Legislator Case Law & Legislation
951.1 VRP CH-SG

Art. 44 Act on Administrative Justice (VRP) - g) in the case of precautionary and enforcement measures by administrative authorities

**Part Three: Legal Protection in Administrative Disputes - B. Appeal**
Open official source Full Act (138 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 44 VRP · g) in the case of precautionary and enforcement measures by administrative authorities

1. Precautionary Measures and Enforcement Measures by Administrative Authorities, including the Threat of Coercive Enforcement, are Appealable to the Appeals Instance Competent in the Main Matter.

2. For the government, the competent department makes the decision; for other collegial authorities, the chairperson does.

3. Decisions on enforcement measures are final.

← Art. 43ter VRP - f) Leap-Frog Appeal Act on Administrative Justice (VRP) - Scope a) Principle Art. 45 VRP - Right of Appeal →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (33)

B.2025.73 · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Appeal Against Fitness-to-Drive Order Due to Procedural Flaw in Single-Judge Decision
Cited in the headnote to indicate the procedural issue regarding the composition of the administrative review body for the appeal against ordering an expert medical examination.
B.2025.54 · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Administrative Commission Single-Judge Review of Fitness-to-Drive Order Invalidated; Refusal of Expert Evidence Remanded
The composition of the panel (single judge vs. three-member panel) for reviewing the appeal against the order for a fitness to drive examination was determined based on whether the order was a provisional measure under VRP.
IV.2024.91 · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Appeals on Fitness-to-Drive Examinations and Evidentiary Weight of Police Reports
Cited to justify the single-judge decision (presidial decision) regarding the appeal against the fitness for transport examination order.
22.9245 · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 1 VRP)
Appeal Dismissed for Premature Construction and Permit Violations
Cited in reasoning (Erw. 1.1) to establish the Department's jurisdiction, but not in the final orders.
B.2021.197 · sg (Art. 44 VRP)
License Withdrawal Period Setting in Repeat Offense Cases
Cited in reasoning (Section 5) as a basis for the administrative authority to decide when only the execution period is contested.
21.11557 · sg (Art. 44 VRP)
Appeal Against Cessation Order Dismissed as Untimely
Cited to establish the Department's jurisdiction for the appeal.
IV.2021.47 · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Special vs. Standard License Suspension Recidivism
Cited in the reasoning regarding the different procedural competencies for appealing substantive versus enforcement decisions, which led to the annulment of enforcement orders.
IV.2021.34 · sg (Art. 44 und Art. 47 Abs. 2 VRP)
License Suspension Upheld, Procedural Error Partially Overturned
Cited in the reasoning (Erwägung 5c) regarding the potential appeal against a subsequent enforcement order, which is procedural context related to the quashing of the enforcement part of the original order.
IV.2021.34 · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Administrative Review Commission Upholds License Suspension Despite Procedural Error in Initial Order
Cited in the reasoning (Erwägung 5.b) regarding jurisdiction for appealing enforcement decisions.
III.1.2021.1.P · sg (Art. 44 VRP)
Challenge to Vocational Permit Enforcement Following Revocation
Cited in the reasoning to establish the jurisdiction for challenging the enforcement decision, which corresponds to the final order of non-admission of the appeal.
III.1.2021.1.P · sg (Art. 44 in Verbindung mit Art. 41 lit. c VRP)
Enforcement of Partially Revoked Vocational Training Permit with Gender Restriction
This provision determined the competence of the President of Division III/1 to rule on the appeal because the contested decision was qualified as an enforcement order.
IV.2020.168.P · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Driver Diabetes Fitness Review and Appeal Procedure
Cited in the title regarding the authority of the single judge versus the collegial body, relating to procedural handling.
IV.2021.11.P · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Administrative Commission Upholds Mandatory Traffic Medical Examination Based on Cognitive Impairment Findings
Cited in the reasoning (E. 1) in connection with the delegation of authority to the single judge for interim decisions, consistent with the procedural context of the decision.
IV.2020.168.P · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP)
Driver Fitness Assessment for Insulin-Treated Diabetic Driver
Cited in the introductory section summarizing the case background/rules, but it is not explicitly cited in the final orders (1. or 2.).
IV.2021.168.P · sg (Art. 44 Abs. 2 VRP (sGS 951.1))
Driver Fitness to Drive Assessment for Diabetic with Complication Upheld
This provision is cited in the header but not explicitly in the dispositive orders (1. and 2.). Therefore, it is excluded based on the rules.