Supreme Court dismissed appeal against rejection of retrial claim based on newly discovered evidence. Appeal rejected as second instance court properly handled case merits.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the appellate court's rejection of a retrial request. The appellant argued that a crucial employment certificate was overlooked by the second-instance court despite being newly discovered, while the court held that formal citation of the retrial ground does not guarantee its substantive existence. The decision clarified that a second-instance court ruling on the merits, even by dismissing an appeal, constitutes a judgment on the case's substance, making it the proper venue for retrial proceedings.