Legislator Case Law & Legislation
721.0 BAUGLC CH-BE

Art. 10b Building Act (BauG) - 4.2 Protection and Preservation

Public Building Law - Classification and Design
Open official source Full Act (215 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 10b Building Act (BauG) - 4.2 Protection and Preservation · 4.2 Protection and Preservation

**1. Monuments of Historical Importance**

Monuments of historical importance can be adapted for their existing or suitable new purposes according to the needs of modern living and housing, and they can be modified considering their value. They shall not be impaired by changes in their surrounding environment.

**2. Protected Monuments**

Protected monuments generally must not be demolished. Interior building components, spatial structures, and fixed furnishings must be preserved according to their significance, as long as this is necessary for the purpose of protection and reasonable for the owner.

**3. Preservable Monuments**

Preservable monuments must be maintained in their external conditions and with their significant spatial structures. Demolition is permissible if the preservation is disproportionate; in the case of new construction, the monument must be replaced with an object of equal design quality.

**4. Conditions in Building Permit Procedures**

In the building permit procedure, conditions and requirements necessary to avert dangers must be set; project changes may be demanded, building restrictions imposed, or construction permits denied as necessary.

**5. Protection Through Special Legislation**

The protection of monuments listed in federal inventories or cantonal registers due to special legislation is defined by that legislation.

**6. Winter Thermal Protection**

Monuments can be provided with adequate winter thermal protection, as long as they are not significantly impaired thereby.

← Art. 10a Building Act (BauG) Public Construction Law - Prerequisites for Building Art. 10c Building Act (BauG) →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (34)

110 2023 145 · be (Art. 10b al. 1 LC)
Appeal Against Heating System Replacement and Parking Space Enlargement Permit
Cited in the context of protecting the exterior of the listed building when discussing the unsuitability of moving the heat pump to the west facade.
110 2021 40 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 BauG)
Appeal Against Building Permit for Mobile Communication Mast Due to Radiation and Scenery Concerns
Cited in the reasoning section regarding the prohibition against impairing protected monuments through environmental changes.
110 2021 3 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 Satz 2 BauG)
Appeal Against Municipal Permit for 5G Antenna Installation in Protected Townscape
Cited in the reasoning regarding the protection of architectural monuments from environmental changes.
110 2024 53 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 3 BauG)
Administrative Appeal Against Building Permit for Demolition and New High School Construction
The basis for establishing that the demolition of the buildings is permissible because preservation would be disproportionate.
110 2023 116 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 3 BauG)
Heritage Building Demolition Permit and Economic Burden
Cited as the legal basis defining preservation requirements for listed buildings, the violation of which led to allowing the demolition.
110 2023 116 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 3 BauG)
Heritage Building Demolition Permit and Economic Burden
The court mentioned this provision regarding the replacement requirement for a listed building if new construction were to occur.
110 2023 113 · be (art. 10b al. 1 LC)
Municipality Building Permit Appeal for Historic Farm Conversion
Used to justify adding a condition that execution details for the climbing wall be submitted to the Historical Monuments Service for prior approval.
110 2022 144 · be (Art. 10b al. 1 et 3 LC)
Appeal Against Refusal of Building Permit for Stove Installation in Historic Building
The appeal was rejected because the construction project violated the provisions governing the transformation of heritage monuments.
110 2022 143 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 3 BauG)
Bridge Replacement Zoning and Nature Protection Appeal Dismissal
The decision confirmed that the replacement structure met the monument protection requirements, specifically regarding the obligation to replace a listed monument with a visually equivalent object.
110 2021 199 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 BauG)
Appeal Dismissed: Building Permit Denial Upheld Despite Architectural Competition Assurances Due to ISOS Impairment
The construction project was rejected because it would impair the neighboring protected monument (Villa Cranz) through environmental changes.
110 2021 199 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 3 BauG)
Appeal Dismissed: Building Permit Denial Upheld Despite Architectural Competition Assurances Due to ISOS Impairment
The building permit could not be granted because the applicant failed to prove that the preservation of the two heritage buildings (fire station and arsenal) was disproportionate.
110 2021 162 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 Satz 2 BauG)
Appeal Regarding Non-Conforming Shed Construction Near Protected Landmark Upheld
The decision confirms that the construction violates this provision by impairing a listed monument, used as a secondary justification if the res iudicata argument failed.
110 2021 50 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 BauG)
Administrative Review of Permit Revocation for Construction Violating Heritage Area Regulations
The decision ruled that the new construction constitutes an inadmissible impairment of the protected neighboring monument.
100 2019 413 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 Satz 2 BauG)
Developer v. Cantonal Directorate for Building and Traffic (Building Permit and Aesthetic Regulations)
Cited while addressing the objection regarding the impact on the protected farm building.
110 2019 196 · be (Art. 10b Abs. 1 BauG)
Mobile Mast Height Versus Visual Integrity in Historic Village Center
Provision stating that monuments must not be impaired by changes in their surroundings, cited as a ground for upholding the appeal and refusing the building permit.