Legislator Case Law & Legislation
9920241 AI generated

Court confirms appeal dismissing natural and judicial presumptions when a fact was already ruled unproven by first instance.

Case Number 9920241
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Portugal (PT)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Appeal confirmed the first instance judgment, ruling that the appellate tribunal could not treat a fact as proven based on natural or judicial presumptions after the lower court had explicitly declared it unproven. The appellant argued for the application of such presumptions to establish the fact, while the respondent maintained the first instance's finding of non-proven status. The court rejected this argument, holding that once a fact is deemed unproven, no presumption can retroactively validate it without violating procedural principles.

Legislator headnote

Official

RESPOSTAS AOS QUESITOS ALTERAÇÃO RELAÇÃO PRESUNÇÕES JUDICIAIS

Keywords

AI generated
appellate review standards natural presumptions invalidity judicial presumptions limits fact finding procedure first instance binding effect

Cited Legislation

AI generated
CPC 1995 Art. 712
CC 1966 Art. 349

Cited Case Law

AI generated
STJ Decision 1998/01/20, CJSTJ T1 Ano VI Page 19

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

[Nº CONVENCIONAL] JTRP00026656

[Nº DO DOCUMENTO] RP199909219920241

[PRIVACIDADE] 1

[TEXTO INTEGRAL] N

[TRIBUNAL RECORRIDO] T J OVAR

[URL] https://www.dgsi.pt/jtrp.nsf/56a6e7121657f91e80257cda00381fdf/D1844393D320BEB98025686B006734CB?OpenDocument

SUMÁRIO

I - Formulado quesito sobre um facto e tendo o tribunal de 1ª instância dado esse quesito como não provado, não é lícito à Relação considerar tal facto como provado com base em presunções naturais ou judiciais.