Liquidated Damages as Unenforceable Penalty for Breach of Settlement Agreement
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAA dispute arose over whether a party was entitled to liquidated damages after the other party materially breached a settlement agreement regarding outstanding debt and the provision of security interests. The court held that the liquidated damages clause was an unenforceable penalty because the stipulated amount bore no reasonable relation to the actual or probable injury caused by the breach, as the parties did not engage in a proper pre-estimate of damages, thereby constituting an illegal penalty rather than a valid liquidated damage provision.
Regesto Legislator
Generato dall'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Liquidated Damages as Unenforceable Penalty for Breach of Settlement Agreement: The court held that the liquidated damages clause was an unenforceable penalty because the stipulated amount bore no reasonable relation to the actual or probable injury caused by the breach, as the parties did not engage in a proper pre-estimate of damages, thereby constituting an illegal penalty rather than a valid liquidated damage provision.
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IAThis provision is cited in the final order concerning the allocation of court costs.
Testo completo
!" #$%%%%%%
& '
( )
!"
(
'( )* ++++++ ,*-./ 0 1 ++++++'2$&3 4*5* +++++++3-6**7859-.-*++++++761 * 19*: * ,*-./ 610 4*;*1 .; ,*-./ 4*;*10 1-9 * -**:(
( '$19< %%$379=*;*13 ;*> 61 *6*1 7 =*11 ;*9( =*11 1* *1 - ;* ?1 *;*1 * -. 9< *;*1 15.3 :* 1-* 59 *-*<**1 9- 9-*<;8*85-67-*9-7=*;*1 .;3*>@131 %%'7 %% 3 <*1--1*=?97.;( =*11 6** 5 <*6 =*;*1 7 6* - - *;*1 * -. = *;*1( * 1* * -81 =;* -1 9-9 **3 *A*? -6* 9B 7 =15 > 61 ** 1-9 * -**: =;* 9:1 7 ;* < =:C *; ? ; < *;*1 *( 1**3 =*11 -;* *A 3 1* *? A3 ; 1* 1-9 =** -<*: ,*-./ 03 6919 7 =* 'D' *1 " * =**-<*:,0(
D( D%19< %%$3=*111 *= 85 * **1 E 66** =;*9E( -*5* : ** ;* 11 < 91* ;1 9*. *15 * *61( ;* 6* =<A = ;* ***( *3 * ;* -6*9 9-* F8 =*59 883-86917151*A*6*1(
$( *'#A;* %%"31*A*;:1 6* * 3;*>613 4**(
"( $ 61;* %%&3 1* 7 99** 4*;*1 , 0 - :4 ?9* * -1 - 613 . :4* 1* ; ( -*5* : 4;*9 -1 7 1*61***<*;--* * 1*:3 * 9 -*;1( 1** 41* - 69741*(
!# $! %%& D!"
&( 1- 29 %%&34*;*174*;<**1 3 41-9-19*.4;*9-1 --**4('D%('(3 *4 85 9*.16***;(
#( -. ;* 99*:1 -* <;* 613 9-51 851 -*.3 'D ;* %%&3 517A5(
'( *?9*=66*9-1,(''( * -1 9***; ' -9< '2G" H " '%I --*< - ;*=(D$ .59**6?-1=--** "61;*'2##HI0(
( =* DD * =*;*1 & 9* '2#D , 'D%03.59=*;*1, 'D%(%&019*** 9*1*=--**99<-*5 1** **;* 3 1; * ' G 7 'D *=**-<*:, ''%0(
199<-*53*;*19** 9-1 - @ *A1 1**'$19< %%$(
D( =*'D'-1;*-.99** - *5 =** -<*: , 0 - 1** :* 9* 7 * =66* ,( ' G 03 **9 ,( ' 2 03 1*** -- ;* - 9*6 <A*;9 61 ,(' 2 03*9**-**,('D%('0 ** : -* -;** - :C ,( 'D% 0( 4* 'D' *1"**; *4 85- ;*9<F93****-**9*1;.3 -1--**4*'D%*1'<(
$( =-.31**:1;*9-*--** 4*'D%*1'3:*-C:11**?A ;1*3:*9*.16***;(
3 4-9-1-,(DD 0(
!# $! %%& $!"
*3-11**-*3;* 2 **6113:**4.7*1A***3 41*-;*5*-:8*18*:**1 --C-67**:(
;*-1*:9J *4 85 9*. 4;*9 9*. 16***; ,('D'*1"03 4--9-1- 1;1*A*99*-*1(
"( ;:*-1.3*C11*;<(
**5199-B3**9*1 1,(DD0(
KKKKK
* (+
,-.!$/
1*;<*A1 $61;* %%&-)*++++++ 1**--**=*;*1.;'$19< %%$L
*:=*=--B=1993*14*9*1L
* :3 6919 ? * G *; * 611 *< 611'#A* %%", MN'#D(''%03-11**-C-1 A :* *; *6** -; *< 6113 - ;* 9*.*-<*L919****:*3 9*69>-;-*59*L* * C 1 *< 6113 '%%% '$3 - ;* - - ;* 1*: ? ** =* $ M( -1 1** -*. -* 3 *;:1 99 9> -;3 *; C A* 7 =;*L
99*: -1 1** 7 )* ++++++3 ;* A**: 4*;*13761 *19*:***:41-9 4**-<*:(
N*15/ )9;>3-1*L )9OO***OO*)* 8399<
!# $! %%& "!"
999**4*;*1/
566*./ -1*/ (;* (;>
-*691**1199*:1?-*(
.;3 566*./
!# $! %%&