Legislator Case Law & Legislation
111.1 KV CH-SG

Art. 89 Constitution of the Canton of St. Gallen (KV) - Municipal Autonomy

VIII. Municipalities
Open official source Full Act (127 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 89 KV - Municipal Autonomy · Municipal Autonomy

1. The municipality is autonomous insofar as the law does not limit its decision-making freedom.

2. In legislation, the municipality has decision-making freedom when the law does not provide a comprehensive regulation or expressly authorizes the municipality to legislate.

3. The canton considers the potential impacts on the municipalities in its actions.

← Art. 88 KV - Types of Municipalities Constitution of the Canton of St. Gallen (KV) - Canton of St. Gallen Art. 90 KV →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (9)

B.2021.273 · sg (Art. 89 KV)
Naturalization Upheld Despite Minor Deficiencies
Cited as the constitutional basis for municipal autonomy, which frames the context of the review of the discretionary decision.
B.2021.273 · sg (Art. 89 KV)
Cantonal Authority Grants Naturalization Despite Municipal Rejection Based on Overall Integration Assessment
The court's decision confirms the lower court's ruling, implying that the communal authority acted within its mandate protected by this article concerning municipal autonomy, as used in the reasoning when dismissing the appeal based on granting the application.
B.2016.133 · sg (Art. 89 Abs. 1 KV)
Social Assistance Recipient Appeals Mandatory Full-Time Integration Program
Cited in the reasoning section regarding municipal autonomy.
B.2016.133 · sg (Art. 89 Abs. 1 KV)
Social Assistance Recipient v. Mandatory Full-Time Integration Program Requirement
Cited in the context of municipal autonomy regarding social assistance.
B.2013.122 · sg (Art. 89 KV)
Building Permit Appeal Regarding Definition of "Anbaute" and Cantonal Law Compliance
Cited in the reasoning section when discussing the municipality's autonomy in rulemaking, which is fundamental to the final assessment of the communal regulation.
B.2011.229 · sg (Art. 89 Abs. 1 KV)
Applicant v. Municipality on Naturalization Denial Based on Minor Traffic Fines
Cited in the reasoning (4.1) regarding municipal autonomy, but not in the dispositive.
B.2011.229 · sg (Art. 89 Abs. 1 KV)
Naturalization Rejection Over Minor Traffic Infractions
Cited in connection with municipal autonomy when evaluating the validity of a naturalization decision based on objective reasons.
B.2008.206 · sg (Art. 89 Abs. 1 KV)
Political Community v. Cantonal Department on Naturalization Rejection Based on Prior Military Service
The court granted the appeal and overturned the decision of the Department of the Interior because the latter violated the municipal autonomy guaranteed by this article.
B.2008.206 · sg (Art. 89 Abs. 1 KV)
Voters' Rejection of Naturalization Upheld Against Cantonal Annulment
The appeal was granted because the decision of the lower instance violated the municipal autonomy guaranteed by this article.