140.2
OeffG
CH-SG
Art. 6 Freedom of Information Act (OeffG) - Restrictions a) public or protected private interests
III. Access to Information - 1. Principle of Public Access
Art. 6 OeffG · Restrictions a) public or protected private interests
1. The public authority shall inform and grant access to official documents unless there are overriding public or legitimate private interests against it.
2. A public interest notably opposes access when the information
a) could endanger public order and safety;
b) could weaken the position of the public authority in negotiations;
c) could impair relations with other communities;
d) could thwart or diminish the effectiveness of official measures;
e) would cause a disproportionate effort.
3. A legitimate private interest notably opposes access when the information is likely to
a) infringe on the personal rights of third parties;
b) violate intellectual property rights;
c) breach a professional, business, or manufacturing secret.
Court Decisions Applying This Provision (5)
III.3.2024.4 · sg (Art. 6 Abs. 3 lit. c OeffG)
Appeal Regarding Denial of Access to Feasibility Study During Public Participation
The court found that the condition for applying this exception regarding business secrets was not met as there was no will to keep the information secret.
B.2022.81 · sg (Art. 6 OeffG)
Access to Water Consumption Data Upheld Against Trade Secret Claim
Cited in the reasoning as the basis for restricting access rights when public or private interests oppose them, confirming the legal framework applied.
B.2022.81 · sg (Art. 6 OeffG)
Water Consumption Fee Disclosure Appeal
The court ruled on the admissibility of the restriction of access based on the criteria in this article, finding no grounds for refusal.
22.1240 · sg (Art. 6 Abs. 3 Bst. c OeffG)
Appeal Dismissed: Expert Reports Exempted Due to Commercial and Confidential Nature
This provision was cited as an additional ground for refusal, concerning the protection of business secrets.
B.2019.116 · sg (Art. 6 Abs. 1 lit. e OeffG)
Access to Departmental Tree Removal Decisions Upheld
Cited in the reasoning (section 5) regarding the lack of evidence for an excessive burden of work, which supports the final order dismissing the appeal (Order 1).