Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
BS-1405/1993-VLR ECLI:DK:VLR:2024:BS0000000458 Généré par l'IA

Court allows partial claim for depreciation of a used car after repair due to trade value loss.

Numéro de cause BS-1405/1993-VLR
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Danemark (DK)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court partially allowed the appellant's claim for additional compensation regarding a used car's trade value after repair. The appellant argued that the repair caused a significant drop in the vehicle's market value, while the insurer contended the loss was negligible given the car's pre-existing condition. The court ruled that despite the uncertainty inherent in used cars, the depreciation was substantial enough to warrant compensation for the specific loss in trade value.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Insurance Act; Contract Law: Where a repaired used vehicle suffers a reduction in trade value due to the repair, the insurer must compensate for this loss if it is not negligible, considering the vehicle's specific characteristics.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
used car trade value repair depreciation insurance liability market value loss partial compensation suspension de l'assurance demande de prestation d'assurance réexamen par l'assureur
Généré par l'IA
BS-46966/2023-OLR
Court upholds insurance coverage for traffic accident damages including lost earnings and pain and suffering.
BS-3334/2010-OLR
Insurance company allowed to recover costs from seller for gross negligence in failing to disclose property defects.
BS-940/2007-VLR
Court dismisses appeal against by-court judgment, upholding conviction for illegal possession of firearms.
BS-985/1992-ESB
Court allows partial claim for car depreciation exceeding insurance payout due to high-value vehicle risk.
SS-889/2017-OLR
Court orders police to pay compensation for unlawful detention exceeding ten minutes without clear release notice.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

Landsretten stadfæster byrettens afgørelse i sag om krav til forsikringsselskab i forbindelse med bilsalg

[DOKUMENT] Afgørelse (2 sider) DOM

afsagE den 19. i anuar 1994 af VesE.re lJandsreEs B. afdell-ncr (landsdomnerne ilohs. Jorgenaen, Marie S. Mikkelsea og Ingrid Drengegaard (ksE . ) )

1 ankesag B 1405/1993

ellant Tjereborg, mod NorallyseE. Forsikring A/S, IIelsingor.

Den indankede dom er afsagE. den 8. juni 1993 af reE.E.en i Esbjerg,2. afdeling.

For landsreEt.en har Appellanten , nedlagE pasEand om beEaling af yderligere 110.000 kr. med sadvanlig procesrenEe fra den 27. flia) L992, E.iI beEaling sker.

hdsEEvnt.e, Nordlyset. Forsikring A/S, har piisud.et frifindelse.

Det er for landsreE.ten oplyst, aE. deIr indankede dom er opfyldE.

Part.err.e har i deE \rasenElige gent.ageE deres procedure for byret t.en .

L,andsrett.en udE.aler :

Ved de afgiwne erklaringer findes det. godEgjorE, au beskadigelsen af appellanCens biL uanse! reparaE.ioneB har medfarE en nedgang i bllens handelsvardi. Under hensyn Ei1 den usikker tred, der pd grund af bi].enE karakEer af liebhaverbil_ er forbundeE. med at, fastssle denne nedgang, f indes den aE m,iic.E.e fasE - satstes skonsmessigl. ReEEen ansEE.Eer herefEer nedgaogeo i handelsvardien efEer reparatioEen E.i1 1O0.OOO kr.

UanseE. at nedgangeE i handel,srrardien er usadwanlig sEor Eom falge af biLens hoje v-erdi og karakEer af liebhaverbil, og uanseE om oedgangen i hendelsvardien muligE vil1e have .uareE. mindre eller vi11e vare undgleE.. hvis.salg af bilen forsE, var ske! efter en irrakke, findes appeLlanEen at have krav pi aL fi den ovenfor nEurEe nedgang af handelsvardien ersEaEE.eE..

Landsret.E.en tager derfor appellanEens pestsand t.i1 fotge for eE belob af yderligere 85.0OO kr.

Thi. kendes for reE.:

fndsEavnE.e, Nordlyset forsikring A/s, beLaler yderligere cil Appellanten 85.000 kr. med eadvanlig procesrent,e fra den 27. riEj 1992, EiI betaling sker.

Sagens omkosEninger for begge reE.E.er skal indsEavnt.e beE.a1e Ej.l appellanE,en med 30.000 kr.

DeE. idomEe skal betales inden 14 dage.

.foha. ilorgensen Marie S. Mikkelsen Ingrid Drengsgaard (ksE. )

cfr.