Legislator Case Law & Legislation
702 ZWGLRSLASEC CH

Art. 8 Federal Act of 20 March 2015 on Second Homes (SHA) - Homes used in connection with organised accommodation businesses

SHA; Chapter 4 Construction of New Homes in Communes with a Proportion of Second Homes in excess of 20 per cent
Open official source Full Act (28 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 8 SHA · Homes used in connection with organised accommodation businesses

In communes where the proportion of second homes exceeds 20 per cent, organised accommodation businesses may be authorised to construct homes without restrictions on use in accordance with Article 7 paragraph 1 if: a. the business can only be run or continue to be run profitably with the income obtained if such homes are constructed; b. the owner or the operator on request provides proof that the income from the homes will be invested in constructing or running the organised accommodation; c. the main usable area of these homes does not exceed 20 per cent of the entire main usable area of the rooms and homes; d. the homes and the organised accommodation complex form a structural and functional unit, unless the regulations on preserving the appearance of the locality or cultural heritage management require otherwise; and e. there are no other overriding interests to the contrary.

For homes in accordance with paragraph 1 that permanently remain the property of the organised accommodation business and are rented out by the same, the total main usable area in accordance with paragraph 1 letter c may amount to a maximum of 33 per cent. A related restriction on alienation must be noted in the land register. Article 7 paragraphs 4 and 5 apply by analogy.

If the business constructs homes in accordance with both paragraph 1 and paragraph 2, the maximum percentage of 33 per cent shall be reduced by the value obtained by dividing the area of the homes in accordance with paragraph 1 by the sum of the area of the homes in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2 and multiplying the result by 13 per cent.

In an organised accommodation complex that already existed on 11 March 2012, a maximum of 50 per cent of the main usable area may be converted for use as homes without restriction on use under Article 7 paragraph 1 provided: a the business has been run as such for at least 25 years; b. it can no longer be run profitably and cannot be converted for use as homes intended as managed tourist accommodation; c. the fact that the accommodation business concerned can no longer be run profitably is not due to any failure on the part of the owner or operator; and d. there are no overriding interests to the contrary.

An independent expert report must be provided as proof that the requirements in paragraphs 1 or 4 have been met. The Federal Council shall regulate the details.

← Art. 7 SHA Federal Act of 20 March 2015 on Second Homes (SHA) - Subject matter Art. 9 SHA →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (5)

VR3 2023 47 · gr (Art. 8 Abs. 1 ZWG)
Appeal Against Partial Revision of Local Development Plan for Hotel Resort Expansion
Cited regarding the prerequisites for financing structured accommodation businesses through the sale of non-restricted dwellings, but not explicitly cited in the final orders 1-4.
VR3 2019 99 · gr (Art. 8 Abs. 1 ZWG)
Cantonal Land-Use Plan Revision Appeal: Parking Clearing Overturned, Resort Approval Upheld
The court explicitly examined but ultimately dismissed the challenge concerning the circumvention of the Second Home Legislation (ZWG) based on the existing ZWG assessment.
R 2021 87 · gr (Art. 8 Abs. 1 lit. a ZWG)
Nature Protection Organization v. Cantonal Government (Land-Use Plan Revision)
Cited in the reasoning to define the condition under which a business might only be viable through the proceeds from building non-restricted residential units.
R 2021 87 · gr (Art. 8 Abs. 1 oder 4 ZWG)
Nature Protection Organization v. Cantonal Government (Land-Use Plan Revision)
Cited in the reasoning regarding the legal basis for the expert report requirement under the Second Homes Act.
R 2021 87 · gr (Art. 8 Abs. 5 ZWG)
Nature Protection Organization v. Cantonal Government (Land-Use Plan Revision)
Cited in the reasoning to address the appellant's objection concerning the missing expert report regarding economic viability in relation to secondary housing law.