Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
1-08-2794\4 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against settlement agreement regarding compensation for personal injury claims.

Case Number 1-08-2794\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Open official source Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against a settlement agreement reached between the parties. The appellant argued that the settlement amount was insufficient and violated their right to a full trial on damages. The court ruled that the parties are free to settle their dispute and that the agreement was validly concluded without legal defects.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 100 of the Civil Procedure Code; s. 101 of the Civil Procedure Code: The court's decision on an appeal against a settlement agreement is subject to strict scrutiny, and the agreement remains valid unless proven to be void or voidable under specific statutory conditions.

Keywords

AI generated
settlement agreement civil procedure code appeal dismissal personal injury compensation dispute

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 100 of the Civil Procedure Code
s. 101 of the Civil Procedure Code

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



 



              !!"#$ %    

  & !'()) &!&  

      *+   ,# -.%/'      !0( //1/  

   !)/% , %--0(%. % "#"" )/''/1//.) %/% ! 2  ),  ' 3 2  ),  ' 3 2  ),  '  4! 2 5 4,(     !( /(%!!          %(" "##0 67( %-(!/,8 ++

!/1 "(1(!!)"#!% "!(%.!. 0  ) "#!)8 & &&5!&  (!"#$. '##).  2  ),  '  !) %/)

9 .(,(1(%( 6!:!0 %/"!#. % ! "!.%/!4!,! !3 & &&5!&  (!"#$. '##).  2 + ),  ' ;;+ 4! 2  ),  ' ; !) %/) 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % +!& 7')(" "!(%. % 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % +! *"3 +& &*&!& ()4!0( !!"#$. '##).  2 + ),  ' ;;+3 2  ),  '  4! 2  ),  '  !) %/) 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % ! *"& 7')(" "!(%. % 6!:!0 %/"!#. % !3 & &&!&  !!"#$. '##).  2  ),  ' ;;+ !) %/) 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % ! 3 5& *&&!&  !!"#$. '##).  2 + ),  ' ; 4! 2  ),  '  !) %/) 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % +! 3 *& *&&!&  !!"#$. '##).  2 < ),  ' ;; 4!

2 <5 ),  !) %/) 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % +! *" 3 & +&&!& !4 !!"#$. '##). ! 2 ++ !) %/) 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % "& 7')(" "!(%. % 9 6!:!0 %/"!#. % " *';



  6!:!/% &*&5&!& 7"/0  /) "#$!%. )!$" 1(%/ "//)0 "#$!)0!. 0 !)/% , % $./% &5&*&!&    !06#"!!. -# ##%1!!  !" = $(0 0/%  2 ;  4,(         # #$%& $'&     (     )   *               # $%+   $ ' &       (       &

    *          #$,-    (     )  *         #&./ $'$    (     0

   *

 #)0 $ #)/ &     

     

  (       0

   *

! 2  ), ; + !) %/) 4..! "!(%. % .(/)(" ). .(,(1 %)(" ). .(.1(%/)/ '>>!1!.! " ( !)/% , /( '!/ + !!%.!%/ "(. 1(%"#.#))(,! "!.%/!4! 4##"% ) .#(1/ . .!$.)("" " (./, 4! .(0!: ! 2 5 %./%.!. 0 "#.#))7 0/(0 4! "#$ %. %(&

! 2 * ),  !) %/) ) ,/0! //)6!,(%. %/% 6((:(. 0 !/, &&*&!& " ( &5&*&!& %&#& +* '/6! "!(%. %/ "!01(%/ !4! $ )"!&   2 5 !) %/) 6)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). 1//.) %" ) 08 !"##.()(%/ !(/ /"%'/.((%

/"%'/.((%(!". &**?++  5 "##(& @ /"%'/.((% /"%'/.((%(!". &* *?+ 9   "##(&

!$ )0!0! .%(6(()$!,( 4! 6)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). *+ "##( =&  "!% "%&

7"/0 9 /) "#$!%. )!$" 1(%/ "//)0 .-$(%.!0! "#$. #.% %/ 47 %. 1(%/)& !(%. %/ "!01(%/ !4! !), %. !6!.! !)!./% &&!

)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). .!% ((,( 7(, %!:( //%. /)( . $!. "#)1%!0! "!$/"%!"-11/0 + "##( 4! 5 %/.( (,  2  ),  '  !) %/) % 0!$!  5 "-11/ . $!. "!$/"%!%!0! %/(.%/"-11/0 6((% "##( ((,(. ) 0/%%/&

1 (   9 /"%'/.((%()/ %!!0/. 0 !"##.()(/ !(/ !1A/.!1(( 9 4..! !))(! #$. /"%'/.((%( 4! (1(!)(%.("! "/%" %%/ !) %8 %(%/1((%.( 1 %  ; &&5&!& -$4!0 1((,('' "()/"#.(0

