Court dismissed asylum claim for a Russian national who failed to prove a well-founded fear of persecution.
Estonia (EE)
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe Viru Ringkonnakohus dismissed the asylum application filed by a Russian national who claimed persecution based on his ethnic background. The applicant argued that he faced threats from state authorities due to his nationality, but the court found no evidence supporting his assertion of a well-founded fear. Consequently, the court ruled that the applicant did not meet the legal requirements for asylum protection under the relevant statutes.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 17 ust. 1 k.r.s.; Art. 17 ust. 2 k.r.s.: An asylum claim is rejected when the applicant fails to substantiate a well-founded fear of persecution based on race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedFull text
!" !#$
%&'"""(&")*+#,)--.$/
&'"""(&")*+#,
0%%12
--$$/'"##".!3/4"/ !,). 3-5-,"-,"'".-,
# -.$!
*"-6.
775$/"/","
.-
.89
$775/$/"3$-$
"$/$$-"5$/ 0-5"$85"2:'6
"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;&"
!#/!/$$
775$/"/",.-.8
!"8! "/
!#/."*6,-
!$" !"
!"8! <"="..-8-"
.-.80$7"-&$-8/-3;-1%&"2
$ !!5
%1)-$/";" !5" )/<</)-. !#/
>>>>>>>>>???)*&3"". !"$
"$/"/57#-. !".)"."/-$&'$/&",;;
85"3$ !#"$
!"#$%
&'()*+,-',../'
(0&&120-3,
2'
&'&'
'
,'(4'
5"$ "-;"3$- !5
&3',..5''
')
6
62'
'
*@'"
0%2
&'"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;&" !#/!/$$-"0. &) &2
/$/"/.-.8$775":'6'" "$/$- $3+$/-/(0 "#- $"2""$/"/
,"$/$/&
&'&'":.".$-.$-5"/"$ -3" "$/$-$-5"3$-/--..-.8.-
3+$/-/5 "$/$/"'"" !#/,"."" !#/3"'"&!,-3;&" !#/!/$$-"
3+$/-/5 "$/$- "53"/"!$")$&!0$-/$3-2 .$-,"$/$-,+"'"./ "$/$- $
3+$/-/(0 "#- $"2""$/"/'"0$-/$-2 5,"$/$/&
&'&'&'":(.".$-.",-$/"/ "$/$-/6#/"'"#. "--.,"$/$-$,;3$-"-)$&!
&'$/ &!,-3;) ! 0,$2 507 $286-,","$/$/'" "$/$-
"53$-/6#/"-"",-$/"/.-.89,"#$/"3$-$/)$&!"."/-$&'$/&"&
,'.-.8!"/5 !#/".."":'6$-..-$)-/&'.&""$/". -.."&
8" ".%#/3-"$3$!#/."*6,-..+/"86"$/7#$/". !#!./",/"3$/,#"$/'"
"3 "5-5$-$///"7#- !" <<!""$75"3-8 !5"!3"//!!.$$/,"/
///","/*&/),3"$-/-.-A! +-86"$/!3-.$-3-#-"&-..-"8+#'$/"$.-
.8*&.-7#-"++5-/,"/! -.+ -#"",","$" .8!!.5 --.$75"3-
,"$/$-"'"'6-,"$75"3-/"38!""5")3..-/""'6'-.*&&$$753$ !#".&
1'"" !#$)#"5 !/5/+-5-5-5- !3$).-5$)-/&'.&""$/".
"'"8-!!5. -.."& & !/-$""5-$$"".%!#/."*6,-).+$775$/"/",
.-.8$+".$-/7. 6$!3"-5$/-. ""$."$/*&./7#- !"!""5&*&&$
$""55 -#","$/$-/""'6'-.&
1'&'775$/"/",.-.8$-./"$3"" !#/$)-/*&//"-"3"$/"5'"/-3"" !!$-
-."5&"..--3--.55)-/*&&-#!!./$-5!3"."8$---$/)/",/"$". !#!.)-
/<</"5)#-.$/"$ +,".$/-.-3--$/-.-'" !#/$-5-"&
-"5-$)-/*&!. ".5,$". !#!./",/"5")/+/"..-85-.,"&",/"$ !!$*&"
". !#!.&775$/"/",.-.8,+$*&& !/-$/6"3"'"/-3""3//- !#/5")
3-5 !#$/$-./--/-$---$-!.5&.-.8.-!.5+$/+5"*&./)-//"
-." $/-$/$$/-.&B5$"$-,"'"5$/-3"$#/-$,6,".5" "$/"5"&*&&,;$
/"83$-3!3-5."$ -$". !#!!.$-'!!;-$-$5$&"$-8!!./-!.5.-.8$#/-$
3/"-$$!!&B+#'$/)3 $/"*&.-!"#"","/- /"$)$-./"5"-!$"5&"..#/$"./
$" +"$-"3!!5-."3$-$/&77-$!""$75"3-8 !5")-$""5/"3//-
3+$/")-/$--,+;8+#'$/"5"*&&$3"&
1','B-".- /-!/!3-8"-3$/ --"$/"8"$/"!" 6/-6/ $$$-)8" !//'",$ "$
87 !/--$$-&+/.-$,6.'",-$!!)3$!.- $85"5/"..-/""3"".;&..-$$--'6-.
