Legislator Case Law & Legislation
150.960 IVÖB CH-AG

Art. 53 Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (IVöB) - Subject of Appeal

10. Legal Protection Legal protection refers to the safeguarding of individuals' rights under the law. It encompasses various mechanisms and procedures designed to enforce and secure the legal rights and remedies available to individuals. This includes access to the courts, fair trial procedures, and remedies such as injunctions, damages, or specific performance. Legal protection ensures that individuals can seek redress for violations of their legal rights through proper legal channels.
Open official source Full Act (65 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 53 IVöB - Subject of Appeal · Subject of Appeal

1. Only the following decisions are subject to appeal

a) the publication of the contract notice;

b) the decision regarding the selection of the bidders in the selective procedure;

c) the decision regarding the inclusion of a provider in a directory or the removal of a provider from a directory;

d) the decision on requests for disqualification;

e) the award;

f) the withdrawal of the award;

g) the termination of the procedure;

h) the exclusion from the procedure;

i) the imposition of a sanction.

2. Provisions in the tender documents that are clearly identifiable must be contested together with the tender notice.

3. The provisions of this agreement concerning the right to be heard in the decision-making process, the suspensive effect, and the limitation of grounds for appeal do not apply to appeals against the imposition of a sanction.

4. Decisions under paragraph 1 letters c and i may be contested by an appeal regardless of the contract value.

5. In all other respects, legal protection against decisions under this agreement is excluded.

6. The appeal against the conclusion of individual contracts pursuant to Article 25 paragraphs 4 and 5 is excluded.

← Art. 52 IVöB - Complaint Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (IVöB) - Subject Matter Art. 54 IVöB - Suspensive Effect →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (10)

WBE.2025.129 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. e IVöB)
Home care contract award upheld due to expired appeal window.
Mentioned as a potential basis for appeal against a 'de facto' award.
WBE.2025.131 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. a IVöB)
Challenged Award Decision Due to Insufficient Justification and Evaluation
The appeal was declared admissible against the award of the contract.
WBE.2025.8 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. e IVöB)
Public Works Bid Challenge: Procedural Flaw Insufficient, Price Evaluation Error Leads to Annulment
Cited to establish that the award of a contract is a reviewable decision in public procurement.
WBE.2024.183 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. e IVöB)
Waste Collection Contract Award Unlawful Due to Flat Price Evaluation Curve
Allows for the appeal of contract awards in public procurement procedures when thresholds are met.
WBE.2024.125 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. g IVöB)
Public Procurement Authority's Cancellation of Bidding Process Upheld After Unlawful Award
This article concerns the appealability of the termination of a procedure, which is relevant to the admissibility of the appeal, but not directly cited in the dispositive orders.
WBE.2023.371 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. e IVöB)
Contract Award Annulled Due to Flawed Bid Evaluation
This provision allows for appeals against contract awards, which is the subject of the current case.
VBE.2022.455 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. a-i IVöB)
Bidder Exclusion and Contract Award for Tunnel Spoil Transport
Cited to confirm that the award decision and the exclusion decision are appealable administrative decisions under IVöB.
WBE.2022.314 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. e IVöB)
Municipality's Flawed Bid Evaluation Overturned
Cited as the legal basis for the appealability of award decisions when thresholds for the invitation procedure are met.
WBE.2022.381 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. e IVöB)
Municipality's Direct Award of Reservation Solution Unlawful Due to Underestimated Contract Value
Cited to establish that the award could be challenged by appeal when the thresholds for an invitation-to-tender procedure were met.
WBE.2022.157 · ag (Art. 53 Abs. 1 lit. h IVöB)
City's Bidder Exclusion Upheld Due to Insufficient Engineer Experience
Cited as the legal basis for the appealability of the exclusion from the tendering procedure.