Contract Enforceability Based on Ambiguous Written Notations
Sintesi Legislator
Generato dall'IAThe court considered whether certain agreements, evidenced by notations referencing monetary amounts and specific dates or codes, constituted enforceable contracts, particularly in light of alleged prior agreements or understandings between the parties regarding the underlying business relationship and property transfers. The court reasoned that despite the presence of various written documents, the totality of the evidence, including the context of the relationship and the ambiguous or conditional language within the notations, failed to establish a clear, definite, and mutual assent on all essential terms required for the formation of a binding contract, thus finding against the enforcement of the later agreements.
Regesto Legislator
UfficialeAMENDE; REMISE EN L'ETAT; CONSTRUCTION ET INSTALLATION; AMENAGEMENT DU TERRITOIRE; REVISION; RECONSIDERATION; FAITS NOUVEAUX; EGALITE DE TRAITEMENT; EGALITE DANS L'ILLEGALITE; EMOLUMENT | Rappel des conditions de recevabilité des demandes en révision et en reconsidération (art. 48 et 80ss LPA) et des conditions d'application du principe d'égalité de traitement dans l'illégalité. | LPA.48; LPA.80; LPA.81
Parole chiave
Generato dall'IADisposizioni normative citate
Generato dall'IADecisioni correlate
Generato dall'IAQuestioni giuridiche chiave estratte da Legislator
Generato dall'IACited in the dispositive to rule on court costs.
Testo completo
!"#
$%&#''''''
( (( ()(*(( +()(, (( ( *((
!"#
(
$( ) * +,-. !%%! / "0$"!%%! * +,-. !%%!12 .3 4...++.4,54 67$%8%%%( .+.9,:,:4 54,942 5,;.:4 94 /. :<= 1 > ?. @@@@@@.4.>A9. .,44 67$8*%%( 2, :,.,;5-+. 67*%%( -.,,++,:5.,,(
!( ) - ,+...+ B,.2 . :3. .C,:?(@@@@@@:< .3+,,D,,,,.-3 : ) E 4. !%%!2 5- +. 5D : ,, +. ,. .4:./) .3+,,$($FF"!%%!E4.!%%!1(
'( F C. !%%!2 ?( @@@@@@ , ,4. ,44 .34...+2;. .C,: "'E'"!%%!!*C.!%%! ;5,.-3(
F( !'C.!%%'2?(@@@@@@:., .34...+G9H -45,44:,.,2. 67$8%%%( 2;-. +.. -. C... . ,4.( ;) C.+..2 G4: 53 5B,. 5) .3 4...+H *+,-.!%%!(
*( 5 .-. : . C9 ,,9,2 ?(@@@@@@ 2:,.,:4D+.4:, :.$'4.!%%F,.54> 67*8%%%( :; . . :D, '% C2 + ;. . ,3. > 67$%8%%%( 44 ,, ::, > ?( @@@@@@ : . ! C. !%%F(
#( ,$!C.2,:.,: .34...+$FC. !%%F2 ?( @@@@@@ ,:, 4 ,-.. 5) :,., * +,-. !%%!2 :. $* C. !%%F2 4 .,. 4)4 )(
