud or a material breach by the withdrawing party, the action was permissible under the terms agreed to by both entities, thus affirming the right to the withdrawal.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Contractual Right to Unilateral Fund Withdrawal Upheld: The court reasoned that the plain language of the contract clearly granted the right to withdraw the funds under the specified conditions, and absent evidence of fraud or a material breach by the withdrawing party, the action was permissible under the terms agreed to by both entities, thus affirming the right to the withdrawal.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
The court orders the respondent to pay part of the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Testo completo
!""""""""""
# $
!"#$
%
0 12., 2 /3 ,4,, 1,50, ,678'
!' .,, !9 ( !$$)* :5 ,4,, 0,,,4 .,6 7 8;.,0*0,5<,3=,, 5,,3,55,,>1,9&,':3?01//,,, 1,4,.6 8,@@ = ,312.,2 10>6, /3A,,481.,/0/,'
.,,5 7 ',0,<0,55,/.2, ,..,,,<1.,.0,<0,./'
:C0?/,@#0,!$$@*,D,,0'4,5,5D /(305,,,(*,/< EF9G$$$' /0,4 50, , 5 D :?' ,,, .20 0 12.,'
./, , % 40( !$$)' 7 ,., , 00//,,D.,,!9(!$$)*5,//3+'
,;1//,,' 55*/3.20,5,* ,0, < ,, 1// /, / ,3 =,, 5,,3 ,55,,>' 55* /.;, ,, 5,,3 /4,.;D,!$$@*4. D,H /0.??/,.1./?'
&' #! ;4, !$$&* ./. ?55 0,* +'
81.,,//,,#@.0(!$$)'
., ,, 5. 0., /, . .0,< !$$)"!$$&'4,,4!&D@$:(,?,/0,* <,,,,/0/4,/.I,4,4,4 / 2 53 J 6#& #$ 8 //0 50,.,//,.,'7/3*K?.&&*4,..,,.5,0,!$$@ ,:,4, EFLG$$$' /0,1,:C0? 4 50, , , (..5,,, / D /, ;,' 4,/1,1.*0?../C10'7
"%%"!$$& @"#$
034,,/'550,0/,//0 :. EF 9$9G$$$' * < ., ?4. 1 :M/:3< D EF&$NG9$$' '
71?, ?,5 ,4<. D 1 .,, <.*
,312.,210'55,0,B,, 5,,3 ,55,,* 50.0 D 1, @ ,,4 7' 4, / ,., 5, < /3 :, / ,0,. :C0? D /, # ;, !$$&' 7 /3 4, :. 4 ,0/ !$$@* 0, 2 , /4, B /, ,.,*,/.,,0,.,,0,<' 00 4, /0, =0/ 00.0 (, 0,< 4OP/>*,1,/,*1?M..55.2 ./ / (, 50,' .5, ?0 7 * 55,0 < 1,0,. ,,0 14, / / B ./?.* /35,5D:?01.4D4,F'#$G$$$' / 0,'
7(,,,0* //,, 1' @ ,,4* 0, D <1, , , //,<. = ,?> /.4 / 1'),,4' 7 4,4,./4,1//.,,1 / /4, / , (..5, ,? <, , , 4 , D 2.,' D 1, .,, //,,*DB0,(..5,1 2.,210 /1..0,<!$$)"!$$&'
9' ./ #) 0 !$$&* 7 4, <* /3 4 20 ,5 ,* ..0 4 /0, 4, .,,//,,' 0<4(!$$)/3 6 EF%@G@L&8.,(306 EF##$G@L$' 8/ ?/ 50,,* 7 0,, /,, , D ,. 4!$$@*<,2*1.4,D EF@)@GN!L' '1,,0.,0,<
2 ,4,, / !$$)"!$$&' 4:* 1?, 1 .4 0 12., 2 !$$&"!$$9* 4 (
00=,?>* 7 4,/..D/.,.B /4,1//.,,',<,/.;, ,,5,,350,!$$)*/4,/,. 00 ,?* 1//,, ,/,, . 2B00 *1.,4<1., =0,.1.> 0,,,5,,3,2B00,55,,' 7 ;'
"%%"!$$& )"#$
