Legislator Case Law & Legislation
641.1 STBGLCSULCS CH-BE

Art. 23 State Contribution Act (SCA) - Revocation

Securing the Purpose of the Contribution
Open official source Full Act (39 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 23 State Contribution Act (SCA) - Revocation · Revocation

1. The competent authority shall revoke a state contribution decision if the contribution was wrongfully promised or paid due to a violation of legal regulations or based on an incorrect or incomplete set of facts.

2. The authority shall refrain from revocation if

a) the legal violation was not easily recognizable to the recipient of the state contribution,

b) the recipient of the state contribution has taken measures based on the decision that cannot be undone without unreasonable financial losses, and

c) any incorrect or incomplete determination of facts is not attributable to the recipient's culpable behavior.

3. In the case of contracts concerning financial assistance and compensations, the competent authority declares the withdrawal from the contract.

4. With the revocation or withdrawal, the authority demands the return of the state contributions already paid out. The recipient of the state contribution must also pay interest from the date of payment if this was caused by their culpable behavior. In this case, compensation must also be made for any further damage.

← Art. 22 State Contribution Act (StCA) - Recovery in Case of Misuse and Disposal Purpose, Scope, and Definitions Art. 24 State Contributions Act (StBG) - Interest Rate →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (9)

100 2023 134 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 4 StBG)
Cultural Enterprise Clawback for Improper Profit Shifting to Sister Company
Cited as the basis for the actual reclaiming of the unduly paid allowance in the dispositive reasoning (E. 4.6 and E. 5).
100 2023 134 · be (Art. 23 StBG)
Cultural Enterprise Clawback for Improper Profit Shifting to Sister Company
This article served as the legal basis for the administrative authority reviewing and reclaiming the subsidy that was unduly granted.
100 2024 162 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 1 StBG)
Repayment of Covid-19 Aid Due to Dividend Distribution in Contravention of Restrictions
Cited as the basis for the revocation of the administrative act granting the immediate support due to misuse of funds.
100 2024 162 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 4 StBG)
Repayment of Covid-19 Aid Due to Dividend Distribution in Contravention of Restrictions
Cited, together with Art. 25 Abs. 2 StBG, concerning the non-statute of limitations for the claim for reimbursement.
100 2024 162 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 4 erster Satz StBG)
Repayment of Covid-19 Aid Due to Dividend Distribution in Contravention of Restrictions
Cited as the basis for the claim to reimbursement of the disbursed immediate support.
100 2023 76 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 1 StBG)
GmbH Covid-19 Fund Repayment Due to Failure to Meet Revenue Threshold
This article provided the legal basis cited in the reasoning (E. 3.7, 5) for the rightful revocation of the unlawfully granted state contribution (Sofortunterstützung).
100 2023 76 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 4 StBG)
GmbH Covid-19 Fund Repayment Due to Failure to Meet Revenue Threshold
This article governs the right to reclaim the repaid state contribution, cited in the final disposition (E. 5).
100 2011 374 · be (Art. 23 Abs. 4 StBG)
Hospital Repayment Obligation for Improperly Subsidized Pension Contributions
Used to grant the appeal in part, overturning the interest obligation because the withdrawal was not caused by the appellant's culpable conduct.
140 2014 34 · be (Art. 23 StBG)
Subsidy Revocation Due to Pre-Application Construction Start
The provision cited for the formal revocation of the subsidy commitment, which corrects the contested decision.