Legislator Case Law & Legislation
173.32 LJGLJC CH-VD

Art. 10 Constitutional Jurisdiction Act (LJC) - Opposing Communal Acts [4]

Title II, Chapter II
Open official source Full Act (25 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 10 LJC - Opposing Communal Acts [4] · Opposing Communal Acts [4]

1. Standing to challenge a communal or intercommunal legal norm shall be granted to any natural or legal person who has a protectable interest in the annulment of the contested act.

2. The following also have standing to file a request

a. the municipality;

b. one-tenth of the members of the municipal council, one-fifth of the members of the general council, or a political group;

c. the executive board of an association of municipalities, a federation of municipalities, or an agglomeration;

d. one-tenth of the members of the intercommunal council, or a political group;

e. the Canton of Vaud, through the Council of State.

3. Only the municipality, the executive board of an association of municipalities, or a fraction of the legislative authority, as defined in letters b and d above, may appeal against the cantonal refusal to approve a communal or intercommunal regulation. Only the Council of State may appeal against the refusal of a communal authority to submit for approval communal and intercommunal regulations, resolutions, or tariffs containing legal norms for which cantonal approval is required.

← Art. 9 LJC Constitutional Jurisdiction Act (LJC) - Purpose Art. 11 LJC - Opening of the Procedure →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (17)

CCST.2018.0006 · vd (Art. 10 al. 2 LJC)
Municipal Parking Fee Modification Overruled Due to Tax Component
Used to confirm the applicants' standing to file the request as members of the Communal Council.
CCST.2015.0002 · vd (art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Ride-Sharing Platform v. Intercommunal Taxi Service Regulation (Call Center Requirements)
Cited in the reasoning to establish the requirement for standing to appeal against a communal or intercommunal rule of law, leading to the partial rejection of the appeal.
CCST.2015.0003 · vd (Art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Taxi Operators Challenge Intercommunal Service Regulation Amendments
Cited in the reasoning (which is heavily cited) regarding the standing to sue (qualité pour agir) but is not explicitly repeated in the final orders (Dispositif I, II, III).
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision establishes the general requirement for a legally protected interest to have standing to challenge a communal act.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision establishes the general rule for standing in challenging communal acts.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision sets the general requirement for standing in challenging communal acts.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 2 LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision was used to determine the standing of the municipalities in challenging the intercommunal act.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 2 LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision was used to establish the standing of the applicant municipalities to challenge the act without demonstrating a protected interest.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 2 LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision was used to recognize the standing of the municipalities to bring the request (recourse) against the intercommunal act without necessarily demonstrating a direct interest.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 2 let. a LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision was cited in the reasoning to confirm that municipalities challenging an intercommunal act do not need to assert a direct protected interest.
CCST.2011.0008 · vd (art. 10 al. 2 let. a LJC)
Challenge to Regional Fire and Rescue Association Statutes Upheld
This provision was used to recognize the standing of the municipalities to bring the request (recourse) against the intercommunal act.
CCST.2011.0003 · vd (Art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Property Owners Challenge Retroactive Wastewater Fee Application
Implied in the admissibility finding, as the parties were found to have the standing to sue under this article, although the article itself is not explicitly cited in the final orders.
CCST.2010.0003 · vd (art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Municipal Police Regulations on Dangerous Animals Upheld Against Cantonal Law Challenge
The rejection of the appeal is based on the fact that the request was admissible, referencing the article governing who has standing to appeal.
CCST.2009.0006 · vd (art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Waste Bylaw Annulment for Lack of Causal Principle Adherence
Cited in the reasoning when establishing the applicant's standing to sue, which is a prerequisite for admissibility (although the decision on the substance is the ground for inclusion here, procedural aspects related to admissibility are often cited alongside the main ground).
CCST.2007.0003 · vd (Art. 10 al. 1 LJC)
Taxi Operator Challenge to Municipal Taxi Regulations
Establishes the standing to challenge communal regulations.