Legislator Case Law & Legislation
451 NHGLPN CH AI generated

Art. 7 Federal Act of 1 July 1966 on the Protection of Nature and Cultural Heritage (NCHA)

NCHA; Aim; Section 1 Nature Protection, Cultural Heritage Protection and Monument Preservation in the Fulfilment of Federal Tasks ; Expert report prepared by commission
Open official source Full Act (69 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

If the Confederation is responsible for the fulfilment of a federal task, then, depending on its remit, either the Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN), the Federal Office of Culture or the Federal Roads Office shall assess whether it is necessary for an expert report to be prepared by a commission as specified in Article 25 paragraph 1. If the canton is responsible, this assessment shall be made by the cantonal expert body as specified in Article 25 paragraph 2. {note: Amended by the Annex to the FD of 21 March 2014 (Nagoya Protocol), in force since 1 Sept. 2014 ( AS 2014 2629; BBl 2013 3009).} If, in connection with the fulfilment of a federal task, a site listed in a federal inventory in accordance with Article 5 may be significantly damaged or fundamental issues are raised, the commission shall prepare an expert report for the decision-making authority, indicating whether the site should be preserved undiminished or how it must be protected. The expert report shall be one of the factors considered by the decision-making authority when weighing up all the interests. {note: Inserted by No I of the FA of 27 Sept. 2019, in force since 1 April 2020 ( AS 2020 1217; BBl 2019 349 1335).}

Art. 7 NCHA

If the Confederation is responsible for the fulfilment of a federal task, then, depending on its remit, either the Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN), the Federal Office of Culture or the Federal Roads Office shall assess whether it is necessary for an expert report to be prepared by a commission as specified in Article 25 paragraph 1. If the canton is responsible, this assessment shall be made by the cantonal expert body as specified in Article 25 paragraph 2.

If, in connection with the fulfilment of a federal task, a site listed in a federal inventory in accordance with Article 5 may be significantly damaged or fundamental issues are raised, the commission shall prepare an expert report for the decision-making authority, indicating whether the site should be preserved undiminished or how it must be protected.

The expert report shall be one of the factors considered by the decision-making authority when weighing up all the interests.

← Art. 6 NCHA Federal Act of 1 July 1966 on the Protection of Nature and Cultural Heritage (NCHA) Art. 8 NCHA →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (64)

60/2008/48A · sh (Art. 7 NHG/Bund)
Municipality v. Cantonal Government: Cellular Facility Permit Dispute
Cited regarding the duty to consult expert commissions (ENHK or EKD) when there is a risk of significant impairment to a protected object.
60/2008/48A · sh (Art. 7 NHG/SH)
Municipality v. Cantonal Government: Cellular Facility Permit Dispute
Mentioned in relation to communal provisions on ensemble protection zones, but the federal standard (Art. 6 NHG/Bund) was deemed decisive for the national importance aspect.
VB.2003.00421 · zh (Art. 7 NHG)
Appeal Regarding Exception Permit for Joint Municipal Shooting Range Construction
This provision of the Nature and Heritage Protection Act was considered in the context of the project's impact on the landscape.
VB.2024.00496 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. II NHG)
Appeal Against Mobile Phone Antenna Permit Dismissed
The provision concerning the requirement for an expert opinion from the EKD/ENHK was addressed in the reasoning concluding that there was no significant impairment as per this article, leading to the rejection of the appeal.
VB.2024.00449 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. 1 NHG)
Building Permit Appeal: Failure to Justify Agency Opinion in Protected Area
This provision was mentioned in the context of the involvement of the relevant cantonal authority, though the main issue was the failure to rule on the findings under Art. 7 Abs. 2 NHG.
VB.2024.00449 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. 2 NHG)
Building Permit Appeal: Failure to Justify Agency Opinion in Protected Area
The court found that the lower court failed to review the ARE's assessment regarding significant impairment or a fundamental question under this article.
BRGE.I.Nrn.0100.010 · zh (Art. 7 NHG)
Appeal Against Residential Complex Permit Design and Tree Preservation
This provision concerning the mandatory requirement to obtain an expert opinion from federal commissions if an object in a federal inventory is significantly affected was relevant to the ISOS objection, but the conditions for its application were not met.
WBE.2023.375.384 · ag (Art. 7 Abs. 2 NHG)
Regional Government's Road Project Decision Partially Overturned Due to Noise, Traffic Safety, and Access to Information Concerns
Cited as the legal basis requiring consultation with the Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN) when a federal task could significantly impair a protected object.
VB.2024.00110 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. 1 NHG)
Appeal Regarding Photovoltaic Permit Denial in Area of National Significance
This provision regarding the protection of nature and landscape is listed as a cited legal norm relevant to the case subject matter.
VB.2024.00110 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. 2 NHG)
Appeal Regarding Photovoltaic Permit Denial in Area of National Significance
This provision regarding the protection of nature and landscape is listed as a cited legal norm relevant to the case subject matter.
WBE.2023.287 · ag (Art. 7 Abs. 2 NHG)
Judicial Review of Hydropower Plant Optimization Project Approval
The court discussed the requirement for expert opinions from the ENHK or EKD when federal inventory objects are significantly impacted, although it ultimately did not find a decisive procedural error in its absence for the 2015 decision.
VB.2023.00729 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. I NHG)
Building Permit for ISOS Property Upheld Despite Procedural Error
Cited for the violation concerning the federal agency's involvement in assessing whether an expert report from the Federal Office of Culture (ENHK) or the Federal Office of Civil Defence (EKD) was required.
VB.2023.00062 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. I NHG)
Appeal Regarding Building Permit Near Protected Area and Villa
This provision is listed under 'Rechtsnormen' cited in the context of the decision regarding heritage protection.
VB.2023.00062 · zh (Art. 7 Abs. II NHG)
Appeal Regarding Building Permit Near Protected Area and Villa
This provision is listed under 'Rechtsnormen' cited in the context of the decision regarding heritage protection.
VB.2024.00239 · zh (Art. 7 NHG)
Mobile Antenna Permit Appeal Remanded for Expert Assessment
Cited in the context of the required assessment by the FOT regarding the necessity of an expert opinion mentioned in the case background, which justified the remand.