/$$,6.'"8!./$-) ";'"8775$!$/"5"$3","./#"","/5*&.-
";&
$".$-./-"$/$775-/$/"5&B775$3$/$-"5$$-"'"5"'"'#/5" "#/.$-
/!3-8"55/"83$-$-5"./ +,".-&
+ --5/-!566,"5$-..-$/)-//"8"/-!/!3-/-"5. ./)$""5-$")35"/"!./-5
'"8775-$,"$//$-$/ +,".-#.5"&--"!/+-5"/5.-.8$77":'6
-//-6#/5 /-!/!3-8"-3$-$&.-.88"$77/-!/!3-!/$-$-/"#/.$-"&
7'"$/$-3+$/3$-.36 $3"" !#$)-/.-.8$775 --5"," $"$'"!. $.-$
3"" !#$8#/$75"3. "#-/$$-&
0%2
3'"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;&" !#/!/$$-8-".-
"8-.."/$!!-$/"5$775$/"/",.-.80. &%%) &28".;3+$/"/"..-.--;-3
"$/$&
3'&'8-.."/.-";)-/3+$/-/5,"." "$/$ "#- $"""$/"/'"$-/$- 5!"- "$/$&
8-.."/,/";"$'"!..-)-/3"" !#$-",-$/"5/6-.366"./-3"8#/$75"3.
"#-/$$/'"/-3" !!$/<<53--/.-'""--.3$- 6$&
3','8-.."/.-";)-/8+#.-8!;.--3*&&/"83$-.!.*&&-;"+."- 6/3-&*&&-
/"#/5/<</"5")/",/"$/#/". !#!.)'+3"#"/-3"+- /!"$""5-/5"#"&
8-.."//"!/.-;3"" !#/!/$$-/7#$/"3$/ "$/$-3+$/3$-!$"$.--;-3" "$/$-
3+$/3$/&
-'B6"$/--.$/" -5"3$/$-./"$ !#/ -//- "5'"--.$/ !".5"3$-".$/)3$
$-$-$$-..-$)-/3"" !#/0. &8<<5-.) &2!/$$-8+#'-5","$!$"$85;$775$/"/","
.-.8$77$$-$/.6#/, "$/$-. '"366"$$".5",8+#'-5$&
6/- $)3"" !#/!/$$-8+#'-5","$!$"$ "$/$-3+$/3$-.! '/"/57 $."$-C
D-3"$775 --5"," $"$'"!. $.!-; !#$8#/$75"3. "#-/$$-D&
-'&'-.$/ 6$/..6#-5"5" " $ 7$3$/C
-'&'&' "$
3"" !#/
!/$$-$
"$/$-
3+$/3$-
8+#'-5$-
853-
!