#' ,,?. .,, //,, #@ .0( !$$) ,;. .,.?50/,/31,.0/.* 4(6'9!,1,4,.!90,#NL@ Q #@$I' %L3?01,4,.L/0(#N%% Q #@$'$9I'!9 !L 3?0 , ,5 2 /. 1//,, !& 5.4,#NLL 8'
!' 1' 9@ 5,2 /,,/ 2 ,4,,* 0* .0,. / ./0 //,, * / / B /.,D EF&$$' /0/.,'
@' 02,4,,..5,2.D EF&$$' /0 / .,* / 1' 9& 3?0 1//,, , 1,4,. 6 Q #@$'$#8' 2,4,25,210 EF 9&' 2101.4D EF)@&' 6'9&'! 8'
)' ' /,(,,. 155, 12., 2 10 .?. D 1' 9& * <, ,/ < ., 4 ,, .,/1'9&,'(D,(..5,,2.,*/<1, ,52,,1'@#'#3?01//,,, 1?02.6 Q #!$'$#8'
(' 1'9&,': /.4,<=.,, , 1?0 2 . ,, 5,,3 ,55,, <, /,400.>/,<25,2' ,,.,/,,, G?0 2 . ) ( #N%N 6 # !$8 6,' (8* ,0,6,'8*(,6,'8*.,?6,'8* ., 6,' 58* ., ,4 , ,,,,41,4,.6,'?8*.,?.6,',8'
' 1'9&,':/,/1'&,':3?0,,52 2,4,,2*#!0!$$!6 8'
0/,0,.D1'9& *1D; ,< 7 20,.,,,1'9&,':.,0/,'
, ,50/,2,,* 1B/, A,,B=,,5,,3,55,,>/,4 00.' ,3,,0/,1/3*
/0,3 . 5. 0.,' <, ,,?, 4
"%%"!$$& &"#$
1 ,,* 7 M 5. 12., ,* * 1( ,, 5,,3 ,55,,' ,, M. , /3'
&' 7/.,,45,2= ,312.,2 10>6,,48*,/,(,/37'1'# ,,4/.4,<1.,<,/.012., 2 10 ,4,, / B 2.. D 2 ,, 0,4* /0,30* /,4 00 .* 2,300* ///4<,./=,,5,,3,55,,>'
9' 1,/:,,41'9&,' : 6 +"N@"!$$) !% /0( !$$)8' ;?. < ,/,, ., 50 2 /,,/ /. ' 71?, ,,4*1//..?,.' ,0.<1,1?,, 1 ,,4 1,/.,* ;? 4, , 0/ 0 R /0, //,, ,/,, .? 1/3*0B0;?41.,01.,/50 23?.?//,('
1'#,,45,</,,5,2./1' 9&,': '
, =,, 5,,3 ,55,,> , ;,,< ,.0,.*<,1.5,,, , ' 4:* 5,2(30/?/50,,*5,.0,,// (..5,, 1 ,' ,,4 7 .0, .?0 (30/?/50,,'
L' 7 ;,/ * < ,, 5,,3 1 ., , B .0,. 0,3 2 ,4,,* , B 20,. ? /,,/ .(, /
6 +"N@"!$$);,/,.8'
./>*,1/4//',/,,.?/, M/(;,,/,,3,4D* ..:/, '
%' ' 71'#9'# *1,1.,./ 5.4.0,?/50,,'1,.!.< ?/50,,0/./;,*,,< 5'
(' 1'#%'# 5,2,0,4.0,?/50,, 1 ., 0, !$ <, , /0, M 50, /
"%%"!$$& 9"#$
(,?,D00 EF@9GL#$' *?0. EFLG)9$' /00( ?/50,,'
' 1'#L .5,,4.0,?/50,,00,A 4 ( ./ ;,* /3 ., , 50,,* ,,. 4 5 <,S,30 5 10( / // ?/50,,*/3.,15:, EF@$G$$$' //'
012.,2'750,0/./ 253J' ,,*,/,,/.,.*,0,4 ?/50,,1.34D EFL)G$#$' '
N' ,,4.5,,4.0,?/50,,0B0 0,3< 6'@,,48' (30 5,2.D EF##$G@L$' 1?/50,,<,'
1.4, D EF @)@GN!L' ' 00 /., (30
1,/<50,,(..5,,..5,,3/ ,0/!$$@'34,0/0<450,:. !$$)'
' 71?, 1. .5. 5,2, 4 .0,* 1')9'!3?01//,,,1?02.
6 # !$'$# Q 8 ,/ < 4 ( 0/ 4 <.0,./10,,,5,*//,, 1,#9,,(,/(,<' ,,/,, ,*1,#9*..(?./,00, 1,0/,,//:M,<6@#! 8' ,,/< 4 ,0/( .0, 1/3 4 <, / /., 5,* , / D 1. ,4, 6' # ' ! ! ' #8' 1' #L /.4M, < G,0/C ., /T ( 4 .,. / ,((/G.<,/..,<G,0/C., 2,?,(' /,,/ 2, ,, , 5. 4 .,. G. /..' 2/, /4 B 4,?. < , 2:,40/.4/,' G,,<G//,,/,,/* /,< ?4, 5* 00* 0 (..5, G 2/, ? :C0 <, 4, .( G. 2,I , 2.4(G./..*0?.,,/.,6 '$#'$!'#N%)I7 #N%)!!'@U!I5,:;,/U&N%#" 8'
"%%"!$$& L"#$
(' 1' @ :' @ ,,4 / /,,/ .. .?0,/.,./.,<4,..,5,? ,4,2,5,*4/,0/.21. ,4,/....0,</<12.,0.'