'!"/0    " ) 6!0 $6(.!1(%/)/&

!)/% ,<) .!% 0! 6)4!17(%./. 0 % 11!0 !$!0 %1((%.//( 1( !6/)0 %!6/)/ +  !,!% 67( +** !%!'!,!%& !"%/"#!)0 %/)/ 1"(0! 6((./ 1:/ ** (, %/),(. %8 B!)/% , ; ((,( 7(, %!:(C; B!)/% ,  ; % 0!$!C& ((,( 7(, %!:( .!% 4! % 0!$! .!% 0! + '/6! 4##"% ) "/%#)/6! "#$. #.% %/

47 %. 1(%/%. !6!./%& ( !$!)(%/0 7 0/0 '#)/ .(/% )!. %/% .(0/. 0 % !.!"%/ 7 0/0 .(./1//.) %/ ):(6((1(%/"% "#$. .(. ()/ .(./1//.) %/ %/!0 %.(" % %./%.!. 0 "#!%&



+       

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



  2 ((             ' 

2        '    '          '      2 '       # $%&   $ ' &     3       *

!1 .( ./1!; (%(" !; "/% # 6!/1 .#(1/ '! 0 6!, %/ 4! #1!%.!1(%/; #))/% %!! 0 +&&*&!& =&  6((1!%/  (.//.('!,! %!)!%7! 4! '!##)("##0(0; /%(.!% &&*&!&  % =&  (1/) !6/)0 %!6/ (.//.('!,! "! 0 )!/ .!#.) %/ %1%)!/ A(1!%%/ D   % 11!% + "##(& !%. (1/.!. % 11! )!/" 1(%. =& !6/)0 %!6/)/ "!0(% !)/% , %/))/ %!1!) '/6!) /0!%( /0! !6/)0 %"#.#)/&



  2        



            (      

2  '2    '        2'    # $%+ $'&   3       *

!1 .( ./1!; #))/% !0 0 %-,(%/) *&!& .'%/). . 6!%.!1!.! " '/6!)  % =& )!/ 5 "##(; 7 0(% 6((1!%/). &&&!& "/))! *&5 '!("  )(!% !/"-)!% & E 4 /% !% 6!% '!")!% 5 "##(; $6!0!0/% 6((1!%. A--%()(%/ 6,(6!))!,!; '/!)/ 1(0! =& !0(% !)/% ,()/ 5 "##(&



 2     (    

     2      

  

2'    #$,-   3       *

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



  2                   

2   

      

2        '    '         '     

   2'    #&./ $'$   3       *



     ' '(  

 #" >( !:( .!#.)/% !)/% ,<( %--0( . (%.!1(%. ! 2  ),  '  4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"% * " 0 6!,(%. %.& --0( . (%.!0! !)/% , ! 2  ),  '  4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"%  !!%.! 6!,(%. %.& --0( . (%.!0! !)/% , ! 2 5 4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"% * " 0 6!,(%. %.& --0( . (%.!0! !)/% , ! 2  ),  '  4,( (, 17(%.! "!(%. %/"% + !!%.!. 6!,(%. %.& ! 2 *+ ),  4! 2 * ),  !) %/) ) ,/0! "/,/1!0 "!(%. %/0 "!/. "% !%"/1!,! 4! 17(%.! )((."!(%. %/"% + !!%.!. 6!,(%. %.; 1())(/ 4..! ! 2  ), ; + !) %/) .(/)(" ). .(,(1 %)(" ). .(.1(%/)/ '>>!1!.! " ( !)/% , /( '!/ + !!%.!%/ "(. 1(%"#.#))(,! "!.%/!4! 4##"% ) .#(1/ . .!$.)("" " (./, 4! .(0!: ! 2 5 %./%.!. 0 "#.#))7 0/(0 4! "#$ %. %(& ! 2 * ),  !) %/) ) ,/0! "!. "% //)6!,(%. %/% 6((:(. 0 !/, &&*&!& " ( &5&*&!& %&#& +* '/6!&  2 5 !) %/) 6)4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). 1//.) %" ) 08 !"##.()(%/ !(/ /"%'/.((%

/"%'/.((%(!". &**?++  5 "##(& @ /"%'/.((% /"%'/.((%(!". &* *?+ 9   "##(&

%(.7/0(0 9 /"%'/.((%()/ %!!0/. 0 !"##.()(/ !(/ !1A/.!1(( 9 4..! !))(! #$. /"%'/.((%( 4! (1(!)(%.("! "/%" %%/ !) %8 %(%/1((%.( 1 %  ; &&5&!& -$4!0 1((,(' "()/"#.(0 '!"/0    "(1(!!)!%4! 4 /% " ) 6!0 $6(.!1(%/)/& )4! 17(%.! !)/% ,<). .%(6(()$!,( =&  "!% "% % 11!% *+ "##(& 7"/0 9 /) "#$!%. )!$" 1(%/ "//)0 0/% (6(%/), % $./% .-$(%.!0! "#$. #.% %/ 47 %. 1(%/)& !(.%4! 4( %7)1(. 0 "#"" )/''/ 4 0/ 4! '!) % %/))/ "((.!0!& 

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

,# -.%/' #$. ("