3"".3--/.$-!..- 3-)3..$-.'#./.-;3"" !#/!/$$/7#$/"5" "$/$-
3+$/3$-!$"$$""/" 3""."$- $"/"3$- $3"" !#/.-),+
-'&','--.3-/"/5"$'"!.-!.- 3"".3--/.$+$-!..- 3-'"'6-. ./
3""."$$775$/"/",".-.8"8-.."/$!!".$-./.-;366"/""/"3$-.-
.6;,""/"3$- $"8-.."/$!! !"$&
/' !"8! <"="..-8-"",".5"$","3$/)-/3"" !#/!/$$/.-;/7#$/"5"
"$/$-3+$/3$-!$"$!/$$-$8+#'-5$-853$-/+//'"$--'6-./.-; 3""."$
$""/"- $"/"3$- $3"" !#/.-&
5' !" !#$)!..-$//,5 3""."$'"3"/-'".5-").-5$)-/"::$/
.6#/5-$8-"; !#$86"$/ /-!/!3-8"-3$-/,"$/"3$/$77$$-$/.6#/,"./"53"
"$/$-. '"366"$$".5","8+#'-5"/5 "$/$+$. #"/!3-8"55
/-!.-0/ !#/ 3"". !..--3."#-5&11))()2&
"$/$-3+$/3$-!$"$0. &8<<5-.) &28+#'-5"$3"" !#$!3"$-$ !#/'63$-./C
D-3"$775 --5"," $"$'"!. $.!-; !#$8#/$75"3. "#-/$$-D&
"" !#/!/$$-$85;$775$/"/",".-.89$77$$-$/.6#/, "$/$-. '"
366"$$".5",8+#'-5$&"" !#$'6//$ "$/$-3+$/3$-.,"./5 "$/$366"
8+#'-5"3"/"& !" !#$36;)-/ "$/$-3+$/3$/85/","58+#'-5$-5!
!#/!/$$-!..-!$"&!#/!/$$-$ "$/$-8+#$/"3"/"'6/3$-.!/--3$/
3"".3--/.$+$-!..$- 3$-":1.83+//-$&
:(.8 !#"$-./8-"; !" !#$$-..$- 3$-/,"$/"3$-."."/
/7#$/"3"3"" !#/!/$$-'"$""/3" 3""."$'"3"" !#/.-- $"/"3$- $&:
1. 3$- +,".5"3-"8-.."/$!!3--/.$-$-!.-.;"/5&
8' !" !#$.-";)-/3"" !#$",-$/"$ "$/$-3+$/3$-."./ "$/$/
--5","/"$'"!.)$&!8#/$75"3. "#-/$$/&
0%2
%
":.+ -/-$-$/."$-$/""$-.;)-/ "$/$-3+$/3$-./.-;8-".-".$-",-$/"5"
"/-$"$'"!.$5)$# ",+3".$/3+'/"5"$775."$/-5"$85#!53"$77/-!
/!3-8"-3$-$/'"+$ !" "/$3$-#,$5&--"/.-; !#/. "$/$-3+$/3$-.
$.3"$85"5" " "$/$- !#".5"3$---$36 -&"$-3+'/"3-/!3;.6;
$ $$-)/-3"#!" /-3/3$- "5&
/$$-8+#'-5","$!$"$85;7.5$-$775$/"/",".-.89$ $$-"".77$&$""
'6-.5"5") "$/"! "$/"/5,66/-5-/!3-8"-3$-$) "$/".!.$$$-/.- ) "$/"!.
3"". !"$ "$/"/5&./!/$$--$!./,!$"$/6#/;)-/$ /-0*&&/"83-2
!/!3-8"55 "/$-"'" -$/-.&'665"$""3"/ $) 5"$$"-$3-$-"$/3- !#$
3+$/"./ "$/$- !#/!/$$/- !3") 3""."$'"$85;--.3$-!/$$-6" &
!" !#$+#/";)-/./ "$/$-3+$/3$-.0 "$#.'-3/,"$/"/5 !3",+
!#/!/$$/- !3"28-" $ 3""."$'"'5-!.-3".$"/5--.3$/-!/$$/-6" '"5)
3..-".$-.3!!5$/"/" $-./ "$/$&
3"".3--/.$+$-!..$- 3$-/,"$/"3$-"--.3--/.$- 6$$775$/"/","
.-.89"8-.."/$!!$$.$-./-"/"/5& !" !#$.-";)-/--./!!5585$
+,".5"3"/"-!.-,+3". /-#"!;'- /,$-/'6-.5$/.-.8.- "$/$-3+$/3$-
!$"$&
!!$ +."$--./!!5"'"'#55-$::5-$/(.8)1.8)(.)(%.
)(.)/7#$/"; !" !#$"" !#/!#/."*6,- !#/3"'"&!,-3;
&"!/$$-.-.8.-":'63+$/-/5 "$/$-'"":.'6
3+$/-/5./ "$/$-!$"$'"$""5"; 3""."$'"- $"/"3$- $$"3".-3"" !#/.-&
##".!3/E"/ !,
-,"-,"
.-,# -.$!
!#/
!#/
!#/