' 1' @) ' # /.4, <15, (..5,, 12., 2*.,,4;,5,,00,,/,'
1/3* 4 .0, 2 !$$@ / 2.,2/1.!$$)"!$$&*0M.../.!9 (!$$)'
' 71?,12/,D/,,/*,,4/.4,<4 1.,..<1/.;,,,, 5,,3/,..*/.;,5,,D:?0 ,,<0,*,4*:C0?*.0.?0' .5.D :?0 ,, 5, .: D 1' N@ * <, .5,, 5, 42/004,1.' /1?,1.,4,*,,.,,.*0,, ,, 4 5 1., , ./ .?* 0B0 < 0( :? 50, 1B 1,/,.'
1/3*,,/31.,*:C0?/, @#0,!$$@*.,00./C0'7,, !$$) !$$& 1., / ,0/.4,,(* ,, 4 1M :?. ,'1,4</,/5,42<,/, V .20 ,,' 0 D < , /, ,.,,,5/3*5,,3#;,!$$&' 1?0,D,<4.??.!$$@/4B/, 0/*./.,B4' 55* 7 ( 4.0,1.,4,/..0*<1,,./. * 50.0 2 /,,/ 5,2' 4 /,,/ .. , */..1/,,<(' *1,4</*/ 20/* ./ 2,, < 50, , / 5, , D 0,?*D.0.?0D0,*<,,/B,.. 00 5, 42 , D .20 0 4 .0,'
.<.,,512.,2,4,,D
(,,,*D4,1//,,=,?>'
##' ,,4 /.4, D , ) < = ,, , /,,30 ,55,, ,?>* 00,,* /3 20
"%%"!$$& %"#$
,5,,*/2/,02.,*0B0 , ,3 12., / 0/, D ' 0 =00,,>.,?1?.5,,/1'9& <,:?. /.4, 0 12., 2 10* 4 1 .,,<,0/.:54,.,6'9& '# 8'
#!' 1' @) ' ! , .?0 = ,?>' ,/,,/.4,<=,.(,.(,,/4<1, 1,0/,(,,..5,,,40(,1,4(,,. D , ,./ 4.* 00,, , /.,/0(0/B,>'
50.0 D ;,/ ,. , 6:' L8* = ,?>,B20,.?/,,/.(,/ '
1,4(,,.'/,,/1'@) //,B//,<.'
#@' 1' ) ,,4 0, ,?2* <1, 12,? / ,4(,,. 1., 0' .0,* D 2 ,/,,* ,? .,? =,, , /,,30 ,55,,>' 1?, 1 , ;,,< ,.0,. , 12, / .5,,,*, 3?0*,,,4' *1') ,,4,/,,/,46=/>8*,? 0? 1//.,, D 00,, 6=2/,0>8' 7 ;,/,0.(,*/4,?,, ,0,. ,(.1//.,,.D1,.,4,,' / 3 (, // //.,, D 1,. ,4,,* 4 , D 4.,5, < ,3 , / 0(. 1(,, 6 +"!@"!$$& !9 4, !$$& ;,/ ,.8' .,,(,,<10,50,(*,<1 ,, .4, 4 ,, 55,4* 4, ?,30 0/,,/;,,<,,.*:<,01.<,. 64, +/.,.8'
00 = ,?>' ,0. < ,.B 1,4,.
/.;,,,5,,350,!$$)*0,,., /00=,?>*2/,<<4,..;<1D /. //,<. D ., 0,. 1.* 0, ,, 5,,3,2B00,55,,'
"%%"!$$& N"#$
1?0 7 /, B ,/.. 00 ,A ,?1//,( <12.,0,.1.'7,1< 4,,1,.,4,,*,/0,1,?1//,. ,.0,.430.,0,.1.///D 2 <, 0,.' , 55 :< , / .430 ' .0,* 1,/., ,( /: /C,4A0B0<.,0/,,,, 0,.1.,,,,,,55,,* 7 0,3 2., ,, 5,,3 , 2B00 ,55,,' . < ,3 ,, /,/.,?,,,?*<.. ,0'
1/3* , 1//V / < 7 , (. 5
32/,1//,,,/,,*/. ,, R 4, .. .;D //,<.' , , 4, //,, (,, /4, 1//.,,' 1 55 /
,..005,,30,02B00,55,,'
.<*,B;.'
,,?.00/T6'@@8' WWWWW
& %'
()*+ ,-
.,,,4,,0,,,4,.,#@.0(!$$)I
*+ .-
;I
,<G,G//TG.00I
0,,,4,.,*4,;,,<1,4,.*,,<1 ./01,,/(,<'
"%%"!$$& #$"#$
7,.?A +04M*/.,I +0 0,,4,+'7::*00('
000,,1,4,.A
?55,3A /.,A 'F< '4M
/,50.,,..00,<.2/,'
34* ?55,3A
"%%"!$$&