Legislator Case Law & Legislation
800.032 DREMTL CH-VD

Art. 9 DECREE on the regulation of heavy medical-technical equipment (DREMTL) - Authorization Procedure [ 2 ]

Open official source Full Act (15 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 9 DREMTL - Authorization Procedure [ 2 ] · Authorization Procedure [ 2 ]

1. The department shall grant authorization if the following cumulative criteria are met

a. the commissioning of the equipment meets a proven public health need;

b. no public health policy imperative stands in the way;

c. the costs incurred by compulsory health insurance, public authorities, or patients are proportionate to the expected health benefit;

d. the applicant has qualified personnel.

2. The department may attach conditions to the authorization, in particular the establishment of a collaboration agreement between equipment operators or the obligation to ensure the availability of heavy equipment during specific hours.

3. When the department follows the Commission's opinion, whether positive or negative, it shall render the decision. If it intends to deviate from it, it shall refer the matter to the Council of State.

4. The decisions of the department or the Council of State must be rendered within a period of six months from the date of transmission of the file to the Commission (art. 8, para. 3), subject to a time limit extension in accordance with paragraph 5. These decisions are subject to an administrative law appeal before the Cantonal Court.

5. The department may, if the examination of the application so requires, extend the period provided for in paragraph 4 by a maximum of three months. Before the expiry of this period, the department shall communicate its intention to extend the period to the operator, who shall have 20 days to state their position.

6. In the absence of a decision within the period provided for in paragraph 4 or within the extended period under paragraph 5, the application shall be deemed accepted.

← Art. 8 DREMTL on the regulation of heavy medical-technical equipment (DREMTL) - Objective Art. 10 DREMTL - Emoluments →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (9)

GE.2023.0043 · vd (art. 9 al. 4 DREMTL)
Corporate Applicants v. Public Health Department: Deemed Acceptance of CT-Scan Installation Application Due to Untimely Decision
This provision establishes the rule that the application is deemed accepted if no decision is made within the six-month deadline, which was the main ground for admitting the appeal and reforming the decision.
GE.2016.0189 · vd (art. 9 DREMTL)
Medical Clinic v. Departmental Decision on Lithotripter Installation
The court reformed the challenged decision, which was a refusal to grant authorization based on this article.
GE.2016.0189 · vd (art. 9 al. 1 let. a DREMTL)
Medical Clinic v. Departmental Decision on Lithotripter Installation
Cited in the reasoning to establish that the lithotripter operation met the criterion of responding to an established public health need.
GE.2016.0189 · vd (art. 9 al. 1 let. b DREMTL)
Medical Clinic v. Departmental Decision on Lithotripter Installation
Cited in the reasoning as one of the cumulative criteria for granting authorization, which the court found to be met.
GE.2016.0189 · vd (art. 9 al. 1 let. c DREMTL)
Medical Clinic v. Departmental Decision on Lithotripter Installation
Cited in the reasoning as one of the cumulative criteria for granting authorization, which the court found to be met regarding cost proportionality.
GE.2017.0030 · vd (art. 9 al. 1 DREMTL)
Medical Imaging Company Denial of PET-CT Authorization Upheld
The court confirmed the decisions which were based on the requirements of this article regarding the authorization for heavy medical equipment.
GE.2017.0030 · vd (art. 9 al. 2 DREMTL)
Medical Imaging Company Denial of PET-CT Authorization Upheld
Mentioned in the reasoning supporting the CHUV's authorization, implying its relevance to the overall decision context.
GE.2016.0192 · vd (art. 9 al. 1 let. a DREMTL)
Appeal against Refusal of CT Scanner Authorization Dismissed
The court implicitly confirmed the finding that the CT-scan did not meet the condition of a 'besoin de santé publique avéré' (proven public health need), which is the main ground for refusing authorization under this article.
GE.2016.0194 · vd (art. 9 al. 1 DREMTL)
Appeal Against Refusal of MRI Machine Commissioning Under DREMTL
The court confirmed the administrative decision which refused authorization based on the cumulative conditions set out in this article.