KKO 800/2013
AI generated
Supreme Court dismissed claim linking knee plica symptoms to 2008 accident due to lack of medical causation evidence.
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe Supreme Court of Finland dismissed the plaintiff's claim regarding a causal link between knee plica symptoms and a 2008 accident. The plaintiff argued the injury caused ongoing pain, but the court found insufficient medical evidence establishing a direct causal relationship. Consequently, the claim was rejected because the plaintiff failed to prove the symptoms resulted from the specific accident.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedLainvoimainen tapaturmavakuutuslain 10.12.1982/1027 10 luku 1 §; 10 luku 2 §: Jos vakuutettu ei osoita, että hänen vammaansa aiheutti tapahtuma, vakuutusyhtiö ei ole velvollinen korvaamaan vauriota.
Keywords
AI generated
workplace accident compensation
medical causation burden
knee plica injury
Supreme Court of Finland
accident liability standard
Cited Legislation
AI generated10 luku 1 § of the Work Accident Insurance Act 10.12.1982/1027
10 luku 2 § of the Work Accident Insurance Act 10.12.1982/1027
Related Decisions
AI generatedkko-other_2002_2072
Supreme Court allows compensation for long-term knee pain caused by horse kicking under tort law.
kko-other_2013_31
Supreme Court dismissed claim that neck pain was causally linked to a 2007 traffic accident.
kko-other_1998_3408
Work injury claim dismissed because bacterial infection from knee injury was not a direct consequence of the accident.
insurance_1980_3329-1979
Workplace chair slip caused knee injury; fracture covered, pre-existing arthritis excluded from compensation.
kko-other_2012_2460
Supreme Court dismissed claim for compensation where pain in left upper limb was not causally linked to the 2007 accident.
Full text
Kysymys siitä, olivatko oikean polven nivelkalvon poimun (plica) oireet syy-yhteydessä 21.5.2008 sattuneeseen tapaturmaan.