KKO 2974/2004
Généré par l'IA
Supreme Court held that appeals in fraud cases relying on oral testimony must be heard in court, not screened.
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe Supreme Court ruled that an appeal in a fraud case could not be screened because its resolution depended on the credibility of oral testimony. Since the core issue required a full hearing, the case had to be transferred back to the Court of Appeal for a proper trial. Consequently, the screening procedure was deemed invalid as it prevented the necessary evaluation of witness credibility.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAOK 26 luku 2 §; An appeal in a fraud case depending on the credibility of oral testimony cannot be screened and must be heard in court.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IA
fraud appeal procedure
oral testimony credibility
court screening invalidity
Supreme Court jurisdiction
verbal evidence evaluation
argumentation motivée
violation du devoir de motiver
principe in dubio pro reo
Dispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IAOK 26 luku 2 §
Décisions connexes
Généré par l'IAkko-other_2001_1436
Supreme Court dismisses appeal regarding failure to submit case file to lower court in criminal proceedings.
kko-other_2001_1437
Supreme Court dismissed appeal regarding failure to submit case file to lower court in criminal proceedings.
ECLI:FI:KKO:2019:18
Supreme Court allows revocation of lawyer's license due to deep distrust of authorities and unfair proceedings.
kko-precedent_2000_62
Supreme Court allows retrial in criminal appeal when lower court misjudged witness credibility without new evidence.
kko-other_2001_500
Supreme Court dismissed appeal regarding failure to submit case file to lower court in criminal proceedings.
Texte complet
Kun asian ratkaiseminen petosta koskevassa asiassa riippui suullisen todistelun uskottavuudesta ja asiassa siten oli toimitettava pääkäsittely hovioikeudessa, valitusta ei voitu seuloa.
OK 26 luku 2 §