Legislator Case Law & Legislation
150.960 IVÖB CH-AG

Art. 29 Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (IVöB) - Award Criteria

Tender Requirements
Open official source Full Act (65 Articles) Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Art. 29 IVöB - Award Criteria · Award Criteria

1. The contracting authority evaluates the offers based on performance-related award criteria. In addition to the price and quality of a service, it may specifically consider criteria such as suitability, deadlines, technical value, cost-effectiveness, lifecycle costs, aesthetics, sustainability, plausibility of the offer, creativity, customer service, delivery conditions, infrastructure, level of innovation, functionality, readiness to provide service, expertise, or efficiency of the methodology.

2. Outside the scope of the state contract area, the contracting authority may additionally consider to what extent the provider offers training positions for apprentices in basic vocational education, jobs for older employees, or reintegration for the long-term unemployed.

3. The contracting authority announces the award criteria and their weighting in the call for tenders or the tender documents. If solutions, solution paths, or procedures are the subject of the procurement, disclosure of the weighting may be waived.

4. For standardized services, the award may be based exclusively on the criterion of the lowest price.

← Art. 28 IVöB - Directories Intercantonal Agreement on Public Procurement (IVöB) - Subject Matter Art. 30 IVöB - Technical Specifications →

Need to analyze how this provision applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this statute against case law, commentaries, and related legislative provisions inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Court Decisions Applying This Provision (9)

WBE.2025.131 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 1 IVöB)
Challenged Award Decision Due to Insufficient Justification and Evaluation
Defines the criteria that can be considered when awarding a contract, such as price, quality, expediency, deadlines, and technical value.
WBE.2025.8 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 1 IVöB)
Public Works Bid Challenge: Procedural Flaw Insufficient, Price Evaluation Error Leads to Annulment
This article outlines the criteria for awarding contracts, including price and quality, and allows for additional criteria to be considered.
WBE.2024.183 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 3 IVöB)
Waste Collection Contract Award Unlawful Due to Flat Price Evaluation Curve
Requires awarding authorities to disclose award criteria and their weighting in the tender documents.
WBE.2024.129 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 1 IVöB)
Contract Award Annulled Due to Bidder's Prior Involvement and Formal Defect
Cited to outline the award criteria that can be considered by the contracting authority.
WBE.2023.371 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 1 IVöB)
Contract Award Annulled Due to Flawed Bid Evaluation
This article outlines the criteria for awarding contracts, including price and quality, which are central to the dispute.
VBE.2022.455 · ag (Art. 29 IVöB)
Bidder Exclusion and Contract Award for Tunnel Spoil Transport
Cited as part of the general duty of the authority to formulate award criteria.
WBE.2022.314 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 1 IVöB)
Municipality's Flawed Bid Evaluation Overturned
Cited as the legal basis for the awarding authority to examine offers based on performance-related award criteria.
WBE.2022.314 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 2 IVöB)
Municipality's Flawed Bid Evaluation Overturned
Referred to in the context of allowing the consideration of apprentice training as a award criterion, but with limitations on its weighting.
WBE.2022.314 · ag (Art. 29 Abs. 3 IVöB)
Municipality's Flawed Bid Evaluation Overturned
The court noted that the transparency principle, which is part of this article, might have been violated, but left this question open.