32.-.+....G;+- ,.,94>...>4. 4)4H/. 4)4125 :D3,,+..,5..,.-,: I9.( ,;254 67*8%%%( ;..-.,,.+.9,:. $'4.!%%F,..::.,3..(
2:, "$%&&"!%%',,-(
"$%&&"!%%' '"#
E( ,: $' J !%%F2 > 5.-3.., 4-..25);,D;.5.,AC9,(
. :2 . ,4. :. .. . ,.-, : K @@@/.4 $%%'&12 @@@ @@@2 .. ;. 5,. : .B. .4 B ,9, ?( @@@@@@(
:2 .)->:.;.,9(
+.2 K!&$$E:,-.?(@@@@@@42 -.,,:,:,.4>5);,(
B94..:+.-B(
0( ,A9 5,.2 :.-4 $% :43 $* 3!%%F25:::,5,,4(
&( .94:.:<-.+..-.C...2 5,44 67$8%%%( ,,:D,:?(@@@@@@'-.!%%F(
(
$( ,4. ,44 ,, A, / "'E'"!%%! !* C. !%%!15,44.,94-,2;;.5: ..9.(
!( 4 .,. 5. F0 . :,4...-$!:43$&0*/ L *$%15:.3; ,..5.,4...-(
..9, 5) .3 , * +,-. !%%!2 4.-3(
'( M4-..5).3,*+,-. !%%! . :.32 : ; .. ,, B . 0% .- .4:.(
G4-...) ,: ,.>C...;. ,...4.<,-4.+-..( . ) +. :,, : $% > 4: .+..,..H/(0$($!2$:A 1(
D . > -.. ;2 ++. ,9, : ,.. ,+...-2 . ::N ; +. 4D :- -B
"$%&&"!%%' F"#
.4: B.2 ; :-. N .-; :,:,,/(0%.31 1(
F( 44 ..;, . 2 5 "0$"!%%! * +,-. !%%! - ,+...+E4.!%%!(
*( 4-..,:,$FC.!%%F:,.$% 5.0$.,!$<:A (
#( >B4.+.4D:-.-;,:?(@@@@@@2 ;. -. ) -B2 .4: . . :, :,,/(0%.31 1(
( ?(@@@@@@::.,.:K@@@44 2.,I9.(
!!J$&&*2 .C.5,--,A.:, .2,>.(
3( +.!%%%2 :.4..;:.,:O 4,.B.59.A.(
?( @@@@@@ , 4. ,2 :,- 5 .. 4:3 > .2 I 9. ,942 -, : (:..5,9.,.4(
5 .. ; : ,.. * 4 !%%$2 ,5>?(@@@@@@,3:#%C;5. ..+.9,4 67$%8%%%( (
E( :K$%*0$3..,I9.(
5.. . . D9 A.4.; ;. . ,, ,.-, $&EF 5 : : ++ G.H : I 9.244,9,(
5.2 .. ,. > 5, -.9 $ C-. $&0% . +,, 54,94 .. !! C. $&E& / LME%%1(
+.2.59.:5+.-P
0( M C.: 2 :..: 5,9., .42 ,:5.0 ..+,,$0-.$&&&/ +,LM $%$12:.4)4.4.,9;.,>.= .5D:5,9.,5.,9.,/ 7$$!3'0E12+.4.-4=
"$%&&"!%%' *"#
...;>Q
,,.,.,94Q
5:<,,.,+4,4>.Q
5.,-.>:.;.,9:.Q
.,) :3. :,:, 5:: > 5,9., 5.,9., 5:<Q
.,):.-,:,:,5.5D::/ 7$%0!$!Q$%* $&!Q$%!!FF"!F*Q&0$#$"$#!1(
&( :...L,C>.L;5.-.,.-, : -.. ?( @@@@@@ :, ;5 . .B.(
-A2 +, 5. $* 4 !%%$ : -9-,A.I9./ $E5# F12;:.; +4 > . ;5. 5 : - > :.; .,92 .. ; 5++.4 ? @@@@@@( .. 4.- :,., : 4:.(
+.2 :,: .5 !'C.!%%'2:,-. :K$%*0$:.53.53R.424. +...5.+.:A,!%%$(
+.-.4:2.-:, )2:4:,>-..(
$%( ,;24,,.-3 "E#E"!%%! ' ,43 !%%!Q "##%"!%%! * -43 !%%!Q "#'E"!%%! !% 3!%%!1(
5. ..92 ,44 67 *%%( 4. > A9 ?(@@@@@@/(0E 1(
SSSSS
( + (
"$%&&"!%%' #"#
, .-3 4 .,. ,-.. ,:, :.-4$FC.$*C.!%%F:?.@@@@@@5) .34...+*+,-.!%%!Q
4>A9?(@@@@@@,44 67*%%( Q
44.; :, ) > ?. @@@@@@ .. ;8 ,:4 84,9428,;.:494(
M.,9= ?4 -D2 :,.2 ?( DA<2 ?4 6.2 ?( A,.2 C92 ?( 2C9::,(
4 .34...+=
,. C.= -. :,.= ?(I M; (-D
:.+4),,44.;,B:.(
<-2 9++.<=
"$%&&"!%%'